Summary
It has been assumed that differences in activity time of diurnal (Falconiform) and nocturnal (Strigiform) raptors reduce competition for food by giving them access to different prey resources. Consequently, dietary similarity should be greater between synchronously active raptors (either diurnal or nocturnal) than between asynchronous ones (diurnal versus nocturnal). Using five collective raptor assemblages I tested the hypothesis that the statistical distribution of food overlaps between synchronous raptors (Falconiform x Falconiform and Strigiform x Strigiform combined) should be composed of larger figures than that obtained from asynchronous pairs (Falconiform x Strigiform). Both a conservative (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test with Chisquare approximation) and a powerful (Mann-Whitney U-test) nonparametric procedure were used to deal with the problem of the degrees of freedom to be assigned to non-indepedent observations such as overlaps. The tests consistently failed to reject the null hypothesis, thus pointing to the inadequacy of temporal segregation as a means to partition prey resources between diurnal and nocturnal raptors. I propose that this can be accounted for by two factors, acting singly or in combination: a) that both Falconiforms and Strigiforms extend their hunting activities to crepuscular hours thus sharing prey of that activity period; b) that reputedly diurnal and nocturnal prey become vulnerable to predators of asynchronous hunting time by extending their activities in the field. Based on records of interspecific territoriality, prevation, and interference competition I propose that the evolution of nocturnality in Strigiforms might be more clearly related to interference interactions rather than exploitation competition with Falconiforms.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barrows C (1980) Feeding ecology of the Spotted Owl in California. Raptor Research 14:73–78
Baumgartner AM, Baumgartner FM (1944) Hawks and owls in Oklahoma 1939–1942: food habits and population changes. Wilson Bulletin 56:209–215
Bent AC (1937) Life histories of North American birds of prey: order Falconiformes (Part I). United States National Museum Bulletin 167:1–409
Bent AC (1938) Life histories of North American birds of prey: orders Falconiformes and Strigiformes. United States National Museum Bulletin 170:1–482
Berger DD (1958) Marsh Hawk takes prey from Short-eared Owl. Wilson Bulletin 70:90
Bildstein KL (1975) Short-eared Owl robs Marsh Hawk of prey. Auk 92:807–808
Bond RM (1936) Some observations on the food of the Prairie Falcon. Condor 38:169–170
Bond RM (1939) Observations on raptorial birds in the Lava Beds-Tule Lake region of northern California. Condor 41:54–61
Borell AE (1937) Cooper Hawk eats a Flammulated Screech Owl. Condor 39:44
Boyle GL (1974) Kestrel taking prey from Short-eared Owl. British Birds 67:474–475
Brown L, Amadon D (1968) Eagles, Hawks and Falcons of the World. Two volumes. McGraw-Hill, New York, New York
Carnie SK (1954) Food habits of nesting Golden Eagles in the coast ranges of California. Condor 56:3–12
Clark RJ, Smith DG, Kelso LH (1978) Working Bibliography of Owls of the World: with Summaries of Current Taxonomy and Distributional Status. National Wildlife Federation, Washington, DC
Craighead JJ, Craighead FC (1969) Hawks, Owls and Wildlife. Second Edition. Dover Publications, New York, New York
Collins CT (1962) Red-tailed Hawk attacks Long-eared Owl. Wilson Bulletin 74:89
Coulombe HN (1971) Behavior and population ecology of the Burrowing Owl, Speotyto cunicularia, in the Imperial Valley of California. Condor 73:162–176
Daggett FS (1913) Another instance of cannibalism in the Spotted Owl. Condor 15:40–41
Dunn PJ (1981) Kestrel robbing Barn Owl. Raptor Research 15:22
Errington PL (1932) Food habits of southern Wisconsin raptors. Part I.-Owls. Condor 34:176–186
Errington PL (1933) Food habits of southern Wisconsin raptors. Part II.-Hawks. Condor 35:19–29
Errington PL, Hamerstrom F, Hamerstrom FN (1940) The Great Horned Owl and its prey in north-central Unites States. Agricultural Experiment Station, Iowa College of Agriculture and Mechanic Arts, Research Bulletin 277:759–850
Fitch HS (1947) Predation by owls in the Sierran foothills of California. Condor 49:137–151
Fitch HS, Swenson F, Tillotson DF (1946) Behavior and food habits of the Red-tailed Hawk. Condor 48:205–237
Glading B, Tillotson DF, Selleck DM (1943) Raptor pellets as indicators of food habits. California Fish and Game 29:92–121
Grossman ML, Hamlet J (1964) Birds of Prey of the World. Bonanza Books, New York, New York
Hamerstrom FN, Hamerstrom F (1951) Food of young raptors on the Edwin S. George Reserve. Wilson Bulletin 63:16–25
Hamerstrom F, Mattson O (1939) Food of central Wisconsin Horned Owls. American Midland Naturalist 22:700–702
Herrera CM, Hiraldo F (1976) Food-niche and trophic relationships among European owls. Ornis Scandinavica 7:29–41
Hunt R (1918) The tragical addition of a new bird to the Campus list. Condor 20:125–126
Jaksić FM, Greene HW, Yáñez JL (1981) The guild structure of a community of predatory vertebrates in central Chile. Oecologia (Berl) 49:21–28
Linton LR, Davies RW, Wrona FJ (1981) Resource utilization indices: an assessment. Journal of Animal Ecology 50:283–292
MacArthur RH, Levins R (1967) The limiting similarity, convergence and divergence of coexisting species. American Naturalist 101:377–385
Marshall JT (1942) Food and habitat of the Spotted Owl. Condor 44:66–67
McGahan J (1968) Ecology of the Golden Eagle. Auk 85:1–12
Mendall HC (1944) Food of hawks and owls in Maine. Journal of Wildlife Management 8:198–208
Meng H (1959) Food habits of nesting Cooper's Hawks and Goshawks in New York and Pennsylvania. Wilson Bulletin 71:169–174
Mikkola H (1976) Owls killing and killed by other owls and raptors in Europe. British Birds 69:144–154
Morse DH (1975) Ecological aspects of adaptive radiation in birds. Biological Reviews 50:167–214
Munro JA (1929) Notes on the food habits of certain raptors in British Columbia and Alberta. Condor 31:112–116
Murphy JR, Caminzind FJ, Smith DG, Weston JB (1969) Nesting ecology of raptorial birds in central Utah. Brigham Young University, Scientific Bulletin, Biological Series 10(4):1–36
Newton I (1976) Population limitation in diurnal raptors. Canadian Field-Naturalist 90:274–300
Orians G, Kuhlman F (1956) Red-tailed Hawk and Horned Owl populations in Wisconsin. Condor 58:371–385
Parmenter HE (1941) Prairie Falcon parasitizing a Marsh Hawk. Condor 43:157
Peyton SB (1945) Western Red-tailed Hawk catches Cooper Hawk. Condor 47:167
Phelan FJS, Robertson RJ (1978) Predatory responses of a raptor guild to changes in prey density. Canadian Journal of Zoology 56:2265–2572
Pianka ER (1973) The structure of lizard communities. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 4:53–74
Pianka ER (1974) Evolutionary Ecology. Harper and Row, New York, New York
Pinkston DR, Caraviotis JG (1980). Probable predation on Whitetailed Kite by Red-tailed Hawk. Raptor Research 14:85–86
Platt JB (1971) A survey of nesting hawks, eagles, falcons and owls in Curlew Valley, Utah. Great Basin Naturalist 31:51–65
Richardson CH (1906) Cannibalism in owls. Condor 8:57
Rudolph SG (1978) Predation ecology of coexisting Great Horned and Barn Owls. Wilson Bulletin 90:134–137
Schmutz JK, Schmutz SM, Boag DA (1980) Coexistence of three species of hawks (Buteo spp.) in the prairie-parkland ecotone. Canadian Journal of Zoology 58:1075–1089
Schoener TW (1974) Resource partitioning in ecological communities. Science 185:27–39
Siegel S (1956) Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences. McGraw-Hill, New York, New York
Smith DG, Murphy JR (1973) Breeding ecology of raptors in the eastern Great Basin of Utah. Brigham Young University, Scientific Bulletin, Biological Series 18(3):1–76
Smith DG, Murphy JR (1979) Breeding responses of raptors to jackrabbit density in the eastern Great Basin desert of Utah. Raptor Research 13:1–14
Thomsen L (1971) Behavior and ecology of Burrowing Owls on the Oakland Municipal Airport. Condor 73:177–192
Valverde JA (1960) Vertebrados de las Marismas del Guadalquivir (Introducción a su estudio ecológico). Archivos del Instituto de Aclimatación (Spain) 9:1–168
Valverde JA (1967) Estructura de una Comunidad de Vertebrados Terrestres. Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas, Madrid, Spain
Wiley JW (1975) Relationships of nesting hawks with Great Horned Owl. Auk 92:157–159
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jaksić, F.M. Inadequacy of activity time as a niche difference: the case of diurnal and nocturnal raptors. Oecologia 52, 171–175 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00363832
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00363832