Abstract
Psychiatric advance directives (PADs) are an emerging method for adults with serious and persistent mental illness to document treatment preferences in advance of periods of incapacity. This article presents and responds to issues most frequently raised by service providers when planning for implementation of PADs. Issues discussed include access to PADs; competency to execute PADs; the relationship of PADs to standards of care, resource availability, and involuntary treatment; roles of service providers and others in execution of PADs; timeliness and redundancy of PAD information; consumer expectations of PADs; complexity of PADs; revocation and “activation”; legal enforceability of PADs; the role and powers of agents; liability for honoring and not honoring PADs; and use of PADs to consent for release of health care information. Recommendations are made for training staff and consumers, consideration of statute development, and methods to reduce logistical, attitudinal, and system barriers to effective use of PADs.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Srebnik D, LaFond J. Advance directives for mental health services: current perspectives and future directions.Psychiatric Services. 1999;50:919–925.
Szasz T. The psychiatric will: a new mechanism for protecting persons against “psychosis” and psychiatry.American Psychologist. 1982;37:762–770.
Appelbaum P. Advance directives for psychiatric care.Hospital and Community Psychiatry. 1991;42: 983–984.
Gallagher E. Advance directives for psychiatric care: a theoretical and practical overview for legal professionals.Psychology, Public Policy and Law. 1998;4:746–787.
Mester R, Toren P, Gonen N, et al. Anticipatory consent for psychiatric treatment: a potential solution for an ethical problem.Journal of Forensic Psychiatry. 1994;5:160–167.
Rogers J, Centifanti J. Beyond “self-paternalism”: response to Rosenson and Kasten.Schizophrenia Bulletin. 1991;17:9–14.
Sherman P. Advance directives for involuntary psychiatric care. In:Proceedings of the 1994 National Symposium on Involuntary Interventions: The Call for a National Legal and Medical Response. Houston: University of Texas; 1995.
Hoge S. The Patient Self-Determination Act and psychiatric care.Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry & the Law. 1994;22:577–586.
Alaska Stat §47.30.950; Ariz Rev Stat §36-3221-3281; Hawaii Rev Stat Ann §327F; Idaho Code §§66-601-613; 755 Ill Comp Stat 43/1; La Stat Ann §28-221-235, Md Code Ann §5-601-617; Minn Stat Ann §253B.03(6)(d); Mont Code Ann §53-21-115-714; NC Gen Stat §122C-71-77; Okla Stat Ann 43A, §11-101-113; Ore Rev Stat §127.700-737 (1999); Tex Civ Prac & Rem Code Ann §§137.001-011; Utah Code Ann §§62A-12-501-504; Laws of Washington, Chapt 283 (2003); Wis Stat §155.20, Wyo Stat §35-22-302-308.
Fleischner R. Advance directives for mental health care: an analysis of State Statutes.Psychology, Public Policy and Law. 1998;4:788–804.
Backlar P, McFarland B, Swanson J, et al. Consumer, provider, and informal caregiver opinions on psychiatric advance directives.Administration and Policy in Mental Health. 2001;28:427–441.
Geller J. The use of advance directives by persons with serious mental illness for psychiatric treatment.Psychiatric Quarterly. 2000;71:1–13.
Anthony W.The Philosophy and Practice of Psychiatric Rehabilitation. Boston University: Center for Psychiatric Rehabilitation; 1991.
Miller R. Advance directives for psychiatric treatment: a view from the trenches.Psychology, Public Policy, and Law. 1998;4:728–745.
Srebnik D, Livingston J, Gordon L, et al. Housing choice and community success for individuals with serious and persistent mental illness.Community Mental Health Journal. 1995;31:139–152.
Swanson J, Tepper M, Backlar P, et al. Psychiatric advance directives: an alternative to coercive treatment?Psychiatry. 2000;63, 160–172.
Winick B. Advance directive instruments for those with mental illness.University of Miami Law Review. 1996;51:57–95.
Backlar P, McFarland B. A survey on use of advance directives for mental health treatment in Oregon.Psychiatric Services. 1996;47:1387–1389.
Rosenson M, Kasten A. Another view of autonomy: arranging for consent in advance.Schizophrenia Bulletin. 1991;17:1–7.
Winick B. Planning for the future through advance directive instruments.Psychology, Public Policy and Law. 1998;4:579–609.
Danis M, Southerland L, Garrett J, et al. A prospective study of advance directives for life-sustaining care.New England Journal of Medicine. 1991;324:882–888.
Fisher D. Making advance directives work for you.Natl Empowerment Cent Newsletter. 2000. Available at: www.power2u.org/selfhep/directive_work.html.
Sutherby K, Szmukler G, Halpern A, et al. A study of “crisis cards” in a community psychiatric service.Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. 1999;100:56–61.
Hawaii Rev Stat §327F-6.
United States General Accounting Office.Patient Self-Determination Act: Providers Offer Information on Advance Directives, But Effectiveness Uncertain. Report to the Ranking Minority Member, Subcommittee on Health, Committee on Ways and Means, House of Representatives; 1995.
Stavis P. The Nexum: a modest proposal for self-guardianship by contract. A system of advance directives and surrogate committees-at-large for the intermittently mentally ill.Contemporary Health Law & Policy. 1999;16:1–95.
Howe E. Lessons from advance directives for PADs.Psychiatry. 2000;63:173–177.
Kapp M. Implications of the Patient Self-Determination Act for psychiatric practice.Hospital and Community Psychiatry. 1994;45:355–358.
Dunlap J. Psychiatric advance directives: having one's say?Kentucky Law Journal. 2001;89: 327.
Tex Health & Safety Code Ann §576.002, Vernon, 1992;T.J.V. v State, 899 SW2d 379 (1995);Vo v Pham, 81 Wash App 781, 916 P2d 462 (1996),Binder v Binder, 50 Wash 2d 142, 309 P2d 1050 (1957).
Ritchie J, Sklar R, Steiner W. Advance directives in psychiatry.International Journal of Law and Psychiatry. 1998;21:245–260.
Molloy D, Silberfeld M, Darzins P, et al. Measuring capacity to complete an advance directive.Journal of the American Geriatric Society. 1996;44:660–664.
Sherman P. Computer-assisted creation of psychiatric advance directives.Community Mental Health Journal. 1998;34:351–362.
Appelbaum P, Grisso T. Assessing patients' capacities to consent to treatment.New England Journal of Medicine. 1988;319:1635–1638.
Grisso T, Appelbaum P.Assessing Competence to Consent to Treatment. New York: Oxford University Press; 1998.
Idaho Code §66-604(1).
Backlar P. The longing for order: oregon's medical advance directive for mental health treatment.Community Mental Health Journal. 1995;31:103–108.
Hawaii Rev Stat §327F-3(b)(4)(C), Wash Rev Code §70.122.030.
Dawson J, King M, Papageorgiou A, et al. Legal pitfalls of psychiatric research.British Journal of Psychiatry. 2001;176:67–70.
Halpern A, Szmukler G. Psychiatric advance directives: reconciling autonomy and non-consensual treatment.Psychiatric Bulletin. 1997;21:323–327.
Macklin A. Bound to freedom: the Ulysses contract and the psychiatric will.University of Toronto Faculty of Law Review. 1987;45:37–68.
La Stat Ann §28:224.
NC Gen Stat §122C-71, NC Gen Stat §122C-112, NC Gen Stat 32A §3. See also, La Stat Ann §28:229 and Alaska Stat §47.30.956.
Hargrave v Vermont, US Dist Ct for Vermont, File no. 2:99-CV-128, opinion and order dated October 11, 2001.
Emanuel E, Emanuel L. Four models of the physician-patient relationship.Journal of the American Medical Association. 1992;267:2221–2226.
Charles C, Gafni A, Whelan T. Decision-making in the physician-patient encounter: revisiting the shared treatment decision-making model.Social Science and Medicine. 1999;49:651–661.
Hare J, Nelson C. Will outpatients complete living wills? A comparison of two interventions.Journal of General Internal Medicine. 1991;6:41–46.
High D. Advance directives and the elderly: a study of intervention strategies to increase use.The Gerontologist. 1993;33:342–349.
Sachs G, Stocking C, Miles S. Empowerment of the older patient? A randomized, controlled trial to increase discussion and use of advance directives.Journal of the American Geriatrics Society. 1992;40:269–273.
755 Ill Comp Stat Ann §43/10, Or Rev Stat §127.702, La Stat Ann §28:222(B).
Alaska Stat §47.30.970, 755 Ill Comp Stat §43/75, Or Rev Stat §127.736.
Alaska Stat §47.30.956 and La Stat Ann §28:229.
Alaska Stat §47.30.950, Alaska Stat §47.30.980, Idaho Code §66-601, Idaho Code §66-613, 755 Ill Comp Stat §43/1, 755 Ill Comp Stat §43/1151, Okla Stat 43A §11-101, Okla Stat 43A §11-113, Or Rev Stat §127.700, Or Rev Stat §127.736.
Cuca R. Ulysses in Minnesota: first steps toward a self-binding psychiatric advance directive statute.Cornell Law Review. 1993;78:1152.
Dresser R. Bound to treatment: the Ulysses contract.The Hastings Center Report. 1984;6:13–16.
Hawaii Rev Stat §327F-1, Hawaii Rev Stat §327F-16, Alaska Stat §47.30.950, Alaska Stat §47.30.980
Sales G. The health care proxy for mental illness: can it work and should we want it?Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry & the Law. 1993;21:161–179.
Wash Rev Code §11.94.043, Wash Rev Code §70.122.010.
In re Quinlan, 70 NJ 10, 355 A2d 647 (NJ 1976), andCruzan v Dir., Mo. Department of Health, 497 US 261, 110 S Ct 2841 (1990).
64(127)Federal Register, Rules and Regulations, 36069–36089 (July 2, 1999). From theFederal Register Online via GPO Access (wais.access.gpo.gov) 64Federal Register 36069, 36069–36089 (July 2, 1999).
Alaska Stat §47.30.962, Idaho Code §66.609, Or Rev Stat §127.720
Alaska Stat §47.30.962(2), Idaho Code §66.609(2), La Stat Ann §28:230, Or Rev Stat §127.720(1)(b).
In re Grant, 747 P2d 445 (Wash 1987), In re Colyer, 660 P2d 738 (Wash 1983), In re Ingram, 689 P2d 1363 (Wash 1984).
755 Ill Comp Stat Ann §43/10-43/75, Or Rev Stat §127.700.
Or Rev Stat §127.710.
Colo Rev Stat §15-14-506(3).
Brock D. A proposal for the use of advance directives in the treatment of incompetent mentally ill persons.Bioethics. 1993;7:247–256.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Srebnik, D., Brodoff, L. Implementing psychiatric advance directives: Service provider issues and answers. The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research 30, 253–268 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02287316
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02287316