Abstract
Background
This study concerns depression among women living in developing and developed parts of the world. Using a continuum of environments conceptualized as ranging from traditional to modern, the goal is to explore the hypothesis that the prevalence of depression will be higher among those living in modern compared to traditional societies. This issue is examined among samples from West Africa and North America.
Methods
The subjects are 657 women who reside in four locations. An operational definition of modernization is used to place the locales as a continuum in the following order: rural Yorubaland in Nigeria, Yorubas living in urban Nigeria, rural Canada, and urban United States. Variables employed include education, religious orientation, and the role of women as mothers and workers. Depression is assessed using an algorithm based on generally acknowledged criteria. Multivariate logistic regression is used to generate point estimates and confidence intervals for prevalence odds ratios, to adjust for potential confounders, and to assess effect modification.
Results
The prevalence of depression was lowest among rural Nigerians and highest among urban residents in the United States. The association of depression with the proposed continuum was strongest among women under the age of 45 who had living children (Odds Ratio: 2.1; 95% Confidence Interval: 1.6–2.9).
Conclusions
In the areas studied, a traditional way of life seems to offer protection against some of the stresses associated with modernization although it does not appear to compensate for the adversity of childlessness. Level of modernization may be a useful concept for understanding differences in rates of depression in different parts of the world.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Murphy JM (1976) Psychiatric labeling in cross-cultural perspective. Science 191:1019–1028
Kleinman A, Good B (1985) Culture and depression: studies in the anthropology and cross-cultural psychiatry of affect and disorder. University of California Press, Berkeley
World Health Organization (1979) Schizophrenia: an International Follow-up Study. John Wiley & Sons, New York
Torrey EF (1980) Schizophrenia and civilization. Jason Aronson, New York
Warner R, de Girolamo G (1995) Schizophrenia. World Health Organization, Geneva
Cross-National Collaborative Group (1992) The changing rate of major depression. JAMA 268(21):3098–3105
Kessler RC, McGonagle KA, Nelson CB, Hughes M, Swartz M, Blazer DG (1994) Sex and depression in the National Comorbidity Survey II: cohort effects. J Affect Disord 30:15–26
Murphy JM, Laird NM, Monson RR, Sobol AM, Leighton AH (2000) Incidence of depression in the Stirling County Study: historical and comparative perspectives. Psychol Med 30(3):505–514
Patten SC (2003) Recall bias and major depression lifetime prevalence. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 38:290–296
Divale W, Seda A (2001) Modernization as changes in cultural complexity: new cross-cultural measurements. Cross-Cultural Res 35:127–153
Lloyd BB (1966) Education and family life in the development of class identification among the Yoruba. In: Lloyd PC (ed) The new elites of tropical Africa. Oxford University Press, London
Fadipe NA (1970) The sociology of the Yoruba. In: Okediji FO, Okediji QO (eds). Ibadan University Press, Ibadan
Togunu-Bickersteth F (1988) Perception of old age among Yoruba aged. J Comp Fam Stud 19(1):113–122
Cahill T (1998) The gifts of the Jews: how a tribe of desert nomads changed the way everyone thinks and feels. Doubleday, New York
Devos G, Miner H (1959) Oasis and Casbah: a study of acculturative stress. In: Opler MK (ed) Culture and mental health. New York, Macmillan, pp. 333–350
Inkeles A, Smith D (1970) The fate of personal adjustment in the process of modernization. Int J Comp Sociol 11:81–113
Cortes DE (2003) Idioms of distress, acculturation, and depression: the Puerto Rican experience. In: Chun KM, Organista PM, Marin G (eds) Acculturation: advances in theory, measurement, and applied research, American Psychological Association, Washington, pp. 207–222
Kosic A (2004) Acculturation strategies, coping process and acculturative stress. Scand J Psychol 45:269–278
Leighton AH (1959) My name is Legion: the Stirling County study of psychiatric disorder and social environment. Basic Books, New York
Hughes CC, Tremblay MA, Rapoport RN, Leighton AH (1960) People of Cove and Woodlot: the Stirling County study. Basic Books, New York
Leighton DC, Harding JS, Macklin DB, Macmillan AM, Leighton AH (1963) The character of danger: the Stirling County study. Basic Books, New York
Leighton AH, Lambo TA, Hughes CC, Leighton DC, Murphy JM, Macklin DB (1963) Psychiatric disorder among the Yoruba: a report from the Cornell-Aro mental health research project in the western region, Nigeria. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
Benfari RC, Beiser M, Leighton AH, Mertens C (1972) Some dimensions of psychoneurotic behavior in an urban sample. J Nerv Ment Dis 155(2):77–90
Murphy JM (1973) Sociocultural change and psychiatric disorder among rural Yorubas in Nigeria. Ethos 1(2):239–262
Zahner GEP, Murphy JM (1989) Loss in childhood: anxiety in adulthood. Compr Psychiatry 30(6):553–563
Murphy JM (1995) The Stirling County study: then and now. In: Guse SB, Compton WM (eds) Special Issue on Psychiatric Epidemiology, Int Rev Psychiatry
Shuter J (2003) Ancient West African Kingdoms. Heineman Library, Chicago
Inglehart R, Baker WE (2000) Modernization, cultural change, and the persistence of traditional values. Am Soc Rev 65:19–51
Diagnostic Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3 (1980) American Psychiatric Association, Washington
Diagnostic Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4 (1994) American Psychiatric Association, Washington
Brown GW, Harris TO (1978) Social Origins of Depression. Free Press, New York
Brown GW, Prudo R (1981) Psychiatric disorder in a rural and an urban population: 1 Aetiology of depression. Psychol Med 11:581–599
Prudo R, Brown GW, Harris T, Dowland J (1981) Psychiatric disorder in a rural and an urban population: 2 Sensitivity to loss. Psychol Med 11:601–616
Bebbington PE, Stuart E, Tennant C, Hurry J (1984) Misfortune and resilience: a community study of women Psychol Med 14:347–63
Nolen-Hoeksema S (1990) Sex differences in depression. Stanford University Press, Stanford
Weissman MM, Bruce ML, Leaf PJ, Florio LP, Holzer C (1991) Affective disorders. In: Robins LN, Regier DA (eds) Psychiatric disorders in America. The Free Press, New York
Abiodun OA, Parakoyi DB (1992) Mental morbidity in a rural community in Nigeria. Int J Ment Health 21(1):23–35
Brown DR, Ahmed F, Gary LE, Milburn NC (1995) Major depression in a community survey of African Americans. Am J Psychiatry 152(3):373–378
Horwath E, Weissman MM (1995) Epidemiology of depression and anxiety disorders. In: Tsuang MT, Tohen M, Zahner GEP (eds) Textbook in psychiatric epidemiology. John Wiley & Sons, New York
Stata Release 7 (2002) College Station, Texas
Sartorious N, Davidian H, Ernberg G, Fenton FR, Fujii I, Gastpar M, Gulbinat W, Jablensky A, Kielholz P, Lehmann HE, Naraghi M, Shimizu M, Shinfuku N, Takahashi R (1983) Depressive disorders in different cultures (1983). World Health Organization, Geneva
Langner TS, Michael ST (1963) Life stress and mental health. Free Press, New York
Dohrenwend BS, Dohrenwend BP (1981) Life stress and illness: formulation of the issues. In: Dohrenwend BS, Dohrenwend BP (eds) Stressful life events and their contexts. Prodist, New York
Hinkle LE (1987) Stress and disease: the concept after 50 years. Soc Sci Med 25(6):561–566
Kessler RC, Price RH, Wortman CB (1985) Social factors in psychopathology: stress, social support, and coping processes. Annu Rev Psychol 36:531–572
Hollos M (1991) Migration, education and the status of women in southern Nigeria. Am Anthropol 93(4):852–870
Harris M (1993) The evolution of human gender hierarchies: a trial formulation. In: Miller BD (ed) Sex and gender hierarchies. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Brown GW, Davidson S, Harris T, Maclean U, Pollock S, Prudo R (1977) Psychiatric disorder in London and North Uist. Soc Sci Med 11:367–377
Romans-Clarkson E, Walton VA, Herbison GP, Mullen PE (1988) Marriage, motherhood and psychiatric morbidity in New Zealand. Psychol Med 18:983–990
Brown BW, Harris T (1986) Stressor, vulnerability and depression: a question of replication. Psychol Med 16:739–744
Rogler LH (1994) Culturally sensitive research in mental health. In: Mezzich JE, Jorge MR, Salloum IM (eds) Psychiatric epidemiology. Assessment concepts and methods. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, pp. 565–580
Pierce CM, Earls FJ, Kleinman A (1999) Race and culture in psychiatry. In: Nicholi AM (ed) The Harvard guide to psychiatry. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, pp. 735–743
Kleinman A (1982) Neurasthenia and depression: a study of somatization and culture in China. Cult Med Psychiatry 6:117–189
Orley J, Blitt DM, Wing JE (1979) Psychiatric disorders in two African villages. Arch Gen Psychiatry 36:513–520
Murray DJL, Lopez AD (1996) Summary: the global burden of disease. The Harvard School of Public Health on behalf of The World Health Organization and The World Bank, Harvard University Press, Cambridge
The WHO World Mental Health Survey Consortium (2004) Prevalence, severity, and unmet need for treatment of mental disorders in the World Health Organization World Mental Health Surveys. JAMA 291:2581–2590
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Supported by Fellowship, National Institute of Mental Health Training Grant T32 MH17119 in Psychiatric Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Dr. Colla) and by National Institute of Mental Health Grant MH 39576, A Longitudinal Study in Psychiatric Epidemiology (Dr. Murphy).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Colla, J., Buka, S., Harrington, D. et al. Depression and modernization. Soc Psychiat Epidemiol 41, 271–279 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-006-0032-8
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-006-0032-8