Retraction Note: Property evaluations of coir fibres for use as reinforcement in composites

The authors have retracted this article. After publication, the authors found that they did not have permission to publish the data used in the article.


Introduction
One of the key attractions in the composites industries is the possibility of improving the properties of the composites through fibre reinforcement. Engineers have kept on searching for materials capable of meeting certain designs and specific product requirements. The non-renewable nature of fossil resources and the environmental hazards associated with their extractions has led to awareness of potential uses of agricultural resources. Though natural fibres possess certain disadvantages such as high moisture ingress, high porosity and are susceptible to thermal degradation [1][2][3] yet they are making inroads into the composites industries. Some of the issues with natural fibres can be addressed by appropriate fibre treatments [4][5][6][7][8][9]. Natural fibres are cost effective, environmentally-friendly, sustainable and are much lighter than glass and most synthetic fibres and therefore offer significant weight savings and fuel efficiency when compared with synthetic fibres [10][11][12]. The physical and chemical properties of coir fibre shown in Table 1, shows that coir is a natural lignocellulosic fibre. The global average annual production of coir stood at 998.3 × 10 3 tonnes between 2012 and 2017, an increase of 0.17% was observed in 2019 leading to 10,00,000 tonnes being produced with Sri Lanka being the third largest producer of coir fibre [13,14]. Coir is one of the cheapest natural fibres [13] available for technical purposes. The tensile properties, surface treatments and chemical composition of coir fibre have been investigated however; the porosity and water absorption of coir at elevated temperature have been scarcely investigated. This is necessary for increased utilization of the fibre for technical purposes. The properties of coir fibres have been reported to be affected by the origin of the fibre. This project is therefore centred on the evaluation of several properties of coir fibres of specific origin for use as reinforcement in composites. The properties evaluated include: tensile properties at different gauge lengths, porosity at specified diameters. TGA, water absorption and diffusion coefficients at elevated temperatures were investigated. Optical and scanning electron microscopy of these fibres were conducted to analyse their failure modes and to observe the trend in changes in the mechanical properties.

Coir fibres
The retted, matured brown coir fibres were supplied by Hayleys Fibre Plc, Sri Lanka in three-tie bundles of non-uniform lengths of 100-320 mm. The fibres were fumigated prior to dispatch to the UK. The coir fibres were cleaned using vacuum pump to remove the debris. They were washed five times using water at a temperature of 50 °C to remove dirt particles. The fibres were dried in the aircirculating oven for 2 h at 80 °C. The dried samples were stored in the desiccator at a temperature of 50 °C and humidity of 50% until the desired time.

Tensile tests on single coir fibres
The coir fibre samples for tensile tests were selected manually after careful visual inspection to ensure that the surfaces of the fibres were free of debris from the defiberising procedure. The presence of residual debris and defiberising procedures can affect the tensile properties. The gauge lengths for the tensile tests were taken from the middle of the selected fibres. The diameters measured using optical microscopy was taken at three points along this gauge length. For proper alignment and dimensional accuracy, coir fibre was end-tabbed on a graph paper (Fig. 1). Tensile tests were carried out on single coir fibres of average diameter 0.250 mm and of gauge lengths of 20, 60 and 100 mm (the coir lengths were arbitrarily chosen for comparison purposes with respect to ASTMD3822-07) using Instron universal testing machine model 5566 with load cell of 100 N and at a cross-head displacement rate of 1 mm/minute in accordance with ASTM D3822-07. In order to get meaningful results, a total of 30 fibres were tested for each gauge length. The relative humidity and temperature of the laboratory as at the time of the experiment were 45% and 21 °C respectively.

Scanning electron microscopy (SEM)
Coir fibre samples were sputter-coated with gold to render them conductive for SEM. The morphological characterizations of the fibres were carried out using Table  top scanning electron microscopy model TM 3030. Zeiss Axioskop-2 optical microscope was used to obtain good quality images of polished samples of coir fibre for porosity measurement. At this point, ImageJ software was introduced and used to determine the degree of porosity of coir fibres.

Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA)
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) is a standard method used to study the overall thermal stability of natural fibers. Usually, the thermal degradation of natural fiber composites with increasing the temperature is studied along with numerical calculation of quality degradation. Raise in temperature, results in the weight of the fiber to drop slowly and at the point of glass transition the weight drops sharply over a narrow range and finally turns back to zero slopes as the reactant is exhausted. The degradation process in TGA can be presented in the curve, which is dependent on the kinetic parameters of the pyrolysis such as frequency factor, reaction order, and activation energy. The value obtained in the curve depends on factors like sample mass, sample shape, atmosphere, flow rate, heating rate, and the mathematical treatment applied. Major transition (α 2 peak) at about 120 °C for brown coir and at about 130 °C for white coir which is most likely the lignin glass transition [15]. The thermal properties of coir fibres were studied using Netzsch instrument for thermogravimetry under Argon atmosphere. The sample weight for each test was 10 ± 2 mg. The temperature range was between 25 °C and 1000 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C/minute.

Water absorption of coir fibres
Coir fibres were cut to tensile lengths of 60 mm. Each fibre was placed in a glass vial. Each vial with known mass of pre-dried coir fibres was filled with distilled water and the immersion time of the fibre was noted. The vials were placed in a 500 ml beaker and the beaker filled with distilled water. This assembly was placed in a temperature-regulated water bath that was set at 40 °C. Each vial was taken out and fibre was removed from the water-filled glass vial and dried with lint-free tissue. The fibre was weighed and returned to the vial filled with distilled water and placed in the glass beaker and returned to the water bath.
The weight of the individual fibres was measured every 60 min until equilibrium was reached and the measurement frequency was every day. These experiments were repeated at 60 and 80 °C.

Density measurement
The density measurement of coir fibres was carried out using helium gas Pycnometer model: Micromeritics AccuPyc II 1340 with instrument schematics ( Fig. 2a and b) in accordance with ASTM B923-10. The sample mass was 0.09 g. The repeat option was 5 purges and 5 cycles. Pycnometer measures the volume of the sample using gas displacement and Boyle's law volume-pressure relationship (PV = K). The density was calculated from the measured volume and mass. The instrument schematic is as shown in Fig. 2.

Tensile properties of coir fibres
The tensile properties of the coir fibres were studied as a function of the gauge lengths. The tensile strength of thirty individual coir fibres per batch at gauge lengths of 20, 60 and 100 mm were determined.  [19][20][21][22]. As stated previously, the coir fibre samples were selected manually after careful visual inspection to ensure that the surface of the fibres were free of debris from the de-fiberising procedure. The presence of residual debris and defiberising procedures can affect the tensile properties. Furthermore, comparing tensile data of natural fibres from different labs is notoriously difficult as a result of the variability in the fibre distribution. The tensile strength obtained experimentally can also be influenced by the alignment of the sample in the grips of the tensile test machine. Fibre slippage from within the end-tabbed region can also have a bearing on the data obtained. Previous authors have attributed the variations in the tensile data on differences in the fibre diameter, defect density, origin of the fibre, growing conditions, extraction method or level of maturity of the coir fibres.

Weibull distribution of coir fibres at gauge lengths of 20, 40 and 60 mm
The two-parameter Weibull equation was used to characterize the tensile strength results of the fibres. The Weibull parameters of coir fibres at the three specified gauge lengths are given in Table 3 and the Weibull plot shown in Fig. 3. The Weibull modulus for the selected gauge lengths is 3 to the nearest whole number. The results of the Weibull modulus are in accordance with the Weibull modulus for natural fibres (1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6). This trend has been observed by other authors [23][24][25]. However, the tensile properties of sisal fibres were evaluated for varying gauge lengths but at a constant strain rate, no effect on the tensile strength was observed rather a 35% decrease in Weibull modulus was observed with increase in gauge length [26]. Bamboo fibre

Morphological characterization of coir fibre
The micrographs of coir fibre surface shows globular protrusions otherwise known as tylosis ( Fig. 4a and b). The globular protrusions appear to be in an ordered form. A pit-like structures can be seen at intervals and in-between the tyloses making the surface of the fibre rough. These observations have also been made by other researchers on coir fibre [1,27]. The micrograph of the transverse section of coir fibres shows that coir fibre consists of numerous lumens and a lacuna usually located at the centre making the fibre highly porous (Fig. 5). Similar observations have been made by other researchers on coir fibre [17,29]. The size, shape and position of the lacuna differ even in fibres of the same origin and within the same species.
The SEM micrographs of the fractured surfaces of the fibres at the specified gauge lengths (Fig. 6) shows failure of the fibers to be uneven and irregular. Defects were observed on the failed surfaces. Elongation of the helical structures after brittle failure of the fibres was observed. Pull out of the cellulose fibril is evident on the failed surfaces. This is more noticeable at 100 mm gauge length hence influencing the tensile strength of the fibres. Similar observations have been made by several authors on coir fibre [22,30].

Optical microscopy of coir fibre for the determination of the porosity of the fibre
The optical micrograph of coir fibre and the ImageJ detection of the pores shows that coir fibres are highly porous ( Fig. 7a and b). The results of the analysed fibres are given in Table 4. The diameters of the tested fibres determined from the cross-sectional area of the fibre with the assumption that the cross-sectional area of the fibre is that of a circle were in the range of 0.162-0.313 mm. The results obtained showed that the porosity of these coir fibres is in the range of 32.9-48.1%. Porosity range of 21.1-46.3%  have been obtained [31,32]. The slight difference in the porosity can be attributed to the fibre origin and processing conditions. The average pore count was found to be in the range of 130-475. The average cell diameter ranges from 6.8 to 13.7 µm. The porosity of coir fibre increases as the diameter increases (Fig. 8). Some of the coir samples may show deviations to this as a likely result of defects. The number of pores as well as the pore size does not depend on the fibre diameter but varies from fibre to fibre (Fig. 9). The average cell diameter is independent of the fibre size. Table 5 shows the results of the density measurements of coir fibre. The average density of the fibres measured using gas pycnometer was found to be 1438 ± 4.72 kg/m 3 . The density of Indian coir fiber using specific gravity bottle and toluene was 1150 kg/m 3 [33]. This was about 25% higher than the density of Thailand coir fibre measured using Oil Pycnometer [34]. The density of Philippine coir fibre measured by compounding in polypropylene was 1320 kg/m 3 [35]. These variations can be attributed to several factors such as the method used in measuring the density, the presence of debris or residual components on the fibre, fibre specie, the level of maturity of the fibre.

Thermal properties of coir fibre
The results of the thermogravimetric analysis of coir fibres obtained in argon atmosphere shows the decomposition profile of the fibre (Fig. 10). The decomposition occured in three stages of weight loss: (1) 0-200 °C; this was due to evaporation of water (2) 200-360 °C; this was attributed to the degradation of hemicellulose and (3) above 360; this has been linked to the thermal degradation of cellulose [17,36,37] . 8 Relationship between the diameter and the porosity of coir fibre Fig. 9 Relationship between the coir fibre diameter and the pore size/count  [30,38]. These differences in the weight loss can be attributed to the differences in the heating atmosphere, mass of fibre, flow rate and the heating rate employed as well as the origin and processing conditions of the fibres. Figure 11 shows the percentage weight gain as a result of water absorbed by coir fibre samples at the given temperatures as a function of the square root of time. The water absorption curves are similar to those obtained on bowstring hemp, okra and bethel nut fibres [39], sisal and jute [40] as well as Napier grass [41]. The 2 stage absorption characteristic of natural fibre is displayed in the graph. The first stage was a rapid linear uptake resulting to more than 8% weight gain in the fibre. This rapid linear uptake is proportional to the square root of time. The initial rapid linear response has been attributed t the presence of hydroxyl group and the capillary action with respect to Fick's law of diffusion [39]. The percentage weight loss after the first 5 min was found to be 5.6, 6.4, 7.4, and 7.6% at 40, 50, 60 and 80 °C respectively. The weight gain increases non-uniformly with increase in the temperature. The second stage of weight gain was much slower than the first stage until full saturation was achieved. The second stage has been attributed to Non-Fickian diffusion. The diffusion coefficient at temperatures of 40, 50, 60 and 80 °C are shown in Table 6. The diffusion coefficient was found to increase with increase in temperature.

Water absorption of coir fibres
Water absorption was calculated using the following equation: M d = constant mass (g) of dry coir fibre sample, M w = mass (g) of wet coir fibre sample after time t.
The kinetics of absorption of water by fibre at specified temperature is given as Mm = maximum absorbed water content at equilibrium, h = initial diameter of the sample, D = diffusion coefficient, n = summation index.
From the slope of the linear portion of weight gain curve versus the square root of time, the diffusion coefficient D of the coir fibre samples for the specified temperatures was determined using:

Fig. 10
Thermal analysis of coir fibre in argon atmosphere

Conclusion
The density of coir fibres of Sri Lanka was found to be 1438 kg/m 3 . At an average diameter of 0.250 mm, the tensile strength and stiffness of the fibres decreased by 51 and 68% respectively as the gauge length increased from 20 to 100 mm. The elongation at break increased from 33.3 to 62.5% as the gauge length increased from 20 to 100 mm. No significant difference was observed in the Weibull shape parameter at all the gauge lengths. The porosity of the fibres is in the range of 32.9-48.1% with an average pore count of 130 to 475. These were within the studied diameter range of 0.162-0.313 mm. The porosity of coir fibres increased as the diameter increased. Thermal analysis of coir fibres under argon atmosphere revealed weight losses of 9.47 and 42.47% at peaks of onset and endset degradation temperatures of 278.8 and 343.1 °C respectively. Water aborption of the fibres increased from 9.4 to 12.1% as the temperature increased from 40 to 80 °C. The diffusion coefficients of the fibre increased as the temperature increased.
The use of coir fibre as reinforcement in composites can be optimised with the above information on the density, water absorption at elevated temperatures, length and diameter of the fibre as well as the porosity of the fibre.

Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest The authors declare that they have no known competing interests that could potentially influence or bias the submitted work.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creat iveco mmons .org/licen ses/by/4.0/.