Abstract
This chapter assesses various critiques that have been levelled over the years against Thiriwall’s Law and the balance of payments constrained growth model. It starts by assessing the criticisms that the law is largely capturing an identity, that the law of one price renders the model incoherent, and that statistical testing using cross-country data rejects the hypothesis that the actual and the balance of payments equilibrium growth rates are the same. It goes on to consider the argument that calculations of the “constant-market-share” income elasticities of demand for exports demonstrate that the UK (and by implication other advanced countries) could not have been balance of payments constrained in the early post-war period. Next, Krugman’s interpretation that the law (or what he terms the “45-degree rule”) which is at variance with the usual demand-oriented explanation is examined. The chapter next assesses attempts to reconcile the demand and supply side of the model and examines whether or not the balance of payments constrained growth model is subject to the fallacy of composition. It concludes that none of these criticisms invalidate the model, which remains a powerful explanation of why growth rates differ.
Cambridge Centre for Economic and Public Policy, Department of Land Economy, University of Cambridge, UK. I am grateful to Tony Thirlwall for helpful comments.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Araujo, R.A., and Lima, G.T. (2007), “A Structural Economic Dynamics Approach to Balance-of-Payments-Constrained Growth”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 31(5), September, 755–74.
Balassa, B. (1978), “Exports and Economic Growth. Further Evidence”, Journal of Development Economics, 5(2), 181–89.
Balassa, B. (1979), “Export Composition and Export Performance in the Industrial Countries, 1953–71”, Review of Economics and Statistics, 61(4), 604–7.
Balassa, B. (1983), “Outward Versus Inward Orientation Once Again”, World Economy, 6(2), 215–18.
Blecker, R.A., and A. Razmi (2010), “Export-Led Growth, Real Exchange Rates and the Fallacy of Composition” in M. Setterfield (ed.) Handbook of Alternative Theories of Economic Growth (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar).
Chow, P.C.Y. (1987), “Causality between Export Growth and Industrial Development: Empirical Evidence from MICs”, Journal of Development Economics, 26(1), 55–63.
Cline, W.R. (1982), “Can the East Asian Model of Development be Generalized?” World Development, 10(2), 81–90.
Connell, D. (1979) The U.K.’s Performance in Export Markets — Some evidence from International Trade Data, National Economic Development Office, discussion paper 6.
Cornwall, J. (1977), Modern Capitalism: Its Growth and Transformation (London: Martin Robertson).
Crafts, N.F.R. (1988), “The Assessment: British Economic Growth over the Long Run,” Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 4(1), i–xxi, spring.
Crafts, N.F.R. (1991), “Economic Growth” in N.F.R. Crafts and N.W.C. Woodward (eds) with the assistance of B.F. Duckham, The British Economy Since1945 (Oxford: Clarendon Press).
Darrat, A.F. (1987), “Are Exports an Engine of Growth? Another Look at the Evidence”, Applied Economics, 19(2), 1153–65.
Davidson, P. (1990–91), “A Post Keynesian Positive Contribution to ‘Theory’”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 13(2) winter, 298–303.
Davidson, P. (2006), “Keynes, Post Keynesian Analysis, and the Open Economies of the Twenty-First Century” in P. Arestis, J.S.L. McCombie, and R.W. Vickerman (eds), Growth and Economic Development: Essays in Honour of A.P. Thirlwall (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar).
Edwards, E. (1993), “Openness, Trade Liberalization, and Growth in Developing Countries”, Journal of Economic Literature, 31, September, 1358–93.
Eltis, W. (1979), “Comment” on Singh, A., “North Sea Oil and the Reconstruction of UK Industry” in F.T. Blackaby (ed.) De-industrialisation (London: Heinemann).
Felipe, J. (2010) Inclusive Growth, Full Employment, and Structural Change: Implications and Policies for Developing Asia (London: Anthem Press, 2nd edn).
Goldstein, M., and M.S. Khan (1978), “The Supply and Demand for Exports: A Simultaneous Approach,” Review of Economics and Statistics, 60(2), 275–86.
Gouvea, R.R., and G.T. Lima (2010), “Structural Change, Balance of Payments Constraint and Economic Growth: Evidence from the Multisectoral Thirlwall’s Law”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 3391, 169–204.
Harrod, R.F. (1933) International Economics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Harrod, R.F. (1939), “An Essay in Dynamic Theory”, Economic Journal, 49(193), 14–33.
Hausmann, R., J. Hwang, and D. Rodrik (2007) “What You Export Matters”, Journal of Economic Growth, 12(1), 1–25.
Havrylyshyn, O. (1990), “Penetrating the Fallacy of Export Composition” in H. Singer, N. Hatti, and T. Tandon, (eds) North-South Trade in Manufactures (Delhi: Indus Publishing Co.).
Hidalgo, C.A., B. Klinger, A-L. Barabasi, and R. Hausmann (2007), “The Product Space Conditions the Development of Nations”, Science, 317 (July), 482–87.
Houthakker, H.S., and S.P. Magee (1969), “Income and Price Elasticities in World Trade”, Review of Economics and Statistics, 51(2), 111–25.
Kaldor, N. (1957), “A Model of Economic Growth”, Economic Journal, 67 (268), 591–624.
Kindleberger, C.P. (1967) Europe’s Postwar Growth: The Role of Labor Supply (Cambridge: Harvard University Press).
Krugman, P. (1989), “Differences in Income Elasticities and Trends in Real Exchange Rates”, European Economic Review, 33(5), 1001–46.
Lamfalussy, A. (1961) Investment and Growth in Mature Economies (London: Macmillan).
León-Ledesma, M.A., and A.P. Thirlwall (2002), “The Endogeneity of the Natural Rate of Growth,” Cambridge Journal of Economics, 26(24), 441–59.
McCombie, J.S.L. (1980) “On the Quantitative Importance of Kaldor’s Laws”, Bulletin of Economic Research, 32(2), 102–12.
McCombie, J.S.L. (1981) “Are International Growth Rates Constrained by the Balance of Payments? A Comment on Professor Thirlwall”, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review, 139, 455–58.
McCombie, J.S.L. (1985) “Economic Growth, the Harrod Foreign Trade Multiplier and the Hicks Super-multiplier,” Applied Economics, 17(1), 55–72, February (reprinted in McCombie and Thirlwall, 2004).
McCombie, J.S.L. (1989) “‘Thirlwall’s Law’ and Balance of Payments Constrained Growth — A Comment on the Debate”, Applied Economics, 21(5), 611–29.
McCombie, J.S.L. (1992) “‘Thirlwall’s Law’ and Balance of Payments-of-Constrained Growth: More on the on the Debate”, Applied Economics, 24(5), 493–512.
McCombie, J.S.L. (1993) “Economic Growth, Trade Inter-linkages and the Balance-of-Payments Constraint”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 15(4), 471–505 (reprinted in McCombie and Thirlwall, 2004).
McCombie, J.S.L., and A.P. Thirlwall (1994) Economic Growth and the Balance-of-Payments Constraint (Basingstoke: Macmillan).
McCombie, J.S.L., and A.P. Thirlwall (2004) Essays on Balance of Payments Constrained Growth. Theory and Evidence (London: Routledge).
McCombie, J.S.L., M. Pugno, and B. Soro (eds) (2002) Productivity Growth and Economic Performance: Essays on Verdoorn’s Law, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
McGregor, P.G., and J.K. Swales (1985) “Professor Thirlwall and Balance of Payments Constrained Growth”, Applied Economics, 17(1), 17–32.
McGregor, P.G., and J.K. Swales (1986) “Balance of Payments Constrained Growth: A Rejoinder”, Applied Economics, 18(12), 1265–74.
McGregor, P.G., and J.K. Swales (1991) “Thirlwall’s Law and Balance of Payments Constrained Growth: Further Comment on the Debate”, Applied Economics, 23(1), 9–20.
Marin, D. (1992) “Is the Export-Led Growth Hypothesis Valid for Industrialized Countries?” Review of Economics and Statistics, 74(4), 678–88.
Mayer, J. (2002) “The Fallacy of Composition: A Review of the Literature,” World Economy, Blackwell, 25(6), 875–94.
Myrdal, G. (1957) Economic Theory and Underdeveloped Regions (London: Duckworth).
Nell, K. (2003) “A Generalized Version of the Balance-of-Payments Growth Model: An Application to Neighbouring Regions”, International Review of Applied Economics, 17(3), July, 249–67 (reprinted in McCombie and Thirlwall, 2004).
Pacheco-López, P., and A.P. Thirlwall (2007) “Trade Liberalisation and the Trade-Off Between Growth and the Balance of Payments in Latin America”, International Review of Applied Economics, 21(4), 469–90.
Palley, T.I. (2002) “Pitfalls in the Theory of Growth: An Application to the Balance-of-Payments-Constrained Growth Model” in M. Setterfield (ed.) The Economics of Demand-led Growth (Cheltenham, Edward Elgar) 115–25.
Palley, T.I. (2003) “Export -Led Growth: Evidence of Developing Country Crowding-out” in P. Arestis, M. Baddeley, and J. S. L. McCombie (eds) Economic Integration, Regionalism and Globalization (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar).
Pasinetti, L.L. (1993) Structural Economic Dynamics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Setterfield, M. (2006) “Thirlwall’s Law and Palley’s pitfalls: A Reconsideration” in P. Arestis, J.S.L. McCombie, and R. Vickerman (eds) Growth and Economic Development: Essays in Honour of A.P. Thirlwall (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar).
Setterfield, M. (2011) “The Remarkable Durability of Thirlwall Law”, keynote address given at the workshop on Thirlwall’s Law and balance of payments constrained growth, Faculty of Economics, University of Coimbra, Portugal, 24–25 June 2011 (also PSL Quarterly Review, this volume).
Shirazi, N.S., T.A.A. Manap (2004) “Exports and Economic Growth Nexus: The Case of Pakistan”, Pakistan Development Review, 43(4), 563–81.
Thirlwall, A.P. (1979) “The Balance of Payments Constraint as an Explanation of International Growth Rate Differences”, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review, 128(791), March, 45–53 (reprinted in McCombie and Thirlwall, 2004).
Thirlwall, A.P. (1981) “Balance of Payments Constrained Growth: A Reply to Mr. McCombie”, 139, 458–9, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review (also in Moneta e Credito, December 1981).
Thirlwall, A.P. (1986) Balance of Payments Constrained Growth: A Reply to McGregor and Swales”, Applied Economics, 18(12), 1259–63.
Thirlwall, A.P. (1991) “Professor Krugman’s 45-Degree Rule”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 14(1), 23–8.
Thirlwall, A.P. (2001) “The Relationship between the Warranted Growth Rate, the Natural Rate, and the Balance of Payments Equilibrium Growth Rate”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 24(1), 81–8.
Thirlwall, A.P. (2011) “Balance-of-payments Constrained Growth Models: History and Overview”, PSL Quarterly Review, 64, 307–51.
Thirlwall, A.P., and R. Dixon (1979) “A Model of Export-Led Growth with a Bal-ance of Payments Constraint”, in J. Bowers (ed.) Inflation, Development and Integration, Essays in Honour of A.J. Brown (Leeds: Leeds University Press).
Thirlwall, A.P. and Hughes, J.J (1979), “Imports and Labour Market Bottlenecks: A Disaggregated Study for the U.K.”, Applied Economics, 11(1), 77–94.
Thirlwall, A.P., and N. Hussain (1982) “The Balance of Payments Constraint, Capital Flows and Growth Rate Differences Between Developing Countries”, Oxford Economic Papers, 34(3), 498–510.
Tyler, W.G. (1981) “Growth and Export Expansion in Developing Countries: Some Empirical Evidence”, Journal of Development Economics, 9(1), 121–30.
Wade, R. (1990) Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization (Princeton: Princeton University Press).
White, H., and A.P. Thirlwall (1974) “U.S. Merchandise Imports and the Dispersion of Demand”, Applied Economics, 6(4), 275–92.
Williamson, J. (1984) “Is There an External Constraint”, National Institute Economic Review, 109, (August), 73–277.
World Bank (1987) Barriers to Adjustment and Growth in the World Economy; Industrialization and Foreign Trade (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 2012 John S.L. McCombie
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
McCombie, J.S.L. (2012). Criticisms and Defences of the Balance of Payments Constrained Growth Model: Some Old, Some New. In: Soukiazis, E., Cerqueira, P.A. (eds) Models of Balance of Payments Constrained Growth. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137023957_3
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137023957_3
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-1-349-43840-2
Online ISBN: 978-1-137-02395-7
eBook Packages: Palgrave Economics & Finance CollectionEconomics and Finance (R0)