Abstract
Objectives
To describe carotid plaque composition by computed tomography angiography (CTA) in asymptomatic subjects and to compare this to carotid plaque assessment by ultrasound, coronary plaques by coronary CTA, and inflammatory biomarkers in plasma.
Methods
Middle-aged asymptomatic men, n = 43, without known cardiovascular disease and diabetes were included. Plaques in coronary and carotid arteries were evaluated using CTA. Total plaque volumes and plaque composition were assessed by a validated plaque analysis software. The 60% centile cut point was used to divide the population into low or high carotid total plaque volumes. The occurrence of carotid plaques and intima-media thickness (IMT) was estimated by ultrasound.
Results
Carotid plaque by ultrasound was undiagnosed in 13 of 28 participants (46%) compared to CTA. Participants having carotid plaques by ultrasound had significantly higher absolute volumes of all CTA-defined carotid plaque subtypes and a higher fraction of calcified plaque. A high carotid total plaque volume was independently associated with age (adjusted odds ratio (OR) 1.41 [95% confidence interval (CI) 1.14–1.74], p = 0.001), IMT (adjusted OR 2.26 [95% CI 1.10–4.65], p = 0.03), and D-dimer (adjusted OR 8.86 [95% CI 1.26–62.37], p = 0.03). All coronary plaque features were significantly higher in participants with a high carotid total plaque volume.
Conclusion
The occurrence of carotid plaques in asymptomatic individuals is underestimated by ultrasound compared to plaque assessment by CTA. Carotid plaque composition by CTA is different in individuals with and without carotid plaques by ultrasound.
Key Points
• The occurrence of carotid plaques by ultrasound was underestimated in 46% of participants who had plaques by carotid CTA.
• Participants with carotid plaques by ultrasound had higher volumes of all plaque subtypes and a higher calcified plaque component as determined by carotid CTA compared to participants without carotid plaques by ultrasound.
• A high carotid total plaque volume was independently associated with age, intima-media thickness, and D-dimer.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- Ag:
-
Agatston score
- BMI:
-
Body mass index
- CAC:
-
Coronary artery calcification
- CRP:
-
C-reactive protein
- CT:
-
Computed tomography
- CTA:
-
Computed tomography angiography
- CVD:
-
Cardiovascular disease
- HDL:
-
High-density lipoprotein
- IMT:
-
Intima-media thickness
- IQR:
-
Interquartile range
- LDL:
-
Low-density lipoprotein
- LD-NCP vol.:
-
Low-density non-calcified plaque volume
- MRI:
-
Magnetic resonance imaging
- NCP vol.:
-
Non-calcified plaque volume
- SD:
-
Standard deviation
- TPV:
-
Total plaque volume
References
Donnan GA, Fisher M, Macleod M, Davis SM (2008) Stroke. Lancet 371:1612–1623
Brinjikji W, Rabinstein AA, Lanzino G et al (2015) Ultrasound characteristics of symptomatic carotid plaques: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Cerebrovasc Dis 40:165–174
van Lammeren GW, den Hartog AG, Pasterkamp G et al (2012) Asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis: identification of subgroups with different underlying plaque characteristics. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 43:632–636
Eliasziw M, Rankin RN, Fox AJ, Haynes RB, Barnett HJ (1995) Accuracy and prognostic consequences of ultrasonography in identifying severe carotid artery stenosis. North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial (NASCET) Group. Stroke 26:1747–1752
O'Leary DH, Holen J, Ricotta JJ, Roe S, Schenk EA (1987) Carotid bifurcation disease: prediction of ulceration with B-mode US. Radiology 162:523–525
Rafailidis V, Chryssogonidis I, Tegos T, Kouskouras K, Charitanti-Kouridou A (2017) Imaging of the ulcerated carotid atherosclerotic plaque: a review of the literature. Insights Imaging 8:213–225
Mono ML, Karameshev A, Slotboom J et al (2012) Plaque characteristics of asymptomatic carotid stenosis and risk of stroke. Cerebrovasc Dis 34:343–350
van den Bouwhuijsen QJ, Bos D, Ikram MA et al (2015) Coexistence of calcification, intraplaque hemorrhage and lipid core within the asymptomatic atherosclerotic carotid plaque: the Rotterdam study. Cerebrovasc Dis 39:319–324
de Weert TT, Cretier S, Groen HC et al (2009) Atherosclerotic plaque surface morphology in the carotid bifurcation assessed with multidetector computed tomography angiography. Stroke 40:1334–1340
Homburg PJ, Rozie S, van Gils MJ et al (2011) Association between carotid artery plaque ulceration and plaque composition evaluated with multidetector CT angiography. Stroke 42:367–372
Hatsukami TS, Ferguson MS, Beach KW et al (1997) Carotid plaque morphology and clinical events. Stroke 28:95–100
ten Kate GL, van Dijk AC, van den Oord SC et al (2013) Usefulness of contrast-enhanced ultrasound for detection of carotid plaque ulceration in patients with symptomatic carotid atherosclerosis. Am J Cardiol 112:292–298
Dey D, Schepis T, Marwan M, Slomka PJ, Berman DS, Achenbach S (2010) Automated three-dimensional quantification of noncalcified coronary plaque from coronary CT angiography: comparison with intravascular US. Radiology 257:516–522
Christiansen MK, Jensen JM, Norgaard BL, Dey D, Botker HE, Jensen HK (2017) Coronary plaque burden and adverse plaque characteristics are increased in healthy relatives of patients with early onset coronary artery disease. JACC Cardiovasc Imaging 10:1128–1135
Gaur S, Ovrehus KA, Dey D et al (2016) Coronary plaque quantification and fractional flow reserve by coronary computed tomography angiography identify ischaemia-causing lesions. Eur Heart J 37:1220–1227
Mrgan M, Funck KL, Gaur S et al (2017) High burden of coronary atherosclerosis in patients with a new diagnosis of type 2 diabetes. Diab Vasc Dis Res 14:468–476
Hell MM, Motwani M, Otaki Y et al (2017) Quantitative global plaque characteristics from coronary computed tomography angiography for the prediction of future cardiac mortality during long-term follow-up. Eur Heart J Cardiovasc Imaging 18:1331–1339
Motoyama S, Sarai M, Harigaya H et al (2009) Computed tomographic angiography characteristics of atherosclerotic plaques subsequently resulting in acute coronary syndrome. J Am Coll Cardiol 54:49–57
Motoyama S, Ito H, Sarai M et al (2015) Plaque characterization by coronary computed tomography angiography and the likelihood of acute coronary events in mid-term follow-up. J Am Coll Cardiol 66:337–346
Ramanathan R, Gram JB, Sand NPR et al (2017) Factor VII-activating protease: sex-related association with coronary artery calcification. Blood Coagul Fibrinolysis 28:558–563
Bjerrum IS, Sand NP, Poulsen MK et al (2013) Non-invasive assessments reveal that more than half of randomly selected middle-aged individuals have evidence of subclinical atherosclerosis: a DanRisk substudy. Int J Cardiovasc Imaging 29:301–308
Diederichsen AC, Sand NP, Norgaard B et al (2012) Discrepancy between coronary artery calcium score and HeartScore in middle-aged Danes: the DanRisk study. Eur J Prev Cardiol 19:558–564
Ramanathan R, Sand NPR, Sidelmann JJ, Norgaard BL, Gram JB (2018) Sex difference in clot lysability and association to coronary artery calcification. Biol Sex Differ 9(1):9
Agatston AS, Janowitz WR, Hildner FJ, Zusmer NR, Viamonte M Jr, Detrano R (1990) Quantification of coronary artery calcium using ultrafast computed tomography. J Am Coll Cardiol 15:827–832
Adjedj J, De Bruyne B, Flore V et al (2016) Significance of intermediate values of fractional flow reserve in patients with coronary artery disease. Circulation 133:502–508
North American symptomatic carotid endarterectomy trial. Methods, patient characteristics, and progress (1991) Stroke 22:711–720
Dey D, Cheng VY, Slomka PJ et al (2009) Automated 3-dimensional quantification of noncalcified and calcified coronary plaque from coronary CT angiography. J Cardiovasc Comput Tomogr 3:372–382
Ovrehus KA, Schuhbaeck A, Marwan M et al (2016) Reproducibility of semi-automatic coronary plaque quantification in coronary CT angiography with sub-mSv radiation dose. J Cardiovasc Comput Tomogr 10:114–120
Leipsic J, Abbara S, Achenbach S et al (2014) SCCT guidelines for the interpretation and reporting of coronary CT angiography: a report of the Society of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography Guidelines Committee. J Cardiovasc Comput Tomogr 8:342–358
Escaned J, Collet C, Ryan N et al (2017) Clinical outcomes of state-of-the-art percutaneous coronary revascularization in patients with de novo three vessel disease: 1-year results of the SYNTAX II study. Eur Heart J 38:3124–3134
Collet C, Miyazaki Y, Ryan N et al (2018) Fractional flow reserve derived from computed tomographic angiography in patients with multivessel CAD. J Am Coll Cardiol 71:2756–2769
Bots ML, Hoes AW, Koudstaal PJ, Hofman A, Grobbee DE (1997) Common carotid intima-media thickness and risk of stroke and myocardial infarction: the Rotterdam study. Circulation 96:1432–1437
Kataoka Y, Uno K, Puri R, Nicholls SJ (2012) Current imaging modalities for atherosclerosis. Expert Rev Cardiovasc Ther 10:457–471
Naqvi TZ, Lee MS (2014) Carotid intima-media thickness and plaque in cardiovascular risk assessment. JACC Cardiovasc Imaging 7:1025–1038
Kanters SD, Algra A, van Leeuwen MS, Banga JD (1997) Reproducibility of in vivo carotid intima-media thickness measurements: a review. Stroke 28:665–671
Jashari F, Ibrahimi P, Johansson E et al (2015) Atherosclerotic calcification detection: a comparative study of carotid ultrasound and cone beam CT. Int J Mol Sci 16:19978–19988
Yang J, Pan X, Zhang B et al (2018) Superficial and multiple calcifications and ulceration associate with intraplaque hemorrhage in the carotid atherosclerotic plaque. Eur Radiol. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-018-5535-7
Saba L, Sanfilippo R, Montisci R, Atzeni M, Ribuffo D, Mallarini G (2011) Vulnerable plaque: detection of agreement between multi-detector-row CT angiography and US-ECD. Eur J Radiol 77:509–515
Zavanone C, Ragone E, Samson Y (2012) Concordance rates of Doppler ultrasound and CT angiography in the grading of carotid artery stenosis: a systematic literature review. J Neurol 259:1015–1018
Rafailidis V, Chryssogonidis I, Xerras C et al (2018) A comparative study of color Doppler imaging and contrast-enhanced ultrasound for the detection of ulceration in patients with carotid atherosclerotic disease. Eur Radiol. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-018-5773-8
Iwakiri T, Yano Y, Sato Y et al (2012) Usefulness of carotid intima-media thickness measurement as an indicator of generalized atherosclerosis: findings from autopsy analysis. Atherosclerosis 225:359–362
Uchiyama S, Goto S, Matsumoto M et al (2009) Cardiovascular event rates in patients with cerebrovascular disease and atherothrombosis at other vascular locations: results from 1-year outcomes in the Japanese REACH Registry. J Neurol Sci 287:45–51
Bots ML, Hofman A, De Jong PT, Grobbee DE (1996) Common carotid intima-media thickness as an indicator of atherosclerosis at other sites of the carotid artery. The Rotterdam study. Ann Epidemiol 6:147–153
UK-I JM, Young V, Gillard JH (2009) Carotid-artery imaging in the diagnosis and management of patients at risk of stroke. Lancet Neurol 8:569–580
Okuchi S, Fushimi Y, Okada T et al (2018) Visualization of carotid vessel wall and atherosclerotic plaque: T1-SPACE vs. compressed sensing T1-SPACE. Eur Radiol. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-018-5862-8
Salomaa V, Stinson V, Kark JD, Folsom AR, Davis CE, Wu KK (1995) Association of fibrinolytic parameters with early atherosclerosis. The ARIC Study Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study. Circulation 91:284–290
Krupinski J, Catena E, Miguel M et al (2007) D-dimer local expression is increased in symptomatic patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy. Int J Cardiol 116:174–179
de Maat MP, Bladbjerg EM, Drivsholm T, Borch-Johnsen K, Moller L, Jespersen J (2003) Inflammation, thrombosis and atherosclerosis: results of the Glostrup study. J Thromb Haemost 1:950–957
Takx RA, Partovi S, Ghoshhajra BB (2016) Imaging of atherosclerosis. Int J Cardiovasc Imaging 32:5–12
Taylor CA, Fonte TA, Min JK (2013) Computational fluid dynamics applied to cardiac computed tomography for noninvasive quantification of fractional flow reserve: scientific basis. J Am Coll Cardiol 61:2233–2241
Norgaard BL, Leipsic J, Gaur S et al (2014) Diagnostic performance of noninvasive fractional flow reserve derived from coronary computed tomography angiography in suspected coronary artery disease: the NXT trial (analysis of coronary blood flow using CT angiography: next steps). J Am Coll Cardiol 63:1145–1155
Brott TG, Halperin JL, Abbara S et al (2013) 2011 ASA/ACCF/AHA/AANN/AANS/ACR/ASNR/CNS/SAIP/SCAI/SIR/SNIS/SVM/SVS guideline on the management of patients with extracranial carotid and vertebral artery disease: executive summary: a report of the American College of Cardiology Foundation/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines, and the American Stroke Association, American Association of Neuroscience Nurses, American Association of Neurological Surgeons, American College of Radiology, American Society of Neuroradiology, Congress of Neurological Surgeons, Society of Atherosclerosis Imaging and Prevention, Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions, Society of Interventional Radiology, Society of NeuroInterventional Surgery, Society for Vascular Medicine, and Society for Vascular Surgery. Developed in collaboration with the American Academy of Neurology and Society of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography. Catheter Cardiovasc Interv 81:E76–E123
Yang L, Zhou T, Zhang R et al (2014) Meta-analysis: diagnostic accuracy of coronary CT angiography with prospective ECG gating based on step-and-shoot, flash and volume modes for detection of coronary artery disease. Eur Radiol 24:2345–2352
Investigators S-H, Newby DE, Adamson PD et al (2018) Coronary CT angiography and 5-year risk of myocardial infarction. N Engl J Med 379:924–933
Acknowledgments
We express our gratitude to the study participants in the current study and the dedicated staffs at the Departments of Cardiology, Radiology, and Clinical Biochemistry, University Hospital of Southern Denmark, Esbjerg, Denmark and at the Unit for Thrombosis Research, University of Southern Denmark, Esbjerg, Denmark. The authors thank Martin W. Kusk, Department of Radiology, University Hospital of Southern Denmark, Esbjerg, Denmark, for the valuable help with designing the CTA protocols and assistance provided during collection of the CTA data.
Funding
This work was supported by Cardiac Research Fund, University Hospital of Southern Denmark, Esbjerg; Institute of Regional Health Research: Centre South West Jutland, University Hospital of Southern Denmark, Esbjerg; Institute of Regional Health Research, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Southern Denmark; Edith and Vagn Hedegaard Jensen Foundation, Esbjerg; Karola Jørgensens Research Foundation, Esbjerg; and A. P. Møller Foundation, Copenhagen; all Denmark.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Guarantor
The scientific guarantor of this publication is Dr. Niels Peter R. Sand, PhD, Department of Cardiology, University Hospital of Southern Denmark, Esbjerg, and Department of Regional Health Research, University of Southern Denmark, Denmark.
Conflict of interest
The authors of this manuscript declare relationships with the following companies: Dr. Bjarne L. Nørgaard has received research grant from Siemens, Edwards Lifesciences and Heartflow. Dr. Damini Dey is a patent-holder of Autoplaque research software and receives royalties from Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA. All other authors have reported that they have no relationships relevant to the contents of this paper to disclose.
Statistics and biometry
Ramshanker Ramanathan and Damini Dey performed the statistical analyses. Statistician Pia V. Larsen, Department of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, provided statistical advice.
Informed consent
Written informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study. All procedures performed in the study were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the Regional Scientific Ethics Committee for Southern Denmark and with the ethical guidelines of the 1975 Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments.
Ethical approval
The study protocol was approved by the Regional Scientific Ethics Committee for Southern Denmark, reference number: S20080140 and S20130169 (45023).
Study subjects or cohorts overlap
Some study subjects or cohorts have been previously reported in the following papers: [1–9]. The study subjects recruited in the current study were part of the Danish Risk Score Study (the DanRisk study) conducted in 2009/2010 with follow-up examinations performed in 2015. The DanRisk study was a multicenter study involving four regional centers (Odense, Esbjerg, Vejle, and Svendborg).
The current study is based on follow-up examinations on asymptomatic male study subjects from one study center, Esbjerg, who were free of cardiovascular disease (CVD), diabetes, and any medication at baseline. The current study differs from the other studies by examining the carotid plaque composition by computed tomography angiography (CTA) and by comparing these findings with carotid plaque by ultrasound. In addition, this is the first study from DanRisk focusing on CTA.
[1] A.C. Diederichsen, N.P. Sand, B. Norgaard, J. Lambrechtsen, J.M. Jensen, H. Munkholm, A. Aziz, O. Gerke, K. Egstrup, M.L. Larsen, H. Petersen, P.F. Hoilund-Carlsen, H. Mickley, Discrepancy between coronary artery calcium score and HeartScore in middle-aged Danes: the DanRisk study, European journal of preventive cardiology 19(3) (2012) 558–64.
[2] I.S. Bjerrum, N.P. Sand, M.K. Poulsen, B.L. Norgaard, J.J. Sidelmann, A. Johansen, H. Mickley, A.C. Diederichsen, Non-invasive assessments reveal that more than half of randomly selected middle-aged individuals have evidence of subclinical atherosclerosis: a DanRisk substudy, The international journal of cardiovascular imaging 29(2) (2013) 301–8.
[3] R. Ramanathan, J.B. Gram, N.P.R. Sand, B.L. Norgaard, A.C.P. Diederichsen, F. Vitzthum, H. Schwarz, J.J. Sidelmann, Factor VII-activating protease: sex-related association with coronary artery calcification, Blood coagulation & fibrinolysis: an international journal in haemostasis and thrombosis 28(7) (2017) 558–563.
[4] R. Ramanathan, N.P.R. Sand, J.J. Sidelmann, B.L. Norgaard, J.B. Gram, Sex difference in clot lysability and association to coronary artery calcification, Biol Sex Differ 9(1) (2018) 9.
[5] S.Z. Diederichsen, M.H. Gronhoj, H. Mickley, O. Gerke, F.H. Steffensen, J. Lambrechtsen, N.P. Ronnow Sand, L.M. Rasmussen, M.H. Olsen, A. Diederichsen, CT-Detected Growth of Coronary Artery Calcification in Asymptomatic Middle-Aged Subjects and Association With 15 Biomarkers, JACC. Cardiovascular imaging 10(8) (2017) 858–866.
[6] J. Lambrechtsen, O. Gerke, K. Egstrup, N.P. Sand, B.L. Norgaard, H. Petersen, H. Mickley, A.C. Diederichsen, The relation between coronary artery calcification in asymptomatic subjects and both traditional risk factors and living in the city centre: a DanRisk substudy, Journal of internal medicine 271(5) (2012) 444–50.
[7] M.H. Sorensen, O. Gerke, J. Eugen-Olsen, H. Munkholm, J. Lambrechtsen, N.P. Sand, H. Mickley, L.M. Rasmussen, M.H. Olsen, A. Diederichsen, Soluble urokinase plasminogen activator receptor is in contrast to high-sensitive C-reactive-protein associated with coronary artery calcifications in healthy middle-aged subjects, Atherosclerosis 237(1) (2014) 60–6.
[8] M.Z. Diederichsen, S.Z. Diederichsen, H. Mickley, F.H. Steffensen, J. Lambrechtsen, N.P.R. Sand, K.L. Christensen, M.H. Olsen, A. Diederichsen, M.H. Gronhoj, Prognostic value of suPAR and hs-CRP on cardiovascular disease, Atherosclerosis 271 (2018) 245–251.
[9] M.H. Gronhoj, O. Gerke, H. Mickley, F.H. Steffensen, J. Lambrechtsen, N.P.R. Sand, L.M. Rasmussen, M.H. Olsen, A. Diederichsen, Associations between calcium-phosphate metabolism and coronary artery calcification; a cross-sectional study of a middle-aged general population, Atherosclerosis 251 (2016) 101–108.
Methodology
• prospective
• cross-sectional study/observational
• performed at one institution
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
ESM 1
(DOCX 18 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ramanathan, R., Dey, D., Nørgaard, B.L. et al. Carotid plaque composition by CT angiography in asymptomatic subjects: a head-to-head comparison to ultrasound. Eur Radiol 29, 5920–5931 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-019-06086-y
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-019-06086-y