Abstract
The variance of testing was compared between the College of American Pathologists clinical survey and that of a recent review about hair mineral testing. The review suggested that the accuracy of hair mineral testing was unreliable. In general, there was a greater range of variance in the College of American Pathologists testing results. These latter results are based on laboratory testing and are used as a “yardstick” to determine if a laboratory passes or fails that analyte and are considered a “gold standard.” An extract, which resulted from a method that avoided the washing step, was compared among five laboratories. Very good precision resulted, indicating that the varied washing steps used by the laboratories in a recent review were probably the source of much variance.
Analysis of hair analysis seemed to yield important information in several historical or forensic cases involving Ludwig von Beethoven, Napoleon Bonaparte, ex-US-presidents Zachary Taylor and Andrew Jackson, and Charles Hall, an Arctic explorer.
Several elements that were reviewed, including arsenic, cadmium, cobalt, germanium, lead, lithium, manganese, mercury, nickel, and thallium, showed relationships between body burden, dosage, and exposure or toxicity. Evidence of toxicity could not be found by measuring hair aluminum or vanadium. Chromium, selenium, and zinc seemed to have nutritional value. Ratios of hair elements with clinical importance could not be found.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
S. Seidel, R. Kruetzer, D. Smith, S. McNee, and D. Gilliss, Assessment of commercial laboratories performing hair mineral analysis, JAMA 285, 67–72 (2001).
S. Barrett, Commercial hair analysis: science or scam? JAMA 254, 1041–1045 (1985).
R. Martin, Beethovens Hair, Random House, New York (2000).
P. F. Corso, J.T. Hindmarsh and F.D. Strizto, The death of Napoleon, Am. J. Forensic Med. Pathol. 21, 300–303 (2000).
B. Weider and J. Fournier, Author’s reply, Am. J. Forensic Med. Pathol. 21, 303–305 (2000).
B. Weider, Authors reply, Sci. Prog. 81, 81–92 (1998).
F. K. Paddock, C. C. Loomis, and A. K. Perkons, An inquest on the death of Charles Hall, N. Enge. J. Med. 282, 784–786 (1970).
L. M. Deppisch, J. A. Centeno, D. Gemmel, and N. L. Torres, Andrew Jackson’s exposure to mercury and lead, JAMA 282, 569–571 (1999).
E. Cernichiari, G. M. Myers, T. W. Clarkson, and B. Weiss, Did Andrew Jackson have mercury poisoning? JAMA 283, 200 (2000).
L. M. DePisch and D. J. Gemmel, Did Andrew Jackson have mercury poisoning? Reply, JAMA 283, 201 (2000).
P. Chappuis, M. de Vernejoul, F. Paolaggi, and F. Rousselet, Relationship between hair, serum and bone and aluminum in hemodialyzed patients, Clini. Chimi. Acta 2(179), 271–278 (1989).
A. Pineau, O. Guillar, F. Huguet, M. Speich, S. Gelot, and H. Boiteau, An evaluation of the biological significance of aluminum in plasma and hair of patients on long-term hemodialysis, Eur. J. Pharmacol. Environ. Toxicol. Pharm. 228, 263–268 (1993).
M. Wilhelm, J. Passlick, T. Busch, M. Szydlik, and F. K. Ohnesorge, Scalp hair as an indicator of aluminum exposure: comparison to bone and plasma, Hum. Toxicity 8, 5–9 (1989).
A. Poklis, Chapter 8, Forensic Toxicology, in Introduction to Forensic Sciences, W. G. Eckert ed., CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, Fla., p. 107–132 (1997).
G. S. Zhuang, Y. S. Yang, M. G. Tan, M. Zhi, W. Q. Pan, and Y. D. Cheng, Preliminary study of the distribution of the toxic elements As, Cd, and Hg in human hair and tissues by RNAA, Biol. Trace Element Res. 27, 729–736 (1990).
T. H. Lin, Y. H. Huang, and M. Y. Wang, Arsenic species in drinking water, hair, fingernails; and urine of patients with Blackfoot disease, J. Toxicol. Environ. Health A 53, 85–93 (1998).
M. A. Armienta, R. Rodriguez, and O. Cruz, Arsenic content in hair of people exposed to natural arsenic polluted groundwater at Zimapan, Mexico, Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 59, 583–589 (1997).
WHO, Environmental Health Criteria, Volume 18, World Health Organization, Geneva (1981).
J. T. Hindmarsh, O. R. McLetchie, L. P. M. Hefferman, O. A. Hayne, H. A. Ellenberger, R. F. McCurdy, et al., Electromyographic abnormalities in chronic environmental arsenicalism, J. Anal. Toxicol. 1, 270–276 (1977).
A. Pazirandeh, A. H. Brati, and M. G. Marageh, Determination of arsenic in hair using neutron activation, Appl. Radiat. Isot. 49, 753–759 (1998).
D. Das, A. Chatterjee, B. K. Mandal, G. Samanta, and D. Chakraborti, Arsenic in groud water in six districts of West Bengal, India: the biggest arsenic calamity in the world. Part 2. Arsenic concentration in drinking water, hair, nails, urine, skin-scale, and liver tissue (biopsy) of the affected people, Analyst 120, 917–924 (1995).
K. A. Bustueva, B. A. Revich, and L. E. Bezpalko, Cadmium in the environment of three Russian cities and in human hair and urine, Arch. Environ Health 49, 284–288 (1994).
N. Frery, F. Girard, T. Moreau, P. Blot, J. Saluquillo, S. Hajem, et al. Validity of hair cadmium in detecting chronic cadmium exposure in general populations, Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 50, 736–743 (1993).
M. Marlowe, L. Bliss, and H. G. Schneider, Hair trace element content of violence prone male children, J. Adv. Med. 7, 5–18 (1994).
M. Marlowe, C. Moon, J. Errera, and J. Stellern, Hair mineral content as a predictor of mental retardation, Orthomol. Psychiatry 12, 26–33 (1983).
H. L. Needleman, C. Gunnoe, A. Leviton, R. Reed, H. Pereise, and C. Barrett, Deficits in psychologic and classroom performance of children with elevated dentine lead levels, N. Engl. J. Med. 300, 689–695 (1979).
P. O. Phil and F. Ervin, Lead and cadmium levels in violent criminals, Psychol. Rep. 66, 839–844 (1990).
J. Basco, G. Lusztig, A. Pal, and I Uzonyi, Comparative investigation of some mineral elements in the aortic wall and the Ca concentration in the hair, Exp. Pathol. 29, 119–125 (1986).
A. MacPherson and J. Bacso, Relationship of hair concentration to incidence of coronary heart disease, Sci. Total Environ. 25, 11–19 (2000).
A. V. Skalny, R. S. Dadashev, F. I. Slavin, and A. S. Semenov, Ca, Mg, Na, K levels in the hair of alcoholics, Laboratamoe Delo 2, 42–44 (1989).
S. Y. Ng, Hair calcium and magnesium levels in patients with fibromyalgia: a case center study, J. Manipulative Physiol. Ther. 22, 586–593 (1999).
L. Kotowiak, Behavior of selected bio-elements in women with osteoporosis, Ann. Acad. Med. Stetin 43, 225–238 (1997).
A. Ahoroni, B. Tesler, Y. Paltieli, J. Tal, Z. Dori, and M. Sharf, Hair chromium content of women with gestational diabetes compared with nondiabetic pregnant women, Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 55, 104–107 (1992).
S. Davies, J. M. Howard, A. Hunnisett, and M. Howard, Age-related decreases in chromium levels in 51,665 hair, sweat and serum samples from 40,872 patients—implications for the prevention of cardiovascular disease and type II diabetes mellitus, Metabolism 46, 469–473 (1997).
S. Kazi, S. S. Ali, T. G. Kazi, and G. H. Kazi, Chromium: its role in diabetes and concentration in human scalp hair, Am. Clin. Lab. 18, 8 (1999).
K. M. Hambridge and D. O. Rodgerson, Comparisons of hair chromium levels of nulliparous and parous women, Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 103, 320–321 (1969).
K. M. Hambridge, D. O. Rodgerson, and D. O’Brien, Concentration of chromium in the hair of normal children and children with juvenile mellitus, Diabetes 17, 517–519 (1968).
J. Q. J. Jarvis, E. Hammond, R. Meier, and C. Robinson, Cobalt cardiomyopathy. A report of two cases from the mineral assay laboratories and a review of the literature, J. Occup. Med. 34, 620–626 (1992).
K. P. Shrestha and A. E. Carrera, Hair trace elements and mental retardation among children, Arch. Environ. Health 43, 396–398 (1998).
T. Suzuki, J. Koizumi, T. Moroji, H. Shiraishi, T. Hari, A. Baba, et al., Effects of long-term anticonvulescent therapy on copper, zinc, and magnesium in hair and serum of epileptics, Biol. Psychiatry 31, 571–581 (1992).
I. D. Capel, M. H. Pinnock, H. M. Darrell, D. C. Williams, and E. C. G. Grant, Comparison of concentrations of some trace, bulk, and toxic metals in hair of normal and dyslexic children, Clin. Chem. 27, 879–881 (1981).
M. Oishi, T. Takasu, M. Tateno, and H. Uchida, Hair trace elements in cerebellar degeneration: low copper levels in late cortical cerebellar atrophy, J. Neurol. 237, 163–165 (1990).
A. Ilhan, E. Uz, S. Kali, A. Var, and O. Akyo, Serum and hair trace element levels in patients with epilepsy and healthy subjects: does the antiepileptic therapy affect the element concentrations of hair, Eur. J. Neurol. 6, 705–709 (1999).
S. K. Taneja, S. Girhotra, and K. P. Singh, Detection of potentially myocardial infarction susceptible individuals in Indian population. A mathematical model based on copper and zinc status, Biol. Trace Element Res. 75, 177–186 (2000).
L. M. Klevay, Coronary heart disease: the zinc copper hypothesis, Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 8, 764–774 (1975); N. V. Davydenko, I. P. Smirnova, E. A. Kvasha, and I. M. Gorbas, The relationship between the Cu and Zn intake with food and the prevalence of ischemic heart disease and its risk factors, Liksprow 6, 73–77 (1975).
S. M. Tang, Hair zinc and copper concentration in patients with epilepsy, The Chinese Journal of Neurology and Psychiatry 24, 124–125 (1991).
K. P. Shrestha and A. Oswaldo, Trace elements in hair of epileptic and normal subjects, Sci. Total Environ. 67, 215–225 (1987).
S. K. Taneja, M. Mahajan, S. Gupta, and K. P. Singh, Assessment of copper and zinc status in hair and urine of young women descendants of NIDOM parents, Biol. Trace Element Res. 62, 255–264 (1998).
K. Obara, T. Saito, H. Sato, K. Yamakage, T. Watanabe, M. Kizawa, et al. Germanium poisoning: clinical symptoms and renal damage caused by long-term intake of germanium, Jpn. J. Med. 30, 67–72 (1991).
M. Iijima, A case of inorganic germanium poisoning with peripheral and cranial neuropathy, myopathy, and autonomic dysfunction, No To Shinkei 42, 851–856 (1990).
H. Morita, S. Shimomura, K. Okagawa, S. Saito, C. Sakigawa, and H. Sato, Determination of germanium and some other elements in hair, nail, and toenail from persons exposed and unexposed to germanium, Sci. Total Environ. 58, 237–242 (1986).
X. Peng, Z. Lingxia, G. N. Schrauzer, and G. Xiong, Selenium, boron, and germanium deficiency in the etiology of Kashin-Beck disease, Biol. Trace Element Res. 77, 193–197 (2000).
M. Benderour, K. Hess, M. D. Gadet, B. Dousset, P. Nabet, and F. Bellville, Effect of boric acid solution on cartilage metabolism, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 234, 263–268 (1997).
T. K. Cherniaeva, N. A. Matveeva, I. G. Kuzmichev, and M. P. Gracheva, Heavy metal content of the hair of children in industrial cities, Gigiena I Sanitariia 3, 26–28 (1997).
B. Nowak and J. Chmielnicka, Relationship of lead and cadmium to essential elements in hair, teeth and nails of environmentally exposed people, Ecotoxicol. environ. Safety 46, 265–274 (2000).
A. Furman and M. Laleli, Semi-occupational exposure to lead: a case study of child and adolescent street vendors in Istanbul, Environ. Res. A 83, 41–45 (2000).
M. Schuhmacher, M. Belles, A. Rico, J. J. Domingo, and J. Corbella. Impact of reduction of lead in gasoline on the blood and hair lead levels in the population of Tarragona Province, Spain, 1990–1995, Sci. Total Environ. 184, 203–209 (1996).
S. C. Foo, N. Y. Khoo, A. Heng, L. H. Chua, S. E. Chia, S. N. Ong, et al. Metals in hair as biological induces for exposure, Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health 65, 583–586 (1993).
M. Wilhelm and H. Idel, Hair analysis in environmental medicine, Zbl. Hyg. 198, 485–501 (1996).
L. Gerhardsson, V. Englyst, N. G. Lundstrom, G. Nordberg, S. Sanberg, and F. Steinall, Lead in tissues of deceased lead smelter workers, J. Trace Element Med. Biol. 9, 136–143 (1995).
E. Esteban, Hair and blood as substrate for screening children for lead, Arch. Environ. Health 54, 436–440 (1999).
R. Tuthill, Hair lead levels related to children’s classroom attention-deficit behavior, Arch. Environ. Health 51, 214–220 (1996).
B. Minder, E. A. Das-Smaal, E. F. J. M. Brand, and J. F. Orlebeke, Exposure to lead and specific attentional problems in schoolchildren, J. Learning Disabil. 27, 393–399 (1994).
G. N. Schrauzer, K. P. Shrestha, and M. F. Flores-Acre, Lithium in scalp hair of adults, students and violent criminals, Biol. Trace Element Res. 34, 161–176 (1992).
M. Marlowe, D. M. Medeiros, J. Errera, and L. C. Medeiros, Hair minerals and diet of Prader-Willi syndrome youth, J. Autism Dev. Disord. 17, 365–374 (1987).
P. S. Gentile, M. J. Trentalange, and W. Zamichek, Brief report: trace elements in the hair of autistic and control children, J. Autism Dev. Disord. 13, 205–206 (1983).
C. Huang, N. Chu, C. Lu, J. Wang, J. Tsai, J. Tzeng, et al., Chronic manganese intoxication, Arch. Neurol. 46, 1104–1106 (1989).
C. C. Huang, N. S. Chu, C. S. Lu, R. S. Chen, and D. B. Calne, Long-term progression in chronic manganism, ten years of follow-up, Neurology 50, 698–700 (1998).
I. Luse, M. A. Bake, G. Bergmanis, and Z. Podniece, Risk assessment of manganese, Cent. Eur. J. Public Health 51(Suppl.), 8 (2000).
L. A. Gottschalk, T. Rebello, M. S. Buchsbaum, H. G. Tucker, and E. L. Hodges, Abnormalities in hair trace elements as indicators of aberrant behavior, Comp. Psychiatry 32, 229–237 (1991).
G. Saner, T. Dagoglu, and T. Ozden, Hair manganese concentrations in newborns and their mothers, Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 41, 1042–1044 (1985).
O. Malm, Gold mining as a source of mercury exposure in the Brazilian amazon, Environ. Res. A 77, 73–78 (1998).
WHO, Inorganic mercury, in Environmental Health Criteria, Volume 118, World Health Organization, Geneva (1991).
WHO, Methylmercury, in Environmental Health Criteria, Volume 101, World Health Organization Geneva (1990).
P. Grandjean, R. F. White, A. Nielson, D. Cleary, and E. C. de Olivera-Santos, Methylmercury neurotoxicity in Amazonian children downstream from gold mining, Environ. Health Perspect. 107, 587–591 (1999).
G. B. Ramirez, C. V. Cruz, M. S. Pagulayan, E. Ostrea, and C. Oalisay, The Tagum study. I: Analysis and clinical correlates of mercury in maternal and cord blood, breast milk, meconium and infants’ hair, Pediatrics 106, 774–781 (2000).
A. Oskarsson, B. J. Lagervist, B. Ohlin, and K. Lundberg, Mercury levels in the hair of pregnant women in a polluted area in Sweden, Sci. Total Environ. 151, 29–35 (1994).
K. Juhlshamn, A. Andersen, O. Ringdal, and J. Morkore, Trace elements in the Faroe Islands I. Element levels in edible parts of whales (Globicephalus mekanus), Sci. Total Environ. 65, 53–62 (1987).
A. D. Matthews, Mercury content of commercially important fish of the Seychelles and hair mercury levels of a selected part of the population, Environ. Res. 30, 305–312 (1983).
J. C. Hansen, H. C. Wulf, N. Kormann, and K. Alog, Human exposure to heavy metals in East Greenland, I. Mercury, Sci. Total Environ. 26, 233–243 (1983).
J. C. Sherlock, D. G. Lindsay, J. E. Hislop, W. H. Evans, and T. R. Collier, Duplication diet study on mercury intake by fish consumers in the United Kingdom, Arch. Environ. Health 37, 271–278 (1982).
N. Ishihara, K. Urashiyama, and T. Suzuki, Inorganic and organic mercury in blood, urine and hair in low level mercury vapor exposure, Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health 40, 249–253 (1997).
F. Bakir, S. F. Damluji, L. Amin-Zaki, M. Murtadha, A. Khalida, Y. Al-Raulin, et al., Methylmercury poisoning in Iraq, Science 181, 230–241 (1973).
R. W. Phelps, T. W. Clarkson, T. G. Kershaw, and B. Wheatly, Interrelationships of blood and hair mercury in a North American population exposed to methylmercury, Arch. Environ. Health 35, 161–167 (1980).
S. Skerfving, Methylmercury exposure, mercury levels in blood and hair, and health status in Swedes consuming contaminated fish, Toxicology 2, 3–23 (1974).
I. Amin-Zaki, S. Elhassani, M. A. Majeed, T. W. Clarkson, R. A. Doherty, M. R. Greenwood, et al., Perinatal methylmercury poisoning in Iraq, Am. J. Dis. Child 130, 1070–1076 (1976).
M. Harada, J. Nakanishi, S. Konuma, K. Ohno, T. Kimura, H. Yamaguchi, et al., The present mercury contents of the scalp hair and clinical symptoms in inhabitants of the Minamata area, Environ. Res. A 77, 160–164 (1998).
J. T. Salonen, K. Seppanen, K. Nyyssonen, H. Korpela, J. Kauhanen, M. Kantola, et al., Intake of mercury from fish, lipid peroxidation, and the risk of myocardial infarction and coronary, cardiovascular and any death in Eastern Finnish men, Circulation 91, 645–655 (1995).
J. T. Salonen, K. Seppanen, T. A. Lakka, R. Salonen, and G. H. Kaplan, Mercury accumulation and accelerated progression of carotid atherosclerosis: a population-based prospective 4-year follow-up study in men in Eastern Finland, Atherosclerosis 148, 265–273 (2000).
T. Suzuki, T. Hongo, N. Matsuo, H. Imai, M. Nakazawa, T. Abe, et al., An acute mercuric mercury poisoning: chemical speciation of hair mercury shows a peak of inorganic mercury value, Hum. Exp. Toxicol. 11, 53–57 (1992).
Y. Mano, T. Takayanagi, A. Ishitani, and T. Hirota, Mercury in the hair of patients with ALS, Clin. Neurol. 29, 844–848 (1989).
F. N. Marzulli and D. W. C. Brown, Potential systemic hazards of topically applied mercurials, J. Soc. Cosmet. Chem. 23, 875–886 (1972).
B. Gammelgaard and N. K. Veien, Nickel in nails, hair and plasma from nickel-hypersensitive women, Derm Venerol. (Stock.) 70, 417–420 (1990).
Y. D. Cheng, G. S. Zhuang, M. G. Tan, M. Zhi, and W. Zhou, Study of correlation of Se content in human hair and internal organs by INAA, Biol. Trace Element Res. 26–27, 737–741 (1990).
P. Bratter, V. E. Negretti de Bratter, W. G. Jaffe, and H. M. Castellano, Selenium status of children living in seleniferous areas of Venezuela, J. Trace Element Electrolytes Health Dis. 5, 269–270 (1991).
K. Seppanen, M. Kantola, R. Laatikainen, K. Nyyssonen, V. P. Valkonen, V. Kaarlopp, et al., Effect of supplementation with organic selenium on mercury status as measured by mercury in pubic hair, J. Trace Elements Med. Biol. 14, 84–87 (2000).
I. Lombeck, K. Kasperek, H. D. Harbisch, K. Becker, E. Schumann, W. Schroter, et al., The selenium state of children. II. Selenium content of serum, whole blood, hair and activity of erythrocyte glutathione peroxidase in dietically treated patients with phenylketonuria and maple syrup urine disease, Eur. J. Pediatr. 128, 213–223 (1978).
M. L. Gallagher, P. Webb, R. Crounse, I. Bray, A. Webb, and E. Settle, Selenium levels in new growth hair and in white blood during ingestion of a selenium supplement for 6 weeks, Nutr. Res. 4, 577–582 (1984).
J. McCormack and W. McKinney, Thallium poisoning in group assassination attempt, Postgrad. Med. 74, 239–244 (1983).
P. Trenkwalder, K. Bencze, and H. Lydtin, Chronische thalliumintoxikation. Dtsch. Med. Wschr, 109, 1561–1566 (1984).
J. Kucera, A. R. Byrne, A. Mravcova, and J. Lener, Vanadium levels in hair and blood of normal and exposed persons, Sci. Total Environ. 15, 191–205 (1992).
K. M. Hambridge, C. Hambridge, M. Jacobs, and J. B. Baum, Low levels of zinc in hair, anorexia, poor growth, and hypogeusia in children, Pediatr. Res. 6, 868–874 (1972).
J. A. Halsted, H. A. Ronaghy, P. Abadi, H. Haghsheann, G. H. Amirhakem, R. H. Barakat, et al., Zinc deficiency in man: the Shiraz experiment, Am. J. Med. 53, 277–284 (1972).
W. H. Strain, L. T. Steadman, C. A. Lankau, W. P. Berliner, and W. J. Pories, Analysis of zinc levels in hair for the diagnosis of zinc deficiency in man, J. Lab. Clin. Med. 68, 244–249 (1966).
P. A. Walravens and K. M. Hambridge, Growth of infants fed a zinc supplemented formula, Am. J. Clin. Nurt. 29, 1114–1121 (1976).
C. Castillo-Duran, H. Garcia, P. Venegas, I. Torrealba, E. Panteon, N. Concha, et al., Zinc supplementation increases growth velocity of male children and adolescents with short stature, Acta Paediatr. 83, 633–637 (1994).
C. W. Weber, G. W. Nelson, M. V. de Vaquera, and P. B. Pearson, Trace elements in the hair of healthy and malnourished children, J. Trop. Pediatr. 36, 230–234 (1990).
L. Perrone, G. Gialanella, V. Giardano, A. La Manna, R. Moro, and R. Di Toro, Impaired zinc metabolic status in children affected by idiopathic nephrotic syndrome, Eur. J. Pediatr. 149, 438–440 (1990).
R. S. Gibson and M. S. DeWolfe, Copper, zinc, manganese, vanadium, and iodine concentrations in the hair of Canadian low birth weight neonates, Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 32, 1728–1733 (1979).
A. Varkonyi, M. Boda, S. Nagy and B. Nyilasi, Determination of hair trace elements in childhood celiac disease and in optic fibrosis, Acta Pediatr. Hung. 32, 159–165 (1992).
B. Falkiewicz, E. Dabrowska, J. Lukasiak, D. Cajzer, and I. Jablonska-Kaszewska, Zinc deficiency and normal contents of magnesium and calcium in metabolic X syndrome patients as assessed by the analysis of hair element concentrations, BioFactors 11, 139–141 (2000).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Shamberger, R.J. Validity of hair mineral testing. Biol Trace Elem Res 87, 1–28 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1385/BTER:87:1-3:001
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1385/BTER:87:1-3:001