Summary
Many studies have shown high carbohydrate, high fibre diets to benefit diabetic control, the improvement being attributed mainly to an effect of fibre. This study investigated the possible beneficial effects of the digestible carbohydrate component. A diet rich in carbohydrate was compared with a traditional low carbohydrate diet in 10 Type 2 (non-insulin-dependent) diabetic patients, using a crossover design; both diets contained <20 g dietary fibre/day. During 24-h metabolic profiles carried out after 4 weeks on each diet, the mean basal plasma glucose (mean of 03.00, 05.00 and 07.00 h values) was 5.3 mmol/l on the high carbohydrate diet and 5.9 mmol/l on the low carbohydrate diet (p<0.05), despite the 2-h postprandial glucose (mean of three main meals) being higher on the high carbohydrate diet than on the low carbohydrate diet (8.7 versus 7.3 mmol/l, p<0.01). Overall diabetic control was the same throughout the study, as judged by a mean 24-h plasma glucose of 6.7 mmol/l on the high carbohydrate and 6.6 mmol/l on the low carbohydrate diet, and haemoglobin A1c percentage of 8.3 on both diets. Mean cholesterol was 4.55 mmol/l on both diets and fasting plasma triglyceride was 2.83 mmol/l on the high carbohydrate and 2.55 mmol/l on the low carbohydrate diet (p = NS). These results indicate that a diet rich in carbohydrate, but restricted in fibre, does not cause overall deterioration of diabetic control or lipid metabolism in stable Type 2 diabetic patients, and suggest that digestible carbohydrate has an effect on basal blood glucose independent of fibre.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Simpson RW, Mann JI, Eaton J, Carter RD, Hockaday TDR (1979) High carbohydrate diets and insulin-dependent diabetics. Br Med J 2: 523–525
Rivellese A, Riccardi G, Giacco A, Pacioni D, Genovese S, Mattioli PL, Mancini M (1980) Effect of dietary fibre on glucose control and serum lipoproteins in diabetic patients. Lancet 2: 447–450
Simpson HCR, Lousley S, Geekie M, Simpson RW, Carter RD, Hockaday TDR, Mann JI (1981) A high carbohydrate leguminous fibre diet improves all aspects of diabetic control. Lancet 1: 1–5
Simpson RW, Mann JI, Eaton J, Moore RA, Carter RD, Hockaday TDR (1979) Improved glucose control in maturity onset diabetes treated with high carbohydrate-modified fat diet. Br Med J 1: 1753–1756
Jenkins DJA, Wolever TMS, Nineham R, Taylor R, Metz GL, Bacon S, Hockaday TDR (1978) Guar crispbread in the diabetic diet. Br Med J 2: 1744–1746
Holt S, Heading RC, Carter DC, Prescott LF, Tothill P (1976) Effect of gel fibre on gastric emptying and absorption of glucose and paracetamol. Lancet 1: 636–639
Morgan LM, Goulder TJ, Tsioladis D, Marks V, Alberti KGMM (1979) The effect of unabsorbable carbohydrate on gut hormones: Modification of post-prandial GIP secretion by guar. Diabetologia 17: 85–89
Pederson O, Hjøllund E, Lindskow HO, Schwartz Sørensen N (1980) Increased insulin receptors on monocytes from insulin-dependent diabetics after a high-starch, high fibre diet. Diabetologia 19: 306 (Abstract)
Jenkins DJA, Wolever TMS, Hockaday TDR, Leeds AR, Howarth R, Bacon S, Apling EC, Dilawari J (1977) Treatment of diabetes with guar gum. Lancet 2: 779–780
Miranda PM, Horwitz DL (1978) High fibre diets in the treatment of diabetes mellitus. Ann Intern Med 88: 482–486
Brunzell JD, Lerner RL, Porte D, Bierman EL (1973) Effect of a fat free, high carbohydrate diet on diabetic subjects with fasting hyper-glycemia. Diabetes 23: 138–142
Albano JDM, Ekins RP, Maritz G, Turner RC (1972) Sensitive, precise radioimmunoassay of serum insulin relying on charcoal separation of bound and free hormone moieties. Acta Endocrinol 70: 487–509
Haung TC, Chen CP, Wefler V, Rafter A (1961) A stable reagent for the Liebermann-Burchard reaction. Anal Chem 33: 1405–1407
Ononga IC, Lewis B (1976) Lipoprotein fractionation by a precipitation method — A simple quantitative procedure. Clin Chim Acta 71: 397–402
Eggstein M, Kreutz FH (1966) Eine neue Bestimmung der Neutralfette im Blutserum und Gewebe. Klin Wschr 44: 262–267
Jeppson JD, Franzen B, Gaal AB (1980) Simplified determination of haemoglobin A1 in diabetic patients by use of electrofocussing. In: Radola BJ (ed) Electrophoresis 1979 advanced methods. Walter de Gryter, Berlin New York, pp 656–661
Truswell AS, Thomas BJ, Brown AM (1975) Survey of dietary policy and management in British diabetic clinics. Br Med J 2: 7–11
Perkins JR, West TET, Sonksen PH, Lowy C, Iles C (1977) The effects of energy and carbohydrate restriction in patients with chronic diabetes mellitus. Diabetologia 13: 607–614
Anderson JW, Ward K (1978) Long-term effects of high-carbohydrate, high-fiber diets in glucose and lipid metabolism: a preliminary report on patients with diabetes. Diabetes Care 1: 77–82
Jenkins DJA, Wolever TMS, Leeds AR, Gassull MA, Haisman P, Dilawari J, Goff DV, Metz GL, Alberti KGMM (1978) Dietary fibres, fibre analogues and glucose tolerance — Importance of viscosity. Br Med J 1: 1392–1394
Elsenhans B, Süfke U, Blume R, Caspary WF (1980) The influence of carbohydrate gelling agents on rat intestinal transport of mono-saccharides and neutral amino acids in vitro. Clin Sci 59: 373–80
Ward GM, Simpson RW, Simpson HCR, Naylor BA, Mann JI, Turner RC (1982) Insulin receptor binding increased by high carbohydrate diet in non insulin-dependent diabetics. Europ J Clin Invest 12: (in press)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Simpson, H.C.R., Carter, R.D., Lousley, S. et al. Digestible carbohydrate — an independent effect on diabetic control in type 2 (non-insulin-dependent) diabetic patients?. Diabetologia 23, 235–239 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00252847
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00252847