Waterfowl-wetland relationships in the Aspen Parkland of British Columbia: comparison of analytical methods

Abstract

We explored the relationships between aquatic bird abundance and various pond features (physical and chemical) using data from 112 ponds located in the Aspen Parkland of British Columbia. As expected, pond size was the most important factor influencing the number of aquatic birds present. Total dissolved nitrogen, conductivity and calcium were positively associated with the abundance of several species whereas chloride tended to be negatively associated. The abundance of dabbling ducks was positively associated with turbidity and total dissolved nitrogen and negatively with percent of forested shoreline, percent of marsh and chloride. The abundance of diving ducks was associated positively with pond depth, conductivity and total dissolved nitrogen and negatively with percent of marsh and phosphorus levels. Pond area influenced more the abundance of diving ducks than dabbling ducks. Relationships between bird density and pond features were affected significantly by the area unit used to calculate density. For example, the density of Bufehead (Bucephala albeola) was correlated positively with pH and conductivity when expressed per area of water 0–2 m deep but negatively when expressed per total area of pond. Results highlight the problems associated with interpreting correlative type studies especially the difficulties in assessing the biological significance of the observed correlations. It underscores the urgent need for experimental approaches to bird-habitat studies.