Abstract
The following kinds of data were collected on three samples of cancer research literature representing three levels of quality: (1) collaboration as measured by the number of authors per paper, (2) quantitative productivity of countries, (3) diachronous citations covering the first five years of publication, (4) total self-citations, (5) proportions of self-citations made by first-named authors, and (6) the extent of dispersion of articles among journals. Analyses showed that as the number of authors per paper increases, the proportion of high quality papers also increases and the Collaborative Index can be used to measure quality in the aggregate. It was found that the quantity and quality of cancer research done in a country are positively related. All analyses of the citation data confirmed the hypotheses that highly rated papers are significantly more highly cited than average papers and the rates of uncitedness decline with quality. The proportion of self-citations to total citations decreases with increasing quality and, on average, first-named authors of quality papers cite them proportionally fewer times than first-named authors of run-of-the mill papers do. This study also shows that, as quality increases, the extent of literature scatter or dispersion increases.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
M. C. LA FOLLETTE (Ed.),Quality in Science, Cambridge, Mass., The MIT Press, 1982.
B. MAZLISH, The quality of ‘the quality of science’: An evaluation,In: M. C. LA FOLLETTE (Ed.),Quality in Science, Cambridge, Mass., The MIT Press, 1982, p. 48–67.
J. J. GILVARRY, H. K. IHRIG, Group effort in modern physics,Science, 129 (1959) 1277.
D. DE SOLLA PRICE,Little Science, Big Science, New York, Columbia University Press, 1963.
B.L. CLARKE, Multiple authorship trends in scientific papers,Science, 143 (1964) 822.
A. J. MEADOWS,Communication in Science, London, Butterworths, 1974.
D. deB BEAVER, R. ROSEN, Studies in scientific collaboration. Part I. The professional origins of scientific co-authorship,Scientometrics, 1 (1978) 65.
D. deB BEAVER, R. ROSEN, Studies in scientific collaboration. Part II. Scientific co-authorship, research productivity and visibility in the French Scientific Elite, 1799–1830,Scientometrics, 1 (1979) 133.
D. deB BEAVER, R. ROSEN, Studies in scientific collaboration. Part III. Professionalization and the natural history of modern scientific co-authorship.Scientometrics, 1 (1979) 231.
S. M. LAWANI, On the relationship between quantity and quality of a country's research productivity,Journal of Information Science, 5 (4) (1982) 143.
A. E. BAYER, J. FOLGER, Some correlates of a citation measure of productivity in science,Sociology of Education, 39 (1966) 381.
E. GARFIELD, Citation indexing for studying science,Nature (London), 227 (1970) 669.
S. M. LAWANI, Citation analysis and the quality of scientific productivity,Bioscience, 27(1) (1977) 26.
S. M. LAWANI, A. E. BAYER, Validity of citation criteria for assessing the influence of scientific publications: new evidence with peer assessment,Journal of the American Society for Information Science 34 (1) (1983) 59.
J. A. VIRGO, A statistical procedure for evaluating the importance of scientific papers,Library Quarterly, 47 (1977) 415.
S. M. LAWANI, On the heterogeneity and classification of author self-citations,Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 33 (5) (1982) 281.
W. DENNIS, Bibliographies of eminent scientists,Scientific Monthly, 79 (1954) 180.
H. A. ZUCKERMAN, Nobel laureates in science: patterns of productivity, collaboration and authorship,American Sociological Review, 32 (1967) 391.
R. CRANDALL, The relationship between quantity and quality of publications,Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 4 (1978) 379.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lawani, S.M. Some bibliometric correlates of quality in scientific research. Scientometrics 9, 13–25 (1986). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02016604
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02016604