Abstract
Water quality from forested landscapes tends to be very high but can deteriorate during and after silvicultural activities. Practices such as forest harvesting, site preparation, road construction/use, and stream crossings have been shown to contribute sediment, nutrients, and other pollutants to adjacent streams. Although advances in forest management accompanied with Best Management Practices (BMPs) have been very effective at reducing water quality impacts from forest operations, projected increases in demand for forest products may result in unintended environmental degradation. Through a review of the pertinent literature, we identified several research gaps related to water yield, aquatic habitat, sediment source and delivery, and BMP effectiveness that should be addressed for streams in the United States to better understand and address the environmental ramifications of current and future levels of timber production. We explored the current understanding of these topics based on relevant literature and the possible implications of increased demand for forest products in the United States.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arp PA, Yin X (1992) Predicting water fluxes through forests from monthly precipitation and mean monthly air temperature records. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 22:864–877
Arthur MA, Colthrap GB, Brown DL (1998) Effects of best management practices on forest stream water quality in eastern Kentucky. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 34:412–417
Aust WM, Blinn CR (2004) Forestry best management practices for timber harvesting and site preparation in the eastern United States: an overview of water quality and productivity research during the past 20 years (1982–2002). Water, Air, and Soil Pollution: Focus 4:5–36
Beasley RS, Granillo AB (1982) Sediment losses from forest practices in the Gulf Coastal Plain of Arkansas. In: Jones EP Jr (ed) Proceedings of the second biennial southern silviculture research conference. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report SE-24
Beasley RS, Miller EL, Blackburn WH, Lawson ER (2004) Assessing the impacts of intensive forest management: watershed studies of the mid-south. In: Ice GG, Stednick D (eds) A century of forest and wildland watershed lessons. The Society of American Foresters, Bethesda
Berg NH, Roby KB, McGuk BJ (1996) Cumulative watershed effects: applicability of available methodologies to the Sierra Nevada. In: Sierra Nevada ecosystems project: final report to congress, vol III, Assessmnets, commissioned reports, and background information. Center for Water and Wildland Resources, University of California, Davis, pp 39–78
Beschta RL (1998) Forest hydrology in the Pacific Northwest: additional research needs. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 34:729–741
Beschta RL, Jackson WL (2008) Forest practices and sediment production in the Alsea Watershed Study. In: Stednick JD (ed) Hydrological and biological responses to forest practices. Springer, New York, pp 55–66
Beschta RL, Rhodes JJ, Kauffman JB, Gresswell RE, Minshall GW, Karr JR, Perry DA, Hauer FR, Frissell CA (2004) Postfire management on forested public lands of the western United States. Conservation Biology 18:957–967
Bilby RE, Sullivan K, Duncan SH (1989) The generation and fate of road-surface sediment in forested watersheds in southwestern Washington. Forest Science 35:453–468
Binkley D, Brown TC (1993) Forest practices as nonpoint sources of pollution in North America. Water Resources Bulletin 29:729–740
Binkley D, Ice GG, Kaye J, Williams CA (2004) Nitrogen and phosphorus concentrations in forest streams of the United States. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 40:1277–1291
Blackburn WH, Wood JC, DeHarven MG (1986) Storm flow and sediment losses site-prescribed forestland in east Texas. Water Resources Research 22:776–784
Borah DK, Yagow G, Saleh A, Barnes PL, Rosenthal W, Krug EC, Hauck LM (2006) Sediment and nutrient modeling for TMDL development and implementation. Journal of the Society of American Agricultural and Biological Engineers 49:967–986
Brown TC, Binkley D (1994) Effects of management on water quality in North American forests. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report RM-248, 27 pp
Carroll GD, Schoenholtz SH, Young BW, Dibble ED (2004) Effectiveness of forestry streamside management zones in the sand-clay hills of Mississippi: early indications. Water, Air, and Soil: Focus 4:275–296
Croke JC, Hairsine PB (2006) Sediment delivery in managed forests: a review. Environmental Reviews 14:59–87
Eisenbies MH, Aust WM, Burger JA, Adams MB (2007) Forest operations, extreme flooding events, and considerations for hydrologic modeling in the Appalachians—a review. Forest Ecology and Management 242:77–98
Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations (FAO) (2009) State of the world’s forests 2009. Food and Agricultural Organization, 152 pp
Gomi T, Moore RD, Hassan MA (2005) Suspended sediment dynamics in small forest streams of the Pacific Northwest. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 41:877–898
Grace JM III (2005) Forest operations and water quality in the south. Transactions of the ASAE 48:871–880
Grant GE, Lewis SL, Swanson FJ, Cissel JH, McDonnell JJ (2008) Effects of forest practices on peak flows and consequent channel response: a state-of-science report for western Oregon and Washington. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PNW-GTR-760, 76 pp
Gucinski H, Furniss MJ, Ziemer RR, Brookes MH (2001) Forest roads: a synthesis of scientific information. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PNW-GTR-509, 103 pp
Harr RD (1983) Potential for augmenting water yield through forest practices in western Washington and western Oregon. Water Resources Bulletin 19:383–392
Hartano H, Prabhu R, Widavat ASE, Asdak C (2003) Factors affecting runoff and soil erosion: plot-level soil loss monitoring for assessing sustainability of forest management. Forest Ecology and Management 180:361–374
Henley WF, Patterson MA, Neves RJ, Lemly AD (2000) Effects of sedimentation and turbidity on lotic food webs: a concise review for natural resource manangers. Reviews in Fisheries Science 8:125–139
Hubbart JA, Link TE, Gravelle JA, Elliot WJ (2007) Timber harvest impacts on water yield in the continental/maritime hydroclimatic region of the United States. Forest Science 53:169–180
Ice G (2004) History of innovative best management practice development and its role in addressing water quality limited waterbodies. Journal of Environmental Engineering 130:684–689
Ice GG, Stednick JD (2004) A century of forest and wildland watershed lessons. Society of American Foresters, Bethesda, MD
Ice GG, Stuart GW, Waide JB, Irland LC, Ellefson PV (1997) 25 years of the Clean Water Act: How clean are forest practices? Journal of Forestry 95:9–13
Jackson CR, Sun G, Amatya D, Swank WT, Riedel M, Patric J, Williams T, Vose JM, Trettin C, Aust WM, Beasley RS, Williston H, Ice GG (2004) Fifty years of forest hydrology in the Southeast. In: Ice GG, Stednick D (eds) A century of forest and wildland watershed lessons. The Society of American Foresters, Bethesda, pp 33–112
Jackson CR, Martin JK, Leigh DS, West LT (2005) A southeastern piedmont watershed budget: evidence for a multi-millennial agricultural legacy. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 60:298–310
Karr JR, Rhodes JJ, Minshall GW, Hauer FR, Beschta RL, Frissell CA, Perry DA (2004) The logging effects of postfire salvage logging on aquatic ecosystems in the American west. BioScience 54:1029–1033
Ketheson GL, Megahan WF, King JG (1999) “R1–R4” and “BOISED” sediment prediction model tests using forest roads in granitics. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 35:83–98
Knox JC (1987) Valley floor sedimentation in the Upper Mississippi Valley. Annals of the Association of the American Geographers 77:224–244
Kreutzweiser DP, Capell SS (2001) Fine sediment deposition in streams after selective forest harvesting without riparian buffers. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 31:2134–2142
Lakel WA (2008) Effects of forestry streamside management zones on stream water quality, channel geometry, soil erosion, and timber management in the Virginia Piedmont. PhD dissertation, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, 125 pp
Lakel WA, Aust WM, Dollaff CA, Easterbrook AW (2006) Soil erosion from harvested sites vs. streamside management zone sediment deposition in the Piedmont of Virginia. In: Conner K (ed) Proceedings of 13th biennial southern silvicultural research conference. USDA Forest Service Gen. Tech. Rep. SRS-92, pp 400–401
Loupe TM, Miller WW, Johnson DW, Sedinger JS, Carroll EM, Walker RF, Murphy JD, Stein CM (2009) Effects of mechanical harvest plus chipping and prescribed fire on Sierran runoff water quality. Journal of Environmental Quality 38:537–547
MacDonald LH, Coe D, Litschert S (2002) Assessing cumulative watershed effects in the central Sierra Nevada: hillslope measurements and catchment-scale modeling. USDA Forest Service Gen. Tech. Rep. PSW-GTR-193
Madej MA, Eschenbach EA, Diaz C, Teasley R, Baker K (2006) Optimization strategies for sediment reduction practices on roads in steep, forested terrain. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms 31:1643–1656
McBroom MW, Beasley RS, Chang M, Gowin B, Ice G (2003) Runoff and sediment losses from annual and unusual storm events from the Alto Experimental Watersheds, Texas: 23 years after silvicultural treatments. In: Renard KG et al (eds), Proceedings of interagency conference on research in the watersheds. USDA-ARS, Washington, DC, pp 607–613
McBroom MW, Beasley RS, Chang M, Ice GG (2008a) Storm runoff and sediment losses from forest clearcutting and stand re-establishment with best management practices in East Texas, USA. Hydrological Processes 22:1509–1522
McBroom MW, Beasley RS, Chang M (2008b) Water quality effects of clearcut harvesting and forest fertilization with Best Management Practices. Journal of Environmental Quality 37:114–124
McCaffery M, Switalski TA, Eby L (2007) Effects of road decommissioning on stream habitat characteristics in the South Fork Flathead River Montana. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 136:553–561
Megahan WF, King JG (2004) Erosion, sedimentation, and cumulative effects in the northern Rocky Mountains. In: Ice GG, Stednick D (eds) A century of forest and wildland watershed lessons. The Society of American Foresters, Bethesda, pp 201–222
Mellina E, Hinch SG (2007) A meta-analysis of stream habitat, and salmonid density and biomass response to clear-cut logging: the influence of stream cleaning. In: Abstract in conference program: riparian management in headwater catchments: translating Science into Management, Vancouver, BC
Miller DJ, Benda LE (2000) Effects of punctuated sediment supply on valley-floor landforms and sediment transport. Geological Society of America Bulletin 112(12):1814–1824
Miller EL, Beasley RS, Covert JC (1985) Forest road sediments: production and delivery to streams. In: Blackman BG (ed) Proceedings of forest and water quality: a mid-south symposium. University of Arkansas, Little Rock, AR, pp 164–176
Mitsch WJ, Jørgensen SE (2003) Ecological engineering and ecosystem restoration. Wiley, Hoboken, p 411
Moore RD, Wondzell SM (2005) Physical hydrology and the effects of forest harvesting in the Pacific Northwest: a review. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 41:763–784
Neary DG, Hornbeck JW (1994) Impacts of harvest-ing practices on off-site environmental quality. In: Dyck WJ, Cole DW, Comerford NB (eds) International Energy Agency Project A6 Book, impacts of harvesting on long-term site productivity. Chapman and Hall, London, p 368
Neary DG, Michael JL (1996) Herbicides—protecting long-term sustainability and water quality in forest ecosystems. New Zealand Journal of Forest Science 26(1/2):241–264
Neary DG, Bush PB, Michael JL (1993) Fate of pesticides in southern forests: a review of a decade of progress. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 12:411–428
Neary DG, Ice GG, Jackson CR (2009) Linkages between forest soils and water quality and quantity. Forest Ecology and Management 258:2269–2281
Nelson EJ, Booth DB (2002) Sediment sources in an urbanizing mixed land-use watershed. Journal of Hydrology 264:51–68
Osei E, Gassman PW, Hauck LM, Jones R, Beran L, Dyke PT, Gross DW, Flowers JD, McFarland AMS, Saleh A (2003) Environmental benefits and economic costs of manure incorporation on dairy waste application fields. Journal of Environmental Management 68:1–11
Papanicolaou AN, Fox JF, Marshall J (2003) Soil fingerprinting in the Palouse Basin, USA, using stable carbon and nitrogen isotopes. International Journal of Sediment Research 18:278–284
Peck JA, Mullen A, Moore A, Runschlag JH (2007) The legacy sediment record within the Munroe Falls Dam Pool, Cuyahoga River, Summit County, Ohio. Journal of Great Lakes Research 33:127–141
Prestemon JP, Abt RC (2002) The southern timber market. Journal of Forestry 100:16–22
Reid LM (1993) Research and cumulative watershed effects. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PSW-GTR-141, Albany, CA, 118 pp
Reiter M, Heffner JT, Beech S, Turner T, Bilby RE (2009) Temporal and spatial turbidity patterns over 30 years in a managed forest of western Washington. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 45:793–808
Rhee H, Fridley JL, Foltz RB (2004) Modeling erosion from unpaved forest roads at various levels of geometric detail using the WEPP Model. Journal of the American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers 47:961–968
Rice RM, Lewis J (1991) Estimating erosion risks associated with logging and forest roads in northwestern California. Water Resources Bulletin 27(5):809–817
Rivenbark BL, Jackson CR (2004) Concentrated flow breakthrough moving through silvicultural streamside management zones: southeastern Piedmont, USA. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 40:1043–1051
Rummer B (2004) Managing water quality in wetlands with forestry BMPs. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution: Focus 4:55–66
Schilling E (2009) Compendium of forestry best management practices for controlling nonpoint source pollution in North America. Technical Bulletin No. 966. NCASI, Research Triangle Park
Schilling E, Ice G, Wigley B, Miwa M, Saleh A (2007) Water quality issues facing the forest products industry: current research focus and future research needs. In: McFarland A, Saleh A (eds) Proceedings of the fourth conference on watershed management to meet water quality standards and TMDLs (total maximum daily load). ASABE Publication No. 701P0207, pp 294–301
Schoenholtz SH (2004) Impacts of forest management on water quality. In: Burley J, Evans J, Youngquist J (eds) Encyclopedia of forest sciences. Elsevier, Oxford, pp 377–388
Shepard JP, Aust WM, Dolloff CA, Ice GG, Kolka RK (2004) Forestry best management practices research in the eastern United States: the state of the science 2002. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution: Focus 4:1–3
Standiford RB, Arcilla R (2001) The University of California Committee on cumulative watershed effects. Wildland Resource Center Report No. 46. University of California, 103 pp
Stednick JD (1996) Monitoring the effects of timber harvest on annual water yields. Journal of Hydrology 176:79–95
Stednick JD, Troendle CA, Ice GG (2004) Lessons for watershed research. In: Ice GG, Stednick D (eds) A century of forest and wildland watershed lessons. The Society of American Foresters, Bethesda, pp 277–287
Sun G, Riedel M, Jackson R, Kolka R, Amatya D, Shepard J (2004) Influences of management of southern forests on water quantity and quality. In: Rauscher HM, Johnsen K (eds) Southern forest science: past, present, and future. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report SRS-75, Asheville, pp 195–224
Swank WT, Waide JB, Elliot KJ (2001) Long-term hydrologic and water quality responses following commercial clearcutting of mixed hardwoods on a Southern Appalachian catchment. Forest Ecology and Management 143:163–178
Swift LW Jr (1984) Gravel and grass surfacing reduces soil loss from mountain roads. Forest Science 30:657–670
Swift LW Jr (1988) Forest access roads: design, maintenance, and soil loss. In: Swank WT, Crossley DA Jr (eds) Forest hydrology and ecology at Coweeta: ecological studies, vol 66. Springer-Verlag, New York, p 324
Switalski TA, Bissonette JA, DeLuca TH, Luce CH, Madej MA (2004) Benefits and impacts of road removal. Frontiers of Ecology and the Environment 2:21–28
Thompson M, Sessions J, Boston K, Skaugset A, Tomberlin D (2010) Forest road erosion control using multiobjective optimization. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 46:712–723
Thornton KW, Holbrook SP, Stolte KL, Landy RB (2000) Effects of forest management practices on Mid-Atlantic streams. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 63:31–41
Trimble SW (1974) Man-induced soil erosion on the southern Piedmont: 1700–1970. Soil Conservation Society of America, 179 pp
Ursic SJ, Douglass JE (1979) The effects of forest practice on water resource. In: The W. Kelly Mosley environmental forum, Proc. Auburn University Press, Auburn, AL, pp 33–49
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) (2007) National water quality inventory: report to congress, 2002 reporting cycle. EPA 841-R-07-001, Washington, DC, 30 pp
Veith TL, Wolfe ML, Heatwole CD (2004) Cost-effective BMP placement: optimization versus targeting. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers 47:1585–1594
Vowell JL (2001) Using stream bioassessment to monitor best management practices effectiveness. Forest Ecology and Management 143:237–244
Vowell JL, Frydenborg RB (2004) A biological assessment of best management practices effectiveness during intensive silvicultural and forest chemical application. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution: Focus 4:297–307
Wallbrink PJ, Croke J (2002) A combined rainfall simulator and tracer approach to assess the role of Best Management Practices in minimising sediment redistribution and loss in forests after harvesting. Forest Ecology and Management 170:217–232
Wallbrink PJ, Roddy BP, Olley JM (2002) A tracer budget quantifying soil redistribution on hillslopes after forest harvesting. Catena 47:179–201
Walling DE (2005) Tracing suspended sediment sources in catchments and river systems. Science of the Total Environment 344:159–184
Walter RC, Merritts DJ (2008) Natural streams and the legacy of water-powered mills. Science 39:299–304
Wear DN, Greis JG (2002) Southern Forest Resource Assessment: summary of findings. Journal of Forestry 100:6–14
White WJ, Morris LA, Warnell DB, Pinho AP, Jackson CR, Warnell DB, West LT (2007) Sediment retention by forested filter strips in the Piedmont of Georgia. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 62:453–463
Williams TM, Hook DD, Lipscomb DJ, Zeng X, Albiston JW (1999) Effectiveness of best management practices to protect water quality in South Carolina Piedmont. In: Waldrop A (ed), Proceedings of the tenth biennial southern silvicultural research conference. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report SRS-30T, pp 357–362
Wilzbach MA, Harvey BC, White JI, Nkamoto RJ (2005) Effects of growth riparian canopy openings and salmon carcass addition on the abundance and growth of resident salmonids. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 62(1):58–67
Wynn TM, Mostaghimi S, Frazee JW (2000) Effects of forest harvesting best management practices on surface water quality in Virginia Coastal Plain. Transactions of the ASAE 43:927–936
Xiao-Yue Z, Yu SL, Lin J (2004) Optimal location and sizing of stormwater basins at watershed scale. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 130:339–347
Zeng X, Rasmussen TC (2005) Multivariate statistical characterization of water quality in Lake Lanier, Georgia, USA. Journal of Environmental Quality 34:1980–1991
Ziemer RR, Lewis J, Rice RM, Lisle TE (1991) Modeling the cumulative watershed effects of forest management strategies. Journal of Environmental Quality 20:36–42
Acknowledgments
Financial support for an earlier version of this paper was provided by the U.S. Forest Service and National Council for Air and Stream Improvement, Inc. through participation on the U.S. Forest Productivity Research Gap Analysis: Reducing Environmental Footprint/Quantifying Benefits Associated with Increased Productivity. Helpful comments to earlier versions of this paper were provided by Erik Schilling and George Ice. Four anonymous reviewers also provided helpful comments that improved this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Anderson, C.J., Lockaby, B.G. Research Gaps Related to Forest Management and Stream Sediment in the United States. Environmental Management 47, 303–313 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-010-9604-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-010-9604-1