Abstract
Background
There is a lot of controversy about the best surgical treatment for esophageal carcinoma.
Methods
In this retrospective study, 382 patients with carcinoma of the mid-to-distal esophagus underwent transthoracic or transhiatal esophagectomy. Early morbidity and mortality were compared. Principal endpoints were disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS).
Results
A total of 177 patients underwent transthoracic esophagectomy, and 205 patients underwent transhiatal esophagectomy. Demographic characteristics and characteristics of the tumor were similar in the two groups. Perioperative and postoperative morbidity was higher after transhiatal esophagectomy. In-hospital mortality was also higher after transhiatal esophagectomy. The median follow-up was 4.3 years. Estimated 3-year DFS rates were 44.63 and 31.21%, whereas the 3-year OS rates were 57.06 and 41.46% for the transthoracic and transhiatal groups, respectively (statistically significant). Also, the estimated 5-year DFS rates were 26.55 and 21.46%, whereas the 5-year OS rates were 32.76 and 30.24% for the transthoracic and transhiatal groups, respectively (statistically not significant).
Conclusions
Transhiatal esophagectomy was associated with higher perioperative and postoperative morbidity and in-hospital mortality than transthoracic esophagectomy. The DFS and OS were higher in the transthoracic group and were statistically significant at 3 years but statistically insignificant at 5 years.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Greenlee RT, Murray T, Bolden S et al (2000) Cancer statistics, 2000. CA Cancer J Clin 50:7–33
Khuroo M, Zargar S, Mahajan R et al (1992) High incidence of esophageal and gastric cancer in Kashmir in a population with special personal and dietary habits. Gut 33:11–15
Orringer MB, Marshall B, Stirling MC (1993) Transhiatal esophagectomy for benign and malignant disease. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 105:265–276
Muller JM, Erasmi H, Stelzner M et al (1990) Surgical therapy of esophageal carcinoma. Br J Surg 77:845–857
Hulscher JBF, Tijssen JGP, Obertop H et al (2001) Transthoracic versus transhiatal resection for carcinoma of the esophagus: a meta-analysis. Ann Thorac Surg 72:306–313
Goldminc M, Maddern G, Le Prise E et al (1993) Esophagectomy by a transhiatal approach or thoracotomy: a prospective randomized trial. Br J Surg 80:367–370
Chu KM, Law SY, Fok M et al (1997) A prospective randomized comparison of transhiatal and transthoracic resection for lower-third esophageal carcinoma. Am J Surg 174:320–324
Jacobi CA, Zieren HU, Muller JM et al (1997) Surgical therapy of esophageal carcinoma: the influence of surgical approach and esophageal resection on cardiopulmonary function. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 11:32–37
Matoo AR, Kaul HK (1974) Incidences of malignant neoplasms in Kashmir. J Indian Med Assoc 62:309–311
Dhar GM, Shah GN, Naheed B et al (1993) Epidemiological trend in the distribution of cancer in Kashmir Valley. J Epidemiol Community Health 47:290–292
Hulscher JBF, van Sandick JW, de Boer AGEM et al (2002) Extended transthoracic resection compared with limited transhiatal resection for adenocarcinoma of the esophagus. N Engl J Med 347:1662–1669
Swisher S, Hunt K, Holmes E et al (1995) Changes in the surgical management of esophageal cancer from 1970 to 1983. Am J Surg 169:609–614
Katlic M, Wilkins E, Grillo H (1990) Three decades of treatment of esophageal squamous carcinoma at the Massachusetts General Hospital. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 99:929–938
Jauch KW, Bacha EA, Denecke H et al (1992) Esophageal carcinoma: prognostic features and comparison between blunt transhiatal dissection and transthoracic resection. Eur J Surg Oncol 18:553–562
Pommier RF, Vetto JT, Ferris BL et al (1998) Relationships between operative approaches and outcomes in esophageal cancer. Am J Surg 175:422–425
Orringer MB, Orringer JS (1983) Esophagectomy without thoracotomy: a dangerous operation? J Thorac Cadiovasc Surg 85:72–80
Ellis FH, Gibb SP, Watkins E Jr (1983) Esophagogastrectomy: a safe, widely applicable, and expeditious form of palliation of patients with carcinoma of esophagus and cardia. Ann Surg 198:531–540
Mathisen DJ, Grillo HC, Wilkinson EW et al (1988) Transthoracic esophagectomy: a safe approach to carcinoma of esophagus. Ann Thorac Surg 45:137–143
Hulscher J, Van Sandick J, DeVriese P et al (1999) Vocal cord paralysis after subtotal esophagectomy. Br J Surg 86:1583–1587
Vigneswaran W, Trastek V, Pairolero P et al (1994) Extended esophagectomy in the management of carcinoma of the upper thoracic esophagus. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 107:901–907
McLarty A, Deschamps C, Trastek V et al (1997) Esophageal resection for cancer of the esophagus: long-term function and quality of life. Ann Thorac Surg 63:1568–1572
Tilanus HW, Hop WC, Langenhorst BL et al (1993) Esophagectomy with or without thoracotomy. is there any difference? J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 105:898–903
Rahul R, Christopher J, Michael R (2002) Transhiatal versus Ivor Lewis esophagectomy: is there a difference? Aust N Z J Surg 69:187–194
Stark SP, Romberg MS, Pierce GE et al (1996) Transhiatal versus transthoracic esophagectomy for adenocarcinoma of the distal esophagus and cardia. Am J Surg 172:478–481; discussion 481–482
Iannettoni MD, Whyte RI, Orringer MB (1995) Catastrophic complications of the cervical esophagogastric anastomosis. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 110:1493–1501
Patti M, Corvera C, Glasgow R et al (1998) A hospital’s annual rate of esophagectomy influences the operative mortality rate. J Gastrointest Surg 2:186–192
Miller J, Jain M, De Gara C et al (1997) Effect of surgical experience on results of esophagectomy for esophageal carcinoma. J Surg Oncol 65:20–21
Horstmann O, Verreet PR, Becker H et al (1995) Transhiatal esophagectomy compared with transthoracic resection and systematic lymphadenectomy for the treatment of esophageal cancer. Eur J Surg 161:557–567
Ninh T, David M, Bruce M et al (2000) Comparison of minimally invasive esophagectomy with transthoracic and transhiatal esophagectomy. Arch Surg 135:920–925
Sabanathan S, Shah R, Mearns AJ et al (1996) Results of surgical treatment of esophageal cancer. J R Coll Surg Edinb 41:295–301
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kawoosa, N.U., Dar, A.M., Sharma, M.L. et al. Transthoracic Versus Transhiatal Esophagectomy for Esophageal Carcinoma: Experience from a Single Tertiary Care Institution. World J Surg 35, 1296–1302 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-011-1020-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-011-1020-z