Abstract
Databases on effects of chronic low-LET radiation exposure were analyzed by non-parametric statistical methods, to estimate the threshold dose rates above which radiation effects can be expected in vertebrate organisms. Data were grouped under three umbrella endpoints: effects on morbidity, reproduction, and life shortening. The data sets were compiled on a simple ‘yes’ or ‘no’ basis. Each data set included dose rates at which effects were reported without further details about the size or peculiarity of the effects. In total, the data sets include 84 values for endpoint “morbidity”, 77 values for reproduction, and 41 values for life shortening. The dose rates in each set were ranked from low to higher values. The threshold TDR5 for radiation effects of a given umbrella type was estimated as a dose rate below which only a small percentage (5%) of data reported statistically significant radiation effects. The statistical treatment of the data sets was performed using non-parametric order statistics, and the bootstrap method. The resulting thresholds estimated by the order statistics are for morbidity effects 8.1 × 10−4 Gy day−1 (2.0 × 10−4–1.0 × 10−3), reproduction effects 6.0 × 10−4 Gy day−1 (4.0 × 10−4–1.5 × 10−3), and life shortening 3.0 × 10−3 Gy day−1 (1.0 × 10−3–6.0 × 10−3), respectively. The bootstrap method gave slightly lower values: 2.1 × 10−4 Gy day−1 (1.4 × 10−4–3.2 × 10−4) (morbidity), 4.1 × 10−4 Gy day−1 (3.0 × 10−4–5.7 × 10−4) (reproduction), and 1.1 × 10−3 Gy day−1 (7.9 × 10−4–1.3 × 10−3) (life shortening), respectively. The generic threshold dose rate (based on all umbrella types of effects) was estimated at 1.0 × 10−3 Gy day−1.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andersson P, Beaugelin-Seiller K, Beresford NA, Copplestone D, Della Vedova C, Garnier-Laplace J, Howard BJ, Howe P, Oughton DH, Wells C, Whitehouse P (2008) Numerical benchmarks for protecting biota from radiation in the environment: proposed levels, underlying reasoning and recommendations. PROTECT Deliverable 5. EC contract number: 036425 (FI6R)
Austin JW, Hupp EW (1969) Reproductivity of female Spanish goats exposed continuously to gamma-radiation. J Radiat Biol 15(4):363–368
Bazin H, Platteau B, Pinon-Lataillade G, Maas J (1986) Studies of long-term continuous irradiations using daily doses ranging from 0.07 to 0.3 Gy on the B lymphoid system of the rat. Int J Radiat Biol 49(3):433–447
BEIR III. Committee on Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation (1980) The effects on populations of exposure to low levels of ionizing radiation. United States National Academy of Sciences, National Research Council. National Academy Press, Washington
Belova NV, Verigin BV, Yemeljanova NG, Makeeva AP, Ryabov IN (1993) Radiobiological analysis of silver carp Hypophthalmichthys molitrix in the cooling pond of the Chernobyl NPP in the post-accidental period. I. The condition of the reproductive system of fish survived the accident. Voprosy Ihtiologii (Problems of Ichthyology) 33(6):814–828 (in Russian)
Beresford NA, Balonov M, Beaugelin-Seiller K, Brown J, Copplestone D, Hingston JL, Horyna J, Hosseini A, Howard BJ, Kamboj S, Nedveckaite T, Olyslaegers G, Sazykina T, Vives i Batlle J, Yankovich TL, Yu C (2008) An international comparison of models and approaches for the estimation of the radiological exposure of non-human biota. Appl Radiat Isot 66:1745–1749
Blaylock BG (1969) The fecundity of a Gambusia affinis affinis population exposed to chronic environmental radiation. Radiat Res 37:108–117
Blaylock BG, Trabalka JR (1978) Evaluating the effects of ionizing radiation on aquatic organisms. Adv Radiat Biol 7:103–152
Bonham K, Donaldson LR (1972) Sex ratios and retardation of gonadal development in chronically gamma-irradiated Chinook salmon smolts. Trans Am Fish Soc 101(3):428–434
Brown SO (1964) Effects of continuous low intensity radiation on successive generations of the albino rat. Genetics 50:1101–1113
Brown DG (1978) Physiological response to exercise of irradiated and non-irradiated Shetland ponies: a 5-year study. Am J Vet Res 5:645–652
Brown V, Templeton WL (1964) Resistance of fish embryos to chronic irradiation. Nature 203:1257–1259
Brown JE, Alfonso B, Avila R, Beresford NA, Copplestone D, Pröhl G, Ulanovsky A (2008) The ERICA tool. J Environ Radioact 99(9):1371–1383
Buech RR (1976) Avian nesting success under gamma radiation exposure. Auk 93:627–629
Burnazyan AI (ed) (1990) A review of studies and experience in eliminating consequences of the accidental contamination of the territory with uranium products. Energoatomizdat, Moscow, p 145 (in Russian)
Casarett GW (1970) Pathological changes after protracted exposure to low dose radiation. In: Fry RM, Graham D, Griem ML, Rust JH (eds) Late effects of radiation. Taylor and Francis, London, pp 85–100
Chapman PM, Caldwell RS, Chapman PF (1996) A warning: NOECs are inappropriate for regulatory use. Environ Toxicol Chem 15:77–79
Copplestone D, Hingston JL, Real A (2008) The development and purpose of the FREDERICA radiation effects database. J Environ Radioact 99(9):1456–1463
David HA (1981) Order statistics. Wiley, New York
Davidson AC, Hinkey DV (1997) Bootstrap methods and their application. University Press, Cambridge
DOE: US Department of Energy (2002) A graded approach for evaluating radiation doses to aquatic and terrestrial biota. DOE Technical Standard, DOE-STD-1153
Donaldson LR, Bonham K (1964) Effects of low-level chronic irradiation of Chinook and Coho salmon eggs and alevins. Trans Am Fish Soc 93:333–341
EC, European Commission (2003) Technical guidance document in support of Commission Directive 93/67/EEC on risk assessment for new notified substances and Commission Regulation (EC) N 1488/94 on risk assessment for existing substances. Office for Official Publication of the European Communities, Luxembourg
Erickson BH (1978) Effect of continuous gamma-radiation on the stem and differentiating spermatogonia of the adult rat. Mutat Res 52(1):117–128
Erickson BH, Martin PG (1984) Reproductive and genetic effects of continuous prenatal irradiation in the pig. Teratology 30:99–106
Ermokhin VY, Muntyan SP (1977) Some special features of biology of roach from a water body with the increased content of 90Sr and 137Cs. In: Radioecology of animals, Proceedings of the First USSR Conference. Nauka, Moscow, pp 76–78 (in Russian)
Fedorova NL, Markelov BA (1978) Functional activity of the testes of dogs exposed to chronic gamma irradiation over a 3-year course. Kosm Biol Aviakosm Med 12(1):42–47 (in Russian)
Forbes T, Forbes V (1993) A critique of the use of distribution-based extrapolation models in ecotoxicology. Funct Ecol 7:249–254
Forbes V, Calow P, Sibley R (2001) Are current species extrapolation models a good basis for ecological risk assessment? Environ Toxicol Chem 20:442–447
Fritz TE, Norris WP, Tolle DV, Seed TM, Poole CM, Lombard LS, Doyle DE (1978) Relationship of dose rate and total dose to responses of continuously irradiated beagles. In: Late biological effects of ionizing radiation. 2:71–82. IAEA, Vienna
Garnier-Laplace J, Gilek M, Sundell-Bergman S, Larsson C-M (2004) Assessing ecological effects of radionuclides and extrapolation gaps. J Radiol Protect 24:A139–A155
Garnier-Laplace J, Della-Vedova C, Gilbin R, Copplestone D, Hingston J, Ciffroy P (2006) First derivation of predicted-no-effect values for freshwater and terrestrial ecosystems exposed to radioactive substances. Environ Sci Technol 40:6498–6505
Greenwood LN, Knowles JF (1995) Effect of chronic irradiation on the humoral immune response of a marine fish, the eelpout (Zoarces viviparous L). J Radiat Biol 67:71–77
Grigoriev YG, Markelov BA, Popov VI, Akhunov AA, Tsessarskaya TP, Ilyukhin AV, Fedorova NL, Burkovskaya TE, Shafirkin AV (1972) Physiological and hematological effects of chronic irradiation. Life Sci Space Res 10:147–154
Grigoriev YG, Popov VI, Shafirkin AV et al (1986) Somatic effects of chronic gamma-irradiation. Energoatomizdat, Moscow (in Russian)
Guskova AK, Baisogolov GD (1971) Radiation sickness in man. Moscow, p 383 (in Russian). (English translation, USA, Washington, 1973.) Tech Inf Center
Hoekstra JA, van Ewijk PH (1993) Alternatives for the no-observed-effect level. Environ Toxicol Chem 12:187–194
Hupp EW (1976) Effects of continuous life-time irradiation of Spanish goats. In: Biological and environmental effects of low-level irradiation. IAEA, Vienna, pp 113–126
IAEA, International Atomic Energy Agency (1976) Effects of ionizing radiation on aquatic organisms and ecosystems. Technical Report Series, Vienna, N 172
IAEA, International Atomic Energy Agency (1979) Methodology for assessing impacts of radioactivity on aquatic organisms. Technical Report Series, Vienna, N 190
IAEA, International Atomic Energy Agency (1992) Effects of ionizing radiation on plants and animals at levels implied by current radiation protection standards. Technical Report Series, Vienna, N 332
Ilyenko AI (1967) On the biological effect of contamination of the soil surface with 90Sr on the population of short-tailed voles. In: Ecology of mammals and birds. Nauka, Moscow, pp 122–126 (in Russian)
Ilyenko AI (1974) Concentrating by animals of radioisotopes and their influence on the population. Nauka, Moscow, p 168 (in Russian)
Ilyenko AI, Krapivko TP (1989) Ecology of Animals in Radiation Biogeocenoses. Nauka, Moscow (in Russian)
Ilyenko AI, Krapivko TP, Mazheikite RB, Smirnova OV (1980) Investigation of the influence of contamination of the biogeocenosis with 90Sr on the population of wood mice. In: Problems and tasks of radioecology of animals. Nauka, Moscow, pp 97–120 (in Russian)
Jagoe RH, Newman MC (1997) Bootstrap estimation of community NOEC values. Ecotoxicology 6:293–306
Knowles JF (1999) Long-term irradiation of a marine fish, the plaice Pleuronectes platessa: an assessment of the effects on size and composition of the testes and of possible genotoxic changes in peripheral erythrocytes. Int J Radiat Biol 75(6):773–782
Korytny VS, Shvedov VL, Pryakhin YE (1996) Some quantitative relationships between major long-term effects and certain dosimetric parameters of exposure to 90Sr in rats. In: Chronic irradiation: risk of late effects. The Transactions of the first Int.Symp.,Chelyabinsk, 9–13 January 1995, IzdAT, Moscow 1:76–89 (in Russian)
Kozubov GM, Taskaev AI (eds) (1990) Radiation impact on the coniferous forests in the region of the accident on the Chernobyl atomic power station. Syktyvkar, Komi Scientific Center of the Academy of Sciences of USSR, Ural Branch, p 136 (in Russian)
Lebedeva NV (1994) Populations of great tit and pied flycatcher in the area of the Eastern-Ural radioactive pattern. Rep Acad Sci 335(4):535–537 (in Russian)
Leonard A, Delpoux M, Meyer R, Decat G, Leonard ED (1985) Effect of an enhanced natural radioactivity on mammal fertility. Sci Total Environ 45:535–550
Lorenz E (1950) Some biological effects of long continued irradiation. Am J Roentgenol Radium Ther 63(2):176–185
Lorenz E, Jacobson LO, Heston W, Shimkin M, Eschenbrenner AB, Deringer MK, Doniger J, Schweisthal R (1954) Effects of long-continued total-body gamma irradiation of mice, guinea pigs, and rabbits. III. Effects of life span, weight, blood picture and carcinogenesis and the role of intensity of radiation. In: Zirkle RE (ed) Biological effects of external X and gamma radiation. McGraw–Hill, New York, pp 24–248
Lunneborg C (2000) Data analysis for resampling: concepts and applications. Pacific Grove, Duxbury, USA
Maslova KI, Materij LD, Ermakova OV, Taskaev AI (1994) Atlas of pathological and morphological changes in tundra voles from the sites of local radioactive contamination. Nauka, St. Petersburg, p 192 (in Russian)
Mole RH (1957) Shortening of life by chronic irradiation: the experimental facts. Nature 80:456–460
Mooney C, Duval R (1993) Bootstrapping: a non-parametric approach to statistical inference. Sage, London
Moskalev YI, Streltsova VN (1964) The peculiarities of effects of chronic ionizing irradiation on animals. In: The basics of radiation biology, chap 7. Nauka, Moscow (in Russian)
Muramatsu S, Sugahara T, Tsuchiya T, Okazawa Y (1964) Effects of chronic low-dose irradiation for three successive generations on the breeding behavior of mice. Int J Radiat Biol 8(6):523–531
NCRP, National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (1991) Effects of ionizing radiation on aquatic organisms. NCRP Report 109, Bethesda, USA
Nilov VI, Fedoseenko VM, Shekhanova IA (1976) Eye-lesion of grass carp on chronic intake to the organism of 90Sr. Voprosi ihtiologii (Problems of Ichthyology) 16(5):937–942 (in Russian)
Norris WP, Tyler SA, Sacher GA (1976) An interspecies comparison of responses of mice and dogs to continuous 60Co γ irradiation. In: Biological and environmental effects of low-level irradiation. IAEA, Vienna, pp 113–126
Nothdurft W, Fliedner TM, Fritz TE, Seed TM (1995) Response of hemopoiesis in dogs to continuous low dose rate total body irradiation. Stem cells (Dayton, OH) Suppl 1:261–267
Orlov EV (1973) To the assessment of the effect of low doses of chronic radiation in aquarium experiments with Tilapia fish. In: Theoretical and practical aspects of the effect of low doses of ionizing radiation. Syktyvkar, USSR Academy of Sciences, pp 47–48 (in Russian)
Orlov EV (1974) Ecological-physiological aspect in experiments with chronic exposure of Tilapia fish to low doses in solutions of 90Sr. In: Trudy VNIRO (Transactions of the State Research Institute for Marine Fishery and Oceanography) 100:116–127 (in Russian)
Peshkov SP, Shekhanova IA, Romanov GN, Prister BS, Shein GP (1978) Biological characteristic of roach living in the water containing 90Sr and 137Cs. In: Problems of radioecology of cooling ponds of nuclear power plants. Transactions of the Institute of Ecology of Plants and Animals. Ural Scientific Center of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR 110:47–55 (in Russian)
Pinon-Lataillade G, Maas J (1985) Continuous gamma-irradiation of rats: dose–rate effect on loss and recovery of spermatogenesis. Strahlentherapie 161(7):421–426
Pitkyanen GB (1978) The effect of chronic exposure of pike (Esox lucius L.) on its reproductive function. In: Transactions of the Inst of Ecology of Plants and Animals. Ural Sc Center of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR, 114, Sverdlovsk (in Russian)
Plakhuta-Plakhutina GI (1978) Spermatogenesis in dogs during chronic gamma irradiation over years and in the aftereffect period. Kosm Biol Aviakosm Med 12(6):50–55 (in Russian)
Posthuma L, Suter GW, Traas T et al (2002) Species sensitivity distributions in ecotoxicology. Lewis, Boca Raton
Ryabtsev IA, Lebedeva NV (1999) Avian radioecology. BIOS, Rostov-on-Don (in Russian)
Sacher G, Grahn D, Fry R (1970) Epidemiological and cellular effects of chronic radiation exposure: a search for relationship. In: P Metalli (ed) First European symposium on late effects of radiation. Comitato Nazionale Energia Nucleare, Roma, pp 13–38
Savina EA, Iakovleva VI, Plakhuta-Plakutina GI (1976) Characteristics of morphological reactions in dog internal organs and endocrine glands during 6-year gamma irradiation. Kosm Biol Aviakosm Med 10(1):57–61
Sazykina TG (2005) A system of dose–effects relationships for the northern wildlife: radiation protection criteria. Radioprotection 40(S1):889–892
Sazykina TG, Kryshev AI (2003) EPIC database on the effects of chronic radiation in fish: Russian/FSU data. J Environ Radioact 68(1):65–87
Sazykina TG, Kryshev II (2006) Radiation effects in wild terrestrial vertebrates—the EPIC collection. J Environ Radioact 88(1):11–48
Shekhanova IA (1983) Radioecology of fish. Light and Food Industry, Moscow, p 208 (in Russian)
Shekhanova IA, Belmakov VS, Lapin VI (1969) The impact of 90Sr–90Y on mature loach, kept in solutions of different activity. Voprosi ihtiologii (Problems of ichtiology) 9(5):828–838 (in Russian)
Shekhanova IA, Orlov EV, Shleifer GS (1978) The problem of radioactive contamination of aquatic environment and its impact on fish. In: Transactions of the institute of ecology of plants and animals, Ural Scientific Center of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR, 110:27–39 (in Russian)
Shleifer GS, Shekhanova IA (1977) The influence of ionising radiation on some factors of fish immunity. In: Radioecology of animals. Proceedings of the first all-union conference. Nauka, Moscow, pp 93–94 (in Russian)
Shleifer GS, Shekhanova IA (1980) The impact of ionizing radiation on the immuno-physiological state of fish. In: Problems and tasks of animal radioecology. Nauka, Moscow, pp 35–43 (in Russian)
Smagin AI (1996) Radioecological features of the water body for waste storage from radiochemical plants and the state of the population of pike (Esox lucius) inhabiting it. Problemy Radiatsionnoy Bezopasnosti (Problems of Radiation Safety) 2:35–45 (in Russian)
Sokolov VE, Ryabov IN, Ryabtsev IA, Koulikov AO, Tikhomirov FA, Shcheglov AI, Shevchenko VA, Kryshev II, Sidorov VP, Taskaev AI, Kozubov GM, Testov BV, Materii LD (1994) Effects of radioactive contamination on the flora and fauna in the vicinity of the Chernobyl nuclear power plant. Physiology and General Biology Reviews, Harwood Academic Publishers 8, p 124
Spirin DA, Tarasov OV, Shein GP (1996) The current state of animal populations inhabiting the territory of the Eastern-Ural radioactive trace. Issues Radiat Saf 3:39–44
Storozhuk NG, Shekhanova IA (1977) Lipoperoxidation in the liver and muscles of carp yearlings on long-term living in the environment with the increased content of radionuclides. In: Radioecology of animals. Proceedings of the first all-union conference. Nauka, Moscow, pp 89–91. (in Russian)
Thomson JF, Williamson FS, Grahn D (1981) Life shortening in mice exposed to fission neutrons and gamma rays. II. Duration of life and long-term fractionated exposures. Radiat Res 86:573–579
Trabalka JR, Allen CP (1977) Aspects of fitness of a mosquitofish Gambusia affinis population exposed to chronic low-level environmental radiation. Radiat Res 70:198–211
Turner FB (1975) Effects of continuous irradiation on animal populations. Adv Radiat Biol 5:83–144
UNSCEAR, United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (1982) Ionizing radiation: sources and biological effects. Report to the General Assembly. Annex K. Radiation-induced life shortening, New York
UNSCEAR, United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (1996) Effects of radiation on the environment, annex to sources and effects of ionizing radiation (Report to the General Assembly, with one annex). New York
Van der Hoeven N (2001) Estimating the 5-percentile of the species sensitivity distributions without any assumptions about the distribution. Ecotoxicology (10):25–34
Van der Hoeven N (2004) Current issues in statistics and models for ecotoxicological risk assessment. Acta Biotheor 52:201–217
Vives i Batlle J, Balonov M, Beaugelin-Seiller K, Beresford NA, Brown J, Cheng JJ, Copplestone D, Doi M, Filistovic V, Golikov V, Horyna J, Hosseini A, Howard BJ, Jones SR, Kamboj S, Kryshev A, Nedveckaite T, Olyslaegers G, Pröhl G, Sazykina T, Ulanovsky A, Vives Lynch S, Yankovich T, Yu C (2007) Intercomparison of unweighted absorbed dose rates for non-human biota. Radiat Environ Biophys 46:349–373
Voronina EA, Peshkov SP, Shekhanova IA (1974) Growth rate and fertility of fish living in the media with enhanced level of radiation. In: Trudy VNIRO, Transactions of the State Research Institute for Marine Fishery and Oceanography, 100:74–79 (in Russian)
Acknowledgments
This work was performed within the framework of the Norwegian Research Council Project “Impact Assessment of elevated levels of natural/technogenic radioactivity on wildlife of the North” (INTRANOR), leading by the Norwegian Radiation Protection Authority, whose support and useful discussions are gratefully acknowledged.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sazykina, T.G., Kryshev, A.I. & Sanina, K.D. Non-parametric estimation of thresholds for radiation effects in vertebrate species under chronic low-LET exposures. Radiat Environ Biophys 48, 391–404 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00411-009-0233-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00411-009-0233-0