Abstract
Allografts have recently become increasingly popular for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) in the United States even though many studies have shown high allograft failure rates (Gorschewsky et al. in Am J Sports Med 33:1202, 2005; Pritchard et al. in Am J Sports Med 23:593, 2005; Roberts et al. in Am J Sports Med 19:35, 2006) and no meta-analysis or systematic review of allograft clinical stability rates in comparison to autog rafts has previously been performed. We hypothesized that allografts would demonstrate overall lower objective stability rates compared to autografts. To test this hypothesis we performed a meta-analysis of autograft and allograft stability data. A pubmed literature search of all allograft series in humans published in English was performed. Articles were then bibliographically cross-referenced to identify additional studies. Series inclusion criteria were arthrometric follow-up data using at least 30 lb or maximum manual force, stratified presentation of stability data and minimum two-year follow-up. Twenty allograft series were thus selected and compared to a previously published data set of all BPTB and Hamstring (HS) autograft ACLR series using the same study inclusion criteria and analytic and statistical methodology. IKDC standards of 0–2 mm (normal) and >5 mm (abnormal) side-to-side differences were adopted to compare studies. Normal stability for all autografts was 72 versus 59% for all allografts (P < 0.01). Abnormal stability was 5% for all autografts versus 14% for all allografts (P < 0.01). Bone-patellar-tendon-bone (BPTB) autograft normal stability was 66% versus 57% for BPTB allografts (P < 0.01). Abnormal BPTB autograft stability was 6 versus 16% for BPTB allograft. Hamstring autograft normal or abnormal stability rates were 77% and 4% and were compared to soft tissue allografts as a group which were 64% and 12% (P < 0.01). This is the first meta-analysis comparing autograft to allograft stability in ACLR. Allografts had significantly lower normal stability rates than autografts. The allograft abnormal stability rate, which usually represents graft failure, was significantly higher than that of autografts: nearly three times greater. It would therefore appear that autografts are the graft of choice for routine ACLR with allografts better reserved for multiple ligament-injured knees where extra tissue may be required.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bach BR Jr, Aadalen KJ, Dennis MG et al (2005) Primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using fresh-frozen, nonirradiated patellar tendon allograft: Minimum 2-yeasr follow-up. Am J Sports Med 33:284–292
Barrett G, Stokes D, White M (2005) Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in patients older than 40 years: allograft versus autograft patellar tendon. Am J Sports Med 33:1505–1512
Carpenter JE, Wojtys EM, Pribble JM (1993) Significance of culture positive patella tendon allografts in ACL reconstruction. In: Presented at the 12th annual meeting of the Arthroscopy Association of North America
Chang SKY, Egami DK, Shaib MD, Kan DM, Richardson AB (2003) Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: allograft versus autograft. Arthroscopy 19:453–462
Clavert P, Kempf JF, Bonnomet F, Boutemy P, Marcelin L, Kahn JL (2001) Effects of freezing/thawing on the biomechanical properties of human tendons. Surg Radiol Anat 23:259–262
Gorschewsky O, Klakow A, Riechert K, Pitzl M, Becker R (2005) Clinical comparison of the tutoplasty allograft and autologous patellar tendon (Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone) for the reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament: 2- and 6-year results. Am J Sports Med 33:1202–1209
Grieb TA, Forng RY, Bogdansky S et al (2006) High-dose gamma irradiation for soft tissue allografts: high margin of safety with biomechanical integrity. J Orthop Res 24:1011–1018
Harner CD, Olson E, Irrgang JJ, Silverstein S, Fu FH, Silbey M (1996) Allograft versus autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: 3- to 5-year outcome. Clin Orthop Relat Res 324:134–144
Indelli PF, Dillingham MF, Fanton GS, Schurman DJ (2004) Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using cryopreserved allografts. Clin Orthop Relat Res 420:268–275
Jackson DW, Grood ES, Goldstein JD et al (1993) A comparison of patellar tendon autograft and allograft used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the goat model. Am J Sports Med 21:176–185
King W, Mangan D, Endean T et al. (2004) Microbial sterilization and viral inactivation in soft tissue allografts using novel applications of high-dose gamma irradiation: Report of a new graft preparation technique and early clinical follow-up. Presented at 2004 meeting of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
Kleipool AEB, Zijl JAC, Willems WJ (1998) Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone allograft or autograft: a prospective study with an average follow up of 4 years. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 6:224–230
Kurzweil PR, Grafe MW (2005) ACL reconstruction with achilles tendon allografts in revisions and patients over 30. Presented at 2005 meeting of the Arthroscopy Association of North America
Levitt RL, Malinin T, Posada A, Michalow A (1994) Reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligaments with bone-patellar tendon-bone and achilles tendon allografts. Clin Orthop Relat Res 303:67–78
Malinin T, Levitt RL, Mnaymneh W, Temple T (2000) Study of retrieved whole ACL replacement allografts five years post implantation. In: Presented at the 19th annual meeting of the Arthroscopy Association of North America
Nikolaou PK, Seaber AV, Glisson RR, Ribbeck BM, Bassett FH (1986) Anterior cruciate ligament allograft transplantation: long-term function, histology, revascularization, and operative technique. Am J Sports Med 14:348–360
Noyes FR, Barber SD (1991) The effect of an extra-articular procedure on allograft reconstructions for chronic ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament. J Bone Joint Surg Am 73-A:882–892
Noyes FR, Barber-Westin SD (1996) Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with human allograft: comparison of early and later results. J Bone Joint Surg Am 78-A:524–537
Noyes FR, Barber-Westin SD (1997) Arthroscopic-assisted allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in patients with symptomatic arthrosis. Arthroscopy 13:24–32
Nyland J, Caborn DNM, Rothbauer J, Kocabey Y, Couch J (2003) Two-year outcomes following ACL reconstruction with allograft tibialis anterior tendons: a retrospective study. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 11:212–218
Olson EJ, Fu FH, Irrgang JJ, Harner CD (1992) Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with sterilely harvested, fresh frozen allograft: four year results. In: Presented at the 11th annual meeting of the Arthroscopy Association of North America
Pedowitz RA, Mahar A, Schmizzi A, Wedemeyrs M, Odell T (2006) Effects of novel sterilization process on soft tissue mechanical properties for anterior cruciate ligament repair. Presented at the 25th annual meeting of the Arthroscopy Association of North America
Peterson RK, Shelton WR, Bomboy AL (2001) Allograft versus autograft patellar tendon anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a 5-year follow-up. Arthroscopy 17:9–13
Poehling GG, Curl WW, Lee C et al (2005) Analysis of outcomes of anterior cruciate ligament repair with 5-year follow-up: allograft versus autograft. Arthroscopy 21:774–785
Pritchard JC, Drez D Jr, Moss M, Heck S (1995) Long-term followup of anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions using freeze-dried fascia lata allografts. Am J Sports Med 23:593–596
Prodromos CC, Han YS, Keller BL, Bolyard RJ (2005) Stability results of hamstring anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction at two- to eight-year follow-up. Arthroscopy 21:138–146
Prodromos CC, Joyce BT, Shi KS, Keller BL (2005) A meta-analysis of stability after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction as a function of hamstring versus patellar tendon graft and fixation type. Arthroscopy 21:1202–1208
Prodromos CC, Fu F, Howell S, Johnson D, Paulos L (2006) Controversies in soft tissue anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Presented at symposium at the 2006 of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
Rihn JA, Irrgang JJ, Chhabra A, Fu FH, Harner CD (2006) Does irradiation affect the clinical outcome of patellar tendon allograft ACL reconstruction? Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 14:885–896
Roberts TS, Drez D Jr, McCarthy W, Paine R (1991) Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using freeze-dried, ethylene oxide-sterilized, bone-patellar tendon-bone allografts: two year results in thirty-six patients. Am J Sports Med 19:35–41
Schulte K, Thompson W, Jamison J, Harner CD, Irrgang JJ (1996) The immunologic response to allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: clinical correlation. In: Presented at the 15th annual meeting of the Arthroscopy Association of North America
Shelton WR, Papendick L, Dukes AD (1997) Autograft versus allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Arthroscopy 13:446–449
Shino K, Kawasaki T, Hirose H, Gotoh I, Inoue M, Ono K (1984) Replacement of the anterior cruciate ligament by an allogenic tendon graft: an experimental study in the dog. J Bone Joint Surg Br 66-A:672–681
Siebold R, Buelow JU, Bos L, Ellerman A (2003) Primary ACL reconstruction with fresh-frozen patellar versus achilles tendon allografts. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 123:180–185
Sterling JC, Meyers MC, Calvo RD (1995) Allograft failure in cruciate ligament reconstruction: follow-up evaluation of eighteen patients. Am J Sports Med 23:173–178
Thorson E, Rodrigo JJ, Vasseur P, Sharkey N, Heitter D (1989) Replacement of the anterior cruciate ligament: a comparison of autografts and allografts in dogs. Acta Orthop Scand 60:555–560
Zalavras CG, Patzakis MJ (2006) Infections in anterior cruciate ligament surgery. In: Prodromos C (ed) The anterior cruciate ligament: reconstruction and basic science. Elsevier, Philadelphia, pp 55–65
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Prodromos, C., Joyce, B. & Shi, K. A meta-analysis of stability of autografts compared to allografts after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthr 15, 851–856 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-007-0328-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-007-0328-6