Abstract
Due to the strong demand for low-cost and highly efficient products, various approaches are currently being explored and applied so as to contribute to the development and optimization of 4D printing technology. Significant progress is being made in this area of advanced manufacturing, and this comparative study helps to understand the latest developments in materials, additive techniques, and future prospects for this technology. It should, however, be noted that a large amount of progress still remains to be made. While some of the research has focused on the performance of the materials, the rest has focused on the development of new methods and techniques in additive manufacturing. This review critically evaluates the current 4D printing technologies, including the development and optimization of printing methods as well as to the printed objects. Previous developments in this area and contributions to the modern trend in manufacturing technology are briefly summarized. The review is divided into three sections. Firstly, the existing printing methods along with the frequently used printing materials as well as the processing parameters, and the factors which influence the quality and mechanical performances of the printed objects are discussed. Secondly, the optimization techniques, such as topology, shape, structure, and mechanical property, are described. Thirdly, the latest development and applications of additive manufacturing are depicted, and suggestions concerning the scope of future research are put forward.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- 3D:
-
Three dimensional
- 3DP:
-
3D printing
- 4DP:
-
4D printing
- ABS:
-
Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene
- AM:
-
Additive manufacturing
- CFRTC:
-
Continuous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic composites
- CLIP:
-
Continuous liquid interface production
- DE:
-
Dielectric elastomer
- DED:
-
Directed energy deposition
- DLF:
-
Directed light fabrication
- DMD:
-
Direct metal deposition
- EAP:
-
Electroactive polymer
- FDM:
-
Fused deposition modeling
- LBMD:
-
Laser-based metal deposition
- LCE:
-
Liquid crystal elastomer
- LENS:
-
Laser engineering net shaping
- LFF:
-
Laser freeform fabrication
- LOM:
-
Laminated object manufacturing
- PCL:
-
Polycaprolactone
- PLA:
-
Polylactic acid
- PVA:
-
Polyvinyl alcohol
- PEEK:
-
Polyether ether ketone
- SCE:
-
Shape change effect
- SLA:
-
Stereolithography
- SLM:
-
Selective laser melting
- SLS:
-
Selective laser sintering
- SMA:
-
Shape-memory alloy
- SME:
-
Shape-memory effect
- SMMs:
-
Shape-memory materials
- SMP:
-
Shape-memory polymer
- SMPC:
-
Shape-memory polymer composite
- UV:
-
Ultraviolet
References
Wohler T, Gornet T (2014) History of additive manufacturing. Wohlers Report. [Online]. Available: http://www.wohlersassociates.com/history2014.pdf. Accessed 10 Feb 2019.
Lee AY, An J, Chua CK (2017) Two-way 4D printing: a review on the reversibility of 3d-printed shape memory materials. Engineering 3(5):663–674
Huang W, Ding Z, Wang C, Wei J, Zhao Y, Purnawali H (2010) Shape memory materials. Mater Today 13:54–61
Wu J, Huang LM, Zhao Q, Xie T (2017) 4D printing: history and recent progress. Chin J Polym Sci 36:563–575
Tumbleston JR, Shirvanyants D, Ermoshkin N, Janusziewicz R, Johnson AR, Kelly D, Chen K, Pinschmidt R, Rolland JP, Ermoshkin A, Samulski ET, DeSimone JM (2015) Additive manufacturing. Continuous liquid interface production of 3D objects. Science 347(6228):1349–1352
Gebhardt A, Hotter J-S, Ziebura D (2014) Impact of SLM build parameters on the surface quality. RTE J 11
Davis FJ, Mitchell GR (2011) Polymeric materials for rapid manufacturing in rapid manufacturing. In: Bártolo PJ (ed.) Stereolithography: Materials, Processes and Applications. Springer, Boston, pp 113–139
Simmons D BBC News, 6 May 2015. [Online]. Available: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-32597809. [Accessed 10 February 2019]
Davies A Business Insider, 28 February 2014. [Online]. Available: https://www.businessinsider.com/koenigsegg-one1-comes-with-3d-printed-parts-2014-2. [Accessed 10 February 2019].
Grush L The Verge, 17 January 2019. [Online]. Available: https://www.theverge.com/2019/1/17/18185136/relativity-space-3d-printing-terran-1-rocket-cape-canaveral-florida. [Accessed 11 March 2019].
Tibbits S, McKnelly C, Olguin C, Dikovsky D, Hirsch S (2014) 4D printing and universal transformation. Proceedings of the 34th Annual Conference of the Association for Computer Aided Design in Architecture, pp. 539–548
Pei E (2014) 4D printing: dawn of an emerging technology cycle. Assem Autom 34(4):310–314
Parandoush P, Lin D (2017) A review on additive manufacturing of polymer-fiber composites. Compos Struct 182:36–53
Leist SK, Zhou J (2016) Current status of 4D printing technology and the potential of light-reactive smart materials as 4D printable materials. Virtual Phys Prototyping 11(4):249–262
Mu T, Liu L, Lan X, Liu Y, Leng J (2018) Shape memory polymers for composites. Compos Sci Technol 160:169–198
Khoo ZX, Teoh JEM, Liu Y, Chua CK, Yang S, An J, Leong KF, Yeong WY (2015) 3D printing of smart materials: a review on recent progresses in 4D printing. Virtual Phys Prototyping 10(3):103–122
Choong YYC, Maleksaeedi S, Eng H, Wei J, Su P-C (2017) 4D printing of high performance shape memory polymer using stereolithography. Mater Des 126:219–225
Pei E, Loh GH (2018) Technological considerations for 4D printing: an overview. Progr Addit Manuf 3(1–2):95–107
Naficy S, Gately R, Gorkin R III, Xin H, Spinks GM (2017) 4D printing of reversible shape morphing hydrogel structures, Macromol Mater Eng 302
Felton S, Tolley M, Demaine E, Rus D, Wood R (2014) A method for building self-folding machines. Science 345(6197):644–646
Malukhin K, Ehmann K (2006) Material characterization of NiTi based memory alloys fabricated by the laser direct metal deposition process. J Manuf Sci Eng 128(3):691–696
Krishna BV, Bose S, Bandyopadhyay A (2007) Laser processing of net-shape NiTi shape memory alloy. Metall Mater Trans A 38(5):1096–1103
Krishna BV, Bose S, Bandyopadhyay A (2009) Fabrication of porous NiTi shape memory alloy structures using laser engineered net shaping. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater 89B(2):481–490
Halani PR, Kaya I, Shin YC, Karaca HE (2013) Phase transformation characteristics and mechanical characterization of nitinol synthesized by laser direct deposition. Mater Sci Eng A 559:836–843
Tian X, Liu T, Yang C, Wang Q, Li D (2016) Interface and performance of 3D printed continuous carbon fiber reinforced PLA composites. Compos Part A 88:198–205
Tian X, Liu T, Wang Q, Dilmurat A, Li D, Ziegmann G (2017) Recycling and remanufacturing of 3D printed continuous carbon fiber reinforced PLA composites. J Clean Prod 142:1609–1618
Wang Q, Tian X, Huang L, Li D, Malakhov AV, Polilov AN (2018) Programmable morphing composites with embedded continuous fibers by 4D printing. Mater Des 155:404–413
Kang M, Pyo Y, Jang JY, Park Y, Son Y-H, Choi MC, Ha JW, Chang Y-W, Lee CS (2018) Design of a shape memory composite (SMC) using 4D printing technology. Sensors Actuators A(283):187–195
Bodaghi M, Damanpack A, Liao W (2017) Adaptive metamaterials by functionally graded 4D printing. Mater Des 135:26–36
Lu L, Fuh J, Wong Y-S (2001) Laser-induced materials and process for rapid prototyping. Springer Science & Business Media, New York
Gibson I, Rosen D, Stucker B (2010) Additive Manufactoring Tecnologies: Rapid Prototyping to Direct Digital Manufacturing. Springer, New York
Zhao T, Yu R, Li X, Cheng B, Zhang Y, Yang X, Zhao X, Zhao Y, Huang W (2018) 4D printing of shape memory polyurethane via stereolithography. Eur Polym J 101:120–126
Shahzad K, Deckers J, Zhang Z, Kruth J-P, Vleugels J (2014) Additive manufacturing of zirconia parts by indirect selective laser sintering. J Eur Ceram Soc 34(1):81–89
Bai J, Goodridge RD, Hague RJM, Song M (2013) Improving the mechanical properties of laser-sintered polyamide 12 through incorporation of carbon nanotubes. Polym Eng Sci 53
Tan X, Tan YJ (2019) 3D printing of metallic cellular scaffolds for bone implants, in 3D and 4D printing in biomedical applications. Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Hoboken, pp 297–316
Khoo Z, Liu Y, An J, Chua C, Shen Y, Kuo C (2018) A review of selective laser melted NiTi shape memory alloy. Materials 11:4
Shishkovsky I, Yadroitsev I, Smurov I (2012) Direct selective laser melting of nitinol powder. Phys Procedia 39:447–454
Haberland C, Meier H, Frenzel J (2012) On the properties of Ni-rich NiTi shape memory parts produced by selective laser melting. In Volume 1: Development and characterization of multifunctional materials; modeling, simulation and control of adaptive systems; structural health monitoring, Stone Mountain, Georgia, USA
Dadbakhsh S, Speirs M, Kruth J-P, Schrooten J, Luyten J, Van Humbeeck J (2014) Effect of SLM parameters on transformation temperature of shape memory nickel titanium parts. Adv Eng Mater 16(9):1140–1146
Gustmann T, dos Santos JM, Gargarella P, Kuhn U, Van Humbeeck J, Pauly S (2016) Properties of Cu-based shape-memory alloys prepared by selective laser melting. Shape Mem Superelasticity 3(1):24–36
Mazzer EM, Kiminami CS, Gargarella P, Cava RD, Basilio LA, Bolfarini C, Botta WJ, Eckert J, Gutsmann T, Pauly S (2014) Atomization and selective laser melting of a Cu-Al-Ni-Mn shape memory alloy. Mater Sci Forum 802:343–348
Gargarella P, Kiminami CS, Mazzer EM, Cava RD, Basilio LA, Bolfarini C, Botta WJ, Eskerf J, Gustmann T, Pauly S (2015) Phase formation, thermal stability and mechanical properties of a Cu-Al-Ni-Mn shape memory alloy prepared by selective laser melting. Mater Res 18(supple 2):35–38
Li R, Shi Y, Liu J, Xie Z, Wang Z (2009) Selective laser melting W-10 wt.% Cu composite powders. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 48(5–8):597–605
Niendorf T, Brenne F, Krooß P, Vollmer M, Günther J, Schwarze D, Biermann H (2016) Microstructural evolution and functional properties of Fe-Mn-Al-Ni shape memory alloy processed by selective laser melting. Metall Mater Trans A 47(6):2569–2573
Gibson I, Rosen D, Stucker B (2015) Directed energy deposition processes. In Additive manufacturing technologies. 3D printing, rapid prototyping, and direct digital manufacturing. 2nd Edition. New York, Springer, pp 245–268
Marattukalam JJ, Singh AK, Datta S, Das M, Balla VK, Bontha S, Kalpathy SK (2015) Microstructure and corrosion behavior of laser processed NiTi alloy. Mater Sci Eng C 57:309–313
Xu X, Ling X, Yang M, Chen J, Huang W (2009) Microstructure evolution in laser solid forming of Ti-50wt% Ni alloy. J Alloys Compd 480(2):7820787
Bernard S, Balla VK, Bose S, Bandyopadhyay A (2012) Compression fatigue behavior of laser processed porous NiTi alloy. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater 13:62–68
Li X, Jianzhong S, Wong Z (2017) Intelligent materials: a review of applications in 4D printing. Assem. Autom. 37(2). https://doi.org/10.1108/AA-11-2015-093/full/html
Campbell T, Tibbits S, Garrett B (2014) The next wave: 4D printing-programming the material world. Atlantic Council, Washington DC
Wang J, Wang Z, Song Z, Ren L, Liu Q, Ren L (2019) Biomimetic shape–color double-responsive 4D printing. Advanced Materials Technologies. John Wiley & Sons, Inc, Hoboken
Ning J, Sievers D, Harmestani H, Liang S (2019) Analytical modeling of in-process temperature in powder bed manufacturing considering laser power absorption, latent heat, scanning strategy, and powder packing. Materials 12:5
Ali MH, Yerbolat G, Islam G, Amangeldi S, Zhao MY (2019) Shape optimization for composite polymers in 3D printing. Int J Innov Technol Exploring Eng (8, 6C2):55–61
Miao S, Castro N, Nowicki M, Xia L, Cui H, Zhou X, Zhang LG (2017) 4D printing of polymeric materials for tissue and organ regeneration. Mater Today 20(10):577–591
Mao Y, Ding Z, Yuan C, Ai S, Isakov M, Wu J, Wang T, Dunn ML, Qi HJ (2016) 3D printed reversible shape changing components with stimuli responsive materials. Sci Rep 6:24761. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep24761
Trnková P, Knäusl B, Actis O, Bert C, Biegun AK, Boehlen TT, Furtado H, McClelland J, Mori S, Rinaldi I, Rucinski A, Knopf AC (2018) Clinical implementations of 4D pencil beam scanned particle therapy: report on the 4D treatment planning workshop 2016 and 2017. Phys Med 54:121–130
Zhou Y, Huang W, Kang S, Wu X, Lu H, Fu J, Cui H (2015) Smart three-dimensional lightweight structure triggered from a thin composite sheet via 3D printing technique. Sci Rep 6:1
Zhang Q, Zhang K, Hu G (2016) Smart three-dimensional lightweight structure triggered from a thin composite sheet via 3D printing technique. Sci Rep 6(1)
Banudevi S (2016) Current perspectives on printing technology for biomedical applications. Biochem Physiol: Open Access 5:e154
Teoh JE, Zhao Y, An J, Chua CK, Liu Y (2017) Multi-stage responsive 4D printed smart structure through varying geometric thickness of shape memory polymer. Smart Mater Struct 26(12):125001
Liu Y (2010) Some factors affecting the transformation hysteresis in shape memory alloys. In Shape Memory Alloys, Nova Science Publisher, New York, pp 361–369
Ge Q, Dunn CK, Qi HJ, Dunn ML (2014) Active origami by 4D printing. Smart Mater Struct 23(9)
Tobushi H, Hayashi S, Pieczyska E, Date K, Nishimura Y (2011) Three-way shape memory composite actuator. Mater Sci Forum 674:225–230
Auricchio F, Boatti E, Conti M (2015) SMA biomedical applications. In Shape memory alloy engineering. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 307–341. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-099920-3.00011-5
Van Humbeeck J (2001) Shape memory alloys: a material and a technology. Adv Eng Mater 3:11
Hamilton RF, Palmer TA, Bimber BA (2015) Spatial characterization of the thermal-induced phase transformation throughout as-deposited additive manufactured NiTi bulk builds. Scr Mater 101:56–59
Caputo MP, Berkowitz AE, Armstrong A, Mullner P, Solomon CV (2018) 4D printing of net shape parts made from Ni-Mn-Ga magnetic shape memory alloys. Addit Manuf 21:579–588
Dasgupta R (2014) A look into Cu-based shape memory alloys: present scenario and future prospects. J Mater Res 29(16):1681–1698
V. L. &. V. H.M., Process of manufacturing articles of thermoplastic synthetic resins. USA Patent US124460A, 18 March 1941
Zhou Y, Huang W, Kang S, Wu X, Lu H, Fu J, Cui H (2015) From 3D to 4D printing: approaches and typical applications. J Mech Sci Technol 29(10):4281–4288
Xie T (2010) Tunable polymer multi-shape memory effect. Nature 464(7286):267–270
Xie T, Rousseau IA (2009) Facile tailoring of thermal transition temperatures of epoxy shape memory polymers. Polymer 50(8):1852–1856
Ahmed EM (2015) Hydrogel: preparation, characterization, and applications: a review. J Adv Res 6(2):105–121
Bakarich SE, Gorkin R, Panhuis MI, Spinks GM (2015) 4D printing with mechanically robust, thermally actuating hydrogels. Macromol Rapid Commun 36(12):1211–1217
Suo Z (2012) Mechanics of stretchable electronics and soft machines. MRS Bull 37(3):218–225
Jayaramudu T, Li Y, Ko H, Shishir IR, Kim J (2016) Poly(acrylic acid)-poly(vynil alcohol) hydrogels for reconfigurable lens actuators. Int J Precis Eng Manuf-Green Technol 3(4):375–379
Van Wijk A, van Wijk I (2015) Biomaterials. In 3D printing with biomaterials. ISO Press, pp. 35–56
Dong Y, Ghataura A, Takagi H, Haroosh HJ, Nakagaito AN, Lau K-T (2014) Polylactic acid (PLA) biocomposites reinforced with coir fibres: evaluation of mechanical performance and multifunctional properties. Compos Part A 63:76–84
Mulakkal MC, Trask RS, Ting VP, Seddon AM (2018) Responsive cellulose-hydrogel composite ink for 4D printing. Mater Des 160:108–118
Shankar R, Tushar KG, Spontak RJ (2007) Dielectric elastomers as next-generation polymeric actuators. Soft Matter 3(9):1116–1129
Yang Z, Herd GA, Clarke SM, Tajbakhsh AR, Teretjev EM, Huck WTS (2006) Thermal and UV shape shifting of surface topography. J Am Chem Soc 128(4):1074–1075
O'Halloran A, O'Malley F, McHugh P (2008) A review on dielectric elastomer actuators, technology, applications, and challenges. J Appl Phys 104
Rossiter J, Walters P, Stoimenov B (2009) Printing 3D dielectric elastomer actuators for soft robotics. Electroactive Polymer Actuators and Devices 7287
Coulter FB, Ianakiev A (2015) 4D printing inflatable silicone structures. 3D Print Addit Manuf 2(3):140–144
Ambulo CP, Burroughs JJ, Boothby JM, Kim H, Shankar MR, Ware TH Four-dimensional printing of liquid crystal elastomers. ACS 9(42):–37332, 37339
Yuan C, Roach DJ, Dunn CK, Mu Q, Kuang X, Yakacki CM, Wang TJ, Yu K, Qi HJ (2017) 3D printed reversible shape changing soft actuator assisted by liquid crystal elastomer. Soft Matter 13(33):5558–5568
Hu J, Meng H, Li G, Ibekwe SI (2012) A review of stimuli-responsive polymers for smart textile applications. Smart Mater Struct 21:5
Momeni F, Sabzpoushan S, Valizadeh R, Morad MR, Liu X, Ni J (2019) Plant leaf-mimetic smart wind turbine blades by 4D printing. Renew Energy 130:329–351
Momeni F, Ni J (2018) Nature-inspired smart solar concentrators by 4D printing. Renew Energy 122:35–44
Baker AB, Bates SRG, Llewellyn-Jones TM, Valori LPB, Dicker MPM, Trask RS (2019) 4D printing with robust thermoplastic polyurethane hydrogel-elastomer trilayers. Mater Des 163
Liu Y, Zhang W, Zhang F, Lan X, Leng J, Liu S, Jia X, Cotton C, Sun B, Gu B, Chou T-W (2018) Shape memory behavior and recovery force of 4D printed laminated Miura-origami structures subjected to compressive loading. Compos Part B 153:233–242
Gladman AS, Matsumoto EA, Nuzzo RG, Mahadevan L, Lewis JA (2016) Biomimetic 4D printing. Nat Mater 15(4):413–418
Hingorani H, Zhang Y-F, Zhang B, Serjouei A, Ge Q (2019) Modified commercial UV curable elastomers for passive 4D printing. Int J Smart Nano Mater 1–12
Su J-W, Gao W, Trinh K, Kenderes SM, Pulatsu ET, Zhang C, Whittington A, Lin M, Lin J (2019) 4D printing of polyurethane paint-based composites, Int J Smart Nano Mater 1–12
Chen X, Liu X, Ouyang M, Chen J, Taiwo O, Xia Y, Childs PRN, Brandon NP, Wu B (2019) Multi-metal 4D printing with a desktop electrochemical 3D printer. Sci Rep 9
Jeong HY, Lee E, Ha S, Kim N, Jun YC (2018) Multistable thermal actuators via multimaterial 4D printing. Adv Mater Technol
Shiblee MNI, Ahmed K, Kawakami M, Furukawa H (2019) 4D printing of shape-memory hydrogels for soft-robotic functions. Adv Mater Technol
Kuang X, Chen K, Dunn CK, Wu J, Li VCF, Qi HJ (2018) 3D printing of highly stretchable, shape-memory, and self-healing elastomer toward novel 4D printing. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 10(8):7381–7388
Devillard CD, Mandon CA, Lambert SA, Blum LJ, Marquette CA (2018) Bioinspired multi-activities 4D printing objects: a new approach toward complex tissue engineering. Biotechnol J 13(12):e1800098. https://doi.org/10.1002/biot.201800098
Andani MT, Saedi S, Turabi AS, Karamooz MR, Haberland C, Karaca HE, Elahinia M (2017) Mechanical and shape memory properties of porous Ni 50.1 Ti 49.9 alloys manufactured by selective laser melting. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater 68:224–231
Javaid M, Haleem A (2018) 4D printing applications in medical field: a brief review. Clinical Epidemiology and Global Health
An J, Chua CK, Mironov V (2016) A perspective on 4D bioprinting. Int J Bioprinting 2
Mandon C, Blum L, Marquette C (2017) 3D–4D printed objects: new bioactive material opportunities. Micromachines 8(4):102
Behl M, Lendlein A (2011) Shape-memory polymers. Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology
Keall PJ, Joshi S, Vedam SS, Siebers JV, Kini VR, Mohan R (2005) Four-dimensional radiotherapy planning for DMLC-based respiratory motion tracking. Med Phys 32(4):942–951
Pei E, Shen J, Watling J (2015) Direct 3D printing of polymers onto textiles: experimental studies and applications. Rapid Prototyp J 21(5):556–571
Howarth D DEZEEN, 27 February 2019. [Online]. Available: https://www.dezeen.com/2019/02/27/black-panther-best-costume-design-oscar-3d-printing/. [Accessed 3 March 2019]
Liu P, Huang SH, Mokasdar A, Zhou H, Hou L (2013) The impact of additive manufacturing in the aircraft spare parts supply chain: supply chain operation reference (SCOR) model based analysis. Prod Plan Control 25(13–14):1169–1181
Sokolowski W, Tan S, Pryor M (2004) Lightweight shape memory self-deployable structures for gossamer applications. In 45th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics & Materials Conference
Huo SV (2019) Development of composite springs using 4D printing method. Compos Struct 210:869–876
Yoo YI, Lee JJ (2011) Two-way shape memory effect of NiTi under compressive loading cycles. Phys Procedia 22:449–454
Liu Y, Leng J (2010) Applications of shape-memory polymers in aerospace. Shape-Memory Polymers and Multifunctional Composites pp. 233–266
Kamila S (2013) Introduction, classification and applications of smart materials: an overview. Am J Appl Sci 10(8):876–880
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ali, M.H., Abilgaziyev, A. & Adair, D. 4D printing: a critical review of current developments, and future prospects. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 105, 701–717 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-019-04258-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-019-04258-0