Abstract
Purpose
Community Treatment Orders (CTOs) require outpatients to adhere to treatment and permit rapid hospitalisation when necessary. They have become a clinical and policy solution to repeated hospital readmissions despite some strong opposition and the contested nature of published evidence. In this article, we appraise the current literature on CTOs from the viewpoint of Evidence-Based Medicine and discuss the way forward for using and researching CTOs.
Results
Non-randomised outcome studies show conflicting results, but their lack of standardisation of methods and measures makes it difficult to draw conclusions. In contrast, all three randomised controlled trials (RCTs) conducted concur in their findings that CTOs do not impact on hospital outcomes. No systematic review or meta-analysis has identified any clear clinical advantage to CTOs.
Conclusion
The evidence-base does not support the use of CTOs in their current form. Involuntary clinical interventions must conform to the highest standard of evidence-based care. To enable clinicians to take an evidence-based approach and to settle remaining uncertainties about the current evidence, high-quality RCTs should be designed and undertaken, using standardised outcome measures.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Killespy H, Kingett S, Bebbington P et al (2009) Randomised evaluation of assertive community treatment: 3-year outcomes. Br J Psychiatry 195:81–82
Sjöström S, Zetterberg L, Markström U (2011) Why community compulsion became the solution—reforming mental health law in Sweden. Int J Law Psychiatry 34:419–428
Churchill R, Owen G, Hotopf, M Singh S (2007) International experiences of using community treatment orders. London, Department of Health and the Institute of Psychiatry, King’s College
Dawson J (2005) Community treatment orders: international comparisons. University of Otago, Otageo
Lawton-Smith S (2005) A question of numbers. The potential impact of community-based treatment orders in England and Wales. The King’s Fund, London
Care Quality Commission (2012) Monitoring the Mental Health Act in 2011/12. http://www.cqc.org.uk/sites/default/files/media/documents/cqc_mentalhealth_2011_12_main_final_web.pdf. Accessed 13 November 2013
Manning C, Molodynski A, Rugkåsa J, Dawson J, Burns T (2011) Community treatment orders in England and Wales, clinicians’ views and use: a national survey. Psychiatrist 35:1–6
SINTEF (2008) Bruk and tvungent psykisk helsevern uten døgnomsorg i 2007 [The use of community treatment orders in 2007]. SINTEF A8237. Trondheim, SINTEF Helse
Dawson J, Szmukler G (2006) Fusion of mental health and incapacity legislation. Br J Psychiatry 188:504–509
Eastman N (2006) Reforming mental health law in England and Wales. Br Med J 332:737–738
Dawson J (2002) Randomised controlled trials of mental health legislation. Med Law Rev 10:308–321
Swartz MS, Burns BJ, George LK et al (1997) The ethical challenges of a randomised controlled trial of Involuntary Outpatient Commitment. J Ment Health Adm 24:35–43
Burns T, Dawson J (2009) Community treatment orders: how ethical without experimental evidence? Psychol Med 39:1583–1586
Romans S, Dawson J, Mullen R, Gibbs A (2004) How mental health clinicians view community treatment orders: a national New Zealand survey. Aust NZ J Psychiatry 38:836–841
Mullen R, Dawson J, Gibbs A (2006) Dilemmas for clinicians in use of community treatment orders. Int J Law Psychiatry 29:535–550
Dawson J, Mullen R (2008) Insight and use of community treatment orders. J Ment Health 17:269–280
O’Reilly R, Keegan D, Corring D, Shrikhande S, Natarajan D (2006) A qualitative analysis of the use of community treatment orders in Saskatchewan. Int J Law Psychiatry 29:516–524
Mullen R, Gibbs A, Dawson J (2006) Family perspective on community treatment orders: a New Zealand study. Int J Soc Psychiatry 52:469–478
Dawson J, Romans S, Gibbs A, Ratter N (2003) Ambivalence about community treatment orders. Int J Law Psychiatry 26:243–255
Gibbs A, Dawson J, Ansley C, Mullen A (2005) How patients in New Zealand view community treatment orders. J Ment Health 14:357–368
Schwartz K, O’Brien AM, Morel V, Armstrong M, Fleming C, Moore P (2010) Community treatment orders: the service user speaks. Exploring the lived experience of community treatment orders. Int J Psychosoc Rehab 15:39–50
Swartz MS, Swanson JW, Wagner HR, Hannon MJ, Burns BJ, Shumway M (2003) Assessment of four stakeholder groups’ preferences concerning outpatient commitment for persons with schizophrenia. Am J Psychiatry 160:1130–1146
Kisely S, Cambell LA (2007) Methodological issues in assessing the evidence for compulsory community treatment. Curr Psychiatry Rev 3:51–56
O’Reilly R (2009) Research on community treatment orders. In: Vingilis ER, State SA (eds) Applied research and evaluation in community mental health services. McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal, pp 68–79
Maughan D, Molodynski A, Rugkåsa J, Burns T (2013) A systematic review of the effect of community treatment orders on service use. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. doi:10.1007/s00127-013-0781-0
Segal S, Burgess P (2006) Factors in the selection of patients for conditional release from their first psychiatric hospitalization. Psychiatr Serv 57:1614–1622
Segal S, Burgess P (2006) The utility of extended outpatient civil commitment. Int J Law Psychiatry 29:525–534
Swartz M, Wilder C, Swanson J et al (2010) Assessing outcomes for consumers in New York’s assisted outpatient treatment program. Psychiatr Serv 61:976–981
Van Dorn R, Swanson J, Swartz M et al (2010) Continuing medication and hospitalization outcomes after assisted outpatient treatment in New York. Psychiatr Serv 61:982–987
Hunt A, da Silva A, Lurie S, Goldbloom D (2007) Community treatment orders in Toronto: the emerging data. Can J Psychiatry 52:647–655
Muirhead D, Harvey C, Ingram G (2006) Effectiveness of community treatment orders for treatment of schizophrenia with oral or depot antipsychotic medication: clinical outcomes. Aust NZ J Psychiatry 40:596–605
Nakhost A, Perry JC, Frank D (2012) Assessing the outcome of compulsory treatment orders on management of psychiatric patients at two McGill University-associated hospitals. Can J Psychiatry 57:359–365
Christy A, Petrila J, McCranie M, Lotts V (2009) Involuntary outpatient commitment in Florida: case information and provider experience and opinions. Int J Forensic Ment Health 8:122–130
Segal S, Burgess P (2008) Use of community treatment orders to prevent psychiatric hospitalization. Aust NZ J Psychiatry 42:732–739
Kisely S, Preston N, Xiao J et al (2013) An eleven-year evaluation of the effect of community treatment orders on changes in mental health service use. J Psychiatr Res 47:650–656
Segal S, Preston N, Kisely S, Xiao J (2009) Conditional release in Western Australia: effect on hospital length of stay. Psychiatr Serv 60:94–99
Burgess P, Bindman J, Leese M, Henderson C, Szmukler G (2006) Do community treatment orders for mental illness reduce readmission to hospital? An epidemiological study. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 41:574–579
Segal S, Burgess P (2006) Conditional release, a less restrictive alternative to hospitalization? Psychiatr Serv 57:1600–1606
Kisely S, Campbell LA, Preston NJ, Xiao J (2006) Can epidemiological studies assist in the evaluation of community treatment orders?—The experience of Western Australia and Nova Scotia. Int J Law Psychiatry 29:507–515
Zanni G, Stavis P (2007) The effectiveness and ethical justification of psychiatric outpatient commitment. Am J Bioethics 7:31–41
O’Brien A, Farrell S, Faulkner S (2009) Community treatment orders: beyond hospital utilization rates examining the association of community treatment orders with community engagement and supportive housing. Comm Ment Health J 45:415–419
Swartz MS, Swanson JW, Wagner HR, Burns BJ, Hiday VA, Borum R (1999) Can involuntary outpatient commitment reduce hospital recidivism?: findings from a randomized trial with severely mentally ill individuals. Am J Psychiatry 156:1968–1975
Szmukler G, Hotopf M (2001) Effectiveness of involuntary outpatient commitment. Am J Psychiatry 158:653–654
Liberman J, Stroup T, McEvoy J et al (2005) Effectiveness of antipsychotic drugs in patients with chronic schizophrenia. New Eng J Medicine 353:1209–1223
Austin P (2009) The relative ability of different propensity score methods to balance measured covariates between treated and untreated subjects in observational studies. Med Decis Mak 29:661–677
Ioannis JP (2005) Why most published research findings are false. PLoS Med 2:696–701
Dahl F, Grotle M, Benth JS, Natvig B (2008) Data splitting as a countermeasure against hypothesis fishing: with a case study of predictors for low back pain. Eu J Epidemiol 23:237–242
Dawson J, Burns T, Rugkåsa J (2011) Lawfulness of a randomised trial of the new community treatment order regime for England and Wales. Med Law Rev 19:1–26
Steadman H, Gounis K, Dennis D, Hopper K, Roche B, Swartz M et al (2001) Assessing the New York City involuntary outpatient commitment pilot programme. Psychiatr Serv 52:330–336
Burns T, Rugkåsa J, Molodynksi A et al (2013) Community treatment orders for patients with psychosis: a randomised controlled trial (OCTET). Lancet 381:1627–1633
Swartz M, Swanson J (2004) Involuntary outpatient commitment, community treatment orders, and assisted outpatient treatment: what’s in the data? Can J Psychiatry 49:585–591
Kisely K, Cambell L (2006) Community treatment orders for psychiatric patients: the emperor with no clothes. Can J Psychiatry 51:683–685
Telson H, Glickstein R, Trujillo M (1999) Report of the Bellevue Hospital Center outpatient commitment pilot program. Bellevue Hospital Center, Department of Psychiatry, New York
Kisely S, Cambell L, Scott A, Preston N, Xiao J (2007) Randomised and non-randomised evidence for the effect of compulsory and involuntary out-patient treatment of health service use: systematic review and meta-analysis. Psychological Med 37:3–14
Nakhost A, Perry C, Simpson A (2013) Community treatment for patients with psychosis. Letter to the editor. Lancet 382:501
McCutcheon R (2013) Community treatment for patients with psychosis. Letter to the editor. Lancet 382:501
Geller J (2013) Community treatment for patients with psychosis. Letter to the editor. Lancet 382:501
Naudet R (2013) Community treatment for patients with psychosis. Letter to the editor. Lancet 382:502
Mustafa F (2013) On the OCTET and supervised treatment orders. Med Sci Law. doi:10.1177/0025802413506898
Segal S (2013) Commentary to Community treatment orders do not reduce hospital admissions in people with psychosis. Evid Based Ment Health. doi:10.1136/eb-2013-101438
Sweetman E, Doig G (2011) Failure to report protocol violations in clinical trials: a threat to internal validity? Trials 12:214
Lassen K, Høye A, Myrmel T (2012) Randomised trials in surgery: the burden of evidence. Rev Recent Clin Trials 7:244–248
Dawson J (2010) Community treatment orders. In: Gostin L, Bartlett P, Fennell P, McHale J, McKay R (eds) The principles of mental health law and policy. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 513–514
Department of Health (2008) Code of Practice: Mental Health Act 1983. Stationary Office, London
Kisely S, Campbell LA, Preston N (2009) Compulsory community and involuntary outpatient treatment for patients with severe mental health disorders. Cochrane database of systematic reviews 3
Burns T (2007) Hospitalisation as an outcome measure in schizophrenia. Br J Psychiatry 161(suppl. 50):s37–s41
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Daniel Maughan for his input into this manuscript. We also thank the two reviewers for useful comments.
Conflict of interest
The authors are part of the OCTET study team.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rugkåsa, J., Dawson, J. & Burns, T. CTOs: what is the state of the evidence?. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 49, 1861–1871 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-014-0839-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-014-0839-7