Abstract
The widely accepted supposition that Newton’s De gravitatione was written in 1684/5 just before composing the Principia is examined. The basis for this determination has serious difficulties starting with the failure to examine the numerical estimates for the resistance of aether. The estimated range is not nearly nil as claimed but comparable with air at or near the earth’s surface. Moreover, the evidence provided most likely stems from experiments by Boyle, Hooke, and others in the 1660s and does not use evidence available in the late 1684. The document supports Newton’s contention that the aether medium incorporates very large voids thereby proving that body and space differ but does by no means completely reject its corporeal nature or eliminate its resistance. Newton’s use of the term inertia provides no conclusive evidence for a late date as often claimed and his definition of gravitas is difficult to reconcile with a late one.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ball , Rouse W.W. (1893) An essay on Newton’s “Principia”. Macmillan, London
Marie-Francoise Biarnais. (1985) De la gravitation ou les fondements de la méchanique classique. La Belles Lettres, Paris
Robert Boyle. (1662) New experiments physico-mechanicall 2nd ed. H Hall for Tho Robinson, Oxford
Cambridge University Library (CUL) Ms. Add. 3965.12, ff. 175r–176v.
Cambridge University Library (CUL) Ms. Add. 4004, Newton’s “Waste Book.”
Cohen, I. Bernard. (1971) Introduction to Newton’s Principia. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Cohen, I. Bernard. (1980) The Newtonian revolution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Rene Descartes. (1668) Renati Descartes epistolae. John Dunmore and Octavian Pulleyn, London
Descartes, Rene. 1985–1991. The philosophical writings of Descartes, trans. J. Cottingham, R. Stoothoff, and D. Murdoch, 3 vols. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Betty Jo Teeter Dobbs. (1982) Newton’s alchemy and his theory of matter. Isis 73: 511–528
Dobbs, Betty Jo Teeter. 1988. Newton’s rejection of the mechanical aether: empirical difficulties and guiding assumptions. In Scrutinizing science: Empirical studies of scientific change, ed. Arthur Donovan, Larry Laudan, and Rachel Laudan, 69–83. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
BettyJoTeeter Dobbs. (1991) The Janus face of genius, the role of alchemy in Newton’s thought. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Mordechai Feingold. (2004) The Newtonian moment, Isaac Newton and the making of modern culture. Oxford University Press in association with the New York Public Library, New York
Forbes , Eric G. (1975) The Gresham lectures of John Flamsteed. Mansell, London
Alan Gabbey. (1971) Force and inertia in Seventeenth-Century dynamics. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 2: 1–67
Gabbey, Alan. 2002. Newton, active powers, and the mechanical philosophy. In The Cambridge companion to Newton, ed. I. Bernard Cohen and George E. Smith, 329–357. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Stephen Graukroger. (2002) Descartes’ system of natural philosophy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Gunther, R.T. 1967–1968. Early science in Oxford, 15 vols. London: Dawsons of Pall Mall.
SirMatthew Hale. (1673) An essay touching the gravitation and non-gravitation of bodies, and the reasons thereof. W. Godbid, London
Hall , Rupert A. (2002) Pitfalls in the editing of Newton’s papers. History of Science 40: 407–424
Hall, A. Rupert, and Marie B. Hall. 1962. Unpublished scientific papers of Isaac Newton. Cambridge at the University Press.
John Henry. (2011) Gravity and De Gravitatione: the development of Newton’s ideas on action at a distance. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 42: 11–27
John Herivel. (1965) The background to Newton’s Principia. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Johannes Hevelius. (1668) Cometographia. Gedani, S. Reiniger
Hooke, Robert. 1665. Micrographia. London: J. Martyn and J. Allestry.
Iliffe, Rob. 1994. ‘Making a shew’: Apocalyptic hermeneutics and the sociology of Christian idolatry in the work of Isaac Newton and Henry Moore. In The books of nature and scripture, ed. James E. Force and H. Popkin. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Press.
Iliffe, Rob. 1995. Is he like other men? The meaning of the Principia Mathematica, and the author as idol. In Culture and Society in the Stuart Restoration, ed. G. Maclean, 159–176. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rob Iliffe. (2007) Newton: a very short introduction. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Nicholas Kollerstrom. (1999) The path of Halley’s comet, and Newton’s late apprehension of the law of gravity. Annals of Science 56: 331–356
Alexandre Koyré. (1965) Newtonian Studies. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
John Lohne. (1960) Hooke versus Newton. Centaurus 7: 6–52
McGuire J.E. (1968) Force, active principle, and Newton’s invisible realm. Ambix 15: 154–208
McGuire, J.E. 2000. The fate of the date: The theology of Newton’s Principia revisited. In Rethinking the scientific revolution, ed. Margaret J. Osler. Cambridge University, Cambridge Press.
McGuire J.E., Tamny Martin (1983) Certain philosophical questions: Newton’s trinity notebook. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Miller , Rodger Valentine, Miller Reese P. (1991) Rene Descartes: Principles of philosophy. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht
More, Henry. 1676. Remarks upon two late ingenious discourses: The one touching the gravitation and non-gravitation of fluid bodies: The other, observations touching the Torricellian experiment so far as they may concern any passages in his Enchiridium metaphysicum. London: Walter Kettilby.
Newton Project. http://www.newtonproject.sussex.ac.uk.
Newton Project. THEM00093. De gravitatione.
Newton Project. THEM00002. Theological notebooks parts 1 and 2.
Newton Project. THEM00060. Notes and drafts related to Theologiae gentilis origines philosophicae.
Newton, Isaac. 1667. Principia Naturalis Principia Mathematics. London: Jussu Societatis Regiae ac Typis Joseph Streater (facsimile reprint, London, Wm. Dawson, n. d.) and Newton Project NATP00071 (excludes Book 3).
Isaac Newton. (1952) Opticks. Dover Publications, New York
Newton, Isaac. 1958. Isaac Newtojn’s papers & letters of natural philosophy, ed. I.B. Cohen. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Isaac Newton. (1960) Sir Isaac Newton’s mathematical principles of natural philosophy and his system of the world, trans. University of California Press, Florian Cajori. Berkeley
Newton, Isaac. 1962a. The lawes of motion (CUL Ms. Add. 3958, ff. 81r–83v). In Hall and Hall (1962): 157–164 and Newton Project NATP00105.
Newton, Isaac. 1962b. De gravitatione et aequipondio fluidorum (CUL Ms. Add. 4003). In A.R Hall and M.B. Hall (1962): 89–156 and Newton Project THEM00093.
Newton, Isaac. 1962c. De aere et aethere (CUL Ms. Add. 3970, ff. 652-3). In Hall and Hall (1962): 214–228.
Newton, Isaac. 1962d. De motu corporum (CUL Ms. Add. 3965.5a, f. 21). In Hall and Hall (1962): 239–242.
Newton, Isaac. 1962e. De motu sphaericorum corporum in fluidis (CUL Ms. Add 3965.5a, ff. 40-54). In Hall and Hall (1962): 239–292 and Newton Project NATP0090.
Newton, Isaac. 1965a. Extracts from Ms. Add 4003. In Herivel (1965): 219–235.
Newton, Isaac. 1965b. De motu corporum in gyrum (CUL Ms. Add. 3965.7, ff. 55-62v). In Herivel (1965): 257–292 and Newton Project NATP00089.
Newton, Isaac. 1965c. De motu corporum in medijs regularitar cedentibus (CUL 3965.5a, ff. 25r, 26r, 23r, 24r). In Herivel (1965): 304–315, Math. Papers, 6: 188–193, and Newton Project NATP00091.
Newton, Isaac. 1972. Isaac Newton’s Philosophiae naturalis Principia mathematica, the third edition (1726) with variant readings, ed. A. Koyré, I.B. Cohen, and A. Whitman, 2 vols. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Newton, Isaac. 1985. De la Gravitation. In Biarnais (1985).
Newton, Isaac. 1988. Über die Gravitation . . . Texte zu den philophischen Grundlagen der klassichen Mechanik. Text lateinisch.-deutsch. Übersetzt und erlautert von Gernot Böhme, Frankfurt/M, Vittorio Klostermann.
Newton, Isaac. 1999. The principia, mathematical principles of natural philosophy, trans. I.B. Cohen and A. Whitman with A guide to Newton’s Principia, by I.B. Cohen. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Newton, Isaac. 2004. De gravitatione. In Philosophical writings, ed. Andrew Janiak. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Robert Palter. (1987) Saving Newton’s text: Documents, readers, and the way of the world. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 17: 385–439
Ruffner J.A. (2000) Newton’s Propositions on comets: Steps in transition, 1681–84. Archive for History of Exact Sciences 54: 259–277
Ruffner J.A. (2010) Isaac Newton’s Historia Cometarum and the quest for elliptical orbits. Journal for the History of Astronomy 41: 426–451
Schaeffer, Simon. 1993. Comets & idols: Newton’s cosmology and political theology. In Action and reaction, ed. P. Theerman and A. F. Seef, 183–231. Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Presses.
Shapiro Alan E. (1974) Light, pressure, and rectilinear propagation: Descartes’ celestial optics and Newton’s hydrostatics. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 5: 239–296
Smith, George 2000. Fluid resistance: why did Newton change his mind?. In The foundations of Newtonian scholarship, ed. Richard H. Dalitz and Michael Nauenberg, 105–136. Singapore: World Scientific.
Howard Stein. (1967) Newtonian space-time. Texas Quarterly 10: 174–200
Stein, Howard. 1970. On the notion of field in Newton, Maxwell, and beyond. In Minnesota studies in the philosophy of science V, historical and philosophical perspectives of science, ed. Roger H. Stuewer, 264–310. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Stein, Howard. 2002. Newton’s metaphysics. In The Cambridge companion to Newton, ed. I. Bernard Cohen and George E. Smith, 298–299 note 27, 302–303 note 39. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Steinle, Friedrich. 1991. Isaac Newton’s Entwurf Über die Gravitation . . . : ein Stuck Entwicklungsgeschichte seiner Mechanik. Stuttgart: Steiner.
Thomas Streete. (1661) Astronomia Carolina. Lodowick Lloyd, London
Turnbull, H.W., et al., eds. 1969–1977. The Correspondence of Isaac Newton, 7 vols. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Westfall, Richard S. 1971a. Stages in the development of Newton’s dynamics. In Perspectives in the history of science and technology, ed. Duane H.D. Roller, 177–197. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
Westfall, Richard S. 1971b. Force in Newton’s physics, the science of dynamics in the seventeenth century. London: Macdonald.
Westfall, Richard S. 1975. The role of alchemy in Newton’s career. In Reason, experimentation and mysticism in the Scientific Revolution, ed. M.L. Righini Bonelli and William R. Shea, 189–232. New York: Science History Publications.
Westfall RichardS. (1980) Never at Rest a Biography of Isaac Newton. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Whiteside D.T. (1964) Newton’s early thoughts on planetary motion: A fresh look. British Journal for the History of Science 2: 117–137
Whiteside D.T. (1970) Before the Principia: The maturing of Newton’s thoughts on dynamical astronomy, 1664–1684. Journal for the History of Astronomy 1: 5–19
Whiteside, D.T., ed. 1972–1980. The mathematical papers of Isaac Newton, 8 vols. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Whiteside D.T. (1991) The prehistory of the Principia. Notes and Records of the Royal Society 45: 11–61
Curtis Wilson. (1969) From Kepler’s Laws, so called, to Universal Gravitation: Empirical factors. Archive for History of Exact Sciences 6: 89–170
Vincent Wing. (1669) Astronomica Britannica. John Macock, London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by: Niccolò Guicciardini.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ruffner, J.A. Newton’s De gravitatione: a review and reassessment. Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 66, 241–264 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00407-012-0093-x
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00407-012-0093-x