Abstract
This article empirically examines how savings and loan associations' (S&Ls') stock returns respond to asset mix changes. When deposit insurance is underpriced, increases in financial leverage and the riskiness of the asset portfolio should lead to increases in expected return on common stock. In particular, changes in asset components which increase the volatility of an institution's portfolio should lead the stock market to upwardly revalue S&L equity. This hypothesis is examined using data for the July 1984–December 1989 period. Increases in commercial mortgage loans, acquisition and development loans, and investments in service corporations appear to cause higher return for shareholders of poorly capitalized, failing S&Ls. Similar increases appear to have little impact on the common stock returns of well-capitalized S&Ls.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barth, James R., Philip F. Bartholomew and Michael G. Bradley. “The Determinants of Thrift Institution Resolution Costs.”Journal of Finance 45 (July 1990), 731–754.
Barth, James R., Philip F. Bartholomew, and Carol Labich. “Moral Hazard and the Thrift Crisis: An Analysis of 1988 Resolutions.”Proceedings of a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (May 1989), 344–384.
Barth, James R., and Michael G. Bradley. “Thrift Deregulation and Federal Deposit Insurance.”Journal of Financial Services Research 2 (September 1989), 231–259.
Barth, James R., Dan R. Brumbaugh, Jr., Daniel Sauerhaft, and George H. K. Wang. “Thrift Institution Failures: Causes and Policy Issues.”Proceedings of a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (May 1985), 184–216.
Benston, George J., and Michael F. Koehn. “Capital Dissipation, Deregulation, and the Insolvency of Thrifts.” Unpublished paper, December 1989.
Benston, George J., and Mike Carhill. “The Thrift Disaster: A Test of the Moral Hazard and Other Hypotheses.” In. G.G. Kaufman, ed.,Research in Financial Services, Greenwich: JAI Press Inc. 1994.
Benston, George J., and George G. Kaufman.Risk and Solvency Regulation of Depository Institutions: Past Policies and Current Options. Monograph Series in Finance and Economics, Salomon Brothers Center for the Study of Financial Institutions1988.
Benston, George J. “Direct Investments and FSLIC Losses.” In: G. G. Kaufman, ed.,Research in Financial Services: Private and Public Policy. Greenwich: JAI Press Inc. 1989, 25–77.
Benston, George J.An Analysis of the Causes of Savings and Loan Association Failure. Monograph Series in Finance and Economics, Salomon Brothers Center for the Study of Financial Institutions. 1985.
Brickley, James A., and Christopher M. James. “Access to Deposit Insurance, Insolvency Rules and the Stock Returns of Financial Institutions.”Journal of Financial Economics 16 (July 1986), 345–371.
Buser, Stephen A., Andrew H. Chen, and Edward J. Kane. “Federal Deposit Insurance, Regulatory Policy and Optimal Bank Capital.Journal of Finance 36 (March 1981), 51–60.
Calomiris, Charles W. “Do ‘Vulnerable’ Economies Need Deposit Insurance?: Lessons From the U.S. Agricultural Boom and Bust of 1920s.” Working Paper No. 89-18, Issues in Financial Regulation, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, October 1989.
Chance, Don M. and William R. Lane. “A Re-examination of Interest Rate Sensitivity in the Common Stock Returns of Financial Institutions.”Journal. of Financial Research 3 (Spring 1980), 49–55.
Cole, Rebel A. “When are Thrift Institutions Closed? An Agency-Theoretic Model.”Journal of Financial Service Research 7 (December 1993), 283–307.
Cole, Rebel A. “Insolvency Versus Closure: Why the Regulatory Delay in Closing Troubled Thrifts?” Financial Industry Studies Working Paper No. 2-90, Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, July 1990a.
Cole, Rebel A. “Agency Conflicts and Thrift Resolution Cost.” Financial Industry Studies Working Paper No. 3-90, Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, July 1990b.
Cox, John C., and Mark Rubinstein.Options Markets. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, Inc. 1985.
Federal Home Loan Bank Board. “Net Worth Requirements of Insured Institutions.” 12 CFR Parts 561, 563, 570, 571, and 584, proposed rule,Federal Register 49 (December 7 1984), 47852–47870.
Flannery, Mark J. “Recapitalizing the Thrift Industry.”Proceedings of the Eleventh Annual Conference, Federal Home Loan Bank of San Francisco, (December 1985), 91–113.
Flannery, Mark J., and Christopher James “The Effect of Interest Rate Changes on the Common Stock Returns of Financial Institutions.”Journal of Finance 39 (September 1984), 1141–1153.
Furlong, Frederick T., and Michael C. Keeley, “Capital Regulation and Bank Risk-taking: A Note.”Journal of Banking and Finance 13 (December 1989), 883–891.
Garcia, Gillian. “FSLIC is ‘Broke’ in More Ways Than One.”Cato Journal 7 (Winter 1988), 727–741.
Garcia, Gillian, and Michael Polakoff. “Does Capital Forbearance Pay and If So For Whom?”Proceedings of a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (May 1987), 285–305.
Glejser, H. “A New Test for Heteroscedasticity,”Journal of the American Statistical Association 64 (March 1969), 316–323.
Kane, Edward J.The Gathering Crisis in Federal Deposit Insurance. Cambridge: MIT Press. 1985.
Kane, Edward J.The S&L Insurance Mess. Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute Press. 1989.
Kane, Edward J., and Haluk Unal. “Modeling Structural and Temporal Variation in the Market's Valuation of Banking Firms.”Journal of Finance 45 (March 1990), 113–136.
Kwan, Simon H. “Re-examination of Interest Rate Sensitivity of Commercial Bank Stock Returns Using a Random Coefficient Model.”Journal of Financial Services Research 5 (March 1991), 61–76.
Jensen, Michael C. and William H. Meckling. “Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure.”Journal of Financial Economics 3 (October 1976), 305–360.
Keeley, Michael C., and Frederick T. Furlong. “A Reexamination of Mean-Variance Analysis of Bank Capital Regulation.”Journal of Banking and Finance 14 (March 1990), 69–84.
Lloyd, William P., and Richard A. Shick. “A Test of Stone's Two-Index Model of Returns.”Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 12 (September 1977), 363–373.
Lynge, Morgan J., and J. Kenton Zumwalt. “An Empirical Study of the Interest Rate Sensitivity of Commercial Bank Returns: A Market Index Approach.”Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 15 (September 1980), 731–742.
McKenzie, Joseph A., Rebel A. Cole, and Richard A. Brown. “Moral Hazard, Portfolio Allocation, and Asset Returns for Thrift Institutions.”Journal of Financial Service Research 5 (April 1992), 315–339.
Merton, Robert C. “On the Cost of Deposit Insurance When There are Surveillance Costs.”Journal of Business 51 (July 1978), 439–452.
Merton, Robert C. “Analytical Derivation of the Cost of Deposit Insurance and Loan Guarantees: An Application of Modern Option Pricing Theory.”Journal of Banking and Finance 1 (June 1977), 3–11.
Stone, Bernell K. “Systematic Interest Rate Risk in a Two-Index Model of Returns.”Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 9 (November 1974), 709–921.
Unal, Haluk, and Edward J. Kane. “Off-Balance-Sheet Items and the Changing Market and Interest-Rate Sensitivity of Deposit-Institution Equity Returns.”Proceedings of a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (May 1987), 432–455.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brewer, E. The impact of deposit insurance on S&L shareholders' risk/return trade-offs. J Finan Serv Res 9, 65–89 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01051964
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01051964