Abstract
Although it has been suggested that participation by physicians in administrative and policy decisions is linked to outcomes in health care organizations, there is little research on this subject. Using Shortell's framework this paper considers relationships between perceived participation and three intermediate organizational outcomes: physician work satisfaction, perceived staff consensus about day-to-day activities, and attitudes toward patients. Also considered are situational, professional, and personal characteristics which may be related to participation. Data were collected from four staff model health maintenance organizations (HMOs) in 1978 and 1979 through physician questionnaires, administrator interviews, and documents. Physicians who reported greater participation were more satisfied with work, perceived greater staff consensus, and had more favorable attitudes toward patients. Greater participation was associated with full-time employment status and more years in the HMO (but not with the physicians' professional or personal characteristics). Implications of these findings are discussed, and it is proposed that the findings suggest mechanisms by which participation in organizational decision making may affect ultimate outcomes of the organization.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Warner KE, Hutton RC: Cost-benefit and cost-effectiveness analysis in health care: Growth and composition of the literature.Med Care 18:1069, 1980.
Mushlin AI, Appel FA: Testing an outcome-based quality assurance strategy in primary care.Med Care 18 (May Suppl):1, 1980.
Shortell SM: Organization theory and health services delivery. In SM Shoretell & M Brown (eds):Organizational Research in Hospitals. Chicago, Blue Cross Assn., 1976, pp. 1–12.
Roemer MI, Friedman JW: Doctors in Hospitals: Medical Staff Organization and Hospital Performance. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins Press, 1971.
Phillips RR, Dorsey JL: A look inside: Some aspects of structure and function in forty prepaid group practice HMOs.Group Health J 1:16, 1980.
Shortell SM, Evashwick C: The structural configuration of U.S. hospital medical staffs.Med Care 19:419, 1981.
Guest RH: The role of the doctor in institutional management. In BS Georgopoulos (ed):Organization Research on Health Institutions. Ann Arbor, MI, University of Michigan, 1972, pp. 283–300.
Nathanson CA, Becker MH: Work satisfaction and performance of physicians in pediatric outpatient clinics.Health Serv Res 1:17, 1973.
Aiken M, Hage G: Organizational alienation: a comparative analysis.Am Sociological Rev 31:497, 1966.
Goss MEW, Battistella RM, Colombotos J, et al: Social organization and control in medical work: A call for research.Med Care 15(May Suppl):1, 1977.
Goodman L, Bennett E, Odem R: Current status of group medical practice in the United States.Pub Health Rep 92:430, 1977.
U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. National HMO Census of Prepaid Plans 1978. Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Public Health Service, Office of Health Maintenance Organizations, 1978.
Bachman JG, Tannenbaum AS: The control-satisfaction relationship across varied areas of experience. In AS Tannenbaum (ed):Control in Organizations. New York, McGraw-Hill Book Co., 1968, pp. 241–249.
Montagna PD:Occupations and Society. New York, John Wiley and Sons, 1977.
Madison D, Tilson H, Konrad T:Physician Recruitment, Retention, and Satisfaction in Medical Practice Organizations. Chapel Hill, NC, University of North Carolina, Health Services Research Center, 1977.
Nathanson CA, Becker MH: Control structure and conflict in outpatient clinics.J Health Soc Behav 13:251, 1972.
Georgopoulos BS: The hospital as an organization and problem-solving system. In BS Georgopoulos (ed): Organization Research on Health Institutions. Ann Arbor, MI, University of Michigan, 1972, pp. 9–48.
Freidson E: Prepaid group practice and the new “demanding patient.”Milbank Mem Fund Q 51:473, 1973.
Mechanic D: The orgnanization of medical practice and practice orientation among physicians in prepaid and nonprepaid primary care settings.Med Care 13:189, 1975.
Hornung CA, Massagli M: Primary care physicians' affective orientation toward their patients.J Health Social Behav 18:10, 1977.
Salber EJ: Caring and curing: Community participation in health services. New York, Prodist, 1975.
Steinberg MK: Multiple leadership patterns in prepaid group practice: Interaction among administrators, physicians, consumers, and community members. InProceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Group Health Institute. Washington, DC, Group Health Institute, 1978.
Goss MEW: Administration and the physician.J Pub Health 52:183, 1962.
Amsel B: Physicians' sources of professional identification in a low status prepaid group practice. Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Eastern Sociological Association, New York, 1978.
Colombotos JC, Kirchner C, Millman M: Physicians view national health insurance: A national study.Med Care 13:369, 1975.
Rhee S: Relative importance of physicians' personal and situational characteristics for the quality of patient care.J Health Social Behav 18:10, 1977.
Luft HS: Assessing the evidence on HMO performance.Milbank Mem Fund Q 58:501, 1980.
Held P, Reinhardt U (eds):Analysis of Economic Performance in Medical Group Practice: Final Report. Princeton, NJ, Mathematica Policy Research, 1979.
Brayfield AH, Rothe HF: An index of job satisfaction.J Appl Psychol 35:307, 1951.
McElrath DC: Perspective and participation of physicians in prepaid group practice.Am Sociological Rev 26:596, 1961.
Freshnock LJ, Goodman LJ: Medical group practice in the United States: Patterns of survival between 1969 and 1975.J Health Social Behav 20:352, 1979.
Pope CR: Consumer satisfaction in a health maintenance organization.J Health Social Behav 19:291, 1978.
Guest RH: Issues and discussion of part five: Doctor's role in institutional management. In BS Georgopoulos (ed):Organization Research on Health Institutions. Ann Arbor, MI, University of Michigan, 1972, pp. 329–352.
Shortell SM, LoGerfo JP: Hospital medical staff organization and quality of care: Results for myocardial infarction and appendectomy.Med Care 19:1041, 1981.
Morlock L, Nathanson CA, Horne SD: Organizational factors associated with quality of care in 17 general acute care hospitals. Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Association of University Programs in Health Administration, Toronto, 1979.
Bucher R, Stelling J: Characteristics of professional organizations.J Health Social Behav 10:3, 1969.
Additional information
A version of this paper was presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Public Health Association, New York, November, 1979. This research was supported in part by Biomedical Grant RR07059-14, #27-3022 awarded to Judith K. Barr while she was Assistant Professor of Sociology at Rutgers University, Newark. The authors acknowledge the helpful comments of Peter Zauber and Ann G. Zauber on a draft of this paper, as well as those of anonymous reviewers on an earlier versions.
Judith K. Barr is Research Projects Coordinator in the Health Affairs Research Department, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Greater New York, 3 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10016.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Barr, J.K., Steinberg, M.K. Professional participation in organizational decision making: Physicians in HMOs. J Community Health 8, 160–173 (1983). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01666451
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01666451