Abstract
Ragwort (Senecio jacobaea and S. aquaticus) causes major losses to agricultural revenue and induces livestock morbidity throughout parts of Europe, North America, and Australasia. The introduction of legislation in the U.K. and Australia has meant that landowners can be prosecuted if the plant spreads to adjacent land, which has led to an increase in activities attempting to control these species. Commonly used interventions include natural enemies, herbicide applications, manual and mechanical removal. Through the use of explicit systematic methodology involving comprehensive searches and detailed inclusion criteria, data from primary research are collated for each type of intervention. Meta-analyses show that 2,4-D, Asulam, Clopyralid, and MCPA are effective at reducing ragwort densities. However, when the datasets were analysed for their effectiveness against individual species, 2,4-D and MCPA were only effective against S. jacobaea, while Asulam was only effective against S. aquaticus. Natural enemies Longitarsus jacobaeae and a combination of L. jacobaeae and Tyria jacobaeae appear to have the potential to reduce S. jacobaea densities. Only applying T. jacobaeae does not appear to significantly reduce S. jacobaea densities, but does reduce the number of capitula per plant, seeds per capitula, viability of seeds, and dry weight of the plants. There is insufficient experimental evidence available to assess other interventions such as manual or mechanical removal. Further research into these types of interventions is recommended, as well as more detailed reporting of site characteristics and experimental design to allow full investigation of each intervention to explain possible reasons for variations in their effectiveness.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Appleby AP (1979) Chemical control of tansy ragwort (Senecio jacobaea). Symposium on Pyrrolizidine 23:161
Bacon J (2000) Pedestrian and scrub weed-wipers. Enact 8:4–5
Black WN (1976) Effects of herbicide rates and time of application on the control of tansy ragwort in pastures. Canadian Journal of Plant Science 56:605–610
Bornemissza GF (1966) An attempt to control ragwort in Australia with the cinnabar moth (Callimorpha jacobaeae) (Arctiidae:Lepidoptera). Australian Journal of Zoology 14:201–243
Cameron E (1935) A study of the natural control of ragwort (Senecio jacobaea L.). Journal of Ecology 23:265–322
Clay DV, Dixon FL (1998) The susceptibility of compositae weed species to clopyralid: Tests of agrochemicals and cultivars. Supplement to Annals of Applied Biology 132:32–33
Coles PG (1967) Ragwort control with picloram. Proceedings of the 20th New Zealand Weed and Pest Control Conference. pp 32–36
Courtney AD, Johnston R (1976) An extended season of herbicides application for the control of Senecio jacobaea, British Weed Control Conference:611–618
Deeks JJ, Altman DG, Bradburn MJ (2001) Systematic reviews in health cars. In: Eggar M, Altman DG (eds) Meta-analysis in context. British Medical Journal Publishing Group, London, U.K, pp 285–312
Defra (2003) Draft Code of Practice to Prevent and Control the Spread of Ragwort. UK Government Report: Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Defra, London
Dixon FL, Clay DV (2001) Effect of synthetic and natural-product herbicides on Senecio jacobaea (common ragwort). British Crop Protection Council Conference - Weeds 2001, Vols. 1, 2:721–726
Dixon FL, Clay DV (2004) Effect of herbicides applied pre- and post-emergence on forestry weeds grown from seed. British Crop Protection Council Conference, Farnham, U.K
Eadie IM, Robinson BD (1953) Control of ragwort by hormone-type weedicides. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 19:192–196
Eggar M, Smith GD, Altman DG (eds) (2003) Systematic Reviews in Health Care: Meta-analysis in context, 2nd edn. BMJ Publishing Group, London, U.K
EN (English Nature) (2003) The Herbicide Handbook: Guidance on the use of herbicides on nature conservation sites, English Nature Management Handbook Series, English Nature, Peterbourgh, U.K
Forbes JC (1977) Chemical control of marsh ragwort (Senecio aquaticus Huds.) in established grassland. Weed Research 17:247–250
Forbes JC (1978) Control of Senecio jacobaea (ragwort) by autumn or spring herbicide application. Weed Research 18:109–110
Forbes JC (1982) Evaluating herbicides for selective control of Senecio jacobaea in grass/clover swards. Proceedings of the 1982 British Crop Protection Conference - Weeds:375–379
Forbes JC, Kilgour DW, Carnegie HM (1980) Some causes of poor control of Senecio jacobaea L. by herbicides Scotland, Ireland, grassland weed ragwort. British Crop Protection Conference - Weeds:461–468
Fryer JD (1953) The use of 2:4-D for the control of ragwort, Proceedings of the 1st British Weed Control Conference. pp 211–224
Ganeshan S (1992) Direct effect and indirect interactions between flea beetles and cinnabar moths on the ragwort. M.Sc. Thesis, Imperial College, London, U.K
Goodman GT, Gillham ME (1954) Ecology of the Pembrookeshire islands II. Stokholm environment and vegetation. Journal of Ecology 42:296–327
Grime JP, Hodgson JG, Hunt R (1988) Comparative Plant Ecology: a functional approach to common British species. Unwin Hyman, London, U.K
Gurevitch J, Hedges LV (1999) Statistical issues in ecological meta-analyses. Ecology 80:1142–1149
Harper DR (1976) Asulam for tansy ragwort control in alfalfa: Field efficacy and selectivity factors. Ph.D. Thesis, Oregon State University, U.S.A. 124 pp
Harris P (1974) The impact of the cinnabar moth on ragwort in east and west Canada and its implication for biological control. Commonwealth Institute of Biological Control 8:119–123
Harris P, Thompson LS, Wilkinson ATS, Neary ME (1976a) Reproductive biology of tansy ragwort, climate and biological control by the cinnabar moth in Canada, IV International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds, pp 163–173
Harris P, Wilkinson ATS, Thompson LS, Neary ME (1976b) Interaction between the cinnabar moth, Tyria jacobaeae and ragwort, Senecio jacobaea in Canada, IV International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds, pp 174–180
Hawkes RB, Johnson GR (1976). Longitarsus jacobaeae aids moth in the biological control of tansy ragwort. Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds, pp 193–196
Hoenig JM, Heisey DM (2001) The abuse of power: The pervasive fallacy of power calculations for data analysis. American Statistician 55:19–24
James RR, McEvoy PB, Cox CS (1992) Combining the cinnabar moth (Tyria jacobaeae) and the ragwort flea beetle (Longitarsus -jacobaeae) for control of ragwort (Senecio jacobaea): An experimental analysis. Journal of Applied Ecology 29:589–596
James TK, Mortimer J (1983). Control of ragwort and nodding thistle in lucerne with hexazinone. Proceedings 36th New Zealand Weed and Pest Control Conference, pp 17–20
James TK, Rahman A, DeJong P (1997). Flazasulfuron for control of ragwort (Senecio jacobaea) in pasture. Proceedings 15th New Zealand Plant Protection Conference, pp 477–481
Landis RJ, Koch GG (1977). The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 33:159–174
Makepeace W, Thompson A (1982). Ragwort control using a rope wick applicator. Proceedings 35th New Zealand Weed and Pest Conference, pp 256–260
Martin P, Thompson A, Saunders AE, Rahman A (1986) Effect of plant type on the response of ragwort to rates and times of 2,4-D application. Proceedings 39th New Zealand Weed and Pest Control Conference, pp 179–182
McClements I (1992) Marsh ragwort (Senecio aquaticus) biology and control. Ph.D. Thesis, Queen’s University Belfast, Belfast, U.K
McEvoy PB (1985) Depression in ragwort (Senecio jacobaea) abundance following introduction of Tyria jacobaea and Longitarsus jacobaeae on the central coast of Oregon. Proceedings of the VI International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds, pp 57–64
McEvoy PB, Cox C, Coombs E (1991) Successful Biological Control of Ragwort, Senecio jacobaea, by Introduced Insects in Oregon. Ecological Applications 1:430–442
Moher D, Cook DJ, Eastwood S, Olkin I, Rennie D, Stroup DF (1999) Improving the quality of reports of meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials: the QUOROM statement: Review. Lancet 354:1896–1900
Muller-Scharer H (1991) The impact of root herbivory as a function of plant density and competition: survival, growth and fecundity of Centaurea maculosa in field plots. Journal of Applied Ecology 28:759–776
Nagel WP, Isaacson DL (1974) Tyria jacobaea and tansy ragwort in western Oregon. Journal of Economic Entomology 67:494–496
Naish RW (1975) Dowco 290: A new growth regulator herbicide. Proceedings of the 28th New Zealand Weed Pest Control Conference, pp 177–180
Pemberton RW, Turner CE (1990) Biological control of Senecio jacobaea in Northern California, an enduring success. Entomophaga 35:71–77
Pullin AS, Knight TM (2001) Effectiveness in conservation practice: Pointers from medicine and public health. Conservation Biology 15:50–54
Pullin AS, Stewart GB (2006) Guidelines for systematic review in conservation and environmental management. Conservation Biology 20:1647–1656
Pullin AS, Knight TM, Stone DA, Charman K (2004) Do conservation managers use scientific evidence to support their decision-making? Biological Conservation 119:245–252
Roberts PD, Stewart GB, Pullin AS (2006) Are review articles a reliable source of evidence to support conservation and environmental management? A comparison with medicine. Biological Conservation 132:409–423
Schmidl L (1972) Studies on the control of ragwort, Senecio jacobaea L., with the cinnabar moth, Callimorpha jacobaeae (L.) (Arctiidae: Lepidoptera), in Victoria. Weed Research 12:46–57
Shiban A (1976) Effects of herbicides on ragwort. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Aberdeen, U.K
Simpson N (1993) A summary review of information on the autecology and control of six grassland weed species, English Nature Research Report No. 44, Peterborough, U.K
Steinger T, Muller-Scharer H (1992) Physiological and growth responses of Centaurea maculosa (Asteraceae) to root herbivory under varying levels of interspecific plant competition and soil nutrient availability. Ocecologia 91:141–149
Stevens A, Milne R (1997) The effectiveness revolution and public health. In: G Scally (ed) Progress in public health. Royal Society of Medicine Press, London, U.K, pp 197–225
Sutton AJ, Abrams KR, Jones DR, Sheldon TA, Song F (2000) Methods for Meta-Analysis in Medical Research. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester U.K
Thompson A (1974) Herbicide effects on ragwort and pasture. Proceedings of the 27th New Zealand Weed and Pest Control Conference, pp 90–93
Thompson A (1980) Ragwort population and control studies. Proceedings of the 33rd New Zealand Weed and Pest Control Conference, pp 55–62
Thompson A, (1983) Pasture weed control by rope wick applicator. Proceedings 36th New Zealand Weed and Pest Control Conference, pp 96–98
Thompson A, Saunders A (1984) A comparison of 2,4-D and MCPA, alone and in combination, for the control of ragwort. Proceedings 37th New Zealand Weed and Pest Control Conference, pp 33–36
Thompson SG, Sharp SJ (1999). Explaining heterogeneity in meta-analysis: a comparison of methods. Statistics in Medicine 18:2693–2708
Vrieling K, van Wijk CAM (1994) Cost assessment of the production of pyrrolizidine alkaloids in ragwort (Senecio jacobaea L.). Oecologia 97:541–546
Whitson TD, Hawkes B, Brown J, Humphrey D, Langland D (1986) Effect of herbicide treatments on tansy ragwort control. Research progress report Western Society of Weed Science 1986:53–54
Windig JJ (1993) Intensity of Longitarsus jacobaeae herbivory and mortality of Senecio jacobaea. Journal of Applied Ecology 30:179–186
Wolf FM, Guevara JP (2001) Imputation of missing data in systematic reviews: So what is the standard deviation? Cochrane Review Handbook. John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester, UK
Zar JH (1984) Biostatistical Analysis, 2nd edn. Prentice-Hall International, Upper Saddle River, NJ
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank NERC and English Nature for supporting P.D.R. for this systematic review through a CASE PhD stipend. We would especially like to thank Kevin Charman, John Bacon, and Roger Key from English Nature (U.K.) and Matthew Oates from The National Trust (U.K.), the staff at the Centre for Evidence-Based Conservation, especially Gavin Stewart, for all their support and provision of additional information. We would also like to thank all the practitioners and policy makers who responded to enquires for further information.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Roberts, P., Pullin, A. The Effectiveness of Management Interventions Used to Control Ragwort Species. Environmental Management 39, 691–706 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-006-0039-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-006-0039-7