Summary. Do model-based approaches to reasoning have a stake in accounting for errors of reasoning? If mainstream logic is anything to go on, a theory of bad reasoning is wholly subsumed by a theory of good reasoning, with the former construed as the complement of the latter. In an older tradition (e.g., Mill’s System of Logic), errors are best considered as a stand-alone component of any psychologically real approach to logic. Such is the assumption of this essay. Historically, logic’s almost exclusive preoccupation with error is to be found in what it may chance to say about fallacies. In the tradition that has come down to us since Aristotle, fallacies are errors of reasoning that are attractive, widely-distributed enough to be called “universal”, and difficult to correct, that is, possessed of signi.cant levels of incorrigibility.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Magnani, L., Nersessian, N., eds.: Model-Based Reasoning in Scientific Discov-ery, Technological Innovation and Values. Kluwer, New York (2002)
Magnani, L., ed.: Model-Based Reasoning in Science and Engineering. College Publications, London (2006)
Anderson, A., Belnap Jr., N.: Entailment: The Logic of Relevance and Necessity. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ (1975)
Shoesmith, D., Smiley, T.: Multiple-Conclusion Logic. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1978)
Woods, J.: Aristotle’s Earlier Logic. Hermes Science Publications, Oxford (2001)
Hamblin, C.: Fallacies. Methuen, London (1970)
Hansen, H., Pinto, R.: Fallacies: Classical and Contemporary Readings. The Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park, PA (1995)
Johnson, R.: The Rise of Informal Logic. Vale Press, Newport News Va (1996)
Barth, E., Krabbe, E.: From Axiom to Dialogue: A Philosophical Study of Logic and Argumentation. De Gruyter, Berlin and New York (1982)
Hintikka, J.: Knowledge and Belief. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY (1962) 28 Even this is harder than it may first appear.
Woods, J., Walton, D.: Fallacies: Selected Papers 1972-1982. Foris de Gruyter, Berlin and New York (1989)
Mackenzie, J.: Four dialogue systems. Studia Logica XLIX (1990) 567-583
Woods, J., Irvine, A., Walton, D.: Argument: Critical Thinking, Logic and the Fallacies. Prentice Hall, Toronto (2004) 2nd Revised Edition.
Copi, I.: Introduction to Logic. MacMillan, New York (1986)
Carney, J., Scheer, K.: Fundamentals of Logic. Macmillan, New York (1980)
Schipper, E., Schuh, E.: A First Course in Modern Logic. Henry Holt, New York (1959)
Black, M.: Critical Thinking. Prentice-Hall, New York (1946)
Woods, J.: The Death of Argument. Fallacies in Agent-Based Reasoning. Kluwer, Dordrecht and Boston (2004)
Hintikka, J.: The fallacy of fallacies. Argumentation 1 (1987) 211-238
Hintikka, J., Sandu, G.: Game-theoretical semantics. In van Benthem, J., ter Meulen, A., eds.: Handbook of Logic and Language. Elsevier (1997) 361-410
Hintikka, J.: What was aristotle doing in his early logic, anyway? a reply to woods and hansen. Synthese 113 (1997) 241-249
Woods, J.: Begging the question is not a fallacy (2007) to appear.
Govier, T.: Reply to massey. In Hansen, H.V., Pinto, R.C., eds.: Fallacies: Classical and Contemporary Readings. The Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park PA (1995) 172-180
Scriven, M.: Fallacies of statistical substitution. Argumentation 1 (1987) 333-349
Hitchcock, D.: Why there is no argumentum ad hominem fallacy(2006) http://www.humanities.mcmaster.ca/∼hitchckd/. Accessed on 16/07/06.
Eemeren, F.v., Grootendorst, R.: Argumentation, Communication and Fallacies. A Pragma-Dialectical Perspective. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ and London (1992)
Walton, D.: A Pragmatic Theory of Fallacy. University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa (1995)
Woods, J.: Pragma dialectics: A radical departure in fallacy theory. Bulletin of the International Society for the Study of Argumentation (1989) 5-15
Morris, C.: Writings on the General Theory of Signs. Mouton, The Hague (1971)
Jacquette, D.: Psychologism the philosophical shibboleth. In Jacquette, D., ed.: Philosophy, Psychology and Psychologism: Critical and Historical Readings on the Psychological Turn in Philosophy. Kluwer (2003) 245-262
Pelletier, F., Elio, R., Hanson, P.: The many ways of psychologism in logic: History and prospects (2007) Studia Logica, to appear.
Gabbay, D., Woods, J.: The Ring of Truth: Towards a Logic of Plausibility. Volume 3 of A Practical Logic of Cognitive Systems (2007)
Searle, J.: Speech Acts. An Essay in the Philosophy of Language. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1969)
Stalnaker, R.: Presupposition. Journal of Philosophical Logic 2 (1973) 447-457
Stalnaker, R.: Assertion. Syntax and Semantics 9 (1978) 315-332
Gabbay, D., Woods, J.: Agenda Relevance: A Study in Formal Pragmatics, vol. 1 of A Practical Logic of Cognitive Systems. North-Holland, Amsterdam (2003)
Gabbay, D., John Woods, J.: The practical turn in logic. In Gabbay, D.M., Guenthner, F., eds.: Handbook of Philosophical Logic,2nd revised edition. Kluwer (2005) 15-122
Churchland, P.: A Neurocomputational Perspective; The Nature of Mind and the Structure of Science. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (1989)
Bruza, P., Widdows, D., Woods, J.: A quantum logic of down below. In Engesser, K., Gabbay, D.M., eds.: Handbook of Quantum Logic. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2007)
d’Avila Garcez, A., Gabbay, D., Ray, O., Woods, J.: Abductive neural networks: Abductive reasoning in neural-symbolic systems (2007) Topoi, to appear.
Simon, H.: Models of Man. John Wiley, New York (1957)
Simon, H.: Models of Bounded Rationality: Behavioral Economics and Business Organization. The MIT Press, Cambridge and London (1982)
Gigerenzer, G.: Adaptive Thinking: Rationality in the Real World. Oxford Uni-versity Press, New York (2000)
Gigerenzer, G., Selten, R.: Bounded Rationality: The Adaptive Toolbox. MIT Press, Cambridge MA (2000)
Stanovich, K.: Who is Rational? Studies of Individual Differences in Reasoning. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ (1999)
Woods, J., Johnson, R., Gabbay, D., Ohlbach, H.: Logic and the practical turn. In D.M. Gabbay, R.M. Johnson, H.O., Woods, J., eds.: Studies in Logic and Practical Reasoning volume 1 of the Handbook of the Logic of Argument and Inference. Elsevier/North Holland (2002) 1-39
Gabbay, D., Woods, J.: The Reach of Abduction: Insight and Trial, volume 2 of A Practical logic of Cognitive Systems. North-Holland, Amsterdam (2005)
Mill, J.: A System of Logic. Longman’s Green, London (1961) Originally pub-lished in 1843.
Locke, J.: An Essay Concerning Human Understanding. Clarendon Press, Oxford (1975) edited by Peter H. Nidditch, Originally published in 1690.
Carlson, G., Pellerier, F., eds.: The Generic Book. Chicago University Press, Chicago (1995)
Gigerenzer, G.: I think, therefore i err. Social Research 1 (2005) 195-217
Woods, J.: Probability and the law: A plea for not making do (2007) to appear.
Gabbay, D., Woods, J.: Seductions and Shortcuts: Fallacies in the Cognitive Economy, volume 4 of A Practical Logic of Cognitive Systems (2007)
Toulmin, S.: Stephen Toulmin, The Philosophy of Science: An Introduction. The Hutchinson University Library, London (1982)
Magnani, L.: Abduction, Reason and Science: Processes of Discovery and Expla-nation, Dordrecht. Kluwer Plenum, New York (2001)
Gabbay, D., Woods, J.: Advice on abductive logic. Logic Journal of the IGPL 14 (2006) 189-219
Aliseda, A.: Abductive Reasoning: Logical Investigation into the Processes ofDiscovery and Evaluation. Springer, Amsterdam (2006)
Woods, J.: Error (2007) to appear.
Woods, J.: Why is fallacy theory so difficult? (2007) to appear.
Woods, J.: Lightening up on the ad hominem (2007) to appear.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2007 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Woods, J. (2007). The Concept of Fallacy is Empty. In: Magnani, L., Li, P. (eds) Model-Based Reasoning in Science, Technology, and Medicine. Studies in Computational Intelligence, vol 64. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-71986-1_3
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-71986-1_3
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-540-71985-4
Online ISBN: 978-3-540-71986-1
eBook Packages: EngineeringEngineering (R0)