Conclusions
This survey has considered the effects of taxation on risk-taking from both a partial and a general equilibrium viewpoint. The most relevant results to emerge at a very general level are that in the former taxation will typically increase risk-taking, while in the latter it is typically better to tax risky industries more heavily than safe; both results are contrary to conventional views.
While the work surveyed shows that substantial progress has been made on this question it also shows that there remains much to be done. This seems to fall into three categories. Firstly, the investigation by variational methods of the properties of an optimal (not necessary linear) tax function in a simple model; secondly, the combination of these ideas on the optimal taxation of risky property income with those in the taxation of labor income, and also of expenditures; and finally, the incorporation of risk into all forms of optimal taxation model, not only those explicitly concerned with risky assets. These however are far from simple problems.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
M. G. Allingham: Progression and Leisure, The American Economic Review, forthcoming.
M. G. Allingham: Optimal Taxation with Heterogeneous Preferences, presented at Econometric Society Barcelona Meeting, 1971.
M. G. Allingham: The Measurement of Inequality, The Journal of Economic Theory, forthcoming.
K. J. Arrow: Aspects of the Theory of Risk Bearing, Helsinki 1965.
A. B. Atkinson: On the Measurement of Inequality, The Journal of Economic Theory2 (1970), pp. 244–263.
A. B. Atkinson and J. E. Stiglitz: The Structure of Indirect Taxation, The Journal of Public Economics, forthcoming.
G. O. Bierwag and M. A. Grove: Portfolio Selection and Taxation, Oxford Economic Papers, N. S.19 (1967), pp. 215–220.
K. H. Borch: The Economics of Uncertainty, Princeton 1968.
E. C. Brown: Mr. Kaldor on Taxation and Risk Bearing, The Review of Economic StudiesXXV (1957–1958), pp. 49–52.
E. D. Domar and R. A. Musgrave: Proportional Income Taxation and Risk Taking, The Quarterly Journal of EconomicsLVIII (1944), pp. 388–422.
M. Feldstein: The Effects of Taxation on Risk Taking, Journal of Political Economy77 (1969), p. 755–764.
J. S. Flemming: Portfolio Choice and Taxation in Continuous Time, presented at IEA Bergen Meeting, 1971.
J. Lintner: The Valuation of Risk Assets and the Selection of Risky Investments in Stock Portfolios and Capital Budgets, The Review of Economics and StatisticsXLVII (1965), pp. 13–37.
J. A. Mirrlees: An Exploration in the Theory of Optimum Income Taxation, The Review of Economic StudiesXXXVIII (1971), pp. 175–208.
J. Mossin: Taxation and Risk Taking: An Expected Utility Approach, Economica, N. S.XXXV (1968), pp. 74–82.
R. A. Musgrave: The Theory of Public Finance, New York 1959.
B. Näslund: Some Effects of Taxes on Risk Taking, The Review of Economic StudiesXXXV (1968), pp. 289–306.
R. G. Penner: A Note on Portfolio Selection and Taxation, The Review of Economic StudiesXXXI (1964), pp. 83–86.
M. K. Richter: Cardinal Utility, Portfolio Selection and Taxation, The Review of Economic StudiesXXVII (1959–1960), pp. 152–166.
A. D. Roy: Safety first and the Holding of Assets, Econometrica20 (1952), pp. 431–449.
W. R. Russell and P. E. Smith: Taxation, Risk Taking and Stochastic Dominance, Southern Economic JournalXXXVI (1969–1970), pp. 425–433.
A. Sandmo: Capital Risk, Consumption, and Portfolio Choice, Econometrica37 (1969), pp. 586–599.
A. N. Shibata: Effects of Taxation on Risk Taking, The American Economic Review (papers and proceedings)LIX (1969), pp. 553–561.
J. E. Stiglitz: The Effects of Income, Wealth, and Capital Gains Taxation on Risk Taking, The Quarterly Journal of EconomicsLXXXIII (1969), pp. 263–283.
J. E. Stiglitz: Taxation, Risk Taking, and the Allocation of Investment in a Competitive Economy, unpublished Yale discussion paper, 1970.
P. Streeten: The Effect of Taxation on Risk Taking, Oxford Economic Papers, N. S. V (1953), pp. 271–287.
J. Tobin: Liquidity Preference as Behaviour towards Risk, The Review of Economic Studies XXV (1957–1958), pp. 65–86.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Allingham, M.G. Risk-taking and taxation. Zeitschr. f. Nationalökonomie 32, 203–224 (1972). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01282416
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01282416