The shadow of dark matter as a shadow of string theory: string origin of the dipole term

We point out that the Kalb–Ramond field can couple to the Ramond and Neveu–Schwarz fields of superstring theory in a way that can generate a coupling of the Kalb–Ramond field to dark matter dipole moments. Electroweak dipole dark matter could then arise from the Ramond sector of superstrings with low string scale Ms≲120\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$M_s\lesssim 120$$\end{document} TeV.


Introduction
After the confirmation of the Higgs particle as the capstone of the Standard Model, solving the persistent enigma of dark matter has become a major objective of modern particle physics. The completion of the Standard Model (SM) is a great example of successful collaboration between theory and experiment, and theoretical models are needed in the "beyond SM" era to assist with the search for dark matter in particle physics experiments and to provide ideas on what to look for.
It is an intriguing possibility that dark matter might provide a window into low energy string phenomenology, e.g. through the swampland conjecture leading to fading dark matter within a tower of light string states [1,2], or through models where a low string scale [3,4] implies phenomenologically acceptable dark axions or dark gauge bosons [5][6][7][8].
It has been pointed out recently [9] that electroweak dipole dark matter [10,11] may open a window into low energy string phenomenology through the Kalb-Ramond field. The question of the relevant string scale was not addressed in Ref. [9] because no direct link between the dark matter coupling and mass to the string scale was established. However, it turns out that the Kalb-Ramond field can couple to the fermionic Ramond fields in such a way that a low energy coupling of the Kalb-Ramond field to dark fermions can be traced back to string theory. This then allows for an estimate a e-mail: rainer.dick@usask.ca (corresponding author) of the maximal string scale for which perturbatively coupled dipole dark matter could be induced from string theory.
Kalb and Ramond had noticed that gauge interactions between strings can be described in analogy to electromagnetic interactions if the basic Nambu-Goto action is amended with a coupling term to an anti-symmetric tensor field [12]. We follow the conventions of Ref. [9] and denote the Kalb-Ramond field with C μν = − C νμ to avoid confusion with the electroweak U Y (1) field strength tensor B μν . The action for strings coupling to the Kalb-Ramond field is Here T s is the string tension and μ s is a string charge with the dimension of mass. The world sheet measure is The string equations of motion which follow from (1) are invariant under the KR gauge symmetry (2) and under the U (1) gauge transformation B μ → B μ + ∂ μ f , and these gauge symmetries are preserved through addition of a field theory action for the gauge fields, where are the components of the 3-form field strength C 3 = dC of the Kalb-Ramond field. This motivated the proposal in [9] to induce a U Y (1) portal to dark matter through the Lagrangian Elimination of C μν for energies much smaller than m C generates electroweak dipole moments for the dark matter field χ , However, while the bosonic terms in (5) could be motivated through the couplings of string world sheets to Kalb-Ramond fields, the coupling of C μν to the dark fermions had to be postulated. The purpose of the present paper is to point out that the Kalb-Ramond field can couple to the Ramond [13] and Neveu-Schwarz [14] fields of superstrings in a way that does induce magnetic dipole couplings at low energies, thus lending more credibility to the proposal that direct search for electroweak dipole dark matter can provide a window into low energy string phenomenology. The possible string origin of the coupling of the Kalb-Ramond field to dark dipole moments is introduced in Sect. 2 and conclusions are formulated in Sect. 3. The mapping between world-sheet spinors and half-differentials is reviewed in Appendix A, since it helps to understand the proposed coupling of the Kalb-Ramond field to the halfdifferentials μ √ ± . The Kalb-Ramond field in Lorentz gauge and in Coulomb gauge and its polarization is reviewed in Appendix B.

String origin of magnetic dipole terms
We wish to provide a string explanation for the coupling of the Kalb-Ramond field to the dark fermion dipole moments in Eq. (5). This will require a coupling to the Ramond fields ψ μ (τ, σ ) on the world sheet, which we write as components μ √ ± (τ, σ ) of half-differentials. The mapping between 2D spinors and half-differentials is reviewed in Appendix A.
The mapping should respect world-sheet and target space symmetries under coordinate and Lorentz transformations. Since 2D spinors are completely equivalent to half-differentials, and since we can only use C μν or C μνρ for the coupling, the unique solution to this problem is with a dimensionless coupling constant g s . The minus sign is required by parity invariance of the world-sheet Lagrangian. The coupling term (7) is in world-sheet spinor notation (with metric determinant g ≡ g(τ, σ ) and zweibein components e α a ≡ e α a (τ, σ )) given by The coupling (7) preserves the KR gauge symmetry C → C + d f (2) because only the 3-form field strength dC (4) appears. However, for later reference it is also useful to explicitly note this on the level of the equations of motion. The contribution from (7) to the equation of motion of the Kalb-Ramond tensor is a source current This current satisfies due to the anti-symmetry of the bracket in (9) under μ ↔ ρ. Eq. (10) ensures that the addition J μν → J μν + J μν 3 to the source terms of the original Kalb-Ramond equations of motion complies with gauge invariance, see also Appendix B.
The couplings (1, 7) of the Kalb-Ramond field break the world-sheet supersymmetry of the free string theory. However, they do preserve the GSO projection [15], and that is what we really need. The couplings (1, 7) correspond to interactions between string world sheets which are mediated by a spacetime field. This leads to a Dyson representation for the scattering matrix, with the Hamiltonian density in the interaction picture. The contribution to H I from Eq. (7) is in Lorentz gauge 1 The Kalb-Ramond type interactions (1, 7) extend the sector of string interactions by introducing a spacetime field which probes the bosonic and fermionic string excitations across the world sheet. We could think of them in terms of vertex operator insertions on the world sheet, but they do not generate additional constraints from branch cuts. The consistent string theories are therefore still built from tensor products of the Ramond sectors (R, ±) and the Neveu-Schwarz sector (NS, +) [16], where the signs denote the level of fermionic world sheet excitations modulo 2. (1) is like the polarization basis of physical states of a massless vector field with momentum k. However, in Lorentz gauge there are two additional unphysical polarizations of the form 1 Lorentz gauge is not essential, of course, but convenient. Just like in QED, it yields the Lagrangian interaction terms as covariant vertices. It can be imposed on C μν using the KR gauge symmetry (2) while preserving Lorentz gauge for B μ , see Appendix B. 2 There is also another possibility. In multi-scale string theories with different kinds of strings with different tensions T s , T s , the Kalb-Ramond picture might correspond to an effective intermediate energy theory for energies T s E T s , such that for the high scale string modes an effective field theory description applies, whereas for the lowscale strings the world sheet description is still needed. In that case, the Kalb-Ramond field could arise from the field theory description of the anti-symmetric tensor modes of the high tension string theory. The states in the intermediate energy effective theory would still have the form described in the text, but the Kalb-Ramond factors would arise from underlying string states in the high-tension string theory.
If we evaluate the expression (7) on the low-energy states of the Ramond sector, we find in temporal gauge τ = t, dσ = = k 0 /T s , This describes the interaction of the Kalb-Ramond field with a classical fermion. The corresponding quantum mechanical action is The non-relativistic limit of Eq. (16) corresponds to a coupling where we invoked the standard assumption that the low energy string states in the a priori massless sector acquire masses through symmetry breaking. The coupling of the Kalb-Ramond field to fermions on the world-sheet (7) and in the resulting field theory coupling (16) are explicitly invariant under the KR gauge symmetry because the fermions couple to the Kalb-Ramond field strength. The resulting coupling (17) in the non-relativistic limit is effectively invariant within that limit due to m C |k|, where k is the 3-momentum of the Kalb-Ramond field. We have m C |C i j | |∂ 0 C i j | |∂ i C 0 j |, and therefore m C C i j iC 0i j .
Elimination of C i j (x) from the action with the terms (5) yields a magnetic dipole coupling with coupling constant However, the coupling scale M = M d /a m can be determined as a function of dark matter mass m χ through the requirement of thermal dark matter creation in the early universe. This led to M 23 PeV for m χ = 1 MeV and M 3.7 TeV for m χ = 10 GeV, or roughly 3 m χ M 3 × 10 4 GeV 2 , see Fig. 1 in Ref. [9]. However, Eq. (18) relates this to the string scale, String-induced electroweak dipole dark matter with perturbative couplings would therefore require a low string scale √ 8π T s 120 TeV.

Conclusion
Inclusion of the missing piece (7) in the string derivation of electroweak dipole dark matter relates the string tension to dark matter parameters. Assuming perturbative couplings and that dark matter is created from thermal freeze-out then leads to the requirement M s 120 TeV. Since string theory appears to be unique in providing a mechanism to induce electroweak dipole moments in dark matter, discovery of electroweak dipole dark matter with a mass and recoil cross section which agrees with the predictions from thermal dark matter creation would be a strong hint for low-scale string theory. It is intriguing that the geometry of string ground states allows for the construction of phenomenologically viable models with fundamental string scales all the way down to the TeV scale [3][4][5][6][7][8]. Furthermore, it is also conceivable that there may exist different incarnations of fundamental strings with different tensions T s . In that case the Kalb-Ramond model (1) and its extension (7) could find a natural "pure string" explanation within a hierarchy of string scales T s T P = M 2 Planck /8π . The Kalb-Ramond field C μν (x) would then correspond to the low energy description of the anti-symmetric tensor fields of Planck scale superstrings with tension T P , and the couplings (1, 7) would arise from worldsheet couplings between strings with different tensions. If the low scale string sector contains only Ramond sector states, such a scenario would not need to invoke any further assumption about the nature of the string ground state to explain why M Planck M s . Either way, the possibility to induce electroweak dipole dark matter from string theory adds to the anticipation that low scale string theory should become a leading paradigm for particle physics searches beyond the Standard Model, both in direct dark matter search experiments and at future colliders.
Acknowledgements This research was supported at the University of Saskatchewan through a President's NSERC grant.

Data Availability Statement
This manuscript has no associated data or the data will not be deposited. [Authors' comment: This manuscript has no associated data since no datasets were generated or analyzed during the current study].
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecomm ons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Funded by SCOAP 3 .

Appendix A: Half-differentials and fermions on the world sheet
Here we review the mapping between spinors and halfdifferentials on world sheets in the conformal gauge We denote the remaining degree of freedom in the metric by φ(τ, σ ), The metric in the corresponding two-dimensional light-cone coordinates σ ± = σ ± τ , corresponds to zweibein components e α a (note η +− = 1/2), The set of coordinate transformations is restricted by the conformal gauge 4 to On the other hand, the symmetry group SO(1, 1) of tangent plane Lorentz boosts also factorizes in the light-cone basis of tangent vectors. A boost with parameter in the tangent plane yields in the light-cone basis v ± = v 1 ± v 0 the transformation law with components This is the exact square of the transformation of the spinor components in Weyl representation. Every Weyl representation of 2D γ matrices yields either iS 10 or − iS 10 as the spinor representation of the boost generator, where The corresponding Lorentz boost on the spinors is i.e. the matrix elements of the spinor representation relate to the matrix elements of the vector representation through To be specific we use in the following calculations the real Weyl representation of 2D γ matrices However, the mapping between world-sheet spinors and half-differentials, and the fermion action in terms of halfdifferentials, follow in the same form for every Weyl representation.
The tangent plane gamma matrices in the light cone basis follow as and the transformation of the integration measure to the lightcone coordinates on the world sheet is The curved space generalization of the kinetic terms in the Dirac action is However, the spin-connection in two dimensions, anti-commutes both with γ 0 and γ 1 , { α , γ a } = 0. Therefore, splitting the derivative symmetrically between ψ and ψ cancels the spin connection from the Dirac action in two dimensions. The resulting action combining the Fubini-Veneziano fields and Dirac spinors on the world sheet is Combining the spinor and zweibein components yields the half-differentials and the action The 2D metric has completely disappeared, in the scalar sector due to the conformal gauge and in the spinor sector due to absorption into the half-differentials. The The phases of the anti-commuting half-differentials decouple in the action (41), in agreement with the real transformation behavior (30) of the spinors in Weyl representation. The standard phase convention is The superconformal transformation parameters √ ± (σ ± ) are then real anti-commuting (−1/2)-differentials 5 , which yield the transformations and respectively, whereas the mode expansion in Lorentz gauge is We choose polarization vectors whereas (3) Comparison with the operator (54) in Coulomb gauge shows that the single transverse physical polarization in Lorentz gauge is (1) μ (k) (2) ν (k) − (2) μ (k) (1) ν (k), whereas the two spatially longitudinal polarizations, look like spin-0 states. However, it is not possible to consistently replace C μν in interaction terms through a duality transformation into an axion. At the classical level, a relation of the form C μνρ = μνρσ ∂ σ a would require both fields to be massless free fields, and even if the equation would be consistent at the classical level, it would not constitute a canonical transformation of quantum operators.