Abstract
Product improvement and cost reduction have always been important goals in the metal forming industry. The rise of finite element (FEM) simulations for processes has contributed to these goals in a major way. More recently, coupling FEM simulations to mathematical optimisation techniques has shown the potential to make a further giant contribution to product improvement and cost reduction. Much research on the optimisation of metal forming processes has been published during the last couple of years. Although the results are impressive, the optimisation techniques are generally only applicable to specific optimisation problems for specific products and specific metal forming processes. As a consequence, applying optimisation techniques to other metal forming problems requires a lot of optimisation expertise, which forms a barrier for more general industrial application of these techniques. In this paper, we overcome this barrier by proposing a generally applicable optimisation strategy that makes use of FEM simulations of metal forming processes. It consists of a structured methodology for modelling optimisation problems related to metal forming. Subsequently, screening is applied to reduce the size of the optimisation problem by selecting only the most important design variables. Finally, the reduced optimisation problem is solved by an efficient optimisation algorithm. The strategy is generally applicable in a sense that it is not constrained to a certain type of metal forming problem, product or process. Also, any FEM code may be included in the strategy. Furthermore, the structured approach for modelling and solving optimisation problems should enable non-optimisation specialists to apply optimisation techniques to improve their products and processes. The optimisation strategy has been successfully applied to a hydroforming process, which demonstrates the potential of the optimisation of metal forming processes in general and more specific the proposed optimisation strategy.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Abedrabbo N, Zafar N, Averill R, Pourboghrat F, Sidhu R (2004) Optimization of a tube hydroforming process. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
António C, Castro C, Sousa L (2004) Optimization of metal forming processes. Comput Struct 82:1425–1433
Aydemir A, de Vree J, Brekelmans W, Geers M, Sillekens W, Werkhoven R (2005) An adaptive simulation approach design for tube hydroforming processes. J Mater Process Technol 159:303–310
Ben Ayed L, Delamézière A, Batoz J, Knopf-Lenoir C (2004a) Optimization and control of the blankholder force in sheet metal stamping with application to deep drawing of a cylindrical cup. In: Proceedings of ECCOMAS, Jyväskylä, 24–28 July 2004
Ben Ayed L, Delamézière A, Batoz J, Knopf-Lenoir C (2004b) Optimization of the blankholder force with application to the numisheet’02 deep drawing benchmark test b1. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Ben Ayed L, Delamézière A, Batoz J, Knopf-Lenoir C (2005) Optimization of the blankholder force distribution in deep drawing. In: Proceedings of APOMAT, Morschach, 30–31 May 2005
Bonte MHA (2007) Optimisation strategies for metal forming processes. University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands, ISBN: 978-90-365-2523-7
Bonte M, van den Boogaard A, Huétink J (2005a) Metamodelling techniques for the optimisation of metal forming processes. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Cluj-Napoca, pp 155–158
Bonte M, van den Boogaard A, Huétink J (2005b) Solving optimisation problems in metal forming using finite element simulation and metamodelling techniques. In: Proceedings of APOMAT, Morschach, pp 242–251
Bonte M, Do T, Fourment L, van den Boogaard A, Huétink J, Habbal A (2006) A comparison of optimisation algorithms for metal forming processes. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Glasgow, pp 883–886
Bonte M, van den Boogaard A, Huétink J (2007) A metamodel based optimisation algorithm for metal forming processes. In: Banabic D. (ed) Advanced methods in material forming. Springer Verlag, Heidelberg, Germany, pp 55–72
Breitkopf P, Naceur H, Rassineux A, Villon P (2004) Optimizing metal forming processes using response surface approximation and inverse approach surrogate model. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Trondheim, April 2004
Breitkopf P, Naceur H, Rassineux A, Villon P (2005) Moving least squares response surface approximation: Formulation and metal forming applications. Comput Struct 83(17–18):1411–1428
Byon S, Hwang S (2001) FEM-based process optimal design in steady-state metal forming considering strain-hardening. Comput Struct 79(14):1363–1375
Cao J, Li S, Xia Z, Tang S (2001) Analysis of an axisymmetric deep-drawn part forming using reduced forming steps. J Mater Process Technol 117(1–2):193–200
Carrino L, Giuliano G, Napolitano G (2003a) A posteriori optimisation of the forming pressure in superplastic forming processes by the finite element method. Finite Elem Anal Des 39:1083–1093
Carrino L, Giuliano G, Palmieri C (2003b) On the optimisation of superplastic forming processes by the finite-element method. J Mater Process Technol 143–144(1):373–377
Castro C, António C, Sousa L (2004) Optimisation of shape and process parameters in metal forging using genetic algorithms. Int J Mater Process Technol 146:356–364
Debray K, Sun Z, Radjai R, Guo Y, Dai L, Gu Y (2004) Optimum design of addendum surfaces in sheet metal forming process. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Di Lorenzo R, Filice L, Umbrello D, Micari F (2004) An integrated approach to the design of tube hydroforming processes: artificial intelligence, numerical analysis and experimental investigation. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Do T, Fourment L, Laroussi M (2004) Sensitivity analysis and optimization algorithms for 3D forging process design. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Duan X, Sheppard T (2002) Shape optimisation using FEA software: A V-shaped anvil as an example. J Mater Process Technol 120(1–3):426–431
Emmerich M, Giotis A, Özdemir M, Bäck T, Giannakoglou K (2002) Metamodel-assisted evolution strategies. In: Proceedings of the international conference on parallel problem solving from nature, Granada, 7–11 September 2002
Endelt B (2003) Least square optimization techniques applied on sheet metal forming. PhD thesis, Aalborg University, Aalborg
Endelt B, Nielsen K (2001) Least-square formulation of the object function, applied on hydro mechanical tube forming. In: Proceedings of SheMet, Leuven, 2–4 April 2001
Fann K, Hsiao P (2003) Optimization of loading conditions for tube hydroforming. J Mater Process Technol 140(1–3):520–524
Fourment L, Do T, Habbal A, Bouzaiane M (2005a) Gradient, non-gradient and hybrid algorithms for optimizing 2D and 3D forging sequences. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Cluj-Napoca, April 2005
Fourment L, Do T, Habbal A, Bouzaiane M (2005b) Optimization of forging sequences using gradient, non-gradient and hybrid algorithms. In: Proceedings of APOMAT, Morschach, 30–31 May 2005
Jansson T (2002) Optimization of sheet metal forming processes. Licentiate thesis, Universitet Linköping, Linköping
Jansson T, Andersson A, Nilsson L (2005) Optimization of draw-in for an automotive sheet metal part—an evaluation using surrogate models and response surfaces. J Mater Process Technol 159:426–234
Jirathearanat S, Altan T (2004) Optimization of loading paths for tube hydroforming. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Johnson K, Nguyen B, Dawies R, Grant G, Khaleel M (2004) A numerical process control method for circular-tube hydroforming prediction. Int J Plast 20:1111–1137
Kim N, Choi K, Chen J (2001a) Die shape design optimization of sheet metal stamping process using meshfree method. Int J Numer Methods Eng 51:1385–1405
Kim Y, Lee J, Hong S (2001b) Optimal design of superplastic forming processes. J Mater Process Technol 112(2–3):166–173
Kleinermann J (2001) Identification paramétrique et optimisation des procédés de mise à forme par problèmes inverses. PhD thesis, Université de Liège, Liège (in French)
Kleinermann J, Ponthot J (2003) Parameter identification and shape/process optimization in metal forming simulation. J Mater Process Technol 139(1–3):521–526
Koc M, Allen T, Jiratheranat S, Altan T (2000) Use of FEA and design of experiments to establish design guidelines for simple hydroformed parts. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 40(15):2249–2266
Labergère C, Gelin J (2004a) Comparison between optimization and control strategies to determine command laws in hydroforming processes. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Trondheim, April 2004
Labergère C, Gelin J (2004b) New strategies for optimal control of command laws for tube hydroforming processes. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Labergère C, Lejeune A, Gelin J (2004) Control of damage in flanges hydroforming. In: Proceedings of ECCOMAS, Jyväskylä, 24–28 July 2004
Lenoir H, Boudeau N (2003) An optimization procedure for springback compensation. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Salerno, 28–30 April 2003
Liew K, Tan H, Ray T, Tan M (2004) Optimal process design of sheet metal forming for minimum springback via an integrated neural network evolutionary algorithm. Struct Multidisc Optim 26:284–294
Lin Z, Juchen X, Xinyun W, Guoan H (2002) Sensitivity based optimization of sheet metal forming tools. J Mater Process Technol 124(3):319–328
Lin Z, Juchen X, Xinyun W, Guoan H (2003) Optimization of die profile for improving die life in the hot extrusion process. J Mater Process Technol 142(3):659–664
Lophaven S, Nielsen H, Søndergaard J (2002a) Aspects of the MATLAB toolbox DACE. Technical report IMM-REP-2002-13. Technical University of Denmark—Department of Informatics and Mathematical Modelling, Lyngby
Lophaven S, Nielsen H, Søndergaard J (2002b) DACE - A MATLAB Kriging Toolbox. Technical report IMM-TR-2002-12. Technical University of Denmark—Department of Informatics and Mathematical Modelling, Lyngby
McKay M, Beckman R, Conover W (1979) A comparison of three methods for selecting values of input variables in the analysis of output from a computer code. Technometrics 21:239–245
Myers R, Montgomery D (2002) Response surface methodology: process and product optimization using designed experiments, 2nd edn. Wiley, New York
Naceur H, Guo Y, Batoz J, Knopf-Lenoir C (2001) Optimization of drawbead restraining forces and drawbead design in sheet metal forming process. Int J Mech Sci 43(10):2407–2434
Naceur H, Breitkopf P, Knopf-Lenoir C, Rassineux A, Villon P (2003) Response surface methods for the optimal design of the initial blank in sheet metal forming process. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Salerno, 28–30 April 2003
Naceur H, Ben-Elechi S, Batoz J (2004a) The inverse approach for the design of sheet metal forming parameters to control springback effects. In: Proceedings of ECCOMAS, Jyväskylä, 24–28 July 2004
Naceur H, Ben-Elechi S, Knopf-Lenoir C, Batoz J (2004b) Response surface methodology for the design of sheet metal forming parameters to control springback effects using the inverse approach. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Naceur H, Delamézière A, Batoz J, Guo Y, Knopf-Lenoir C (2004c) Optimization of drawbead restraining forces and drawbead design in sheet metal forming process. J Mater Process Technol 146:250–262
Nielsen H (2002) DACE, a MATLAB Kriging toolbox. http://www.imm.dtu.dk/~hbn/dace/
Ohata T, Nakamura Y, Katayama T, Nakamachi E (2003) Development of optimum process design system for sheet fabrication using response surface method. J Mater Process Technol 143–144(1):667–672
Palaniswamy H, Ngaile G, Altan T (2004) Optimization of blank dimensions to reduce springback in the flexforming process. J Mater Process Technol 146:28–34
Papalambros P, Wilde D (2000) Principles of optimal design. Cambridge University Press, New York
Ponthot J, Kleinermann J (2005) Optimisation methods for initial/tool shape optimisation in metal forming processes. Int J Veh Des 39(1–2):14–24
Poursina M, António C, Parvizian J, Sousa L, Castro C (2003) Eliminating folding defect in forging parts using a genetic algorithm. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Salerno, 28–30 April 2003
Ray P, Mac Donald B (2004) Determination of the optimal load path for tube hydroforming processes using a fuzzy load control algorithm and finite element analysis. Finite Elem Anal Des 41:173–192
Repalle J, Grandhi R (2004) Optimum design of forging process parameters and preform shape under uncertainties. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Revuelta A, Larkiola J (2004) Applying neural networks in the final thickness optimisation of a thin hydroformed part. In: Proceedings of ECCOMAS, Jyväskylä, 24–28 July 2004
Sacks J, Schiller S, Welch W (1989a) Design for computer experiments. Technometrics 31:41–47
Sacks J, Welch W, Mitchell T, Wynn H (1989b) Design and analysis of computer experiments. Stat Sci 4:409–423
Sahai A, Schramm U, Buranathiti T, Chen W, Cao J, Xia C (2004) Sequential optimization and reliability assessment method for metal forming processes. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Santner T, Williams B, Notz W (2003) The design and analysis of computer experiments. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Schenk O, Hillmann M (2004) Optimal design of metal forming die surfaces with evolution strategies. Comput Struct 82:1695–1705
Sheng Z, Jirathearanat S, Altan T (2004) Adaptive FEM simulation for prediction of variable blank holder force in conical cup drawing. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 44:487–494
Shi X, Chen J, Peng Y, Ruan X (2004) A new approach of die shape optimization for sheet metal forming processes. J Mater Process Technol 152:35–42
Sillekens W, Werkhoven R (2001) Hydroforming processes for tubular parts: optimisation by means of adaptive and iterative FEM simulation. Int J Form Process 4(3–4):377–393
Sousa L, António C, Castro C (2003) Optimisation of multi-step hot forging operations. In: Proceedings of ESAFORM, Salerno, 28–30 April 2003
Strano M, Carrino L (2004) Adaptive selection of loads during FEM simulation of sheet forming processes. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Thiyagarajan N, Grandhi R (2004) 3-D preform shape optimization in metal forming. In: Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus, OH, 13–17 June 2004
Weyler R, Neamtu L, Duffett G (2004) An approach to the computer simulation of metal forming processes. In: Proceedings of ECCOMAS, Jyväskylä, 24–28 July 2004
Yang J, Jeon B, Oh S (2001) Design sensitivity analysis and optimization of the hydroforming process. J Mater Process Technol 113:666–672
Yang K, El-Haik B (2003) Design for six sigma; a roadmap for product development. McGraw-Hill, New York
Zhao G, Ma X, Zhao X, Grandhi R (2004) Studies on optimization of metal forming processes using sensitivity analysis methods. J Mater Process Technol 147:217–228
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0), which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Bonte, M.H.A., van den Boogaard, A.H. & Huétink, J. An optimisation strategy for industrial metal forming processes. Struct Multidisc Optim 35, 571–586 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00158-007-0206-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00158-007-0206-3