Abstract
This study attempted to examine the economic efficiency of the sulfur dioxide (SO2) emissions control policy in Japan using a cost-benefit analysis (CBA). The SO2 emissions control policy is divided into three stages by epochal policy decisions. Reducing the incidence of chronic bronchitis and asthma are the two main policy benefits considered in this study, and they are estimated mainly based on the cost of illness approach. Policy costs have been derived from private sector investments for pollution control to meet the pollution standards under command and control (CAC) regulations. The estimated results, using a social discount rate of 2.5%, indicate a cost-benefit ratio of 5.39 in stage 1 (1968–1973), 1.18 in stage 2 (1974–1983), and 0.41 in stage 3 (1984–1993). This result indicates that the CAC in Japan used to have strong efficiency but that this efficiency has decreased over time. Our paper suggests that it is necessary to reconsider policy approaches in light of policy efficiency and in moving from SO2 to new target priority pollutants.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amano A (1997) Sogoseisaku Nyumon [Introduction to the policy analysis] (in Japanese). Yuhikaku, Tokyo
Chestnut L (1995) Human health benefits from sulfate reductions under title IV of 1990 clean air act amendments. United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). http://www.epa.gov/airmarkets/articles/
CJEBAP (Committee on Japan’s Experience in the Battle against Air Pollution) (1997) Japan’s experience in the battle against air pollution: working toward sustainable development. Pollution-Related Health Damage Compensation and Prevention Association, Tokyo
Cropper ML, Krupnick AJ (1990) The social costs of chronic heart and lung disease. Discussion paper QE 89-16-REV. Resources for the Future, Washington, DC
Cropper ML, Oats WE (1992) Environmental economics: a survey. Journal of Economic Literature 30:675–740
EAJ (Environmental Agency in Japan) (1986) Taiki Osen Kenkou Eikyou Chosa Houkokusho (Showa 55–59) [Report of air pollution and health impact] (in Japanese). EPA Taiki-Hozen-Kyoku [EAJ Air Pollution Control Department], Tokyo
EAJ (1998) Nihon no Taiki Osen Jokyo: Heisei Junen Ban [Situation of air pollution, FY 1998] (in Japanese). EAJ, Tokyo
EDMC (Energy Data and Modeling Center) (Nihon Energy Keizai Kenkyu-jo: Energy Keiryou Bunseki Center) (1997) Energy Keizai Tokei Yoran [Energy economic statistics] (in Japanese). EDMC, Tokyo
Freeman AM (1993) The measurement of environmental and resource values: theory and methods. Resources for the Future, Washington, DC
Government of Japan (1971) Kogai Hakusho Shouwa 46 Nendo Ban [White paper of environmental pollution, FY1971] (in Japanese). Government of Japan, Tokyo
Helfand GE (1991) Standards versus standards: the effects of different pollution restrictions. American Economic Review 81:622–634
Japan Society of Industrial Machinery Manufacturers (1986) Baien Taisaku Gijutsu Chosa Houkokusho [Report of control technology for point source air pollution] (in Japanese). Japan Society of Industrial Machinery Manufacturers
Matsuno Y (1997) Tekkogyo ni okeru Iousankabutsuhaishutsusakugen heno Kakushu Kankyou-taisaku-shudan no Kiyo (2) [Pollution control technologies effect for reduction of sulfate from steel industry] (in Japanese). Keizaironsou [Kyoto University Economic Journal] 160(3):19–38
Matsuoka S (2000) Environmental policy in developing countries: instruments and efficiency of regulations (in Japanese). Journal of International Development Studies [Kokusai Kaihatsu Kenkyu] 9(2):17–37
MCA (Management Coordination Agency in Japan) (1973) Population statistics 1973 (in Japanese). MCA, Tokyo
MCA (1983) Population statistics 1983 (in Japanese). MCA, Tokyo
MCA (1993) Population statistics 1993 (in Japanese). MCA, Tokyo
MCA (1997) Annual statistics report 1997 (in Japanese). MCA, Tokyo
MCA (2000) Japan statistical yearbook 2000 (in Japanese). MCA, Tokyo
MEIP (Metropolitan Environmental Improvement Program) (1993) Japan’s experience in urban environmental management. World Bank, Washington, DC
MHW (Ministry of Health and Welfare in Japan) (1993) Kanja-Chosa (Zenkoku-ban) [Report of patients, nationwide] (in Japanese). Kosei-Tokei-Kyokai [Association of Public Welfare Statistics]. MHW, Tokyo
MHW (1998) Kokumin-Iryohi Heisei 8nendo (FY 1996 national medical expense) (in Japanese). MHW, Tokyo
Morgernstern R (ed) (1997) Economic analysis at EPA: assessing regulatory impact. Resources for the Future, Washington DC
O’Connor D (1994) Managing the environment with rapid industrialization: lessons from the East Asian experience. OECD, Paris
OECD (1977) Environmental policies in Japan. OECD, Paris
OECD (1981) The costs and benefits of sulfur oxide control: a methodological study. OECD, Paris
Oil Association (1985) Naigai Sekiyu Shiryou 1985 [1985 Report of domestic and foreign oil production] (in Japanese). Oil Association, Tokyo
Oil Association (1992) Naiagai Sekiyu Shiryou 1992 [1992 Report of domestic and foreign oil production] (in Japanese). Oil Association, Tokyo
Oka T (1997) Chokusetsu Kisei [Command and Control]. In: Ueda K, et al (eds) Kankyo seisaku no keizai gaku: riron to genjitu [Economics for environmental policy: theory and application] (in Japanese). Nihon Hyouronsha, Tokyo
Ostro B, Chestnut L (1998) Assessing the health benefits of reducing particulate matter air pollution in the United States. Environmental Research, Section A 7:94–106
Row R, Lang C, Chestnut L, Latimer D, Rae D, Bernow S, White D (1995) New York State environmental externalities cost study. Oceana Publications, New York
Sawamura R, Hamada A, Hayatsu H (1992) Kankyo-Eiseigaku [Environmental Hygienic Sciences] (in Japanese). Nankodo, Tokyo
Sekitu (1984) Oil price statistics 1984 (in Japanese). Sekitu, Tokyo
Sekitu (1994) Oil price statistics 1994 (in Japanese). Sekitu, Tokyo
Shin E, Hufschmidt M, Lee J, Nickum JE, Umetsu C (1997) Valuating the economic impacts of urban environmental problems: Asian cities. UNDP/ UNCHS (Habitat)/ World Bank Urban Management Program Working Paper Series 13. World Bank, Washington, DC
Tsunetoshi Y, Fukutomi K, Yoshida K, Doi M (1987) Epidemiological study of respiratory symptoms in school-children with special reference to effect of air pollution (in Japanese). Journal of Japan Society of Air Pollution 22:431–459
Turner KR, Pearce D, Bateman I (1993) Environmental economics. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
USEPA (1997) The benefit and cost of the clean air act: 1970 to 1990. US EPA, Washington, DC
USEPA (1999) The benefit and cost of the clean air act: 1990 to 2010. US EPA, Washington, DC
Winpenny JT (1991) Values for the environment. HMSO, London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Presented at the Seminar on Economic Analysis of Environmental Management, Policy Research Center for Environment and Economy (PRCEE), State Environmental Protection Administration (SEPA), Beijing, P.R. China, December 1999
About this article
Cite this article
Kochi, I., Matsuoka, S., Memon, M.A. et al. Cost benefit analysis of the sulfur dioxide emissions control policy in Japan. Environ Econ Policy Stud 4, 219–233 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03354017
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03354017