Abstract
This paper first surveys the four principal positions in the debate about the policy influence of professional experts — technocracy, extensive mandates, limited mandates, and “servants of power” — and finds none entirely satisfactory. While the limited mandates position is the best general characterization of the policy influence of experts, many instances reveal more extensive influence. The papers argues for shifting the discussion from general characterizations to the systematic analysis of variation in the extent and significance of professional influence. A framework for analyzing this variation is proposed. The framework highlights the importance of depoliticization, the framing of issues as narrowly technical or involving the protection of a central cultural value, political situations that encourage the informal capture of power by professional experts or the delegation of power to experts, and the differing level of legitimacy enjoyed by professional occupations, based on their centrality in social regulation.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aberbach, Joel D., Robert D. Putnam, andBert A. Rockman 1981 Bureaucrats and Politicians in Western Democracies. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Aberbach, Joel D. andBert A. Rockman 1974 “Clashing beliefs within the executive branch: The Nixon atministrition bureaucracy.” American Political Science Review 70:456–468.
Alford, Robert andRoger Friedland 1985 The Powers of Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Allison, Graham T. 1971 Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cuban Missile Crisis. Boston: Little-Brown.
Alonso, William andPaul Starr, eds. 1987 The Politics of Numbers. New York: Russell Sage.
Arney, William Ray andBernard J. Bergen 1984 Medicine and the Management of Living. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bachrach, Peter andMorton S. Baratz 1970 Power and Poverty. New York: Oxford University Press.
Banfield, Edward 1961 Political Influence. New York: Free Press.
1974/75 “Consensus and conflict among American leaders.” Public Opinion Quarterly 38:504–30.
1984 “Determinants of elite policy attitudes.” In B. A. Rockman and R. H. Linden (eds.), Elite Studies and Comparative Studies. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Bell, Daniel 1973 The Coming of Post-Industrial Society. New York: Basic Books.
Bernstein, Basil 1977 Class, Codes and Control, vol. 3. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Bledstein, Burton 1976 The Culture of Professionalism. New York: W. W. Norton.
Block, N. J. andGerald Dworkin 1976 “IQ, heritability and inequality.” In N. J. Block and Gerald Dworkin (eds.), The IQ Controversy: 410–542. New York: Pantheon.
1981 “Strqtification in the professions: In analyis of academe, science, engineering, medicine, law,(and corporate management.” Unpublished paper, The Huron Institute, Cambridge, MA.
Brint, Steven In press Retainers, Merchants, and Priests: A Political Sociology of the Professional Middle Class America. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Brint, Steven andJerome Karabel 1989 The Diverted Dream: Community Colleges and the Promise of Educational Opportunity in America, 1900–1985. New York: Oxford University Press.
Brzezinski, Zbigniew 1970 Between Two Ages: America's Role in the Technetronic Era. New York: Viking Press.
Burck, Charles G. 1976 “A group profile of the Fortune 500 chief executive.” Fortune (May):173ff.
Carr-Saunders, A. M. andP. A. Wilson 1933 The Professions. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Collins, Randall 1979 The Credential Society. New York: Academic Press.
Cremin, Lawrence 1964 The Transformation of the School. New York: Random House.
Crenson, Matthew A. 1971 The Unpolitics of Air Pollution. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Cronin, Thomas E. andNorman C. Thomas 1971 “Federal advisory processes: Advice and discontent.” Science 171:771–779.
Dalton, Melvin 1959 Men Who Manage. New York: Wiley.
Domhoff, G. William 1970 The Higher Circles. New York: Random House.
Dye, Thomas R. 1978 Understanding Public Policy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Ehrenreich, John and Barbara Ehrenreich 1977 “The professional-managerial class, I.” Radical America (March–April):7–31.
Ellul, Jacques 1964 The Technological Society. New York: Vintage.
1973 “Professions and the occupational principle.” In Freidson (ed.), Professions and Their Prospects: 19–38. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
1986 Professional Powers. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Galbraith, John Kenneth 1967 The New Industrial State. New York: Houghton-Mifflin.
Gaventa, John 1980 Power and Powerlessness. New York: Oxford University Press.
Glaser, Barry G., ed. 1968 Organizational Careers. Chicago: Aldine.
Gordon, Robert J. 1981 “The Consumer Price Index: Measuring inflation and causing it.” The Public Interest 63:112–134.
1976 The Dialectic of Ideology and Technology. New York: Seabury Press.
1979 The Future of Intellectuals and the Rise of the New Class. New York: Seabury Press.
1982 “The idiom of legalism in bar politics: Lawyers, McCarthyism and the Civil Rights era.” American Bar Association Research Journal 1982:911–989.
1985 “Knowledge mandates: Collective influence by scientific, normative and syncretic professions.” British Journal of Sociology 36:421–47.
1987 Beyond Monopoly: Lawyers, State Crises, and Professional Empowerment. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Haskell, Thomas L. 1984 “Professionalism versus capitalism.” In Thomas L. Haskell (ed.), The Authority of Experts: 180–225. Bloomington, IN: University of Indiana Press.
Herman, Edward S. 1981 Corporate Control, Corporate Power. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Heydebrand, Wolf V. 1983 “Technocratic corporatism: Toward a theory of occupational and organizational transformation.” In Robert Hall and Robert Quinn (eds.), Organizational Theory and Public Policy: 93–114. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
1977 “Political parties and macroeconomic policies.” American Political Science Review 71:467–87.
1982 “On the demand for economic outcomes: Macroeconomic performance and mass political support in the United States, Great Britain and Germany.” Journal of Politics 44:426–63.
Hicks, Alexander 1984 “Electrons, Keynes, bureaucracy and class.” American Sociological Review 49:165–82.
Hilgartner, Stephen 1984 “The binary weapons controversy.” In Dorothy Nelkin (ed.), Controversy: The Politics of Technical Decisions: 143–158. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Hilgartner, Stephen andCharles L. Bosk 1988 “The rise and fall of social problems: A public arenas model.” American Journal of Sociology 94:53–78.
Hirschman, Albert O. 1988 “How Keynes was spread in America.” Challenge 31:4–7.
Hofstadter, Richard 1955 The Age of Reform. New York: Knopf.
Houdek, Frank G. 1985 The Freedom of Information Act: A Comprehensive Bibliography of Law-Related Materials, 3rd ed. Austin: University of Texas.
1959 “The study of occupations.” In Robert K. Merton, Leonard Broom, and Leonard S. Cottrell, Jr. (eds.), Sociology Today: 442–458. New York: Basic Books.
1963 “Professions.” Daedalus 92:665–668.
Jacob, Herbert 1988 Silent Revolution: The Transformation of Divorce Law in the United States. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kevles, Daniel J. 1975 “Scientists, the military, and the control of post-war defense research: The case of the Research Board for National Security, 1944–46:” Technology and Culture 16:20–47.
Kissinger, Henry 1969 American Foreign Policy. New York: Norton.
Kristol, Irving 1972 “About equality.” Commentary 54:41–47.
Lakoff, Stanford A. 1977 “Scientists, technologists and political power.” In Ina Spiegel-Rosing and Derek de Solla Price (eds.), Science, Technology, and Society: 355–391. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Lakoff, Sanford A., ed. 1966 Knowledge and Power: Essays on Science and Government. New York: Free Press.
1977 The Rise of Professionalism. Berkeley: University of California Press.
1984 “The production of expertise and the constitution of expert power.” In Thomas L. Haskell (ed.), The Authority of Experts: 28–80. Blcomington: Indiana University Press.
Lasch, Christopher 1977 Haven in a Heartless World: The Family Besieged. New York: Basic Books.
Laumann, Edward O. andDavid Knoke 1987 The Organizational State: Social Change in National Policy Domains. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
Lipset, Seymour Martin 1981 Political Man: The Social Bases of Politics, rev. ed. (1960) Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press.
Lowi, Theodore 1979 The End of Liberalism: The Second Republic in America, 2d ed. New York: W. W. Norton.
Luker, Kristin 1985 Abortion and the Politics of Motherhood. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Lukes, Steven 1974 Power: A Radical View. London: Macmillan.
Malbin, Michael J. 1980 Unelected Representatives. New York: Basic Books.
Marcuse, Herbert 1961 One-Dimensional Man. Boston: Beacon Press.
Mazur, Allan 1973 “Disputes between experts.” Minerva 11:243–262.
Meynaud, Jean 1969 Technocracy. New York: Free Press.
Mills, C. Wright 1956 The Power Elite. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mollenkopf, John II. 1983 The Contested City. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
1965 “The professionalization of reform.” The Public Interest 1:6–16.
1973 The Politics of a Guaranteed Income. New York: Random House.
Mulkay, Michael 1976 “The mediating role of the scientific elite.” Social Studies of Science 6:445–70.
1975 “The political impact of technical expertise.” Social Studies of Science 5:35–54.
1977 “Technology and public policy.” In Ina Spiegel-Rosing and Derek de Solla Price (eds.), Science, Technology, and Society: 392–442. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
1982 The Creation Controversy: Science or Scripture. New York: W. W. Norton.
Nelkin, Dorothy, ed. 1984 Controversy: The Politics of Technical Decisions, 2nd ed. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Netzer, Dick 1978 The Subsidized Muse. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Noble, David 1977 America by Design. New York: Knopf.
Owen, David 1985 None of the Above: The Myth of Scholastic Aptitude. Boston: Houghton-Mifflin.
Padgett, John F. 1981 “Hierarchy and ecological control in federal budgetary decision-making.” American Journal of Sociology 87:75–129.
Piven, Frances Fox andRichard P. Cloward 1972 Regulating the Poor: The Functions of Public Relief. New York: Random House.
Prewitt, Kenneth andWilliam McAllister 1976 “Changes in the American executive elite, 1930–1970.” In H. Eulau and M. M. Czudnowski (eds.), Elite Recruitment in Democratic Politics: 105–132. New York: Sage—John Wiley.
Primack, Joel andFrank von Hippel 1974 Advice and Dissent: Scientists in the Political Arena. New York: Basic Books.
Putnam, Robert D. 1977 “Elite transformation in advanced industrial societies: An empirical assessment of the theory of technocracy.” Comparative Political Studies 10:383–412.
Rado, Leslie 1981 “Death redefined: Social and cultural influences on legislation.” Journal of Communications 31:41–47.
Ravitch, Diane 1983 The Troubled Crusade. New York: Basic Books.
Rothman, David J. 1971 The Discovery of the Asylum. Boston: Little, Brown.
Rothman, Stanley andS. Robert Lichter 1982 “Media and business elites: Two classes in conflict?” The Public Interest 69:117–125.
Russett, Bruce M. 1974 “Political perspectives of U.S. Military and business elites.” Armed Forces and Society 1:79–108.
Salisbury, Robert H. 1979 “Why no corporatism in the United States?” In Phillipe C. Schmitter and Gerhard Lehmbruch (eds.), Trends in Corporatist Intermediation: 213–230. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Schudson, Michael 1972 “Organizing the meritocracy: A history of the college examination boards.” Harvard Educational Review 42:34–69.
Scotch, Richard K. 1984 From Good Will to Civil Rights. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
Scull, Andrew T. 1979 Museums of Madness. London: Allen-Lane.
Shils, Edward A. 1968 “Deference.” In John A. Jackson (ed.), Social Stratification: 104–132. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Shilts, Randy 1986 And the Band Played On. New York: Random House.
Skocpol, Theda 1985 “Bringing the state back in: Strategies of analysis in current research.” In Peter B. Evans, Dietrich Rheschmeyer, and Theda Skocpol (eds.), Bringing the State Back In: 3–43. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Smith, Hedrick 1988 The Power Game. New York: Random House.
1983 The Social Transformation of American Medicine. New York: Basic Books.
1987 “The sociology of official statistics.” In William Alonso and Paul Starr (eds.), The Politics of Numbers: 7–57. New York: Russell Sage.
Stockman, David A. 1986 The Triumph of Politics: Why the Reagan Revolution Failed. New York: Harper & Row.
Suleiman, Ezra 1978 Elites in French Society. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Sussman, Barry 1976 “Elites in America: A Washington Post-Harvard survey.” The Washington Post (September 26–30).
Thomas, George et al. 1987 Institutional Structure: Constituting State, Society, and the Individual. New York: Sage.
Touraine, Alain 1971 The Post-Industrial Society. New York: Random House.
Tyack, David 1974 The One Best System. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Tyack, David andElizabeth Hansot 1982 Managers of Virtue. New York: Basic Books.
Useem, Michael andJerome Karabel 1986 “Pathways to corporate management.” American Sociological Review 51:184–200.
Walker, Jack L. 1977 “Setting the agenda for the U. S. Senate: A problem of selection.” British Journal of Political Science 7:423–445.
Weinstein, James 1968 The Corporate Ideal in the Liberal State, 1900–1918. Boston: Beacon Press.
Wiebe, Robert 1968 The Search for Order. New York: Hill and Wang.
Wilson, Graham K. 1982 “Why is there no corporatism in the United States?” In Gerhard Lehmbruch and Phillipe C. Schmitter, (eds.), Patterns of Corporatist Policy-Making: 219–236. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Wong, Sandra 1990 “Textbooks: The social selection of educational knowledge.” Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Sociology, Yale University.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brint, S. Rethinking the policy influence of experts: From general characterizations to analysis of variation. Sociol Forum 5, 361–385 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01115092
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01115092