Erratum to: Decoherence of quantum parameter estimation for open Dirac particle in Garfinkle–Horowitz–Strominger dilation black hole

There is a small change in the reference of [1], which was reference [20] in the original article.


Introduction
In recent years, the concepts developed in statistical mechanics and quantum foundations have been used to understand quantum effects of spacetime [1][2][3][4]. The ideas of quantum information theory such as quantum entanglement shed new light on some well known effects including Unruh acceleration effects [5,6], Gibbons-Hawking effects [7,8], and Hawking radiation from the black hole [9,10]. It is interesting that the spacetime with a horizon can prevent an observer from having access to the full quantum state of the field. It can a e-mail: xhao@mail.usts.edu.cn result in the information loss in curved spacetime [11,12]. In some proposals [13][14][15][16][17], curved spacetime can be simulated by a system of coupled atoms and quantum fields. Quantum parameter estimation in these simulated experiments can be exploited to study quantum effects of black holes. The combination of relativity and quantum measurement can contribute to the development of relativistic quantum metrology [18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25]. In some previous works [19][20][21][22][23][24], relativistic effects on quantum parameter estimation have been computed using the quantum Fisher and skew information [26][27][28]. Meanwhile, it is worth noticing that information divergence or relative entropy [29][30][31] can be used for the discrimination of quantum states.
Enlightened by that, we put forward the concept of quantum information divergence to evaluate quantum parameter in the relativistic condition. Moreover, we use the theory of open quantum systems to characterize the vacuum structure for Dirac field mode in the GHS dilation black hole. The quantum Fisher information and information divergence can be used to evaluate the amplitude and relative phase of Dirac particle. In this case, one observer freely falls toward the GHS dilation black hole and then hovers near the event horizon. The detector of the observer can detect Dirac particle.
The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2, the vacuum structure for Dirac fields in the GHS dilation black hole is characterized by the quantum channel with dilation parameters. We define quantum information divergence in order to quantify the parameter estimation in Sect. 3. We also investigate the dynamical behavior of quantum parameter estimation and quantum coherence. In Sect. 4, we analyze the relation of quantum coherence and quantum parameter estimation. The impacts of another external noises are taken into account.  [7,9]. The presence of such radiation is known as the Hawking effect. The cosmological parameters M and D are related to the mass of black hole and dilation field. With respect to the Dirac vacuum field in GHS dilation black hole, we choose the global coordinates (t, r, θ, φ) to express the spherically symmetric line element of the GHS black hole as [33][34][35], where the natural unitsh = G = c = κ B = 1 are used. The Dirac equation has the expression of γ α e μ a (∂ μ + μ )ψ = 0 [33]. Here, γ α is the Dirac matrix, e μ a corresponds to the inverse of the tetrad e μ a and μ denotes the spin connection coefficient. By solving the Dirac equation, we can obtain the positive frequency outgoing solutions outside region I and inside region I I of the event horizon, ψ ι+ k = e ∓iωu where ι = (I, I I ) represents two regions, k denotes a variable that labels the field mode, is a 4-component Dirac spinor and ω is a monochromatic frequency of the Dirac field.
To describe the causal structure of the GHS dilation black hole, we plot the Carter-Penrose diagrams for this spacetimes in Fig. 1. This black hole has the singularity r = 2D. The event horizon is given by r = 2M. The diagram contains two regions I and I I that are causally disconnected.
By using the complete orthogonal basis ψ ι± k , we quantize the Dirac field as where c ι k and d ι * k correspond to the fermion annihilation and antifermion creation operators acting on the Kruskal vacuum. The Eqs. 2 and 3 correspond to the decomposition of the Dirac fields in GHS dilation and Kruskal modes respectively. By using the appropriate Bogoliubov transformation between two different sets of coordinates, each annihilation operator c ι k can be expanded by the spacetime operators as where T denotes the radiation temperature [36,37]. The mode of ground state in the GHS dilation coordinates is considered as a two-mode squeezed state in Kruskal coordinates. Therefore, the vacuum and only excited state of the particle can be written as where |n + I and |n − I I represent the orthonormal basis for the outside region I and inside region I I of the event horizon respectively. The superscripts on the kets {+, −} denote the particle and antiparticle. In the following context, the notation of |n ± I,I I is simplified as |n I,I I . Since the exterior region I is causally disconnected from the interior region I I of the corresponding spacetime, we can obtain the physical accessible part I by tracing over the state of the interior region I I . The whole process can be described by a quantum channel [38,39]. According to the dynamics of open quantum system, the state of the open system will change as a consequence of its internal dynamics and of the interaction with the environment. The inevitable coupling to the environment can result in quantum decoherence which is similar to the loss of information in the spacetimes with a horizon. The state change of the open system over time t is called a dynamical map or quantum channel. The map can be expressed by is an initial state and ρ(t) is the evolved state. In general, the mathematical expression of V (t) can be written in the form of the local operators, For an arbitrary qubit state ρ(0) = j,k=0,1 jk | j k|, we can rewrite the map as In regard to GHS dilation black hole, the dynamical map is defined as the Unruh channel, where the partial trace over the state of the interior region is carried out.
For an arbitrary qubit state, the density matrix of the state ρ can be expressed by the vector in four-dimensional space as where ζ μ = tr(ρσ μ ), (μ = 0, 1, 2, 3) are four components of the state vector. σ 0 is the identity operator I and σ i (i = 1, 2, 3) denote the three Pauli operators. By means of the quantum channel, we describe the map from the initial state vector where the vector 0 T = (0, 0, 0) and ζ is the Bloch vector of state. The quantum channel ε U (·) determines the column vector λ with . And another 3 × 3 acting matrix has the components which satisfy The Bloch vector of the evolved state can be obtained by ζ = λ + · ζ (0) . Using Eqs. (5) and (6), the 4 × 4 mathematical mapping matrix U for a Unruh channel can be written as where the mapping matrix is completely determined by the radiation temperature of the Unruh channel. In this way, we can have physical access to the state of the Dirac qubit by the mapping matrix of state vector.

Quantum parameter estimation in the formalism of Bloch vector
In the analogue experimental realization [15], the parameter estimation of quantum fields can play an important role in the study of relativistic effects. Quantum metrology has become a powerful tool for some tasks such as state discrimination [40,41] and tomography [19]. Our aim is to study the quantum effects of dilation black holes from the viewpoint of relativistic quantum metrology. As is well known, quantum Fisher information can provide a tight bound for the precision of parameter estimation. The definition of quantum Fisher information is closely related to the Bures distance for the discrimination of two neighboring states ρ(θ) and = ρ(θ + θ ). Here θ is the estimated parameter and θ denotes the parameter variation. According to reference [40], the expression of Bures distance is given by √ ρ √ is the fidelity of two quantum states. In the second-order approximation of θ , the relation between quantum Fisher information and Bures distance is written as where F θ is the quantum Fisher information. It can be defined by the symmetric logarithmic derivative operator [42,43], i.e., F θ = Tr(ρ L 2 ) = Tr(∂ θ ρ L). The symmetric logarithmic derivative L is a Hermitian operator determined by ∂ θ ρ = 1 2 [ρ L + Lρ] where the notation ∂ θ (·) = ∂ ∂θ (·). In the simplest case of a pure state ρ = |ψ ψ|, In the eigenstate space of ρ = m p m |ψ m ψ m |, quantum Fisher information can be rewritten as, where the first term F c = m (∂ θ p m ) 2 p m is the classical Fisher information.
With the idea of the divergence of parameter distribution, Kullback-Leibler distance is also introduced to distinguish two neighboring states [44]. The definition is D KL (ρ, ) = Tr[ρ(log ρ − log )]. In the Taylor expansion of θ to the second order which is log ρ(θ) − log ρ(θ + θ ) ≈ −(∂ θ log ρ) θ − 1 2 (∂ 2 θ log ρ)( θ ) 2 , we then apply this to the definition of D KL where log ρ can be expressed by its eigenstates as m log p m |ψ m ψ m |.
where ψ m |∂ θ ψ m + ∂ θ ψ m |ψ m = ∂ θ ψ m |ψ m = 0 and m p m = 1. Then, the expression of Eq. (11) can be rewritten as where the relation of Similar to Eq. (9), we can define a quantity G(θ ) to express the Kullback-Leibler distance where G θ is referred to as quantum information divergence. The expression of G θ can be given by where the second term results from the quantum Fisher information of all pure states |ψ m and the third term results from the mixture of all eigenstates. In a sense, Eqs. (14) and (15) can provide an evidence that there is the close relationship between quantum Fisher information and information divergence. For a pure state, G θ = ∞ and F θ = 1. And G θ = F θ = 0 for complete mixed states. As we know, the evolved state of an open quantum system will be mixed if the quantum noise channel acts on an arbitrary initial state. Therefore, quantum information divergence G can be used to estimate the parameter for a general mixed state of an open system. In the formalism of state vector, we can rewrite F θ and G θ as where ζ denotes the Bloch vector of a Dirac qubit. We consider a Unruh channel acting on a Dirac field qubit with an initial state |ψ = cos α 2 |1 +e iβ sin α 2 |0 . α ∈ [0, π) and β ∈ [0, 2π) represent the amplitude and phase parameter of the Dirac field respectively. Here we use the coordinates of the GHS dilation black hole to represent the vacuum state |0 and excited one |1 . In a sense, cos 2 α 2 and sin 2 α 2 correspond to the survival probabilities of the vacuum state and excited one during the evolution of the dilation black hole. According to Eq. (5), we find that there is the oscillation probability between the vacuum state and excited one in the physical accessible part I . The process of the oscillation can give rise to the relative phase β. The Bloch vector of the initial state is expressed as ζ (0) = cos β sin α, sin β sin α, cos α T . Using Eq. (16), we can obtain the quantum parameter estimation about α and β as F α = cos 2 r, F β = cos 2 r sin 2 α, where |ζ | = 1 − cos 2 r sin 2 r (1 + cos α) 2 and cos r = (e − ω T +1) − 1 2 . In the following analysis, we exploit the vector form of quantum parameter estimation to study the decoherence.

Decoherence without and with external noises
The dynamics of the Dirac field state in GHS dilation black hole can be governed by the Unruh channel with the radiation temperature T . The change of G α can be plotted as a function of radiation temperature T in Fig. 2. According to Eq. (17), F α is independent of the initial Dirac field state and only determined by the radiation temperature of the curved spacetime. Different from F α , the quantum information divergence G α decreases from the infinity value to a fixed value. In Fig. 2, we illustrate the asymmetric behavior of the quantum information divergence with respect to α. From Fig. 3, we can see that both of estimation values are monotonically decreased to non-zero steady values with the increase of temperature. It results from the Pauli exclusion principle and Fermi statistics of Dirac fields.
Meanwhile, the estimation precision of parameter β can also be performed by the measures of F β and G β . From Eq. (17), we can see that quantum Fisher information F β is symmetric about α. The maximum value of F β is obtained when the maximally coherent initial state with α = π/2 is chosen. G α is plotted as a function of α and T in Fig. 4. Similar to quantum Fisher information, the maximum value of G α arrives at α = π/2. This phenomenon can demonstrate that quantum information divergence is considered as another efficient measure for quantum parameter estimation.
To explain the mechanism of the decoherence, we further calculate the quantum coherence of the Dirac field in the Unruh-channel spacetime. The relative entropy of coherence Fig. 2 The quantum parameter estimation with respect to α is evaluated by G α as a function of radiation temperature T when the frequency of Dirac field ω = 1 is chosen Fig. 3 The decoherence of F α and G α is illustrated by the black line and red dash line respectively. The parameters of α = π/4 and ω = 1 are chosen [45] is introduced as C(ρ) = S(ρ diag ) − S(ρ) where the von Neumann entropy S(ρ) = −Tr[ρ log(ρ)] and ρ diag denotes the state which is obtained from ρ by deleting all off-diagonal elements. For any Dirac qubit, quantum coherence is written as where ζ is the Bloch vector. When the initial state |ψ = cos α 2 |1 + e iβ sin α 2 |0 is chosen, the changes of quantum coherence is numerically illustrated in Fig. 5. It is clearly shown that quantum coherence keeps a high value at the early stage and then decays gradually to a non-zero steady value. The behaviour of quantum coherence is related to the transition of quantum effects of Dirac fields. The increase in the radiation temperature can give rise to the transition from a high correlated state to a mixed steady state with less coherence. This decoherence Fig. 4 The quantum parameter estimation with respect to β is evaluated by G β as a function of the amplitude α and radiation temperature T when the frequency of Dirac field ω = 1 is chosen phenomenon of quantum coherence is very similar to that of quantum parameter estimation.
Additionally, it is interesting to analyze the effects of external noises on a Dirac qubit in the Unruh channel. Under the influence of ambient effects and cosmological radiation, the behavior of quantum parameter estimation can contribute to the deep understanding of quantum effects of spacetime. For this purpose, we consider two typical kinds of noises which are described by an amplitude damping channel (AD) and phase damping channel (PD) [46]. Here, we exploit the quantum channel to construct the evolution of Dirac state with external noises.
In general, when a series of quantum channels {ε i , i = 1, 2, . . . , N } sequentially act on an initial state ρ (0) , the evolved state ρ can be governed by ρ = ε N ·ε N −1 · · · ε 1 (ρ (0) ). For the simplification of the expression, we assume the notation N i=1 ε i = ε N · ε N −1 · · · ε 1 . If each channel is expressed in the form of mapping matrix i , the state vector during the evolution can be obtained by where the product of these mapping matrices can be expressed by a total mapping matrix tot as Thus, the total evolution process is equivalent to the total mapping matrix with the effective vector λ tot = λ N + N j=2 N k= j k λ j−1 and acting matrix tot = N i=1 i . The Bloch vector of the evolved state can be obtained by ζ = λ tot + tot · ζ (0) .
In the simplest case of N = 2, an open Dirac qubit are subjected to the Unruh channel U and other noisy channel where (1) for the amplitude damping case and (2) for the phase damping one. The parameter p ∈ [0, 1) denotes the decaying coefficient from the environmental noise. p = 0 represents the Unruh channel without any noise. In both of cases, the Bloch vectors ζ (i) for the Dirac state can be calculated as which can be used to evaluate the quantum parameter estimation according to Eq. (16). For example, quantum parameter estimation with respect to β are obtained by means of two measures,

F
where F β is the quantum Fisher information for the Unruh channel without external noises. From the above analytical results, it is found out that the estimation precision can be further suppressed by the external noises.

Discussion
We exploit the theory of quantum channels to study the structure of the vacuum state of Dirac fields propagating in a GHS dilation black hole spacetime. We introduce the concept of quantum information divergence for relativistic parameter estimation. We use the quantum Fisher information and information divergence to estimate the amplitude and relative phase of the Dirac field state. The precision of estimating the phase parameter can decrease with the radiation temperature. The external noise from the amplitude damping channel and phase damping channel can suppress the decoherence of quantum parameter estimation.