Abstract
The Japanese are traditionally regarded as nature-loving people, living in “harmony” with nature. However, this assumption is difficult to accept when observing the environmental problems in Japan. How can one explain the incongruities? Has the Japanese people's attitude toward nature changed as Japan has modernized? Is the concept of the nature-loving Japanese merely a myth? Is there another reason to explain this contradiction? This study shows political and economic origins of the paradox. The origin of the Japanese traditional idea of nature is fear and reverence of nature based on a primitive religion that developed in a rural subsistence living situation. Aesthetic and spiritual values of nature for cultural, educational, and intellectual entertainment were developed by the ruling class in the seventh century. Japan's first nature conservation movement, imported from the West, developed among the intellectual community and was advocated and promoted by the elite in the Meiji period (1868–1911). However, because deep commitment was lacking, the movement was abused by the military government before World War II. In the early 1970s the nature conservation movement seemed to be on the ascendancy, mainly because it was combined with the antipollution movement claiming the basic rights of survival. The Japanese nature conservation movement is still in the embryonic stage; in the future, the blending of some traditional resource management with the scientific philosophy of nature conservation may help promote the new wave of nature conservation in Japan.
Similar content being viewed by others
Literature cited
Asahi Shinbunsha. 1976. Nihonjin no seiji ishiki (Political concerns of the Japanese people). Asahi Shinbunsha, Tokyo. 223 pp.
Carson, R. 1962. Silent spring. Houghton Mifflin, Boston. 368 pp.
Commoner, B. 1972. The closing circle. Bantam Books, New York. 343 pp.
Endo, M. 1974. Nihon kodaishi jiten (Japan ancient history dictionary). Asakusa Shoten, Tokyo. 845 pp.
Higuchi, K. 1979. Shizen (Nature). Kodansha, Tokyo. 237 pp.
Ide, Y. 1974. Policy analysis and development in Japan. United Nations Asian Center for Development Administration-Malaysia. United Nations, New York.
Ienaga, S. 1976. Nihon bunkashi (Japan's cultural history). Iwanami Shoten, Tokyo. 267 pp.
Kakuma, T. 1979. Kasumigaseki no Yuutsu (Gloom of Kasumigaseki). PHP KenkyŪjo, Tokyo. 288 pp.
KankyŌchŌ: Shizen Hogokyoku (Nature Conservation Bureau, The Environment Agency). 1981. Shizen Hogo GyŌsei no Ayumi (The Progress of Nature Conservation Administration). Daiichi HŌki Shuppan, Tokyo. 786 pp.
Kasai, T. 1970. Nihonteki honen-shizen ni tsuite (Japanese passion about nature).Gendai no Bigaku 2:81–117.
Kihara, K. 1972a. Kanko doro to Shizen Gyosei (Scenic road and Nature Conservation Administration).Kanko 41(8):18–22.
Kihara, K. 1972b. Shizen hogo dantai no mita shizen hakai no genjo (Current conditions of natural destruction observed by nature conservation groups).Kanko 41(5):27–39.
Mainichi Shinbun Shakaibu (The Division of Social Affairs in Mainichi Newspaper). 1980. Kanryo: Sono Fushoku to KŌzŌ (The bureaucracy: Its structure of corruption). Tairiku ShobŌ, Tokyo. 286 pp.
Maslow, A. H. 1987. Motivation and personality. Harper & Row, New York. 293 pp.
Miyamoto, K. 1975. Nihon no kankyo mondai (Pollution problems in Japan). Yuhikaku, Tokyo. 299 pp.
Nishioka, T., and others. 1958. Kyodo kenkyu koza, vol. 6, Bunka (Local history series, vol. 6, culture). Kodakewa Shoten, Tokyo. 328 pp.
Oshima, T., and others. 1975. Nihon o shiru jiten (Dictionary for knowing Japan). Shakai Shisosha, Tokyo. 1005 pp.
Oyadomari, M. 1985. Politics of national parks in Japan. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Madison. 521 pp.
Suehiro, Y. 1964. Sakana to Densetsu (Fish and legend). Shinchosha, Tokyo. 243 pp.
Tsuru, S. 1963. Keizai to gendai (Economy and today). Nihon Hyoronshinsha, Tokyo. 263 pp.
Tsurutani, T. 1980. Political change in Japan. Longman, New York. 275 pp.
Uchida, E. 1934. Shiseki meisho tennen kinenbutsu hozonho kaisetsu II (Interpretation of the Law for the Preservation of Historic, Scenic, and Natural Monuments).Shiseki Meisho Tennenkinenbutsu 9(10):834–839.
Uchida, E. 1935. Shiseki meisho tennen kinenbutsu hozonho kaisetsu IV (Interpretation of the Law for the Preservation of Historic, Scenic, and National Monuments).Shiseki Meisho Tennenkinenbutsu 10(4):83–98.
Yanagida, K. 1975a. Kaison seikatsu no kenkyu (Research on fishing villages). Tosho Kankokai, Tokyo. 472 pp.
Yanagida, K. 1975b. Sanson seikatsu no kenkyu (Research on mountain villages). Tosho Kankokai, Tokyo. 593 pp.
Yanagida, Y. 1972. KankyŌhŌ nyŪmon (Introduction to the environmental laws). Simul Shuppan, Tokyo. 220 pp.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Oyadomari, M. The rise and fall of the nature conservation movement in Japan in relation to some cultural values. Environmental Management 13, 23–33 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01867584
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01867584