Abstract
Over the course of a three year observation and study period, some 6% of a representative community residing urban elderly population were admitted to nursing homes. Nearly half of this group were still living in nursing homes at the end of this observation period. One third had died after entering the nursing home, and the remaining people had returned to their own homes in the community. These three groups had significantly different mean lengths of stay in nursing homes; nearly two years for those whose stays were more permanent, 50 days for those whose stays were short-term, and 153 days on average for those who died following admission.
At baseline, the three groups also tended to have different patterns of health, functional and social characteristics. The short term stayers and those who died following admission to a nursing home differed from respondents who did not enter nursing homes—primarily in terms of prior living arrangements and levels of social support. The permanent stayers differed from the two other nursing home sub-groups, and from community residents, in that they tended to be older and more functionally and mentally impaired. However, at baseline they appeared at less risk to expire than those people who later died following admission to nursing homes.
Clinical and research implications based on these findings are discussed.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Kane, RA and Kane, RL, Long-term care: Principles, programs, and policies. New York: Springer Publishing Company, 1987, Pp. 223–278.
Rabin, DL, and Stockton, P, Long-term care for the elderly: A factbook. New York: Oxford University Press, 1987. Pp. 113–140.
Cohen, MA, Tell, EJ, and Wallack, SS, The lifetime risks and costs of nursing home use among the elderly. Med Care 24:12 1161–1172, 1986.
Liang, J, Jow-Ching Tu, E, Estimating lifetime risk of nursing home residency: A further note. Gerontologist 26:5 560–563, 1986.
McConnel, CE, A note on the lifetime risk of nursing home residency. Gerontologist 24:2 193–198, 1984.
Rice, T, and Gabel, J, Protecting the edlerly against high health care costs. Health Aff 5:3 5–21, 1986.
Liu, K, and Manton, KG, The characteristics and utilization pattern of an admission cohort of nursing home patients. Gerontologist 23:1 92–98, 1983.
Guralnik, JM, Yanagishita, M, Schneider, EL, Projecting the older population of the United States: Lessons from the past and prospects for the future. Milbank Q 66:2 283–308, 1988.
Weissert, WG, Estimating the long-term care population: Prevalence rates and selected characteristics. Health Care Financ Rev 6:4 83–91, 1985.
Hing, E, Use of nursing homes by the elderly: Preliminary data from the 1985 national nursing home survey. National Center for Health Statistics, Advance data from vital and health statistics. No. 135. DHHS Pub. No. (PHS) 87–1250. Public Health Service, Hyattsville, Md., 1987.
Strahan, G, Nursing home characteristics: Preliminary data from the 1985 national nursing home survey. National Center for Health Statistics, Advance data from vital and health statistics. No. 131. DHHS Pub. No. (PHS) 87–1250. Public Health Service, Hyattsville, Md., 1987.
Meiners, MR, Thorburn, P, Roddy, PC, and Jones, BJ, Nursing home admissions: The results of an incentive reimbursement experiment. Long-Term Care Studies Program Research Report, DHHS Publication No. (PHS) 86–3397. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Center for Health Services Research and Health Care Technology Assessment, 1985.
Dolinsky, AL, and Rosenwaike, I, The role of demographic factors in the institutionalization of the elderly. Res Aging 10:2 235–257, 1988.
Cohen, MA, Tell, EJ, and Wallack, SS, The risk factors of nursing home entry among residents of six continuing care retirement communities. J Gerontol: Social Sciences 43:1 S15–21, 1988.
Branch, LG, and Jette AM, A prospective study of long-term care institutionalization among the aged. Am J Public Health 72:1373–1379, 1982.
Kane, RL, Bell, R, Riegler, S, Wilson, A, and Keeler, E, Predicting the outcomes of nursing home patients. Gerontologist 23:2 200–206, 1983.
Liu, K, and Manton, KG, The effect of nursing home use on medicaid eligibility. Gerontologist 29:1 59–66, 1989.
Greene, VL, Nursing home admission risk and the cost-effectiveness of community-based long-term care: A framework for analysis. Health Serv Res 22:5 655–669, 1987.
Chiswick, BR, The demand for nursing home care: An analysis of the substitution between institutional and noninstitutional care. J Hum Resour 11:3 295–316.
Weissert, WG, and Cready, CM, Determinants of hospital—to—nursing home placement delays: A pilot study. Health Serv Res 23:5 619–641, 1988.
Cohen, MA, Tell, EJ, and Wallack, SS, Client-related risk factors of nursing home entry among elderly adults. J Gerontol 41:6 785–792, 1986.
Lewis, MA, Leake, B, Clark, V, and Leal-Sotelo, M, Case mix and outcomes of nursing home patients: The importance of prior nursing home care and admission from home versus hospital. Med Care 27:4 376–385, 1989.
Shapiro, E, and Tate, R, Who is really at risk of institutionalization? Gerontologist 28:2 237–245, 1988.
Manheim, LM, and Hughes, SL, Use of nursing homes by a high-risk long-term care population. Health Serv Res 21:2 161–176, 1986.
Vicente, L, Wiley, JA, and Carrington, RA, Duration of stay and other aspects of nursing home use. Int J Aging Hum Dev 12:4 301–312, 1980-81.
Keeler, EB, Kane, RL, and Solomon, DH, Short and long-term residents of nursing homes. Med Care 19:3 363–369, 1981.
Liu, K, and Manton, KG, The length-of-stay pattern of nursing home admissions. Med Care 21:12 1211–1222, 1983.
Swan, JH, and Harrington, C, Estimating undersupply of nursing home beds in states. Health Serv Res 28:1 57–83, 1986.
Ray, WA, Federspiel, CF, Baugh, DK, and Dodds, S, Interstate variation in elderly medicaid nursing home populations: Comparisons of resident characteristics and medical care utilization. Med Care 25:8 738–752, 1987.
Rohrer, JE, Access to nursing home care: A need-based approach. Med Care 25:8 796–800, 1987.
Densen, PM, The elderly and the health care system: Another perspective. Milbank Q 65:4 614–638, 1987.
Morris, JN, Sherwood, S, and Gutkin, CE, Inst-Risk II: An approach to forecasting relative risk of future institutional placement. Health Serv Res 23:4 511–536, 1988.
Kemper, P, Applebaum, R, and Harrigan, M, Community care demonstrations: What have we learned? Health Care Financ Rev 8:4 87–100, 1987.
Weissert, WG, The national channeling demonstration: What we knew, know now, and still need to know. Health Serv Res, 23:1 175–187, 1988.
Shapiro, E, Tate, RB, Roos, NP, Do nursing homes reduce hospital use? Med Care 25:1 1–8, 1987.
Oktay, JS, and Volland, PJ, Foster home care for the frail elderly as an alternative to nursing home care: An experimental evaluation. Am J Public Health 77:12 1505–1510, 1987.
Kelman, HR, and Thomas, C, Hospital and ambulatory service use by the urban elderly under different health care delivery systems. Med Care 26:8 739–749, 1988.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Howard R. Kelman, Ph.D. is Director, and Cynthia Thomas, Ph.D. is Senior Research Associate, Division of Health Services Organization and Policy, Department of Epidemiology and Social Medicine, Montefiore Medical Center and Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, New York 10467
This work was supported by grants PO1 AGO3424 and RO1 AGO8125 from the National Institute on Aging
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kelman, H.R., Thomas, C. Transitions between community and nursing home residence in an urban elderly population. J Community Health 15, 105–122 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01321315
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01321315