Abstract
The mechanisms and circumstances that affect a plant's ability to tolerate herbivory are subjects of ongoing interest and investigation. Phenological differences, and the timing of flowering with respect to pollinators and pre-dispersal seed predators, may provide one mechanism underlying variable responses of plants to herbivore damage. The subalpine wildflower, Ipomopsis aggregata, grows across a wide range of elevations and, because phenology varies with elevation, phenological delays associated with elevation may affect the ability of I. aggregata to compensate for or tolerate browsing. Thus, we examined the response of I. aggregata to herbivory across an elevation gradient and addressed the interactions among phenological delays imposed by damage, elevation, pre-dispersal seed predation and pollination, on I. aggregata's compensatory response. Among high and low elevation populations in areas near the Rocky Mountain Biological Laboratory (RMBL) in Gothic, Colorado, we compared the responses of naturally browsed, artificially browsed (clipped), and unbrowsed (control) plants of I. aggregata. We compared responses in the date of initiation of flowering, timing of peak bloom, floral display, nectar production and sugar concentration, oviposition and fruit destruction by the pre-dispersal seed predator Hylemya sp. (Anthomyiidae), fruit production, and aboveground biomass production. Clipping had the greatest effect on reproductive success and clipped plants at high elevation exhibited the lowest tolerance for herbivory. The effects of browsing appear to be mediated by flowering phenology, and both browsing and elevation delayed flowering phenology. Time needed for regrowth delays flowering, and thus affects the overlap with seed predators and pollinators. As a result of delayed flowering, naturally browsed and clipped plants incurred lower rates of seed predation. In the absence of seed predation, plants would exhibit a lower tolerance to herbivory since naturally and artificially browsed plants had fewer fruits destroyed by Hylemya larvae. We provide additional evidence that, for populations near the RMBL, clipping and natural browsing do not have the same effect on I. aggregata plants. This may be due to the selection of larger plants by herbivores. Although under some conditions plants may tolerate browsing, in areas where the growing season is short a phenological delay imposed by damage is likely to significantly reduce plant fitness. Identifying the mechanisms that allow plants to tolerate herbivore damage will help to develop a general framework for understanding the role of tolerance in plant population and community dynamics, as well as plant-herbivore interactions.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Augspurger CK (1981) Reproductive synchrony of a tropical shrub: experimental studies on effects on pollinators and seed predators on Hybanthus prunifolius (Violaceae). Ecology 62:775–788
Belsky AJ (1986) Does herbivory benefit plants? A review of the evidence. Am Nat 127:870–892
Bergelson J, Crawley MJ (1992a) Herbivory and Ipomopsis aggregata: The disadvantages of being eaten. Am Nat 139:870–882
Bergelson J, Crawley MJ (1992b) The effect of grazers on the performance of individuals and populations of scarlet gilia, Ipomopsis aggregata. Oecologia 140:435–444
Bergelson J, Juenger T, Crawley MJ (1996) Regrowth following herbivory in Ipomopsis aggregata: compensation but not overcompensation. Am Nat 148:744–755
Biere A (1995) Genotypic and plastic variation in plant size: effects on fecundity and allocation patterns in Lychnis flos-cuculi along a gradient of natural soil fertility. J Ecol 83:629–642
Biere A, Honders SJ (1996) Impact of flowering phenology of Silene alba and S. dioica on susceptibility to fungal infection and seed predation. Oikos 77:467–480
Birkenheuer DL (1992) The LAPS specific humidity analysis. Technical Memorandum ERL FSL-1. NOAA, Washington, D.C.
Brody AK (1992a) Oviposition choices by a predispersal seed predator (Hylemya sp.): correspondence with hummingbird pollinators, and the role of plant size, density and floral morphology. Oecologia 91:56–62
Brody AK (1992b) Oviposition choices by a predispersal seed predator (Hylemya sp.): a positive association between female choice and fruit set. Oecologia 91:63–67
Brody AK (1997) Effects of pollinators, herbivores, and seed predators on flowering phenology. Ecology 78:1624–1631
Brody AK, Morita SI (2000) A positive association between oviposition and fruit set: female choice or manipulation? Oecologia 124:418–425
Brody AK, Waser NM (1995) Ovipositional patterns and larval success of a pre-dispersal seed predator attacking two confamilial host plants. Oikos 74:447–452
Campbell DR, Crawford M, Brody AK, Forbis TA (2002) Resistance to pre-dispersal seed predators in a natural hybrid zone. Oecologia 131:436–443
Coley PD, Barone JA (1996) Herbivory and plant defenses in tropical forests. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 27:305–335
English-Loeb GM, Karban R (1992) Consequences of variation in flowering phenology for seed head herbivory and reproductive success of in Erigeron glaucus (Compositae). Oecologia 89:588–595
Escarré J, Lepart J, Sentuc JJ (1996) Effects of simulated herbivory in three old field Compositae with different inflorescence architectures. Oecologia 105:501–508
Grant V, Wilken D (1986) Taxonomy of the Ipomopsis aggregata group (Polemoniaceae). Bot Gaz 147:359–371
Gronemeyer PA, Dilger BJ, Bouzat JL, Paige KN (1997) The effects of herbivory on paternal fitness in scarlet gilia: better moms also make better pops. Am Nat 150:592–602
Gutian J, Sanchez JM (1992) Flowering phenology and fruit set of Petrocoptis grandiflora (Caryophyllaceae). Int J Plant Sci 153:409–412
Hendrix SD, Trapp EJ (1989) Floral herbivory in Pastinaca sativa: do compensatory responses offset reductions in fitness? Evolution 43:891–895
Herms DA, Mattson WJ (1992) The dilemma of plants: to grow or defend. Q Rev Biol 67:283–335
Huhta AP, T Lennartsson, Tuomi J, Rautio P, Laine K (2000) Tolerance of Gentianella campestris in relation to damage intensity: an interplay between apical dominance and herbivory. Evol Ecol 14:373–392
Inouye DW (1982) The consequences of herbivory: A mixed blessing for Iurines mollis (Asteraceae). Oikos 39:269–272
Juenger T, Bergelson J (1997) Pollen and resource limitation of compensation to herbivory in Scarlet Gilia, Ipomopsis aggregata. Ecology 78:1684–1695
Juenger T, Bergelson J (2000) The evolution of compensation to herbivory in Scarlet Gilia, Ipomopsis aggregata: herbivore-imposed natural selection and the quantitative genetics of tolerance. Evolution 54:764–777
Juenger T, Crawley MJ (1996) Regrowth following herbivory in Ipomopsis aggregata: compensation but not overcompensation. Am Nat 148:744–755
Kudo G (1991) The effect of snow-free period on the phenology of alpine plants inhabiting snow patches. Arct Alp Res 23:436–443
Lennartson T, Nilsson P, Tuomi J (1997) Evidence for an evolutionary history of overcompensation in the grassland biennial herb Gentianella campestris (Gentiaceae). Am Nat 149:1147–1155
Lennartson T, Nilsson P, Tuomi J (1998) Induction of overcompensation in the field gentian Gentianella campestris. Ecology 79:1061–1072
Lesica P, Shelly JS (1995) Effects of reproductive mode on demography and life history in Arabis fecunda (Brassicaceae). Am J Bot 82:752–762
Little TM, Hill FJ (1978) Agricultural experimentation: design and analysis. Wiley, New York
Lohman DJ, Zangerl AR, Berenbaum MR (1996) Impact of floral herbivory by parsnip webworm (Oecophoridae: Depressaria pastinacella Duponchel) on pollination and fitness of wild parsnip (Apiaceae, Pastinaca sativa L.). Am Midl Nat 136:407–412
Mahoro S (2002) Individual flowering schedule, fruit set, and flower and seed predation in Vaccinium hirtum Thunb. (Ericaceae). Can J Bot 80:82–92
Marquis RJ (1992) The selective impact of herbivores. In: Fritz RS, Simms EL (eds) Plant resistance to herbivores and pathogens: ecology, evolution and genetics. University of Chicago Press, Illinois, pp 301–325
Maschinski J, Whitham TG (1989) The continuum of plant responses to herbivory: influence of plant association, nutrient availability, and timing. Am Nat 134:1–19
McNaughton SJ (1979) Grazing as an optimization process: grass ungulate relationships in the Serengeti. Am Nat 113:691–703
Osterheld M, McNaughton SJ (1988) Intraspecific variation in the response of Themeda triandra to defoliation. The effect of time of recovery and growth rates on compensatory growth. Oecologia 77:181–186
Osterheld M, McNaughton SJ (1991) Effect of stress and time for recovery on the amount of compensatory growth after grazing. Oecologia 85:305–313
Owen DF (1980) How plants may benefit from the animals that eat them. Oikos 35:230–235
Owen DF, Wiegart RG (1976) Do consumers maximize plant fitness? Oikos 27:488–492
Paige KN (1992) Overcompensation in response to mammalian herbivory: from mutualistic to antagonistic interactions. Ecology 73:2076–2085
Paige KN (1994) Herbivory and Ipomopsis aggregata—differences in response, differences in experimental protocol—a reply. Am Nat 143:739–749.
Paige KN (1999) Regrowth following ungulate herbivory in Ipomopsis aggregata: geographic evidence for overcompensation. Oecologia 118:316–323
Paige KN, Whitham TG (1987) Overcompensation in response to mammalian herbivory: the advantage of being eaten. Am Nat 129:407–416
Pilson D (2000) Herbivory and natural selection on flowering phenology in wild sunflower, Helianthus annus. Oecologia 122:72–82
Pleasants JM (1983) Nectar production patterns in Ipomopsis aggregata (Polemoniaceae). Am J Bot 70:1468–1475
Rathcke BJ, Lacey EP (1985) Phenological patterns of terrestrial plants. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 16:179–214
Reekie EG (1997) Trade-offs between reproduction and growth influence time of reproduction. In: Bazzaz FA, Grace J (eds) Plant resource allocation. Academic Press, California, pp 191–209
Sokal RR, Rohlf FJ (1995) Biometry, 3rd edn. Freeman, San Francisco
Strauss SY (1988) Determining the effects of herbivory using naturally browsed plants. Ecology 69:1628–1630
Tiffin P (2000) Mechanisms of tolerance to herbivore damage: what do we know? Evol Ecol 14:523–536
Waser NM (1978) Competition for hummingbird pollination and sequential flowering in two Colorado wildflowers. Ecology 59:934–944
Waser NM, Price MV(1983) Optimal and actual outcrossing, and the nature of plant-animal interactions. In: Jones CE, Little RJ (eds) Handbook of experimental pollination biology. Scientific and Academic Editions, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, pp 50–72
Zar JH (1999) Biostatistical analysis, 4th edn. Prentice Hall, New Jersey
Zimmerman M (1979) Oviposition behavior and the existence of an oviposition deterring pheromone in Hylemya. Environ Entomol 8:277–279
Zimmerman M (1980) Reproduction in Polemonium: pre-dispersal seed predation. Ecology 61:502–506
Acknowledgements
We thank Mary Price for statistical advice and Shelley Higgins and Holly Prendeville for assistance in the field. We are also grateful to Tom Lee, Kurt May and two anonymous reviewers for insightful and thoughtful comments on previous versions of the manuscript. Our work was supported by the Department of Plant Biology and Graduate School at the University of New Hampshire, Durham and by NSF grant DEB-9806501 to A.K.B. We also thank the Rocky Mountain Biological Laboratory and its staff for providing facilities and support.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Freeman, R.S., Brody, A.K. & Neefus, C.D. Flowering phenology and compensation for herbivory in Ipomopsis aggregata . Oecologia 136, 394–401 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-003-1276-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-003-1276-6