Abstract
It is commonly assumed that psychiatric patients require greater protection than medical patients when they make health care decisions. A review of the literature reveals that there is meager evidence for this belief and that both groups have significant capacity problems. Many factors other than psychiatric illness have been shown to impede understanding of informed consent information in health care settings. These include powerful emotional states, lack of a high school education, the presence of a severe medical illness, and increasing age. Clinicians can help patients become more adequate decision makers by taking such steps as providing adequate disclosure and inquiring about patient understanding. Even then, setting a realistically lenient standard of capacity seems the most practical approach. If screening for capacity is important for a specific health care decision, all vulnerable groups should be targeted.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research: Making Health Care Decisions. Washington, DC, United States Government Printing Office, 1982.
Zinermon v. Burch, 110 S. Ct. 975, 1990.
Golden JS, Johnston GD: Problems of distortion in doctor-patient communication. Psychiatry in Medicine 1:127–148, 1970.
Leonard CO, Chase GA, Childs B: Genetic counseling: A consumer's view. New England Journal of Medicine 287:433–439, 1972.
Byrne DJ, Napier A, Cuschieri A: How informed is signed consent? British Medical Journal 296:839–840, 1988.
Cassileth BR, Zubkis RV, Sutton-Smith K, et al. Informed consent — Why are its goals imperfectly realized? New England Journal of Medicine 302:896–900, 1980.
Wallace LN: Informed consent to elective surgery: The “therapeutic” value? Social Science in Medicine 22:29–33, 1986.
McCollum AT, Schwartz, AH: Pediatric research hospitalization: Its meaning to parents. Pediatric Research 3:199–204, 1969.
Simes RJ, Tattersall MH, Coates AS, et al: Randomized comparison of procedures for obtaining informed consent in clinical trials of treatment for cancer. British Medical Journal 293:1065–1068, 1986.
Riecken HW, Ravich R: Informed consent to biomedical research in Veterans Administration hospitals. Journal of the American Medical Association 248:344–348, 1982.
Fellner CH, Marshall JR: 12 Kidney Donors. Journal of the American Medical Association 206:2703–2707, 1968.
Small IF, Messina JA, Small JG: The meaning of hospitalization: A comparison of attitudes of medical and psychiatric patients. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorders 139:575–580, 1964.
Soskis DA: Schizophrenic and medical inpatients as informed drug consumers. Archives of General Psychiatry 35:645–647, 1978.
Stanley B, Stanley M, Lautin A, et al: Preliminary findings on psychiatric patients as research participants: A population at risk? American Journal of Psychiatry 138:669–671, 1981.
Jaffe R: Problems of long-term informed consent. Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 14:163–169, 1986.
Grisso T, Appelbaum PS: Mentally ill and non-mentally ill patients' abilities to understand informed consent disclosures for medication: Preliminary data. Law and Human Behavior 15:377–388, 1991.
Weiner MF, Lovitt R: An examination of patients' understanding of information from health care providers. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 35:619–620, 1984.
Meisel A, Roth LH: What we do and do not know about informed consent. Journal of the American Medical Association 246:2473–2477, 1981.
Norko MA, Billick SB, McCarrick RG, et al: A clinical study of competency to consent to voluntary psychiatric hospitalization. American Journal of Forensic Psychiatry 11:3–15, 1990.
Roth LH, Lidz CW, Meisel A, et al: Competency to decide about treatment or research: An overview of some empirical data. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 5:51–63, 1982.
Stanley B, Guido J, Stanley M, et al: The elderly patient and informed consent: Empirical findings. Journal of the American Medical Association 252:1302–1306, 1984.
Taub HA, Baker MT, Sturr JF: Informed consent for research: Effects of readability patient age and education. Journal of the American Geriatric Society 34:601–606, 1986.
Hoffman BF, Srinivasan J: A study of competence to consent to treatment in a psychiatric hospital. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 37:179–182, 1992.
Drane JF: The many faces of competency. The Hastings Center Report 15 No. 2:17–21, 1985.
Cournos F, McKinnon K, Stanley B: Outcome of involuntary medication in a state hospital system. American Journal of Psychiatry 148:489–494, 1991.
Cournos F: Involuntary medication and the case of Joyce Brown. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 40:736–740, 1989.
Sarti P, Cournos F: Medication and psychotherapy in the treatment of chronic schizophrenia, in Combined Psychotherapy and Pharmacotherapy, edited by Marcus E, Psychiatric Clinics of North America 13: 215–228, 1990.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cournos, F. Do psychiatric patients need greater protection than medical patients when they consent to treatment?. Psych Quart 64, 319–329 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01064925
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01064925