Abstract
This article surveys various aspects of the measurement of environmental quality from the view point of national accounting and welfare economics. It focuses on the question whether GNP or NNP should be corrected for environmental change (‘green’ or ‘eco’-GNP) or whether physical accounts provide sufficient information for an assessment of the trade-off mentioned above. We conclude that valuation of (services from) environmental capital cannot be avoided for such assessment, but can only be made using a model based approach. Statistical agencies should continue to collect data on environmental quality and to value changes in environmental capital in the context of national resource accounting. However, official statisticians should refrain from correcting GNP or NNP for environmental change, as this correction implicitly contains a political judgment and cannot be based on mere technical knowledge.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arntzen, J. and A. Gilbert (1991), ‘Natural Resource Accounting: State of the Art and Perspectives for the Assessment of Trends in Sustainable Development’, in O. Kuik and H. Verbruggen, eds., InSearch of Indicators of Sustainable Development, Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 45–56.
Boer, J. de, H. Aiking, E. Lammers, V. Sol and J. Feenstra (1991), ‘Contours of an Integrated Environmental Index for Application in Land-Use Zoning’, in O. Kuik and H. Verbruggen, eds., InSearch of Indicators of Sustainable Development, Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 107–120.
Boo, A. J. de, P. R. Bosch, C. N. Gorter and S. J. Keuning (1991), ‘An Environmental Module and the Complete System of National Accounts’,National Accounts Occasional Paper, Nr. NA-046, CBS, Voorburg.
Bos, F. (1992), ‘The History of National Accounting’,National Accounts Occasional Paper, Nr. NA-048, CBS, Voorburg.
Butter, F. A. G. den (1992), ‘The Mirror of Cleanliness: On the Construction and Use of an Environmental Index’, in J. J. Krabbe and W. J. M. Heijman eds.,National Income and Nature: Externalities, Growth and Steady State, Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 49–75.
Clark, C. (1937),National Income and Outlay, MacMillan, London.
Daly, H. E. (1989), ‘Toward a Measure of Sustainable Social Net National Product’, in Y. J. Ahmad, S. El Serafy, and E. Lutz, eds.,Environmental Accounting for Sustainable Development, Washington D.C.:World Bank.
Gilbert, A. J. and J. F. Feenstra (1992),An Indicator of Sustainable Development — Diffusion of Cadmium, Institute for Environmental Studies, VU University Press, Amsterdam.
Gilbert, A. J. (1994),Environmental Accounting and Sustainable Development, Academic Thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam (forthcoming).
Gradus, R. and S. Smulders (1993), The Trade-Off Between Environmental Care and Long-term Growth — Pollution in Three Prototype Growth Models,Journal of Economics 58, 25–51.
Hicks, J. R. (1940), ‘The Valuation of Social Income’,Economica 7, 105–124.
Hicks, J. R. (1948), ‘The Valuation of Social Income — A Comment on Professor Kuznets Reflections’,Economica 15, 163–172.
Hoevenagel, R. and H. Verbruggen (1989),De Waarde van Het Milieu, Institute for Environmental Studies R-89/09, Amsterdam.
Hoevenagel, R. (1994),The Contingent Valuation Methods: Scope and Validity, Academic Thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam.
Hoevenagel, R. and J. B. Opschoor (1990), ‘Economische Waardering van Milieuveranderingen: Mogelijkheden en Beperkingen,Milieu 3, 65–73.
Hope, C., J. Parker and S. Peake (1992), ‘A Pilot Environmental Index for the UK in the 1980s’,Energy Policy 20, 335–343.
Hueting, R., P. Bosch and B. de Boer (1992), ‘Methodology for the Calculation of Sustainable National Income’,Statistical Essays M44, Central Bureau of Statistics, Voorburg.
Keuning, S. J. (1992), ‘National Accounts and the Environment: the Case for an System's Approach’,National Accounts Occasional Paper, Nr. NA-053, CBS, Voorburg.
Krelle, W. (1984), ‘Economic Growth with Exhaustible Resources and Environmental Protection’,Zeitschrift für die Gesamte Staatswissenschaft 140, 399–429.
Kuik, O. and H. Verbruggen (eds.) (1991), InSearch of Indicators of Sustainable Development, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
Kuznets, S. (1948), ‘On the Valuations of Social Income — Reflection on Professor Hick's Article’,Economica 5, 1–16 (Part I) and 116–131 (Part II).
Leipert, Ch. (1989),Die heimlichen Kosten des Fortschritts, Frankfurt a.M.
Mäler, K.-G. (1991), ‘National Accounts and Environmental Resources’,Environmental and Resource Economics 1, 1–15.
Mastenbroek, A. P. and P. Nijkamp (1976), ‘Determination of Social Costs of Environmental Damage’, in M. Chatterji and P. van Rompuy, eds.,Energy, Regional Science and Public Policy, Proceedings of the International Conference on Regional Science, Energy and Environment I, Louvain, May 1975, Berlin: Springer Verlag, pp. 262–290.
Nentjes, A. and D. Wiersma (1992), ‘On Economic Growth, Technology and the Environment’, in J. J. Krabbe and W. J. M. Heijman, eds.,National Income and Nature: Externalities, Growth and Steady State, Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 143–165.
Nicolaisen, J., A. Dean, and P. Hoeller (1991), ‘Economics and the Environment: A Survey of Issues and Policy Options’,OECD Economic Studies 16, 7–43.
Nijkamp, P. and J. Paelinck (1973), ‘Some Models for the Economic Evaluation of the Environment’,Regional and Urban Economics 3, 33–62.
Nyborg, K. (1991),“Eco Domestic Product”: the Answer to Which Question?, Norwegian Central Bureau of Statistics, Oslo, mimeo.
Opschoor, J. B. (1991), ‘GNP and Sustainable Income Measures: Some Problems and a Way Out’, in O. Kuik en H. Verbruggen, eds., InSearch of Indicators of Sustainable Development, Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 39–44.
Opschoor, J. B. and L. Reijnders (1991), ‘Towards Sustainable Development Indicators’, in O. Kuik en H. Verbruggen, eds., InSearch of Indicators of Sustainable Development, Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 7–27.
Ott, W. R. (1978),Environmental Indices; Theory and Practice, Ann Arbor Science, Michigan.
Pearce, D. W. and A. Markandya (1989),Environmental Benefit Estimation: Monetary Evaluation, OECD, Paris.
Pearce, D. W., A. Markandya, and E. Barbier (1989),Blueprint for a Green Economy, Earthscan, London.
Pigou, A. C. (1932),The Economics of Welfare, MacMillan, London.
Ploeg, F. van der and C. Withagen (1991), ‘Pollution Control and the Ramsey Problem’,Environmental and Resource Economics 2, 215–230.
Repetto, R., W. Magrath, M. Wells, C. Beer, and F. Rossini (1989),Wasting Assets: Natural Resources in the National Income Accounts, World Resources, Institute, Washington, D.C.
Repetto, R. (1990),Integrating Natural Resources and Environmental Accounting into the National Accounts, Background paper No. 4, Workshop on the Economics of Sustainable Development, Washington DC, January 23–26, 1990.
Shechter, M. (1991), ‘A Comparative Study of Environmental Amenity Valuations’,Environmental and Resource Economics 1, 129–155.
Statistical Office of the United Nations (1990),SNA Handbook on Integrated Environmental Accounting, United Nations, New York.
Tahvonen, O. and J. Kuuluvainen (1991), ‘Optimal Growth with Renewable Resources and Pollution’,European Economics Review 35, 650–661.
Vellinga, N. and C. Withagen (1993),Some Notes on the Concept of a Green National Income, Department of Mathematics and Computing Science, Eindhoven University of Technology, mimeo.
Verbruggen, H. and O. Kuik (1991), ‘Indicators of Sustainable Development: An Overview’, in O. Kuik and H. Verbruggen, eds., InSearch of Indicators of Sustainable Development, Dordrecht: Kluwer, pp. 1–6.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Den Butter, F.A.G., Verbruggen, H. Measuring the trade-off between economic growth and a clean environment. Environ Resource Econ 4, 187–208 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00692203
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00692203