Abstract
The authors report the results of a preliminary prospective study involving 110 patients who were involuntarily committed from the emergency room. The study was designed to clarify the process of how psychiatric residents evaluate homicidal patients. Eighteen patients (16%) were committed for homicidal ideation, of whom 89% were psychotic. Surprisingly, for patients committed because of a risk of homicide, vital signs were obtained for only 11%, during a mean evaluation time of 2.5 hours. Aspects of an appropriate physical examination and laboratory studies that enable the clinician to distinguish organic from functional illness are described. The authors conclude that patients with homicidal ideation may receive inadequate assessment prior to their involuntary commitment. Possible explanations and solutions for this, and recommendations for further studies are offered.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Weissberg MP, Dubovsky SL: Assessment of psychiatric emergencies in medical practice. Primary Care 4:651–660, 1977.
Tupin JP: The violent patient: A strategy for management and diagnosis. Hospital & Community Psychiatry 34:37–40, 1983.
Grunberg F, Klinger BI, Grumet BR: Homicide and community-based psychiatry. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorders 166:868–873, 1978.
Husain A, Anasseril DE, Harris PW: A study of young-age and mid-life homicidal women admitted to a psychiatric hospital for pre-trial evaluation. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 28:109–112, 1983.
Tennent G, Parker E, McGrath PG, et al: Male admissions to the English Specials Hospitals-1961–1965; A demographic survey. British Journal of Psychiatry 136:181–190, 1980.
Sendi IB, Blomgren PG: A comparative study of predictive criteria in the predisposition of homicidal adolescents. American Journal of Psychiatry 132:423–427, 1975.
Anderson WH: The physical examination in office practice. American Journal of Psychiatry 137:1188–1192, 1980.
Riba M: Medical clearance: Fact or fiction in the hospital emergency room. Psychosomtics 31:400–404, 1990.
Koran LM, Sox HC, Marton KI, et al: Medical evaluation of psychiatric patients. Archives of General Psychiatry 46:733–740, 1989.
Muller JJ, Chafetz ME, Blane HT: Acute psychiatric services in the general hospital: III Statistical survey. American Journal of Psychiatry 124:46–56, 1967.
Atkins RW: Psychiatric emergency services. Archives of General Psychiatry 17:176–182, 1967.
Tischler GL: Decision-making process in the emergency room. Archives of General Psychiatry 14:69–78, 1966.
Anderson WH: Differential Diagnosis, Postgraduate Education Course on Differential Diagnosis, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, 1980.
de Bures I, Houillon G, Debaisleux T, et al: Detection of a brain tumor during a psychiatric evaluation. Annales Medico-Psychologiques 140:453–457, 1982.
Easson WM: Myxedema with psychosis. Archives of General Psychiatry 14:277–283, 1966.
Asher R: Myxoedematous madness. British Medical Journal 2:555–562, 1949.
Milne HB: Epileptic homicide: Drug-induced. British Journal of Psychiatry 134:547–548, 1979.
Trafford PA: Homicide in acute porphyria. Forensic Science 7:113–120, 1976.
Markowitz M: Acute intermittent porphyria: A report of five cases and a review of the literature. Annals of Internal Medicine 41:1170–1188, 1954.
Goldberg A: Acute intermittent porphyria: A study of fifty cases. Quarterly Journal of Medicine 28:183–209, 1959.
Simon RH, Dasilva M: Intracranial tuberculoma coexistent with uncinate seizures and violent behavior. Journal of the American Medical Association 245:1247–1248, 1981.
Peturson H, Gudjonsson GH: Psychiatric aspects of homicide. Acta Psychiatrica Scandanavia 64:363–372, 1981.
Wetli CV: Changing patterns of methaqualone abuse. Journal of the American Medical Association 249:621–626, 1983.
Luchins DJ, Sherwood PM, Gillin JC, et al: Filicide during psychotropic-induced somnambulism: A case report. American Journal of Psychiatry 135:1404–1405, 1978.
Cornelius JR, Soloff PH, Reynolds CF: Paranoia, homicidal behavior and seizures associated with phenylpropanolamine. American Journal of Psychiatry 141:120–121, 1984.
Rofman ES, Askinazi C, Fant E: The prediction of dangerous behavior in emergency civil commitment. American Journal of Psychiatry 137:1061–1064, 1980.
Rosen A: Detection of suicidal patients: An example of some limitations in the prediction of infrequent events. Journal of Consulting Psychology 18:397–403, 1954.
Shah SA: Dangerousness and civil commitment of the mentally ill: Some public policy considerations. American Journal of Psychiatry 132:501–505, 1975.
McDonald A, Paitich D: A study of homicide: The validity of predictive test factors. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 26:549–554, 1981.
Estelle v Smith: Amicus brief for the American Psychiatric Association 445US 926, 1980.
Beck JC, White KA, Gage B: Emergency psychiatric assessment of violence. American Journal of Psychiatry 148:1562–1565, 1991.
Weissberg MP: Emergency medical clearance: An educational problem. American Journal of Psychiatry 136:787–790, 1979.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Theodore A. Stern, M.D., is Associate Professor of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, and Psychiatrist and Director, Resident Psychiatric Consultation Service, Massachusetts General Hospital. Jonathan H. Schwartz, M.D., is Clinical Fellow in Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Massachusetts General Hospital. M. Cornelia Cremens, M.D., is Clinical Fellow in Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, and Chief Resident, Psychiatric Consultation Service, MGH. Albert G. Mulley, M.D., M.P.P., is Associate Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School, and Chief, General Internal Medicine Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Stern, T.A., Schwartz, J.H., Cremens, M.C. et al. The evaluation of homicidal patients by psychiatric residents in the emergency room: A pilot study. Psych Quart 62, 333–344 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01958801
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01958801