Species differences in the deamination of dopamine and other substrates for monoamine oxidase in brain

Abstract

Cortex and caudate specimens from human, non-human primate and rodent brains were examined for their ability to deaminate dopamine and for their sensitivity to irreversible monoamine oxidase (MAO) inhibitors. Using inhibition curves obtained with clorgyline, deprenyl and pargyline to estimate the relative proportions of MAO-A and MAO-B activity, dopamine was found to be deaminated predominantly by MAO-A in rat cortex and caudate. In contrast, dopamine was primarily an MAO-B substrate in human and vervet cortex and caudate. When clorgyline inhibition curves with tyramine or dopamine as substrate were compared in human, vervet and rat cortex, more pronounced species differences were found with dopamine than with tyramine. In all three species caudate tended to be more sensitive to inhibition by low concentrations of clorgyline than was cortex, suggesting a higher proportion of MAO-A activity in caudate. Similar species differences were also found when MAO-A activities were estimated using serotonin (5-HT): β-phenylethylamine (PEA) ratios (5-HT/5-HT + PEA). These ratios with selective substrates were highly correlated with clorgyline inhibition curves obtained with tyramine as substrate across 29 brain regions and tissues from different rodent and primate species (r=0.85, P<0.001). Data from both the substrate ratios and the clorgyline inhibition curves confirmed the relative predominance of MAO-B activity in primate brain regions (70–85%) as compared to rat brain regions (45%). Smaller species differences were observed in liver. Species differences in the proportion of brain MAO-A and B activities and in the deamination of dopamine and other substrates for MAO may have important implications in regard to the widespread use of rodent rather than primate models in the study of biogenic amine metabolism and of drugs affecting amine function.