Abstract
Rapid increases in computer processing power, memory and storage space have not eliminated computational cost and time constraints on the use of structural optimization for design. This is due to the constant increase in the required fidelity (and hence complexity) of analysis models. Anecdotal evidence seems to indicate that analysis models of acceptable accuracy have required at least six to eight hours of computer time (an overnight run) throughout the last thirty years. This poses a severe challenge for global optimization or reliability-based design. In this paper, we review how increases in computer power were utilized in structural optimization. We resolve problem complexity into components relating to complexity of analysis model, analysis procedure and optimization methodology. We explore the structural optimization problems that we can solve at present and conclude that we can solve problems with the highest possible complexity in only two of the three components of model, analysis procedure or optimization. We use examples of optimum design of composite structures to guide the discussion due to our familiarity with such problems. However, these are supplemented with other structural optimization examples to illustrate the universality of the message.
References
Adali, S.; Richter, A.; Verijenko, V.E. 1995: Multiobjective Design of laminated Cylindrical Shells for Maximum Pressure and Buckling Load. Microcomputers in Civil Engineering10, 269–279
Antonio, C.A.C. 1999: Optimisation of geometrically non-linear composite structures based on load-displacement control. Composite Struct46, 345–356
Ashley, H. 1982: TOn making things the best – Aeronautical Uses of Optimization. J Aircr19(1), 5–28
Backlund, J.; Ishby, R. 1998: Shape Optimization of holes in composite shear panels. In: Rozvany, G.I.N.; Karihaloo, B.L. (eds.), Structural Optimization. Kluwer Publishers, 9–16
Belytschko, T.; Krongauz, Y.; Organ, D.; Fleming, M.; Krysl, P. 1996: Meshless methods: An overview and recent developments. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng139, 3–47
Bennett, J.A.; Botkin, M.E. 1985: Structural Shape Optimization with Geometric Description and Adaptive Mesh Refinement. AIAA J23(3), 458–464
Bennet, J.A.; Botkin, M.E. 1986: The Optimum Shape: Automated Structural Design. General Motors Research Laboratories Symposia Series, New York: Plenum Press
Bondophadhyay, P.K. 1998: Moore’s Law governs the silicon revolution. IEEE86(1), 78–81
Botkin, M.E.; Yang, R.J.; Bennett, J.A. 1986: Shape Optimization of Three Dimensional Stamped and Solid Automotive Components. New York: Plenum Press
Bushnell, D. 1987: PANDA2 – program for minimum weight design of stiffened, composite, locally buckled panels. Comput Struct25(4), 469–605
Butler, R.; Williams, F.W. 1992: Optimum Design Using Viconopt, A buckling and strength constraint program for prismatic assemblies of anisotropic plates. Comput Struct43(4), 699–708
Callahan, K.J.; Weeks, G.E. 1992: Optimum design of composite laminates using genetic algorithms. Comput Struct2(3), 149–160
Chamis, C.C.; Murthy, P.L.N.; Gotsis, P.K.; Mital, S.K. 2000: Telescoping composite mechanics for composite behavior simulation. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng185(2–4), 399–411
Craig, K.J.; Stander, N.; Doodge, D.A.; Varadappa, S. 2002: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Automotive Crashworthiness and NVH Using Response Surface Methods. AIAA Paper No. 2002-5607, Proceedings of the 9th AIAA/ISSMO Symposium on Multidisciplinary Analysis and Optimization, 4–6 September 2002, Atlanta, Georgia
Crossley, W.A.; Laananen, D.H. 1996: Genetic Algorithm Based Optimal Design of Stiffened panels for Energy Absorption. Proceedings of the American Helicopter Society 52nd Annual Forum. Washington, D.C., June 4–6, pp. 1367–1376
Falzon, B.G.; Steven, G.P.; Xie, Y.M. 1996: Shape optimization of interior cutouts in composite panels. Struct Optim11, 43–49
Fu, W.; Biggers, S.B.; Latour, R.A. 1998: Design optimization of a laminated composite femoral component for hip joint. Thermoplastic Composite Mater11(2), 99–112
Furuya, H.; Haftka, R.T. 1995: Placing Actuators on Space Structures by Genetic Algorithms and Effectiveness Indices. Struct Optim9, 69–75
Graesser, D.L.; Zabinsky, Z.B.; Tuttle, M.; Kim, G.I. 1993: Optimal design of a composite structure, Composite Struct24, 273–281
Grandhi, R. 1993: Structural Optimization with Frequency Constraints – A Review. AIAA J31(12), 2296–2303
Groenwold, A.A.; Snyman, J.A.; Stander, N. 1996: Modified Trajectory Method for Practical Global Optimization Problems. AIAA J34(10), 2126–2131
Grosset, L.; Venkataraman, S.; Haftka, R.T.; Rastogi, N. 2001: Genetic optimization of two-material composite laminates. Proceeding of the American Society for Composites 16th Technical Conference, September 9–12, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA
Grindeanu, I.; Kim, N.H.; Choi, K.K.; Chen, J.S., to appear, 2002: CAD-based shape optimization using a meshfree method. Concurrent Eng: Res Appl, 10(1), 55–66
Gurdal, Z.; Haftka, R.T. 1988: Automated Design of Composite Plates for Improved Damage Tolerance, Composite Materials: testing and Design (Eighth Conference). ASTM STP 972, Whitcomb, J.D. (ed.), American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, pp. 5–22
Gurdal, Z.; Haftka, R.T.; Hajela, P. 1998: Design and Optimization of Laminated Composite Structures. New York: Wiley
Ha, S.K.; Jeong, J.Y. 1996: Design Optimization of Hip Prosthesis of Thick Laminated Composites by Developing Finite Element Method and Sensitivity Analysis. KSME J10(1), 1–11
Haftka, R.T.; Starnes, J.H. 1976: Applications of a quadratic extended interior penalty function for structural optimization. AIAA J14(6), 718–724
Haftka, R.T.; Starnes, J.H. Jr. 1988: Stiffness tailoring for Improved Compressive Strength of composite plates with Holes. AIAA J26(1), 72–77
Hajela, P.; Shih, C.-J. 1989: Optimal Design of Laminated Composites Using a Modified Mixed Integer and Discrete Programming Algorithm. Comput Struct32(1), 213–221
Hammer, V.B. 2000: Optimization of fibrous laminates undergoing progressive damage. Numer Methods Eng48, 1265–1284
Hyer, M.W.; Charette, R.F. 1991: Use of curvilinear fiber format in composite structural design. AIAA J29, 1011–1015
Hu, H.T.; Wang, S.S. 1992: Optimization for buckling resistance of fiber composite laminate shells with and without cutouts. Composite Struct22, 3–13
Jaunky, N.; Knight, N.F. Jr.; Ambur, D.R. 1998: Optimal design of general stiffened composite circular cylinders for global buckling with strength constraints. Composite Struct41, 243–252
Jegley, D.C.; Bush, H.G.; Lovejoy, A.E. 1999: Structural Response and Failure of a Full Scale Stiched Graphite Epoxy Wing. AIAA Paper No. 2001-1334 Proceedings of the 42nd AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference, April 16–19, 2001, Seatlle, Washington
Kassapogolou, C. 1997: Simultaneous cost and weight minimization of composite-stiffened panels under compress and shear. Composites – Part A28A, 419–435
Kassapogolou, C.; Dobyns, A.L. 2001: Simultaneous cost and weight minimization of postbuckled composite panels under combined compression and shear. Struct Multidisc Optim21, 372–382
Katz, Y.; Haftka, R.T.; Altus, E. 1989: Optimization of fiber directions for increasing the failure load of a plate with a hole. Proceedings of the ASC 4th Technical Conference on Composite Materials, October 3–5, Blacksburg, Virginia, pp. 62–71
Khot, N.S.; Venkaya, V.B.; Berke, L. 1999: Optimum Design of Composite Structures with Stress and Displacement Constraints. AIAA14(2), 131–132
Kim, N.H.; Choi, K.K.; Botkin, M.E. 2003: Numerical method for shape optimization using meshfree method. Struct Multidisc Optim2(6), 418–429
Kim, N.H.; Choi, K.K.; Chen, J.S. 2001: Die Shape Optimization of Sheet Metal Stamping Process Using Meshfree Method. Numer Methods Eng51, 1385–1405
Kim, S.J.; Goo, N.S. 1999: Optimal design of laminated composite plates in a fuzzy environment. AIAA J31(3), 578–583
Kogiso, N.; Shao, S.; Murotsu, Y. 1997: TReliability-based optimum design of symmetric laminated plate subject to buckling. Struct Optim14, 184–192
Lamberti, L.; Venkataraman, S.; Haftka, R.T.; Johnson, T.F. 2000: Comparison of Preliminary Designs of Stiffened Panels Optimized Using PANDA2 for Reusable Launch Vehicle Propellant Tanks. AIAA Paper No. 2000-1657, Proceedings of the 41st AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference, Atlanta, Georgia, USA
Lamberti, L.; Venkataraman, S.; Haftka, R.T.; Johnson, T.F. 2002: Preliminary Design optimization of Stiffened Panels Using Approximate Analysis Models. Int J Numer Methods Eng57, 2003, 1351–1380
Lecina, A.; Petiau, C. 1987: Advances in optimal design with composite materials. Computer Aided Optimal Design: Structural and Mechanical Systems,NATO ASI Series, Vol F27, edited by Mota Soares, C.A., Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer, pp. 943–953
Lee, S.J.; Hinton, S.J. 2000: Dangers inherited in shells optimized with linear assumptions. Comput Struct78, 473–486
LeRiche, R.; Haftka, R.T. 1995: Improved genetic Algorithm for Minimum Thickness Composite Laminate Design. Composites Eng5(2), 143–161
LeRiche, R.; Gaudin, J. 1998: Design of dimensionally stable composites by evolutionary optimization. Composite Struct41, 97–111
Levy, R.; Lev, O.E. 1987: Recent Developments in Structural Optimization. Struct Eng113(9), 1939–1962
Ley, R.; Peltier, A. 2001: Optimal sizing of a composite sandwich fuselage component. Vehicle Des25(1–2), 89–114
Lombardi, M.; Haftka, R.T. 1998: Anti-optimization technique for structural design under load uncertainties. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng157(1–2) , 19–31
Mabson, G.E.; Flynn, B.W.; Ilcewiz, L.B.; Graesser, D.L. 1994: The Use of COSTADE in developing commercial aircraft fuselage structures. AIAA-94-1492, Proceedings of the 35th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics and materials Conference, April 18–20, Hilton Head, South Carolina, 1384–1393
Mesquita, L.; Kamat, M.P. 1987: Optimization of Stiffened laminated Composite Plates with Frequency Constraints. Eng Optim11, 77–88
Miki, M.; Sugiyama, Y. 1993: Optimum Design of Laminated Composite Plates using Lamination Parameters. AIAA J31(5), 921–922
Miki, M.; Murotsu, Y.; Murayama, N.; Tanaka, T. 1993: Application of Lamination Parameters to Reliability-Based Stiffness Design of Composites. AIAA31(10), 1938–1945
Moita, J.S.; Barbosa, J.I.; Mota Soares, C.M.; Mota Soares, C.A. 2000: Sensitivity analysis and optimal design of geometrically non-linear laminated plates and shells. Comput Struct76, 407–420
Moore, G.E. 1999: Cramming more components onto integrated circuits. Electronics38(8), 114–117
Nagendra, S.; Jestin, D.; Gurdal, Z.; Haftka, R.T.; Wat-son, L.T. 1996: Improved Genetic Algorithm for the Design of Stiffened Composite Panels. Comput Struct58(3), 543–555
Niordson, F.I. 2001: Early numerical computations in engineering. Appl Mech Rev54(6), R17–R19
Olhoff, N. 1996: On Optimum Design of Structures and Materials. Meccanica31, 143–161
Parkinson, C.N. 1959: Parkinson’s Law or the pursuit of progress. London: John Murray
Perry, C.A.; Gurdal, Z.; Starnes, J.H. 1997: Minimum Weight Design of Compressively Loaded Stiffened Panels for Post buckling Response. Eng Optim28, 175–197
Qu, X.; Venkataraman, S.; Haftka, R.T.; Johnson, T.F. 2003: Deterministic and reliability based optimization of composite laminates for cryogenic environments. AIAA J41(10), 2029–2036
Renton, W.J. 2001: Aerospace and structures, where are we headed? Int J Solids Struct38, 3309–3319
Saravanos, D.A.; Chamis, C.C. 1992: Multiobjective shape and material optimization of composite structures including damping. AIAA J30(3), 805–813
Sargent, P.M.; Ige, D.O.; Ball, N.R. 1995: Design of Laminate Composite Layups using Genetic Algorithms. Eng Comput11, 59–69
Schaller, R.J. 1997: Moore’s Law: past, present and future. IEEE Spectrum, June 1997, 53–59
Schmit, L.A.; Farshi, B. 1977: Optimum design of laminated fibre composite plates. Int J Numer Methods Eng11, 623–640
Schmit, L.A.; Miura, H. 1976: A New Structural Analysis/Synthesis Capability – ACCESS 1. AIAA J14(5), 661–671
Shin, D.K.; Gurdal, Z.; Griffin, O.H. Jr. 1991: Minimum weight design of laminated composite plates for post buckling performance. Appl Mech Rev44(11), part 2, 219–231
Sobieszczanski-Sobieski, J. 1986: Structural optimization: challenges and opportunities. Vehicle Des7(3–4), 242–263
Sobieszczanski-Sobieski, J.; Haftka, R.T. 1997: Multidisciplinary aerospace design optimization: Survey of recent developments. Struct Optim14, 1–23
Sobieszczanski-Sobieski, J.; Kodiyalam, S.; Yang, R.J. 2001: Optimization of car body under constraints of noise, vibration and harshness (NVH) and crash. Struct Multidisc Optim22, 295–306
Starnes, J.H. Jr.; Haftka, R.T. 1979: Preliminary Design of Composite Wings for Buckling, Strength, and Displacement Constraints. J Aircr16(8), 564–570
Stroud, J.W.; Agranoff, N. 1976: Minimum Mass design of Filamentary Composite Panels Under Combined Loads: Design Procedure Based on Simplified Equations, NASA-TN-D-8257, Washington, D.C.
Stroud, J.W.; Agranoff, N. 1977: Minimum Mass design of Filamentary Composite Panels Under Combined Loads: Design Procedure Based on a Rigorous Buckling Analysis, NASA-TN-D-8257, Washington, D.C.
Stroud, W.J.; Anderson, M.S. 1981: PASCO: Structural Panel Analysis and Sizing Code, Capability and Analytical Foundations, NASA-TM-80181, Washington, D.C.
Thimbleby, H. 1993: Computerized Parkinson’s Law. Comput Control Eng4(5), 197–198
van Bloemen Waanders, B.; Eldered, M.; Guinta, A.; Reese, G.; Bhardwaj, M.; Fulcher, C. 2001: AIAA-2001-1625, Proceedings of the 43rd AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference, April 16–19, 2001, Seattle, Washington
Vanderplaats, G.N. 1982: Structural Optimization – Past, Present and Future. AIAA J20(7), 992–1000
Vanderplaats, G.N. 1993: Thirty years of modern structural optimization. Adv Eng Softw16, 81–88
Vanderplaats, G.N. 2002: Very Large Scale Optimization. NASA/CR-2002-211768, Washington, D.C.
Venkaya, V.B. 1978: Structural Optimization – Review and Some Recommendations. Numer Methods Eng13(2), 203–228
Venter, G.; Haftka, R.T. 2000: Two-Species Genetic Algorithm for Design under Worst Case Conditions. Evol Optim (Internet J)2(1), 1–19
Walsh, J.L.; Weston, R.P.; Samareh, J.A.; Mason, B.H.; Green, L.L.; Bierdon, R.T. 2000: Multidisciplinary High-Fidelity Analysis and Optimization of Aerospace Vehicles, Part 2: Preliminary Results. AIAA-2000-0419, Proceedings of the 38th Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, 10–13 January 2000, Reno, Nevada, USA
Walsh, J.L.; Weston, R.P.; Samareh, J.A.; Mason, B.H.; Green, L.L.; Bierdon, R.T. 1999: Cryogenic tank structure sizing with structural optimization method. AIAA-2001-1599, Proceedings of the 42nd AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference, Seattle Washington, 2001
Wellen, H.; Bartholomew, P. 1987: Structural Optimization in Aircraft Construction, Computer Aided Optimal Design: Structural and Mechanical Systems NATO ASI Series, Vol. F27, edited by Mota Soares, C.A., Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer, pp. 955–970
Yu, M.; Pochtman, L.; Derevyanko, L.V.; Mormul, N.F. 1990: Multicriterial Optimization of Hybrid Composite Cylindrical Shells Under a Stochastic Combined laoding. Mech Composite Mater26(6), 801–806
Yang, L.; Ma, Z.K. 1965: Optimum Design Based on Reliability for a Composite Structural System. Comput Struct36(5), 785–790
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Venkataraman, S., Haftka, R. Structural optimization complexity: what has Moore’s law done for us?. Struct Multidisc Optim 28, 375–387 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00158-004-0415-y
Received:
Revised:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00158-004-0415-y