Abstract
This paper addresses significant misconceptions regarding the etiology of fractures in infants and young children in cases of suspected child abuse. This consensus statement, supported by the Child Abuse Committee and endorsed by the Board of Directors of the Society for Pediatric Radiology, synthesizes the relevant scientific data distinguishing clinical, radiologic and laboratory findings of metabolic disease from findings in abusive injury. This paper discusses medically established epidemiology and etiologies of childhood fractures in infants and young children. The authors also review the body of evidence on the role of vitamin D in bone health and the relationship between vitamin D and fractures. Finally, the authors discuss how courts should properly assess, use, and limit medical evidence and medical opinion testimony in criminal and civil child abuse cases to accomplish optimal care and protection of the children in these cases.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Strouse PJ (2013) ‘Keller & Barnes’ after 5 years — still inadmissible as evidence. Pediatr Radiol 43:1423–1424
Botash AS, Sills IN, Welch TR (2012) Calciferol deficiency mimicking abusive fractures in infants: is there any evidence? J Pediatr 160:199–203
Slovis TL, Chapman S (2008) Evaluating the data concerning vitamin D insufficiency/deficiency and child abuse. Pediatr Radiol 38:1221–1224
Slovis TL, Strouse PJ, Coley BD et al (2012) The creation of non-disease: an assault on the diagnosis of child abuse. Pediatr Radiol 42:903–905
Block RW (1999) Child abuse — controversies and imposters. Curr Probl Pediatr 29:253–272
Sedlak AJ, Mettenburg J, Basena M et al (2010) Fourth national incidence study of child abuse and neglect (NIS–4): report to Congress, executive summary. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families, Washington, DC
Loder RT, O’Donnell PW, Feinberg JR (2006) Epidemiology and mechanisms of femur fractures in children. J Pediatr Orthop 26:561–566
Spady DW, Saunders DL, Schopflocher DP et al (2004) Patterns of injury in children: a population-based approach. Pediatrics 113:522–529
Rennie L, Court-Brown CM, Mok JYQ et al (2007) The epidemiology of fractures in children. Injury 38:913–922
Leventhal JM, Martin KD, Asnes AG (2008) Incidence of fractures attributable to abuse in young hospitalized children: results from analysis of a United States database. Pediatrics 122:599–604
Marlowe A, Pepin MG, Byers PH (2002) Testing for osteogenesis imperfecta in cases of suspected non-accidental injury. J Med Genet 39:382–386
Ravichandiran N, Schuh S, Bejuk M et al (2010) Delayed identification of pediatric abuse-related fractures. Pediatrics 125:60–66
Thorpe EL, Zuckerbraun NS, Wolford JE et al (2014) Missed opportunities to diagnose child physical abuse. Pediatr Emerg Care 30:771–776
Wood JN, Feudtner C, Medina SP et al (2012) Variation in occult injury screening for children with suspected abuse in selected US children’s hospitals. Pediatrics 130:853–860
Taitz J, Moran K, O’Meara M (2004) Long bone fractures in children under 3 years of age: is abuse being missed in emergency department presentations? J Paediatr Child Health 40:170–174
Lindberg D, Beaty B, Juarez-Colunga E et al (2015) Testing for abuse in children with sentinel injuries. Pediatrics 136:831–838
(2015) Child maltreatment 2013. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, DC. https://www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/cb/cm2013.pdf. Accessed 23 Oct 2015
Flaherty EG, Perez-Rossello JM, Levine MA et al (2014) Evaluating children with fractures for child physical abuse. Pediatrics 133:477–489
Farrell C, Rubin DM, Downes K et al (2012) Symptoms and time to medical care in children with accidental extremity fractures. Pediatrics 129:128–133
Eastwood D (1998) Breaks without bruises. Are common and can’t be said to rule out non-accidental injury. BMJ 317:1095–1096
Mathew MO, Ramamohan N, Bennet GC (1998) Importance of bruising associated with paediatric fractures: prospective observational study. BMJ 317:1117–1118
Peters ML, Starling SP, Barnes-Eley ML et al (2008) The presence of bruising associated with fractures. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 162:877–881
Valvano TJ, Binns HJ, Flaherty EG et al (2009) Does bruising help determine which fractures are caused by abuse? Child Maltreat 14:376–381
Wood JN, Fakeye O, Feudtner C et al (2014) Development of guidelines for skeletal survey in young children with fractures. Pediatrics 134:45–53
Manson JE, Bassuk SS (2015) Vitamin D research and clinical practice: at a crossroads. JAMA 313:1311–1312
Welsh P, Sattar N (2014) Vitamin D and chronic disease prevention. BMJ 348:g2280
Welsh P, Sattar N (2014) Vitamin D genes and mortality. BMJ 349:g6599
Powe CE, Evans MK, Wenger J et al (2013) Vitamin D-binding protein and vitamin D status of black Americans and white Americans. N Engl J Med 369:1991–2000
Ross AC, Manson JE, Abrams SA et al (2011) The 2011 report on dietary reference intakes for calcium and vitamin D from the Institute of Medicine: what clinicians need to know. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 96:53–58
Christakos S, Hewison M, Gardner DG et al (2013) Vitamin D: beyond bone. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1287:45–58
Bouillon R, Van Schoor NM, Gielen E et al (2013) Optimal vitamin D status: a critical analysis on the basis of evidence-based medicine. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 98:1283–1304
Shah D, Gupta P (2015) Vitamin D deficiency: is the pandemic for real? Indian J Community Med 40:215–217
Theodaratou E, Tzoulaki L, Zgaga L et al (2014) Vitamin D and multiple health outcomes: umbrella review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses of observational studies and randomized trials. BMJ 348:g2035
Institute of Medicine (2011) Dietary reference intakes for calcium and vitamin D. The National Academies Press, Washington, DC
Wagner CL, Greer FR (2008) Prevention of rickets and vitamin D deficiency in infants, children, and adolescents. Pediatrics 122:1142–1152
Misra M, Pacaud D, Petryk A et al (2008) Vitamin D deficiency in children and its management: review of current knowledge and recommendations. Pediatrics 122:398–417
Braegger C, Campoy C, Colomb V et al (2013) Vitamin D in the healthy European paediatric population. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 56:692–701
Alonso MA, Pallavicini ZF, Rodríguez J et al (2015) Can vitamin D status be assessed by serum 25OHD in children? Pediatr Nephrol 30:327–332
Schilling S, Wood JN, Levine MA et al (2011) Vitamin D status in abused and nonabused children younger than 2 years old with fractures. Pediatrics 127:835
Contreras JJ, Hiestand B, O’Neill JC et al (2014) Vitamin D deficiency in children with fractures. Pediatr Emerg Care 30:777–781
Gordon CM, Feldman HA, Sinclair L et al (2008) Prevalence of vitamin D deficiency among healthy infants and toddlers. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 162:505–512
Shore RM, Chesney RW (2013) Rickets: part II. Pediatr Radiol 43:152–172
Shore RM, Chesney RW (2013) Rickets: part I. Pediatr Radiol 43:140–151
Perez-Rosello JM, Feldman HA, Kleinman PK et al (2012) Rachitic changes, demineralization, and fracture risk in healthy infants and toddlers with Vitamin D deficiency. Radiology 262:234–241
Fraser D, Kooh SW, Scriver CR (1967) Hyperparathyroidism as the cause of hyperaminoaciduria and phosphaturia in human vitamin D deficiency. Pediatr Res 1:425–435
Moon RJ, Harvey NC, Davies JH et al (2014) Vitamin D and skeletal health in infancy and childhood. Osteoporos Int 25:2673–2684
Parfitt AM (2004) Vitamin D and the pathogenesis of rickets and osteomalacia. In: Feldman D, Pike J, Glorieux F (eds) Vitamin D, 2nd edn. Elsevier, London, pp 1029–1048
Chapman T, Sugar N, Done S et al (2010) Fractures in infants and toddlers with rickets. Pediatr Radiol 40:1184–1189
Perez-Rossello JM, McDonald AG, Rosenberg AE et al (2015) Absence of rickets in infants with fatal abusive head trauma and classic metaphyseal lesions. Radiology 275:810–821
Jenny C (2014) Alternate theories of causation in abusive head trauma: what the science tells us. Pediatr Radiol 44:S543–S547
Muhe L, Lulseged S, Mason KE et al (1997) Case-control study of the role of nutritional rickets in the risk of developing pneumonia in Ethiopian children. Lancet 349:1801–1804
Kovacs CS (2011) Fetal mineral homeostasis. In: Glorieux FH, Pettifor JM, Jüppner H (eds) Pediatric bone: biology & diseases. Elsevier, London, pp 271–302
Kovacs CS (2012) The role of vitamin D in pregnancy and lactation: insights from animal models and clinical studies. Annu Rev Nutr 32:97–123
Dabezies EJ, Warren PD (1997) Fractures in very low birth weight infants with rickets. Clin Orthop Relat Res 335:233–239
Koo W, Sherman R, Succop P et al (1989) Serum vitamin D metabolites in very low birth weight infants with and without rickets and fractrues. J Pediatr 114:1017–1022
Shore RM (2013) Metabolic bone disease. In: Coley BD (ed) Caffey’s pediatric diagnostic imaging, 12th edn. Saunders, Philadelphia, pp 1523–1534
Fox GN, Maier MK (1984) Neonatal craniotabes. Am Fam Physician 30:149–151
Pettifor JM, Pentopoulos M, Moodley GP et al (1984) Is craniotabes a pathognomonic sign of rickets in 3-month-old infants? S Afr Med J 65:549–551
Kokkonen J, Koivisto M, Lautala P et al (1983) Serum calcium and 25-OH-D3 in mothers of newborns with craniotabes. J Perinat Med 11:127–131
Teotia M, Teotia SP, Nath M (1995) Metabolic studies in congenital vitamin D deficiency rickets. Indian J Pediatr 62:55–61
Al-Senan K, Al-Alaiyan S, Al-Abbad A et al (2001) Congenital rickets secondary to untreated maternal renal failure. J Perinatol 21:473–475
Wang LY, Hung HY, Hsu CH et al (1997) Congenital rickets — a patient report. J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab 10:437–441
Mohapatra A, Sankaranarayanan K, Kadam SS et al (2003) Congenital rickets. J Trop Pediatr 49:126–127
Gradus D, Le Roith D, Karplus M et al (1981) Congenital hyperparathyroidism and rickets: secondary to maternal hypoparathyroidism and vitamin D deficiency. Isr J Med Sci 17:705–708
Kovacs CS (2011) Fetus, neonate and infant. In: Feldman D, Pike JW, Adams JS (eds) Vitamin D, 3rd edn. Elsevier, London, pp 625–646
(2015) ACR-SPR practice parameter for skeletal surveys in children. American College of Radiology, Reston. http://www.acr.org/Quality-Safety/Standards-Guidelines/Practice-Guidelines-by-Modality/Pediatric. Accessed 23 Oct 2015
Kemp AM, Dunstan F, Harrison S et al (2008) Patterns of skeletal fractures in child abuse: systematic review. BMJ 337:a1518
Kleinman PK, Marks SC Jr, Spevak MR et al (1991) Extension of growth-plate cartilage into the metaphysis: a sign of healing fracture in abused infants. AJR Am J Roentgenol 156:775–779
Caffey J (1972) The parent-infant traumatic stress syndrome (Caffey-Kempe syndrome), (battered babe syndrome). Am J Roentgenol Radium Ther Nucl Med 114:218–229
Duffy SO, Squires J, Fromkin JB et al (2011) Use of skeletal surveys to evaluate for physical abuse: analysis of 703 consecutive skeletal surveys. Pediatrics 127:e47–e52
Meyer JS, Gunderman R, Coley BD et al (2011) Appropriateness criteria® on suspected physical abuse — child. J Am Coll Radiol 8:87–94
Pandya NK, Baldwin K, Wolfgruber H et al (2009) Child abuse and orthopaedic injury patterns: analysis at a level I pediatric trauma center. J Pediatr Orthop 29:618–625
Wood JN, Fakeye O, Mondestin V et al (2014) Prevalence of abuse among young children with femur fractures: a systematic review. BMC Pediatr 14:169
Thomas SA, Rosenfield NS, Leventhal JM et al (1991) Long-bone fractures in young children: distinguishing accidental injuries from child abuse. Pediatrics 88:471–476
Harper NS, Eddleman S, Lindberg DM et al (2013) The utility of follow-up skeletal surveys in child abuse. Pediatrics 131:e672–e678
Singh R, Squires J, Fromkin JB et al (2012) Assessing the use of follow-up skeletal surveys in children with suspected physical abuse. J Trauma Acute Care Surg 73:972–976
Zimmerman S, Makoroff K, Care M et al (2005) Utility of follow-up skeletal surveys in suspected child physical abuse evaluations. Child Abuse Negl 29:1075–1083
Barsness KA, Cha ES, Bensard DD et al (2003) The positive predictive value of rib fractures as an indicator of nonaccidental trauma in children. J Trauma 54:1107–1110
Kleinman PK, Marks SC Jr (1996) A regional approach to classic metaphyseal lesions in abused infants: the distal tibia. AJR Am J Roentgenol 166:1207–1212
Kleinman PK, Marks SC, Blackbourne B (1986) The metaphyseal lesion in abused infants: a radiologic-histopathologic study. AJR Am J Roentgenol 146:895–905
Tsai A, McDonald AG, Rosenberg AE et al (2014) High-resolution CT with histopathological correlates of the classic metaphyseal lesion of infant abuse. Pediatr Radiol 44:124–140
Thompson A, Bertocci G, Kaczor K et al (2015) Biomechanical investigation of the classic metaphyseal lesion using an immature porcine model. AJR Am J Roentgenol 204:W503–W509
Faden MA, Krakow D, Ezgu F et al (2009) The Erlenmeyer flask bone deformity in the skeletal dysplasias. Am J Med Genet A 149A:1334–1345
Sinigaglia R, Gigante C, Bisinella G et al (2008) Musculoskeletal manifestations in pediatric acute leukemia. J Pediatr Orthop 28:20–28
Kogutt MS, Swischuk LE, Fagan CJ (1974) Patterns of injury and significance of uncommon fractures in the battered child syndrome. Am J Roentgenol Radium Ther Nucl Med 121:143–149
(2015) Child abuse prevention. Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta. http://www.cdc.gov/Features/HealthyChildren/. Accessed 23 Oct 2015
Koc F, Oral R, Butteris R (2014) Missed cases of multiple forms of abuse and neglect. Int J Psychiatry Med 47:131–139
Jenny C, Hymel KP, Ritzen A et al (1999) Analysis of missed cases of abusive head trauma. JAMA 281:621–626
Lindberg DM, Shapiro RA, Laskey AL et al (2012) Prevalence of abusive injuries in siblings and household contacts of physically abused children. Pediatrics 130:193–201
McEwen BS (2007) Physiology and neurobiology of stress and adaptation: central role of the brain. Physiol Rev 87:873–904
Widom CS (1989) The cycle of violence. Science 244:160–166
Fang X, Brown DS, Florence CS et al (2012) The economic burden of child maltreatment in the United States and implications for prevention. Child Abuse Negl 36:156–165
Moreno JA (2013) What do pediatric healthcare experts really need to know about Daubert and the rules of evidence? Pediatr Radiol 43:135–139
Campbell KA, Olson LM, Keenan HT (2015) Critical elements in the medical evaluation of suspected child physical abuse. Pediatrics 136:35–43
(2012) ACR appropriateness criteria®: suspected physical abuse – child. American College of Radiology. http://www.acr.org/~/media/300cc40d9d3e4e498bd77074af814c68.pdf. Accessed 23 Oct 2015
Mendelson KL (2005) Critical review of ‘temporary brittle bone disease’. Pediatr Radiol 35:1036–1040
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflicts of interest
Dr. Christian and Dr. Palusci provide medico-legal expert work in child abuse cases. All other authors have no disclosures.
Additional information
This review was endorsed by the Society for Pediatric Radiology Board of Directors on Nov. 29, 2015.
Sabah Servaes, Stephen D. Brown, Arabinda K. Choudhary, Laura L. Hayes, and Joëlle A. Moreno are members of the Child Abuse Committee of the Society for Pediatric Radiology.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Servaes, S., Brown, S.D., Choudhary, A.K. et al. The etiology and significance of fractures in infants and young children: a critical multidisciplinary review. Pediatr Radiol 46, 591–600 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00247-016-3546-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00247-016-3546-6