Abstract
Coral reef conservation strategies such as marine protected areas have met limited success in many developing countries. Some researchers attribute part of these shortcomings to inadequate attention to the social context of conserving marine resources. To gain insights into applying Western conservation theory more successfully in the socioeconomic context of developing countries, this study examines how long-enduring, customary reef closures appear to reflect local socioeconomic conditions in two Papua New Guinean communities. Attributes of the customary management (including size, shape, permanence, and gear restrictions) are examined in relation to prevailing socioeconomic conditions (including resource users’ ability to switch gears, fishing grounds, and occupations). Customary closures in the two communities appear to reflect local socioeconomic circumstances in three ways. First, in situations where people can readily switch between occupations, full closures are acceptable with periodic harvests to benefit from the closure. In comparison, communities with high dependence on the marine resources are more conducive to employing strategies that restrict certain gear types while still allowing others. Second, where there is multiple clan and family spatial ownership of resources, the communities have one closure per clan/family; one large no-take area would have disproportionate affect on those compared to the rest of the community. In contrast, communities that have joint ownership can establish one large closure as long as there are other areas available to harvest. Third, historical and trade relationships with neighboring communities can influence regulations by creating the need for occasional harvests to provide fish for feasts. This study further demonstrates the importance of understanding the socioeconomic context of factors such as community governance and levels of dependence for the conservation of marine resources.
References
Agardy T (1997) Marine protected areas and ocean conservation. R.G. Landes, Academic, Austin
Agardy T (2000) Information needs for marine protected areas: scientific and social. Bull Mar Sci 66:875–888
Agrawal A (2001) Common property institutions and sustainable governance of resources. World Dev 29:1649–1672
Agrawal A (2002) Common resources and institutional stability. In: Ostrom E, Dietz T, Dolsak N, Stern P, Stonich S, Weber E (eds) The drama of the commons. National Academies, Washington, pp 293–321
Alvard M (1995) Intraspecific prey choice by Amazon hunters. Curr Anthropol 36:789–818
Alvard M (1998) Indigenous hunting in the neotropics: conservation or optimal foraging? In: Caro TM (ed) Behavioral ecology and conservation biology. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 474–500
Asafu-Adjaye J (2000) Customary marine tenure systems and sustainable fisheries management in Papua New Guinea. Int J Soc Econ 27:917–926
Aswani S (1998) Patterns of marine harvest effort in SW New Georgia, Solomon Islands: resource management or optimal foraging? Ocean Coast Manage 40:207–235
Aswani S (1999) Common property models of sea tenure: a case study from the Roviana and Vonavona Lagoons, New Georgia, Solomon Islands. Hum Ecol 27:417–453
Aswani S, Hamilton RJ (2004) Integrating indigenous ecological knowledge and customary sea tenure with marine science and social science for conservation of bumphead parrotfish (Bolbometopon muricatum) in the Roviana Lagoon, Solomon Islands. Environ Conserv 31:69–83
Aswani S, Weiant P (2004) Scientific evaluation in women’s participatory management: monitoring marine invertebrate refugia in the Solomon Islands. Hum Organ 63:301–319
Becker C, Ostrom E (1995) Human ecology and resource sustainability: the importance of institutional diversity. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 26:113–133
Becker CD, Ghimire K (2003) Synergy between traditional ecological knowledge and conservation science supports forest preservation in Ecuador. Conserv Ecol 8. URL: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol8/iss1/art1/
Berkes F (1989) Cooperation from the perspective of human ecology. In: Berkes F (ed) Common property resources: ecology and community-based sustainable development. Belhaven, London, pp 70–88
Berkes F, Colding J, Folke C (2000) Rediscovery of traditional ecological knowledge as adaptive management. Ecol Appl 10:1251–1262
Bunce L, Townsley P, Pomeroy RS, Pollnac RB (2000) Socioeconomic manual for coral reef management. Australian Institute of Marine Science, Townsville
Carrier J (1982) Conservation and conceptions of the environment: a Manus Province case study. In: Morauta L, Pernetta J, Heaney (eds) Traditional conservation in Papua New Guinea: implications for today. Institute of Applied Social and Economic Research, Boroko, pp 39–43
Carrier J (1987) Marine tenure and conservation in Papua New Guinea. In: McCay B, Acheson J (eds) The question of the commons: the culture and ecology of common resources. University of Arizona Press, Tucson, pp 143–167
Carrier J, Carrier A (1989a) Marine tenure and economic reward on Ponham Island, Manus Province. In: Cordell J (ed) A sea of small boats. Cultural Survival, Cambridge, pp 60–93
Carrier J, Carrier A (1989b) Wage, trade, and exchange in Melanesia: a Manus society in the modern state. University of California Press, Berkeley
Christie P (2004) MPAs as biological successes and social failures in Southeast Asia. In: Shipley JB (ed) Aquatic protected areas as fisheries management tools: design, use, and evaluation of these fully protected areas. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, p 275
Christie P, McCay BJ, Miller ML, Lowe C, White AT, Stoffle R, Fluharty DL, McManus LT, Chuenpagdee R, Pomeroy C, Suman DO, Blount BG, Huppert D, Eisma RLV, Oracion E, Lowry K, Pollnac RB (2003) Toward developing a complete understanding: a social science research agenda for marine protected areas. Fisheries 28:22–26
Cinner J (2005a) Socioeconomic factors influencing customary marine tenure in the Indo-Pacific. Ecol Soc 10, p 36. URL: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol10/iss1/art36/
Cinner J (2005b) The role of socioeconomic factors in customary coral reef management in Papua New Guinea. PhD Thesis, James Cook University, p 221
Cinner J, McClanahan TR (2006) Socioeconomic factors that lead to overfishing in a small-scale coral reef fishery of Papua New Guinea. Environ Conserv 33:1–8
Cinner J, Marnane MJ, McClanahan TR (2005a) Conservation and community benefits from traditional coral reef management at Ahus Island, Papua New Guinea. Conserv Biol 19:1714–1723
Cinner J, Marnane MJ, McClanahan TR, Clark TH, Ben J (2005b) Trade, tenure, and tradition: influence of sociocultural factors on resource use in Melanesia. Conserv Biol 19:1469–1477
Cinner J, Marnane MJ, McClanahan TR, Almany G (2006) Periodic closures as adaptive coral reef management in the Indo-Pacific. Ecol Soc 11, p 31. URL: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol11/iss1/art31/
Colding J, Folke C (2001) Social taboos “invisible” systems of local resource management and biological conservation. Ecol Appl 11:584–600
Crawford BR, Siahainenia A, Rotinsulu C, Sukmara A (2004) Compliance and enforcement of community-based coastal resource management regulations in North Sulawesi, Indonesia. Coast Manage 32:39–50
Dahlgren CP, Sobel J (2000) Designing a Dry Tortugas ecological reserve: how big is big enough? To do what? Bull Mar Sci 66:707–719
Dietz T, Ostrom E, Stern P (2003) The struggle to govern the commons. Science 302:1907–1912
Evans SM, Gill ME, Retraubun ASW, Abrahamz J, Dangeubun J (1997) Traditional management practices and the conservation of the gastropod (Trochus nilitocus) and fish stocks in the Maluku Province (eastern Indonesia). Fish Res 31:83–91
Fiske S (1992) Sociocultural aspects of establishing marine protected areas. Ocean Coast Manage 17:25–46
Halpern BS (2003) The impact of marine reserves: do reserves work and does reserve size matter? Ecol Appl 13:S117–S137
Henry GT (1990) Practical sampling. Sage, Newbury Park
Hughes TP, Baird AH, Bellwood DR, Card M, Connolly SR, Folke C, Grosberg R, Hoegh-Guldberg O, Jackson JBC, Kleypas J, Lough JM, Marshall P, Nystrom M, Palumbi S, Pandolfi JM, Rosen B, Rougharden J (2003) Climate change, human impacts, and the resilience of coral reefs. Science 301:929–933
Hviding E (1996) Guardians of the Marovo Lagoon: practice, place, and politics in maritime Melanesia. University Press of Hawai’i, Honolulu
Johannes RE (2002) The renaissance of community-based marine resource management in Oceania. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 33:317–340
Lise W (2000) Factors influencing people’s participation in forest management in India. Ecol Econ 34:379–392
McClanahan T (1999) Is there a future for coral reef parks in poor tropical countries. Coral Reefs 18:321–325
McClanahan TR (2002) The near future of coral reefs. Environ Conserv 29:460–483
McClanahan T, Glaesel H, Rubens J, Kiambo R (1997) The effects of traditional fisheries management on fisheries yields and the coral-reef ecosystems of southern Kenya. Environ Conserv 24:105–120
McClanahan T, Marnane M, Cinner J, Clark T, Kiene W (2006) A comparison of marine protected areas and alternative approaches to coral reef conservation. Curr Biol 16:1408–1413
Neitschmann B (1985) Torres Strait Islander sea resource management and sea rights. In: Ruddle K, Johannes RE (eds) The traditional knowledge and management of coastal systems in Asia and the Pacific. UNESCO, Jakarta Pusat, pp 53–77
Ostrom E (1990) Governing the commons: the evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Pearce J (2002) The future of fisheries—marine protected areas—a new way forward or another management glitch? Mar Pollut Bull 44:89–91
Pollnac RB (1998) Rapid assessment of management parameters for coral reefs. Coastal Resources Center, University of Rhode Island, Narragansett
Pollnac RB, Crawford B (2000) Assessing behavioural aspects of coastal resource use. Coastal Resources Center, University of Rhode Island, Narragansett
Pollnac RB, Crawford BR, Gorospe M (2001) Discovering factors that influence the success of community-based marine protected areas in the Visayas, Philippines. Ocean Coast Manage 44:683–710
Polunin NVC (1984) Do traditional marine “reserves” conserve? A view of Indonesian and New Guinean evidence. In: Ruddle K, Akimichi T (eds) Maritime institutions in the Western Pacific. National Museum of Ethnology, Osaka, pp 267–284
Pretty J (2003) Social capital and the collective management of resources. Science 302:1912–1914
Ravuvu AD (1983) Vaki i Takui. The Fijian way of life. University of the South Pacific, Suva
Roberts CM, Polunin NVC (1991) Are marine reserves effective in management of reef fisheries? Rev Fish Biol Fish 1:65–91
Roberts CM, Andelman S, Branch G, Bustamante RH, Castilla JC, Dugan J, Halpern BS, Lafferty KD, Leslie H, Lubchenco J, McArdle D, Possingham HP, Ruckelshaus M, Warner RR (2003) Ecological criteria for evaluating candidate sites for marine reserves. Ecol Appl 13:S199–S214
Ruddle K (1995) A guide to the literature on traditional community-based fishery management in Fiji. Secretariat of the Pacific Community Traditional Marine Resource Management Knowledge Information Bulletin 5:7–15 (http://www.spc.int/coastfish/)
Ruttan LM (1998) Closing the commons: cooperation for gain or restraint? Hum Ecol 26:43–66
Ruttan LM, Borgerhoff Mulder M (1999) Are east African pastoralists truly conservationists? Curr Anthropol 40:621–652
Sale PF, Cowen RK, Danilowiz BS, Jones JP, Kritzer JP, Lindeman KC, Planes S, Polunin NVC, Russ GR, Sadovy YJ, Steneck RS (2005) Critical science gaps impede use of no-take fishery reserves. Trends Ecol Evol 20:74–80
Scheaffer RL, Mendenhall WI, Ott L (1996) Elementary survey sampling. Wadsworth, Belmont
Sladek Nowlis J, Roberts CM (1999) Fisheries benefits and optimal design of marine reserves. Fish Bull 97:604–616
Smith E, Wishnie M (2000) Conservation and subsistence in small-scale societies. Annu Rev Anthropol 29:493–524
Sutinen JG, Kuperan K (1999) A socio-economic theory of regulatory compliance. Inter J Soc Econ 26:174–193
White AT, Courtney CA, Salamanca A (2002) Experience with marine protected area planning and management in the Philippines. Coast Manage 30:1–26
Willis TJ, Millar RB, Babcock RC, Tolimieri N (2003) Burdens of evidence and the benefits of marine reserves: putting Descartes before des horse? Environ Conserv 30:97–103
Wright A (1985) Marine resource use in Papua New Guinea: can traditional concepts and contemporary development be integrated? In: Ruddle K, Johannes RE (eds) The traditional knowledge and management of coastal systems in Asia and the Pacific. UNESCO, Jakarta Pusat, pp 53–77
Zanetell BA, Knuth BA (2004) Participation rhetoric or community-based management reality? Influences on willingness to participate in a Venezuelan freshwater fishery. World Dev 32:793–807
Acknowledgments
I thank the people of Ahus and Muluk Villages, John Ben, the Manus and Madang Provincial Governments, the PNG Department of Environment and Conservation, the National Fisheries Authority, the University of PNG, T. Poluma, H. Malai, Francis. Thanks to D. Feary and T. Hughes for providing comments on drafts of this manuscript. This work was supported by the David and Lucile Packard Foundation through a grant to the Wildlife Conservation Society.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by Guest Editor R. Pollnac.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cinner, J.E. Designing marine reserves to reflect local socioeconomic conditions: lessons from long-enduring customary management systems. Coral Reefs 26, 1035–1045 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00338-007-0213-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00338-007-0213-2