Abstract
In scintigraphy, the detection of scattered photons degrades both visual image analysis and quantitative accuracy. Many methods have been proposed and are still under investigation to cope with scattered photons. The main features of the problem of scattering in radionuclide imaging are presented first, to provide a sound foundation for a critical review of the existing scatter correction techniques. These are described using a classification relating to their aims and principles. Their theoretical potentials are analysed, as well as the difficulties of their practical implementation. Finally, the problems of their evaluation and comparison are discussed.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
De Vries DJ, Moore SC, Zimmerman RE, Mueller SP, Friedland B, Lanza RC. Development and validation of a Monte Carlo simulation of photon transport in an Anger camera. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1990;9: 430–438.
Ljungberg M, Strand SE. A Monte Carlo program for the simulation of scintillation camera characteristics. Comput Methods Prog Biomed 1989;29: 257–272.
Rosenthal MS, Henry LJ. Evaluation and comparison of two scatter correction techniques. J Nucl Med 1990;31: 878.
Gagnon D, Pouliot N, Laperriere L. Statistical and physical content of low-energy photons in holospectral imaging. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1991;10: 284–289.
Munley MT, Floyd CE, Tourassi GD, Bowsher JE, Coleman RE. Out-of-plane photons in SPECT. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1991;38: 776–779.
Gagnon D, Laperriere L, Pouliot N, de Vries DJ, Moore SC. Monte Carlo analysis of camera-induced spectral contamination for different primary energies. Phys Med Biol 1992;37: 1725–1739.
Beck JW, Jaszczak RJ, Coleman RE, Starmer CF, Nolte LW. Analysis of SPECT including scatter and attenuation using sophisticated Monte-Carlo modeling methods. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1982;29: 506–511.
Floyd CE, Jaszczak RJ, Harris CC, Coleman RE. Energy and spatial distribution of multiple order Compton scatter in SPECT: a Monte Carlo investigation. Phys Med Biol 1984;29: 1217–1230.
Lowry CA, Cooper MJ. The problem of Compton scattering in emission tomography: a measurement of its spatial distribution. Phys Med Biol 1987;32: 1187–1191.
Coleman M, King MA, Glick SJ, Knesaurek K, Penney BC. Investigation of the stationarity of the modulation transfer function and the scatter fraction in conjugate view SPECT restoration filtering. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1989;36 969–972.
Frey EC, Tsui BMW. Parameterization of the scatter response function in SPECT imaging using Monte Carlo simulation. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1990;37: 1308–1315.
Zasadny KR, Koral KF, Floyd CE Jr, Jaszczak RJ. Measurement of Compton scattering in phantoms by germanium detector. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1990;37: 642–646.
Koral KF, Wang X, Zasadny KR, Clinthorne NH, Rogers WL, Floyd CE, Jaszczak RJ. Testing of local gamma-ray scatter fractions determined by spectral fitting. Phys Med Biol 1991;36: 177–190.
Floyd CE, Jaszczak RJ, Coleman RE. Scatter detection in SPECT imaging: dependence on source depth, energy, and energy window. Phys Med Biol 1988;33: 1075–1081.
Beck RN, Schuh MW, Cohen TD, Lembares N. Effects of scattered radiation on scintillation detector response. In: IAEA, ed. Medical radioisotope scintigraphy. Vienna: IAEA; 1969: 595–616.
Rollo FD, Schulz AG. Effect of pulse-height selection on lesion detection performance. J Nucl Med 1971;12: 690–696.
Ehrhardt JC, Oberley LW. Effects of spectral changes on scanning. Radiology 1972;104: 207–208.
Oberley LW, Ehrhardt JC, Lensink SC. The variable baseline scanner. Phys Med Biol 1972;17: 630–637.
Sanders TP, Sanders TD, Kuhl DE. Optimizing the window of an Anger camera for 99mTc. J Nucl Med 1972;12: 703–706.
Atkins FB, Beck RN. Dependence of optimum baseline setting on scatter fraction and detector response function. In: IAEA, ed. Medical radionuclide imaging. Vienna: IAEA; 1977: 101–118.
Collier BD, Palmer DW, Knobel J, Isitman AT, Hellman RS, Zielonka JS. Gamma camera energy for Tc99m bone scintigraphy: effect of asymmetry on contrast resolution. Radiology 1984:151 495–497.
Graham LS, La Fontaine RL, Stein MA. Effects of asymmetric photopeak windows on flood field uniformity and spatial resolution of scintillation cameras. J Nucl Med 1986;27: 706–713.
La Fontaine R, Stein MA, Graham LS, Winter J. Cold lesions: enhanced contrast using asymmetric photopeak windows. Radiology 1986;160: 255–260.
Rogers WL, Clinthorne NH, Stamos J, Koral KF, Mayans R, Knoll GF, Juni J, Keyes JW, Harkness BA. Performance evaluation of SPRINT, a single photon ring tomograph for brain imaging. J Nucl Med 1984;25: 1013–1018.
Koral KF, Clinthorne NH, Rogers WL. Improving emission computed tomography quantification by Compton-scatter rejection through offset windows. Nucl Instrum Methods Phys Res 1986;A242: 610–614.
Beck RN, Zimmer LT, Charleston DB, Hoffer PB. Aspects of imaging and counting in nuclear medicine using scintillation and semi conductor detectors. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1972;19: 173–178.
King MA, Coleman M, Penney BC, Glick SJ. Activity quantitation in SPECT: a study of prereconstruction Metz filtering and use of the scatter degradation factor. Med Phys 1991;18: 184–189.
Jaszczak RJ, Coleman RE, Whitehead FR. Physical factors affecting quantitative measurements using camera-based single photon emission computed tomography. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1981;28 69–80.
King MA, Penney BC, Glick SJ. An image-dependent Metz filter for nuclear medicine images. J Nucl Med 1988;29: 1980–1989.
Jaszczak RJ, Floyd CE, Coleman RE. Scatter compensation techniques for SPECT. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1985;32: 786–793.
Szabo Z, Links JM, Seki C, Rhine J, Wagner HN. Scatter, spatial resolution, and quantitative recovery in high resolution SPECT. J Comput Assist Tomogr 1992;16: 461–467.
Jaszczak RJ, Greer KL, Floyd CE, Harris CC, Coleman RE. Improved SPECT quantification using compensation for scattered photons. J Nucl Med 1984;25: 893–900.
Gilland DR, Jaszczak RJ, Greer KL, Coleman RE. Quantitative SPECT reconstruction of iodine-123 data. J Nucl Med 1991;32: 527–533.
Harris CC, Greer KL, Jaszczak RJ, Floyd CE, Fearnow EC, Coleman RE. Tc-99m attenuation coefficients in water-filled phantoms determined with gamma cameras. Med Phys 1984;11: 681–685.
Wit RK, Siegel JA. Absolute quantification of radioactivity using the buildup factor. Med Phys 1984;11: 189–192.
Almquist H, Palmer J, Ljungberg M, Wollmer P, Strand SE, Jonson B. Quantitative SPECT by attenuation correction of the projection set using transmission data: evaluation of a method. Eur J Nucl Med 1990;16: 587–594.
Siegel JA, Wu RK, Maurer AH. The buildup factor: effect of scatter on absolute volume determination. J Nucl Med 1985;26: 390–394.
Ljungberg M, Strand SE. Attenuation correction in SPECT based on transmission studies and Monte Carlo simulations of buildup functions. J Nucl Med 1990;31: 493–500.
Siegel JA, Maurer AH, Wu RK, Denenberg BS, Gash AK, Carabello BA, Spann JF, Malmud LS. Absolute left ventricular volume by an iterative build-up factor analysis of gated radionuclide study. Radiology 1984;151: 477–481.
Ljungberg M, Strand SE. Attenuation and scatter correction in SPECT for sources in a nonhomogeneous object: a Monte Carlo study. J Nucl Med 1991;32: 1278–1284.
Egbert SD, May RS. An integral-transport method for Compton-scatter correction in emission computed tomography. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1980;27: 543–548.
Chang LT. A method for attenuation correction in radionuclide computed tomography. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1978;25: 638–643.
Floyd CE, Jaszczak RJ, Coleman RE. Inverse Monte Carlo: a unified reconstruction algorithm for SPECT. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1985;32: 779–785.
Floyd CE, Jaszczak RJ, Greer KL, Coleman RE. Inverse Monte Carlo as a unified reconstruction algorithm for ECT. J Nucl Med 1986;27: 1577–1585.
Bowsher JE, Floyd CE. Treatment of Compton scattering in maximum-likelihood, expectation-maximization reconstructions of SPECT images. JNucl Med 1991;32: 1285–1291.
Frey EC, Ju ZW, Tsui BMW. A fast projector-backprojector pair modeling the asymmetric, spatially varying scatter response function for scatter compensation in SPECT imaging. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1993;40: 1192–1197.
Frey EC, Tsui BMW. A practical method for incorporating scatter in a projector-backprojector for accurate scatter compensation in SPECT. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1993;40: 1107–1116.
Frey EC, Tsui BMW. Spatial properties of the scatter response function in SPECT. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1991;38: 789–794.
Beck RN, Zimmer LT, Charleston DB, Harper PV, Hoffer PB. Advances in fundamental aspects of imaging systems and techniques. In: IAEA, ed. Medical radioisotope scintigraphy. Vienna: IAEA;1972: 29–30.
Halama JR, Henkin RE, Friend LE. Gamma camera radionuclide images: improved contrast with energy-weighted acquisition. Radiology 1988;169: 533–538.
DeVito RP, Hamill JJ. Determination of weighting functions for energy-weighted acquisition. J Nucl Med 1991;32: 343–349.
DeVito RP, Hamill JJ, Treffert JD, Stoub EW. Energy-weighted acquisition of scintigraphic images using finite spatial filters. J Nucl Med 1989;30: 2029–2035.
Hamill JJ, DeVito RP. Scatter reduction with energy-weighted acquisition. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1989;36: 1334–1339.
Floyd JL, Mann RB, Shaw A. Changes in quantitative SPECT thallium-201 results associated with the use of energy-weighted acquisition. J Nucl Med 1991;32: 805–807.
Jaszczak RJ, Hoffman DC, DeVito RP. Variance propagation for SPECT with energy-weighted acquisition. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1991;38: 739–747.
King MA, Hademenos GJ, Glick SJ. A dual-photopeak window method for scatter correction. J Nucl Med 1992;33: 605–612.
Hademenos GJ, Ljungberg M, King MA, Glick SJ. A Monte Carlo investigation of the dual photopeak window scatter correction method. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1993;40 179–185.
Pretorius PH, van Rensburg AJ, van Aswegen A, Utter MG, Serfontein DE, Herbst CP. The channel ratio method of scatter correction for radionuclide image quantitation. J Nucl Med 1993;34 330–335.
Logan KW, McFarland WD. Single photon scatter compensation by photopeak energy distribution analysis. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1992;11: 161–164.
Bloch P, Sanders T. Reduction of the effects of scattered radiation on a sodium iodide imaging system. J Nucl Med 1973;14: 67–72.
Liang Z,Turkington TG, Gilland DR, Jaszczak RJ, Coleman RE. Simultaneous compensation for attenuation, scatter and detector response for SPECT reconstruction in three dimensions. Phys Med Biol 1992;37: 587–603.
Atkins FB, Beck RN. Effect of scatter subtraction on image contrast. J Nucl Med 1975;16: 102–104.
Floyd CE, Jaszczak RJ, Harris CC, Greer KL, Coleman RE. Monte Carlo evaluation of Compton scatter subtraction in single photon emission computed tomography. Med Phys 1985;12: 776–778.
Ljungberg M, Msaki P, Strand SE. Comparison of dual-window and convolution scatter correction techniques using the Monte Carlo method. Phys Med Biol 1990;35: 1099–1110.
Meikle SR, Hutton BF, Bailey DL, Fulton RR, Schindhelm K. SPECT scatter correction in non-homogeneous media. In: Colchester ACF, Hawkes DJ, eds. Information processing in medical imaging. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer; 1991: 34–44.
Todd-Pokropek AE, Clarke G, Marsh R. Preprocessing of SPECT data as a precursor for attenuation correction. In: Deconinck F, ed. Information processing in medical imaging. Brussels: Martinus Nijhoff; 1983: 130–150.
Gilardi MC, Bettinardi V, Todd-Pokropek A, Milanesi L, Fazio F. Assessment and comparison of three scatter correction techniques in single photon emission computed tomography. J Nucl Med 1988;29: 1971–1979.
Singh M, Horne C. Use of germanium detector to optimize scatter correction in SPECT. J Nucl Med 1987;28: 1853–1860.
Green AJ, Dewhurst SE, Begent RHJ, Bagshawe KD, Riggs SJ. Accurate quantification of '3'I distribution by gamma camera imaging. Eur J Nucl Med 1990;16: 361–365.
Yanch JC, Flower MA, Webb S. Improved quantification of radionuclide uptake using deconvolution and windowed subtraction techniques for scatter compensation in single photon emission computed tomography. Med Phys 1990;17: 1011–1022.
Koral KF, Swailem FM, Buchbinder S, Clinthorne NH, Rogers WL, Tsui BMW. SPECT dual-energy-window Compton correction: scatter multiplier required for quantification. J Nucl Med 1990;31: 90–98.
Gilland DR, Jaszczak RJ, Turkington TG, Greer KL, Coleman RE. Quantitative SPECT imaging with indium 111. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1991;38: 761–766.
Koral KF, Buchbinder S, Clinthorne NH, Rogers WL, Swailem FM, Tsui BMW. Influence of region of interest selection on the scatter multiplier required for quantification in dual-window Compton correction. J Nucl Med 1991;32: 186.
Ogawa K, Harata Y, Ichihara T, Kubo A, Hashimoto S. A practical method for position-dependent Compton-scattered correction in single photon emission CT. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1991;10: 408–412.
Axelsson B, Msaki P, Israelsson A. Subtraction of Compton-scattered photons in single-photon emission computerized tomography. J Nucl Med 1984;25: 490–494.
Floyd CE, Jaszczak RJ, Greer KL, Coleman RE. Deconvolution of Compton scatter in SPECT. J Nucl Med 1985;26: 403–408.
Msaki P, Axelsson B, Dahl CM, Larsson SA. Generalized scatter correction method in SPECT using point scatter distribution functions. J Nucl Med 1987;28: 1861–1869.
Msaki P, Axelsson B, Larsson SA. Some physical factors influencing the accuracy of convolution scatter correction in SPECT. Phys Med Biol 1989;34: 283–298.
Mukai T, Links JM, Douglass KH, Wagner HN. Scatter correction in SPECT using non-uniform attenuation data. Phys Med Biol 1988;33: 1129–1140.
Msaki P, Erlandsson K, Svensson L, Nolstedt L. The convolution scatter subtraction hypothesis and its validity domain in radioisotope imaging. Phys Med Biol 1993;38: 1359–1370.
Fleming JS. A technique for using CT images in attenuation correction and quantification in SPECT. Nucl Med Commun 1989;10 83–97.
Todd-Pokropek A. Non-stationary deconvolution using a multi-resolution stack. In: de Graaf CN, Viergever MA, eds. Information processing in medical imaging. New York: Plenum; 1988: 277–290.
Ljungberg M, Strand SE. Scatter and attenuation correction in SPECT using density maps and Monte Carlo simulated scatter functions. J Nucl Med 1990;31: 1560–1567.
Ogawa K, Nishizaki N. Accurate scatter compensation using neural networks in radionuclide imaging. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1993;40: 1020–1025.
Waggett DJ, Wilson BC. Improvement of scanner performance by subtraction of Compton scattering using multiple energy windows. Br J Radiol 1978;51: 1004–1010.
Koral KF, Wang X, Rogers WL, Clinthorne NH, Wang X. SPECT Compton-scattering correction by analysis of energy spectra. J Nucl Med 1988;29: 195–202.
East LV, Phillips RL, Strong AR. A fresh approach to NaI scintillation detector spectrum analysis. Nucl Instrum Methods 1982;193: 147–155.
Wang X, Koral KF, Clinthorne NH, Rogers WL, Floyd CE Jr, Jaszczak RJ. Effect of noise, order and range in fitting the photopeak region of local, Anger-camera energy spectra. Nucl Instrum Methods Phys Res 1990;A299: 548–553.
Wang X, Koral KF. A regularized deconvolution-fitting method for Compton-scatter correction in SPECT. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1992;11: 351–360.
Maor D, Berlad G, Chrem Y, Voil A, Todd-Pokropek A. Klein-Nishina based energy factors for Compton free imaging (CFI) [abstract]. J Nucl Med 1991;32: 1000.
Cavailloles F, Morvan D, Boudet F, Bazin JP, Di Paola R. Factor analysis of dynamic structures as an aid for vesicoureteral reflux diagnosis. Contrib Nephrol 1987;56: 238–242.
Todd-Pokropek A, Gagnon D. Scatter correction in tomography. In: MacCuaig N, Holt R, eds. Tomography and scatter imaging. London: IOP Short meetings; 1988: 41–52.
Gagnon D, Todd-Pokropek A, Arsenault A, Dupras G. Introduction to holospectral imaging in nuclear medicine for scatter subtraction. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1989;8: 245–250.
Barber DC. The use of principal components in the quantitative analysis of gamma camera dynamic studies. Phys Med Biol 1980;25: 283–292.
Di Paola R, Bazin JP, Aubry F, Aurengo A, Cavailloles F, Herry JY, Kahn E. Handling of dynamic sequences in nuclear medicine. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1982;29: 1310–1321.
Hannequin P, Liehn JC, Valeyre J. Correction de la diffusion Compton par analyse factorielle des structures dynamiques. J Med Nucl Biophys 1988;12: 460.
Mas J, Hannequin P, Ben Younes R, Bellaton B, Bidet R. Scatter correction in planar imaging and SPECT by constrained factor analysis of dynamic structures (FADS). Phys Med Biol 1990;35: 1451–1465.
Mas J, Hannequin P, Ben Younes R, Bellaton B, Bidet R. Correction de la diffusion Compton en imagerie isotopique par analyse factorielle sous contraintes. Innov Tech Biol Med 1990;11: 641–655.
Buvat I. Correction de la diffusion en imagerie scintigraphique. Thèse de doctorat en Physique. Université de Paris XI, 1992.
Buvat I, Benah H, Frouin F, Bazin JP, Di Paola R. Target apex-seeking in factor analysis of medical image sequences. Phys Med Biol 1993;38: 123–138.
Ljungberg M, King MA, Hademenos GJ, Strand SE. Comparison of four scatter correction methods using Monte Carlo simulated source distributions. J Nucl Med 1994;35: 143–151.
Rosenthal MS, Henry LJ. Scattering in uniform media. Phys Med Biol 1990;35: 265–274.
Yanch JC, Dobrzeniecki AB, Ramanathan C, Behrman R. Physically realistic Monte Carlo simulation of source, collimator and tomographic data acquisition for emission computed tomography. Phys Med Biol 1992;37: 853–870.
Yanch JC, Irvine AT, Webb S, Flower MA. Deconvolution of emission tomographic data: a clinical evaluation. Br J Radiol 1988;61: 221–225.
Rao MG. Bone imaging with energy-weighted acquisition. J Nucl Med 1993;34: 997–999.
Bonnin F, Buvat I, Benali H, Di Paola R. A comparative clinical study of scatter correction methods for scintigraphic images. Eur J Nucl Med 1994;21: 388–393.
Mas J, Ben Younes R, Bidet R. Improvement of quantification in SPELT studies by scatter and attenuation compensation. Eur J Nucl Med 1989;15: 351–356.
Ben Younes R, Mas J, Pousse A, Hannequin P, Bidet R. Introducing simultaneous spatial resolution and attenuation correction after scatter removal in SPELT imaging. Nucl Med Commun 1991;12: 1031–1043.
Yanch JC, Webb S, Flower MA, Irvine AT. Constrained deconvolution to remove resolution degradation caused by scatter in SPELT. In: de Graaf CN, Viergever MA, eds. Information processing in medical imaging. New York: Plenum; 1988: 263–276.
Yanch JC, Flower MA, Webb S. A comparison of deconvolution and windowed subtraction techniques for scatter compensation in SPELT. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 1988;7: 13–20.
Tsui BMW, Zhao XD, Cao ZJ, Frey EC. Reconstruction methods for quantitative brain SPELT. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 1993;40: 214–220.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Correspondence to: I. Buvat
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Buvat, I., Benali, H., Todd-Pokropek, A. et al. Scatter correction in scintigraphy: the state of the art. Eur J Nucl Med 21, 675–694 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00285592
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00285592