Midshaft fractures of the clavicle with a shortening of more than 2 cm predispose to nonunion

Abstract

Up to 15% of all fractures involve the clavicle. Nonunion of the clavicle is a rare complication after conservative treatment. It mainly presents as pain at the fracture site and a limited range of motion of the shoulder. The purpose of this study is to define a certain type of fracture of the clavicle that is predisposed to malunion and therefore should be treated surgically after failure of conservative treatment. Thirty-nine patients with delayed or malunion of the clavicle were analyzed. There were 13 women and 26 men. The average age of the male patients was 36.4 years (range 20–59 years) and of the female patients, 43.6 years (range 18–55 years). The mean follow-up period was 2.3 years (range 6 months to 4.2 years). All of them were treated surgically. There were 33 Allman I fractures and 6 Allman II fractures. Of the Allman I fractures, 30 (91%) were shortened by at least 2 cm. Allman I fractures were treated using a reconstruction plate or a dynamic compression plate in combination with bone grafting. The time of operation after fracture ranged from 6 weeks to 8.5 years (average 9.8 months). Pain at the fracture site was the leading symptom in all patients. At 6 months after the operation, 38 patients were free of pain with an unlimited range of motion of the shoulder. One patient (2.6%) complained of a slight weakness on the operated site. One fracture failed to unite (2.6%) and had to be replated. There were no refractures, infections, vessel or nerve lesions. To conclude, in Allman I fractures with a shortening of more than 2 cm, we recommend operative treatment in symptomatic patients if there are no signs of callus formation after 6 weeks.