Abstract
In this article an attempt is made to evaluate Indonesia's population redistribution policy—transmigration—from 1969 onwards. In addition to population redistribution, transmigration also has socio-economic and political objectives. In spite of the fact that in monetary terms transmigration has become one of Indonesia's main development programmes and the budget per transmigration family has increased enormously since 1969, it is established that for several years the ambitious targets could not be realized. In addition, studies show that in several cases the many promises of the transmigration authorities could not be met. With respect to the objective of population redistribution, it is concluded that so far transmigration has hardly influenced Indonesia's population distribution; only in specific receiving areas have the effects of transmigration been significant. Furthermore, it is shown that there is reason to doubt the role which the agriculturally-oriented transmigration programmes can play in the regional development process. In addition, there is evidence that in some cases the schemes have also been used as an instrument to serve (implicit) political aims.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arndt, H.W. and R.M. Sundrum (1977). “Transmigration: landsettlement or regional development?” Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 13(3): 72–99.
Berens, S. (1982). “Transmigratie-2: een nieuw bestaan in eigen land,” Internationale Samenwerking 14(6): 4–6.
Bienefelt, T. (1982). “Operasi Transmigrasi”, Internationale Samenwerking 14(5): 14–16.
Boeren, F. et al. (1978). Transmigratie in Indonesië. Verslag van de projectgroep Landbouwsystemen, Wageningen.
Collier, W.L. et al. (1981). “Social and economic aspects of based cropping system in the coastal wetlands of Indonesia.” Paper presented at the First International Workshop in Research Priorities in Tidal Swamp Rice in Indonesia, June 22–25.
Comte, M.C. (1978). “Land Settlement: Indonesia,” Ceres 11(4): 30–35.
Department of Information, Republic of Indonesia. Indonesia develops Repelita II, second five year development plan 1974/75–1978/79.
Dixon, J.A. (1980). “Land settlement costs and alternatives,” Prisma: The Indonesian Indicator 18: 17–31.
Ekonomi Indonesia (1983). “One million families to be moved under transmigration program in Repelita IV,” no. 51, March 1–15.
Euroconsult (1976). Findings of the Preparatory Mission “Transmigration N. Bengkulu” - Out-line of a Comprehensive Transmigration Project. Berenschot-Moret-Bosboom, Management Consulting for Development.
Fachurrozie, S.A. and C. MacAndrews (1978). “Buying time: Forty years of transmigration in Belintang,” Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 14(3): 94–103.
Far Eastern Economic Review (6 October 1983). “Go east, young man.”
Geertz, C. (1963). Agricultural Involution: The Process of Ecological Change in Indonesia. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Government of Indonesia (1981). “Transmigration Programme: an overview.” Paper presented by the Government of Indonesia at the IGGI Meeting held in Amsterdam in May 1981.
Guiness, P. (ed.) (1977). Transmigrants in South Kalimantan and South Sulawesi. Inter-island Government Sponsored Migration in Indonesia. Population Institute, Gadjah Mada University, Yogyakarta, Indonesia.
Hanson, A.J. (1981). “Transmigration and marginal land development,” in G.E. Hansen (ed.), Agricultural and Rural Development in Indonesia. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press.
Hardjono, J.M. (1977). Transmigration in Indonesia. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press.
Hardjono, J.M. (1978). “Note: Transmigration: A new concept?” Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 14(1): 107–112.
Hardjono, J.M. (1980). “Assisted and unassisted transmigration in the context of Repelita III targets,” Prisma: The Indonesian Indicator 18: 3–16.
Heeren, H. (1967). Transmigratie in Indonesië. Utrecht, The Netherlands: J.A. Boom.
Hugo, G.J. (1979). “Indonesia: Patterns of population movement to 1971”, in R.J. Pryor (ed.), Migration and Development in South East Asia: A Demographic Perspective. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press.
Hugo, G.J. (1980). “Indonesia: Population distribution and redistribution,” Majalah Demografi Indonesia 13: 70–100.
Hugo, G.J. et al. (1981). “Population distribution and redistribution,” in ESCAP, Migration, Urbanization and Development in Indonesia. Comparative study on migration, urbanization and development in the ESCAP region, Country Reports, United Nations, New York.
Indonesian Observer (10 March 1981). “President wants higher resettlement rate of people.”
Indonesian Observer (24 December 1982). “Transmigration face various deficiencies.”
Indonesian Observer (18 January 1983). “Minister Martono on transmigration program: Living standard transmigrants still bad.”
Indonesian Observer (13 May 1983). “Minister on corruption in transmigration sector.”
Indonesian Observer (9 August 1983).“Corruption cases in Transmigration Department withdrawn to Centre.”
Indonesian Times (10 December 1982). “Exodus of transmigrants from Marisa.”
Indonesian Times (7 October 1983). “Armed Forces may help open land for transmigrants.”
Jones, G.W. (1979). “Indonesia: The transmigration programme and development planning,” in R.J. Pryor (ed.), Migration and Development in South East Asia: A Demographic Perspective. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press.
Laquian, A.A. (1982). “Planned population redistribution: Lessons from Indonesia and Malaysia,” Habitat 6: 39–52.
MacAndrews, C. (1978a). “Transmigration in Indonesia: Prospects and problems,” Asian Survey 18: 458–472.
MacAndrews, C. (1978b). Land Settlement Policies in Malaysia and Indonesia. Occasional Paper Series, no. 52. Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
Manderson, L. (1974). Overpopulation in Java: Problems and Reactions. Australian National University, Canberra.
Mantra, I.B. (1981). “Population Problems and Resettlement Program in Indonesia,” IUSSP General Conference, Manila, December 1981.
MacNicoll, G. (1982). “Recent demographic trends in Indonesia,” Population and Development Review 8: 811–819.
Mustoffa, S. (1978). “Indonesia steps up transmigration,” Populi 5(3): 7–13.
Nijkamp, B. and D. Peeters (1984). “Migratie en rurale werkgelegenheid: een onderzoek naar (trans)migratie vanuit 2 dorpen in ruraal Centraal-Java, Indonesië.” Thesis for Masters' Degree (unpublished), Utrecht State University, The Netherlands, April 1984.
NRC-Handelsblad, (11 June 1982). “De cowboys in Amerika zijn zo begonnen.”
O'Donovan, R.J. (1979). “Indonesia plans resettlement of overcrowded population,” Overseas Trading 31: 550–551.
Oey, M. (1981). “Indonesia's Resettlement Scheme: The Transmigration Scheme.” IUSSP General Conference, Manilla, December 1981.
Perez-Sainz, J. (1979). “Transmigration and Accumulation in Indonesia.” ILO Working Paper no. 74, Geneva.
Poister, T.H. (1978). Public Program Analysis. Applied Research Methods. Baltimore, Maryland: University Park Press.
Soebiantoro, R. (1971). “Experiences in the implementation of transmigration in Indonesia,” in Directorate-General of Transmigration, The Role of Transmigration in National and Regional Development, Jakarta, 1974.
Supadi, D.T. (1980). “The history of transmigration in Indonesia,” Majalah Demografi Indonesia 11(14): 20–49.
Suratman, (first name omitted) and P. Guiness (1977). “The changing focus of transmigration,” Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 13(2): 78–101.
Titus, M.J. (1978). “Interregional migration in Indonesia as a reflection of social and regional inequalities,” Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie 69(4): 194–203.
TTRC (1974). Summary Report on Three Case Studies in Transmigration Areas with Different Agricultural Patterns: Punggur, Way Abung, Upang. Transmigration Training and Research Centre, Directorate General for Transmigration, Department of Manpower, Transmigration and Cooperatives.
Van Berkel, J. (1981). Harjomulyo: Inkomensvorming en sociaaal - ekonomische relaties in een transmigratieproject in Zuid - Sumatra, Indonesië. CASP, serie werkdocumenten I, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Van Loo, H.L. (1978). “Transmigratie in Indonesië: Een beleid dat de armsten van de samenleving raakt,” Intermediair 14(46): 11–21.
Van der Wijst, C.A. (1983). Bevolkingsspreiding in Indonesië. Een evaluatie - onderzoek naar het transmigratiebeleid vanaf 1 april 1969. NIDI, Intern Rapport no. 26, Voorburg.
Willekens, F.J. (1981). “Evaluatie-onderzoek: mogelijkheden en problemen,” in Vereniging voor Economie, Overheidsinterventies: effectiviteit en efficiëntie. Universitaire Pers, Leuven.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
This is a revised version of NIDI Working Paper No. 43, “An Evaluation of Recent Indonesian Transmigration Programmes,” November 1983.
The author would like to thank Dr. Ir. Frans Willekens for his valuable advice and stimulating comments. Thanks are also due to Lieneke Hoeksma for editing.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Van Der Wijst, T. Transmigration in Indonesia: An evaluation of a population redistribution policy. Popul Res Policy Rev 4, 1–30 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00125539
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00125539