Abstract
The central claim made by critics of contingent valuation (CV) is that respondents to a CV survey are inherently unresponsive to the characteristics of the good being valued.1In particular, it is alleged that respondents are not willing to pay more for more of a particular good; in economic jargon, respondents are insensitive to the scope of the good offered in the valuation exercise.2The focus of this debate is not whether CV results showing insensitivity to scope are obtainable, a point readily conceded by CV practitioners, but rather whether this result is generally avoidable with appropriate survey design, pretesting, and administration.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Anderson, Jack, and Dale Van Atta. “The Secret Polls Behind the Libya Raid. ” Washington Post 29 February 1988.
Andreoni, James. “Giving with Impure Altruism: Applications to Charity and Ricardian Equivalence. ” Journal of Political Economy 97, no. 6 (1989): 1447–1458.
Andreoni, James. “Impure Altruism and Donations To Public Goods: A Theory of Warm-Glow Giving. ” The Economic Journal 100 (1990): 464–477.
Arrow, Kenneth, Robert Solow, Paul R. Portney, Edward E. Leamer, Roy Radner, and Howard Schuman. “Contingent Valuation Methodology Report (Report of the NOAA Panel on Contingent Valuation). ” Federal Register 58(15 January 1993): 4602–4614.
Barrick, Kenneth Andrew, and Ronald I. Beazley. “Magnitude and Distribution of Option Value for the Washakie Wilderness, Northwest, Wyoming, USA. ” Environmental Management 14, no. 3 (1990): 367–380.
Bergstrom, John C., B. L. Dillman, and John Raymond Stoll. “Public Environmental Amenity Benefits of Private Land: The Case of Prime Agricultural Land. ” Southern Journal of Agricultural Economics 17, no. 1 (1985): 139–149.
Bishop, Richard C., and Thomas A. Heberlein. “Measuring Values of Extra-Market Goods: Are Indirect Measures Biased?” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 61, no. 5 (1979): 926–930.
Blomquist, Glenn C., and John C. Whitehead. The Effect of Alternative and Reclaimed Areas on the Value of Wetlands. Final report OSM 597 to the U. S. Department of the Interior. Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement, 1990.
Bowker, J. M. and D. D. Didychuk. “Estimation of the Nonmarket Benefits of Agricultural Land Retention in Eastern Canada. ” Agricultural and Resource Economics Review 23, no. 2 (1994): 218–225.
Payne, Stanley L. The Art of Asking Questions. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1951.
Propper, Carol. “Contingent Valuation of Time Spent on NHS Lists. ” The Economics Journal 100, no. 400 (1990): 193–199.
Randall, Alan, Berry C. Ives, and Clyde Eastman. “Bidding Games for Valuation of Aesthetic Environmental Improvements. ” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 1 (1974): 132–149.
Randall, Alan, and W. Kriesel. “Evaluating National Policy Proposals by Contingent Valuation. ” In Economic Valuation of Natural Resources: Issues Theory, and Applications edited by R. L. Johnson and G. V. Johnson. Boulder: Westview Press, 1990.
Ready, Richard C. The Value to Kentuckians of the Kentucky Equine Industry: A Contingent Valuation Study. Preliminary report Lexington Chamber of Commerce, 1990.
Römer, Anselm U., and Werner W. Pommerehne. “Valuing Reductions of Public Risks: The Case of Hazardous Waste. ” In Models and Measurement of Welfare and Inequality edited by Peter Eichhorn. Springer, Heidelberg, Forthcoming.
Rosenthal, Donald H., and Richard G. Walsh. “Hiking Values and the Recreation Opportunity Spectrum. ” Forest Science 32 (1986): 405–415.
Rowe, Robert D., Edward R. Morey, William D. Schulze, and William S. Breffle. Compensable Natural Resource Damage Determination for the Upper Clark Fork River NPL Sites. Report to the State of Montana, December, 1993.
Rowe, Robert D., William D. Schulze, W. D. Shaw, L. G. Chestnut, and D. Schenk. Contingent Valuation of Natural Resource Damage Due to the Nestucca Oil Spill. Final report to the British Columbia Ministry of Environment, June, 1991.
Samuelson, Paul A. “Alturism as a Problem Involving Group Versus Individual Selection in Economics and Biology. ” American Economic Review 83, no. 2 (1993): 143–148.
Schkade, David A., and John W. Payne. “How People Respond to Contingent Valuation Questions: A Verbal Protocol Analysis of Willingness to Pay for an Environmental Regulation. ” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 26, (1994): 88–109.
Schkade, David A., and John W. Payne. “Where Do the Numbers Come From? How People Respond to Contingent Valuation Questions. ” In Contingent Valuation: A Critical Assessment edited by J. A. Hausman. Amsterdam: North Holland Publishers, 1993.
Boyle, Kevin J., and Richard C. Bishop. “Valuing Wildlife in Benefit-Cost Analyses: A Case Study Involving Endangered Species. ” Water Resources Research 23, (1987): 943–950.
Boyle, K. J., M. P. Welsh, and Richard C. B. “The Role of Question Order and Respondent Experience in Contingent Valuation Studies. ” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 25, no. 1 (1993): 45–55.
Boyle, Kevin J., Michael P. Welsh, and Richard C. Bishop. “Valuing Increments and Decrements in Natural Resource Service Flows. ” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 62, no. 3 (1980): 478–488.
Brookshire, David S., Alan Randall, and John Raymond Stoll. “A Tesonmental and Resource Economists. Stockholm, June, 1991.
Carson, Richard T., Robert C. Mitchell, W. Michael Hanemann, Raymond J. Kopp, Stanley Presser, and Paul A. Ruud. A Contingent Valuation Study of Lost Passive Use Values Resulting from the Exxon Valdez Oil Spill. Report to the Attorney General of the State of Alaska. Natural Resource Damage Assessment, Inc., November, 1992.
Carson, Richard T., Robert Cameron Mitchell, and Paul A. Ruud. “Valuing Air Quality Improvements: Simulating a Hedonic Pricing Equation in the Context of a Contingent Valuation Scenario. ” In Visibility and Fine Particles edited by C. V. Mathai, 639–646. Pittsburgh: Air and Waste Management Association, 1990.
Carson, Richard T., Leanne Wilks, and David Imber. “Valuing the Preservation of Australia’s Kakadu Conservation Zone. ” Oxford Economic Papers 46 (1994) 727–749.
Cicchetti, Charles J., and V. Kerry Smith. The Costs of Congestion: An Econometric Analysis of Wilderness Recreation. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, 1976.
Cocheba, Donald J., and William A. Langford. “Wildlife Valuation: The Collective Good Aspect of Hunting. ” Land Economics 54. no. 4 (1978): 490–504.
Cummings, Ronald G. Comment submitted to the Office of Environmental Project Review, Department of the Interior, in response to ANPR Concerning Type B Natural Resource Damage Assessments (54 FR 183, September 22, 1989). 1989.
Cummings, Ronald G., David S. Brookshire, and William D. Schulze. Valuing Environmental Goods: An Assessment of the Contingent Valuation Method. Totowa, NJ: Rowman and Allanheld, 1986.
Daniel, Terry C., Thomas C. Brown, David A. King, Merton T. Richards, and William P. Stewart. “Perceived Scenic Beauty and Contingent Valuation of Forest Campgrounds. ” Forest Science 35, no. 1 (1989): 76–90.
Daubert, John T., and Robert A. Young. “Recreational Demands for Maintaining Instream Flows: A Contingent Valuation Approach. ” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 63, no. 4 (1981): 666–676.
Desvousges, William H., Alicia R. Gable, Richard W. Dunford, and Sara P. Hudson. “Contingent Valuation: The Wrong Tool for Damage Assessment. ” Choices no. 2 (1993): 9–11.
Desvousges, William H., F. Reed Johnson, Richard W. Dunford, Kevin J. Boyle, Sara P. Hudson, and K. Nicole Wilson. Measuring Nonuse Damages Using Contingent Valuation: An Experimental Evaluation of Accuracy. Research Triangle Park, NC: Research Triangle Institute, 1992.
Desvousges, William H., F. Reed Johnson, Richard W. Dunford, Kevin J. Boyle, Sara P. Hudson, and K. Nicole Wilson. “Measuring Natural Resource Damages with Contingent Valuation: Tests of Validity and Reliability. ” In Contingent Valuation: A Critical Assessment edited by J. A. Hausman. Amsterdam: North Holland Publishers, 1993.
Diamond, Peter A. “Testing the Internal Consistency of Contingent Valuation Surveys. ” Working paper 93–1, Department of Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Diamond, Peter A., and Jerry A. Hausman. “Contingent Valuation: Is Some Number Better than No Number?” Journal of Economic Perspectives 8 (1994), 45–64.
Diamond, Peter A., Jerry A. Hausman, Gregory K. Leonard, and Mike A. Denning. “Does Contingent Valuation Measure Preferences? Experimental Evidence. ” In Contingent Valuation: A Critical Assessment edited by J. A. Hausman. Amsterdam: North Holland Publishers, 1993.
Duffield, John W., and Chris Neher. Montana Waterfowl Hunting: A Contingent Valuation Assessment of Economic Benefits and Hunter Attitudes. Report to Montana Department of Fish, May, 1991.
Dunlap, Riley, E., and Rik Scarce. “Environmental Problems and Protection. ” Public Opinion Quarterly 55 (1991): 651–672.
Farkas, Steve, Robert Y. Shapiro, and Benjamin I. Page. The Dynamics of Public Opinion and Policy. Presented at American Association for Public Opinion Research Meeting, 1990.
Ferris, James M. “Demands for Public Spending: An Attitudinal Approach. ” Public Choice 40 (1983): 135–154.
Fischhoff, Baruch, and Lita Furby. “A Review and Critique of Tolley, Randall et al. : ‘Establishing and Valuing the Effects of Improved Visibility in the Eastern United States’. ” Eugene Research Institute, Eugene, October, 1986.
Fischhoff, Baruch, and Lita Furby. “Measuring Values: A Conceptual Framework for Interpreting Transactions with Special Reference to Contingent Valuation of Visibility. ” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 1 (1988): 147–184.
Fischhoff, Baruch, M. J. Quadrel, M. Kamlet, R. Dawes, P. Fischbeck, S. Klepper, J. Leland, and G. Loewenstein. “Embedding Effects: Stimulus Representation and Response Modes. ” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 6 (1993): 211–234.
Flores, Nicholas. “The Effects of Rationing and Valuation Elasticities. ” Unpublished paper. Department of Economics, University of California, San Diego, November 1994.
Gramlich, Frederick W. “The Demand for Clean Water: The Case of the Charles River. ” National Tax Journal 30, no. 2 (1977): 183–194.
Greenley, Douglas A., Richard G. Walsh, and Robert A. Young. “Option Value: Empirical Evidence from a Case Study of Recreation and Water Quality. ” Quarterly Journal of Economics 96, no. 4 (1981): 657–672.
Hanemann, W. Michael. “Willingness to Pay and Willingness to Accept: How Much Can They Differ?” American Economic Review 81, no. 3 (1991): 635–647.
Hanley, Nicholas D., and Stephen Craig. “The Economic Value of Wilderness Areas: An Application to the Krutilla-Fisher Model to Scotland’s’ Flow Country. ” In Environmental Policy and the Economy edited by F. Dietz, R. van der Ploeg and J. van der Straaten, 95–115. Amsterdam: North Holland Publishing Company, 1991.
Harrison, Glenn W. “Valuing Public Goods with the Contingent Valuation Method: A Critique of Kahneman and Knetsch. ” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 23, no. 3 (1992): 248–257.
Hausman, Jerry A., ed. Contingent Valuation: A Critical Assessment. Contributions to Economic Analysis. Amsterdam: North Holland Publishers, 1993.
Hoehn, John P. “Valuing the Multidimensional Impacts of Environmental Policy: Theory and Methods. ” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 73, no. 2 (1991): 289–299.
Hoevenagel, Ruud. The Contingent Valuation Method: Scope and Validity Dissertation, Vrije Universiteit te Amsterdam, 1994.
Jakus, Paul M. Valuing the Private and Public Dimensions of a Mixed Good: An Application to Pest Control. Dissertation. North Carolina State University, 1992.
Johansson, Per-Olov. “Willingness to Pay Measures and Expectations: An Experiment. ” Applied Economics 22 (1990): 313–329.
Jones Stokes Associates, Inc. Environmental Impact Report for the Review of Mono Basin Water Rights of the City of Los Angeles. Draft report to California State Water Resources Control Board. 1993.
Kahneman, Daniel. “Comments. ” In Valuing Environmental Goods: An Assessment of the Contingent Valuation Method edited by Ronald G. Cummings, David S. Brookshire and William D. Schulze, NJ: Rowman and Allanheld, 1986.
Kahneman, Daniel, and Jack Knetsch. “Valuing Public Goods: The Purchase of Moral Satisfaction. ” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 22 (1992a): 57–70.
Kahneman, Daniel, and Jack Knetsch. “Contingent Valuation and the Value of Public Goods: Reply. ” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 22, no. 1 (1992b): 90–94.
Kaoru, Yoshiaki. “Differentiating Use and Nonuse Values for Coastal Pond Water Quality Improvements. ” Environmental and Resource Economics 3(May 1993): 487–494.
Kemp, Michael A., and Christopher Maxwell. “Exploring a Budget Context for Contingent Valuation Estimates. ” In Contingent Valuation: A Critical Assessment edited by Jerry A. Hausman. Amsterdam: North Holland Publishers, 1993.
Knetsch, Jack L., and Robert K. Davis. “Comparisons of Methods for Resource Evaluation. ” In Water Research edited by Allen V. Kneese and Stephen C. Smith, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press for Resources for the Future, 1966.
Krieger, Douglas J. Economic Value of Environmental Risk Information: Theory and Application to Michigan Sport Fishery. Dissertation. Michigan State University, 1994.
Krosnick, J. A., and L. R. Fabrigar. Designing Questionnaires to Measure Attitudes: Insights from Cognitive and Social Psychology. New York: Oxford University Press, Forthcoming.
Lin, C. T. J. and J. W., Milon. “Contingent Valuation of Health Risk Reductions for Shellfish Products,” Presented at U. S. D. A. NE-165 Workshop on Foodsafety and Nutrition, 1993.
Loomis, John B. “Balancing Public Trust Resources of Mono Lake and Los Angeles Water Rights: An Economic Approach. ” Water Resources Research 23, (1987): 1449–1456.
Loomis, John B., Michael Creel, and Timothy Park. “Comparing Benefit Estimates from Travel Cost and Contingent Valuation Using Confidence Intervals for Hicksian Welfare Measures. ” Applied Economics 23, no. 11 (1991): 1725–1731.
Loomis, John B., and Pierre Duvair. “Evaluating the Effect of Alternative Risk Communication Devices on Willingness to Pay: Results from a Dichotomous Choice Contingent Valuation Experiment. ” Land Economics 69, no. 3 (1993): 287–298.
Loomis, John, Michael Lockwood, and Terry DeLacy. “Some Empirical Evidence on Embedding Effects in Contingent Valuation of Forest Protection. ” Journal of Environmental and Economics Management 25, no. 1 (1993): 45–55.
Madden, Paul. “A Generalization of Hicksian Substitutes and Complements with Application to Demand Rationing. ” Econometrica 59, no. 5 (1991): 1497–1508.
McConnell, Kenneth E. “Congestion and Willingness to Pay: A Study of Beach Use. ” Land Economics 53, no. 2 (1977): 186–195
Magnussen, Kristin. “Valuation of Reduced Water Pollution Using the Contingent Valuation Method - Testing for Amenity Misspecification. ” In Pricing the European Environment edited by Ståle Navrud. Oslo, Norway: Scandinavian University Press, 1992.
McClelland, Gary H., William D. Schulze, Donald Waldman, D. Schenk, J. Irwin, T. Stewart, L. Deck, and M. Thayer. Valuing Eastern Visibility: A Field Test of the Contingent Valuation Method - Innovative Approaches for Valuing Perceived Environmental Quality. Report to the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency Cooperative Agreement, 1991.
McDaniels, Timothy L. “Comparing Expressed and Revealed Preferences for Risk Reduction: Different Hazards and Question Frames. ” Risk Analysis 8 (1988): 593–604.
Milon, J. Walter, Eric M. Thunberg, Charles M. Adams, and C. T. Jordan Lin. Recreational Anglers’ Valuation of Near-Shore Marine Fisheries in Florida. Report prepared for the Florida Marine Fisheries Commission, 1993.
Mitchell, Robert C., and Richard T. Carson. Valuing Drinking Water Risk Reductions Using the Contingent Valuation Method: A Methodological Study of Risks from THMand Giardia. Report to the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency, 1986.
Mitchell, Robert C., and Richard T. Carson. Using Surveys to Value Public Goods: The Contingent Valuation Method. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future, 1989.
Mitchell, Robert C., and Richard T. Carson. “Current Issues in the Design, Administration and Analysis of Contingent Valuation Surveys. ” In Current Issues in Environmental Economics edited by P. O. Johansson, B. Kriström and K. G. Mäler. Manchester University Press, forthcoming.
Morin, Richard. “That Misleading Holocaust Survey: A Flawed Poll Overstated the Public’s Skepticism. ” Washington Post, p. C3, March 20, 1994
Note. “Ask a Silly Question. : Contingent Valuation of Natural Resource Damages. ” Harvard Law Review 105, no. 8 (1992): 1981–2000.
Mueller, John E. Policy and Opinion in the Gulf War. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994.
Mueller, John E. War Presidents and Public Opinion. Lanham: University Press of America, Inc., 1985.
National Opinion Research Center. General Social Surveys 1972–1991: Cumulative Codebook. Chicago: NORC, University of Chicago, 1991.
Navrud, StAle. “Estimating Social Benefits of Environmental Improvements from Reduced Acid Rain Deposition: A Contingent Valuation Survey. ” In: Valuation Methods and Policy Making in Environmental Economics, edited by Folmer, H. and E. van Lerland, Elsevier Science Publishers, 1989.
Neill, Helen Rosemary. Valuing Public Goods with the Contingent Valuation Method: Three Essays. Dissertation. Department of Economics, University of New Mexico, July, 1992.
Schuman, Howard, and J. Scott. “Problems in the Use of Survey Questions to Measure Public Opinion. ” Science 236 (1987): 957–959.
Schuman, Howard, and Stanley Presser. Questions and Answers in Attitude Surveys. New York: Academic Press, Inc., 1981.
Smith, Tom W. “That Which We Call Welfare By Any Other Name Would Smell Sweeter. ” Public Opinion Quarterly 51 (1987): 75–83.
Thompson, Mark S. “Willingness to Pay and Accept Risks to Cure Chronic Disease. ” American Journal of Public Health 76, no. 4 (1986): 392–396.
Smith, V. Kerry. “Comment: Arbitrary Values, Good Causes, and Premature Verdicts. ” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 22, no. 1 (1992): 71–89.
Smith, V. Kerry, and Laura Osborne. “Are Contingent Valuation Estimates Economically Consistent? Visibility Changes at National Parks. ” Unpublished paper. Resource and Environmental Economics Program, North Carolina State University, January, 1993.
Smith, V. Kerry and Xiaolong Zhang. “Can Contingent Valuation Pass a Challenging Scope Test?: Visual Displays of Marine Debris,” unpublished paper, Center for Environmental and Resource Economics, Duke University, January 1995.
Stevens, Thomas H., Jaime Echeverria, Ronald J. Glass, Tim Hager, and Thomas A. More. “Measuring the Existence Value of Wildlife: What Do CVM Estimates Really Show?” Land Economics 67 (1991): 390–400.
Schwarz, Norbert and Fritz Strack. “Context Effects in Attitude Surveys: Applying Cognitive Theory to Social Research. ” European Review of Social Psychology 2 (1991): 31–50.
Sudman, S., and N. M. Bradburn. Asking Questions. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1983.
Sutherland, Ronald J., and Richard G. Walsh. “Effect of Distance on the Preservation of Water Quality. ” Land Economics 61, no. 3 (1985): 281–291.
Thayer, Mark. “Contingent Valuation Techniques for Assessing Environmental Impacts: Further Evidence. ” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 8 (1981): 27–44.
Tobin, J., and H. S. Houthakker. “The Effects of Rationing on Demand Elasticities. ” Review of Economic Studies 18 (1951): 140–53.
Tolley, G. S., L. Babcock, M. Berger, A. Bilotti, G. Blomquist, M. Brien, R. Fabian, G. Fishelson, C. Kahn, and et al. Valuation of Reductions in Human Health Symptoms and Risks: Volume II: Comparative Analysis of Approaches to Valuing Health Risks. Final report to the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency, January, 1986.
Veisten, Knut, Hans Fredrik Hoen, Stále Navrud, and Jon Strand. “Valuing Biodiversity in Norwegian Forests. ” Presented at Meeting of the European Association of Environmental and Resource Economists. Paris, June, 1993.
Walsh, Richard G., Donn M. Johnson, and John R. McKean. “Benefit Transfer of Outdoor Recreation Demand Studies: 1968–1988. ” Water Resources Research 28,(1992): 707–713.
Walsh, Richard G., Nicole P. Miller, and Lynde O. Gilliam. “Congestion and Willingness to Pay for Expansion of Skiing Capacity. ” Land Economics 59, no. 2 (1983): 195–210.
Whitehead, John C. “Ex Ante Willingness to Pay with Supply and Demand Uncertainty: Implications for Valuing a Sea Turtle Protection Programme ” Applied Economics 24 (1992): 981–988.
Whitehead, John C., and Glenn C. Blomquist. “Measuring Contingent Values for Wetlands: Effects of Information About Related Environmental Goods. ” Water Resources Research 27, no. 10 (1991): 2523–2531.
Wu, Pei-Ing. “Benefit Evaluation of Multidimensional Environmental Policy: An Application to Ohio’s Big Darby Creek. ” Dissertation. DAI 52 (1991): 2228. Ohio State University.
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1997 Springer Science+Business Media New York
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Carson, R.T. (1997). Contingent Valuation Surveys and Tests of Insensitivity to Scope. In: Kopp, R.J., Pommerehne, W.W., Schwarz, N. (eds) Determining the Value of Non-Marketed Goods. Studies in Risk and Uncertainty, vol 10. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-5364-5_6
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-5364-5_6
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-010-6255-8
Online ISBN: 978-94-011-5364-5
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive