Retreatability analysis of the Musina copper mine tailings in South Africa: an exploratory study

In recent times, the potential beneficial uses of abandoned mine sites have been recognised and acted upon through the retreatment of tailings in order to win minerals of interest still available in economically viable concentrations. The most notable benefit (although not usually factored in financially) is that, once the tailings have been removed, the land has a greater potential to be developed further. The main aim of this study was to investigate the contents of copper and potentially harmful elements in the tailings of the Musina mine, an abandoned Cu mine in the northern Limpopo Province, in order to assess environmental hazards and to provide a first estimate of the feasibility of future economic rehabilitation. The concept of reclaiming was here seen in a broad way and ranged from the reworking of tailings or other residues to residential and/or recreational use. To quantify the potential economic importance and impacts of the metal content of the tailings, geochemical analysis of samples from auger holes and resource modelling were employed. Neutral to slightly basic pH values and very low concentrations of arsenic and lead showed that acid drainage and toxic groundwater contamination (apart from Cu itself) would not be a concern. Three-dimensional (3D) and two-dimensional (2D) models were applied to estimate the resource potential of the tailings dump. The models revealed that residual Cu in the Musina mine tailings is currently at 8555 tonnes. Accordingly, going forward, we recommend a formalised geometallurgical study to assess the economic feasibility of extracting Cu, with a view to reworking the copper tailings dump. It is very important that this tailings dump be mined in future, in order to extract all Cu and ensure that the sterilised land (up to 95 ha) can be used for other purposes.


Introduction
Mine closure is normally the last stage of production, especially when production costs overshoot mineral gains [17], the mine runs out of resources and/or commodity prices drop [36]. Today, mine closure is defined as a budgeted, orderly, safe and environmentally sound conversion of an operating mine to a closed state [26]. However, derelict and ownerless mines exist globally. These are mines whose owners or mining or lease holders have abandoned them without ensuring that environmental impacts are mitigated [12]. The most significant of these impacts relates to communities in the proximity, and the risks include cavities, sinkholes and open shafts, illegal mining, contamination of soils and ground water [30], and risks related to the minerals or chemical substances in the host rock, ore and residue deposits [27]. The increase in copper prices in the last decade [11] has led to the realisation of retreating of tailings. Amerigo Resources in Chile is processing tailings from EL Teniente Mine [39]; Woodlawn Mine in Australia managed by TriAusMin is retreating 10 million tonnes of tailings from 3 abandoned tailings dumps [38]. In most of these operations, extraction of copper (> 90%) was achieved by bioleaching, using microbial consortium, where elemental sulphur was added to the tailings and the pH of leach liquors allowed to fall to ∼pH 1, at which point anaerobic conditions were imposed [6], Ahmadi et al. [2]. The results suggested that bio-processing these waste materials would have economic as well as environmental benefits [5].
In this context, we have studied the tailings of the Musina copper mine in Musina town (Fig. 1), northern Limpopo Province. It is understood that industrial-scale copper mining started here in 1914 and the mine was closed in 1992. No proper rehabilitation was carried out as part of its decommissioning process. The aims of this study are first to assess the environmental hazards associated with the tailings and second, to explore the economic potential of reclaiming Cu. To achieve this, we have conducted systematic sampling by auger, geochemical analyses, mineralogy and resource modelling.

Regional geology
The Musina mine is situated in the central zone of the Limpopo mobile belt (Supplementary Fig. S1) which extends from Botswana to Mozambique, straddling the Limpopo-Zimbabwe boundary [3]. The highly deformed Limpopo belt (one of the oldest orogenic belts known) is more than 700 km long and 250 km wide and is situated between the Archean Zimbabwe craton in the north and the Kaapvaal craton in the south [28,33].
The Limpopo metamorphic complex records two orogenic events, one at around 2.65 Ga and another at 2.0 Ga [25], both of which involved high-grade metamorphism. The complex consists of three zones: the Northern marginal, Central and Southern marginal zone. In the marginal zones, structural trends are ENE-WSW, while the Central zone is characterised by N-S trending structures [10]. Current isotope dating indicates that an important deformational event in the central zone, equated by many workers with the Limpopo orogeny, occurred at 2.0 Ga [18,19,24]. However, the large volume of crustally derived granitoids found in the Central Zone belongs to the older, 2.65 Ga episode [25]. The ~ Ga date reflects extensive strike-slip as well as thrust-sense shearing within the Limpopo belt when substantial relocation of the central zone occurred in a transgressive orogeny [19,34].

Local geology
Five major copper deposits are known in the Musina area ( Supplementary Fig. S2). All are aligned along the Musina Fault line, and they are situated where the line intersects the contact between metaquartzite (and other paragneisses) and granitic gneiss. The mineralisations appear to have been localised in fold structures, faults and fractures at the lithological contacts, due to competency contrasts. The Musina Fault transects all fabrics and structures associated with the 2.0 Ga event, and thus, it (and the orebodies) must be younger than this, although no reliable age has been determined. The ore bodies appear hydrothermal and fall into four categories [3]: Breccia pipes, hydrothermal replacement bodies, open fissure mineralisation and transitions between the three above. The Musina and Harper mines differ from the other three in that the granitic host rock component is Singelele Gneiss, a homogeneous pink variety of the anatectic granitic gneisses in the area.

Drilling and sampling materials
Nominal 500 m by 500 m drill patterns were laid out over the Musina mine tailings dump, and a total of eight exploratory auger boreholes were drilled to a depth of 5 m, from 31 October 2014 to 5 January 2015, using a traditional hand auger drill. Material from each successive metre was pooled into a sample, which resulted in a total of 40 samples from the tailings. Spillage from the tailings at four localities was also sampled as surface samples, yielding five samples ( Supplementary Fig. S3).

Sample analysis
The main analytical work was done at the University of Johannesburg using inductively coupled plasma (ICP) optical emission spectrometry (OES) as part of a multi-element analysis on sample leaches. Cross-checks were carried out by X-ray fluorescence (XRF) on pressed powders by the Johannesburg laboratory of Sociéte Générale de Surveillance (SGS). Pre-treatment methods for the ICP-OES analyses were aligned to comply with the requirements for the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 11464 of 1994.

Aqua regia extractant determinations
The aqua regia extraction procedure followed the ISO 11466 [22] specifications of 1995. Weighed aliquots (approximately 3.0 g) of the tailings samples were placed in 200-ml Erlenmeyer flasks, after which 20 ml of aqua regia was added. The flasks were sealed with parafilm and stored overnight at room temperature to allow for slow oxidation of organic matter in the tailings, followed by boiling under reflux for 2 h using a hot plate (Stuart CB300) set at a temperature of 125 ºC.
The extract was allowed to cool and then passed through filter paper into a funnel, after which the flask was rinsed and the insoluble residue washed onto the filter paper. The filtered solution was evaporated and the remaining solid was moistened with about 5 ml of water, to which was added, while mixing, 5 ml of concentrated nitric acid, drop by drop where necessary, to reduce foaming. The mixture was then shaken vigorously to ensure total dissolution. The solutions were diluted to 100 g of 1 molar nitric acid in a plastic bottle and stored. For analysis of elements by ICP OES, 1 ml of this stored solution was diluted further to 10 ml of 4% nitric acid.

Determination of tailings pH
As per ISO 10390 [20], representative samples weighing 10.0 g (weighed using a Precisa XB 620 M Top Loading Balance) of the tailings (fraction < 2 mm) were placed into 200-ml Erlenmeyer flasks with 25 ml volume of deionised water (pH-H 2 O). This mixture was later shaken vigorously for 5 min, by hand, followed by a waiting period of about 48 h at room temperature prior to determinations. An Erlenmeyer flask was sealed with parafilm and left overnight to allow for normal calibration. Because of the susceptibility of pH-meter probes to particulate slurries, comprehensive and user-friendly pH (pH-Fix 0-14) colour indicator strips (also called dip in, read off ) were used for the pH measurements. The test strips were dipped into the sample suspension until there were no longer changes in colour prior to taking readings. This ensured total calibration of the test kit.

X-ray diffraction and X-ray fluorescence
XRD and XRF analyses were conducted at the Council for Geoscience to determine mineralogical and elemental composition, respectively. Tailings samples were dried, sieved (< 200 mesh) and ground in an agate mortar for XRD analysis. A representative sample of the tailings material was crushed and milled to a fine powder of around 20 µm in grain size. A sub-sample was pressed into a shallow plastic sample holder against a rough filter paper to ensure random orientation.
XRD measurements were performed on a BRUKER D8 ADVANCE instrument with a 2.2-kW Cu long fine focus tube (Cu Kα, λ = 1.54060) and 90 position sample changer. The system was equipped with a Lynx Eye detector with 3.7º active area. Samples were scanned from 2 to 70° 2θ at a speed of 0.02° 2θ steps size/0.5 s and generator settings of 40 kV and 40 mA. Phase identification was based on BRUKER DIFFRAC Plus-EVA evaluation programme. Routinely, phase concentrations are determined as semi-quantitative estimates (with accuracy ± 5%) using the reference intensity ratio (RIR) method and relative peak heights/areas proportions [4]. Mineral composition of the tailings samples was determined by the external standard method of Chung [7]. Pellets for XRF major elements analysis were prepared as follows: the milled sample (< 75 µm fraction) was roasted at 1000 ºC for at least 3 h to oxidise Fe2 + and sulphur and determine the loss on ignition (LOI). Glass discs were prepared by fusing 1 g roasted sample and 10 g flux consisting of 49.5% Li2B4O7, 49.5% LiBO2 and 0.50% LiI at 1150 ºC.

Methods for 3-dimensional block modelling and resource estimation
In order to enable data visualisation and evaluation of resources, a 3D block model was created for the area covered by the tailings dump. These models include all the data and interpret the tailings dump volume. A block model for the grade estimation was generated using the modelled surfaces for the topography of the tailings dump and filling the volume between the two surfaces. Vulcan™ 3D software version 9.1.7 was used to model dump solids and surfaces, followed by block model estimation. Inverse distance squared (IDW) and ordinary Kriging (OK) methods were trialed to obtain reserve estimates. An Excel database file format containing drill hole and sampling information was imported into a database in Vulcan using a database design file (dhd.dsf). The data validation process in Vulcan software forms part of quality assurance and quality control (QAQC) and is suitable for undertaking tailings dumps resource estimation. The accuracy and provenance of the data are of a satisfactory standard. Eight drill holes were used for the Musina mine. The dataset was validated for unique collar location and overlapping intervals. No major errors were identified on either dataset. The data included collar coordinates in the Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM), World Geodetic System (WGS84) system, downhole assays and downhole surveys.

pH and mineralogy of tailings
pH values obtained from the entire study area showed a neutral to weakly basic reaction throughout (7.0-9). Variations in pH levels with depth were insignificant; all tailings were alkaline. This can probably be ascribed to the weathering of plagioclase feldspar, which is a constituent in the host rock of the mineralisation [3], and occurs at 6-8% in the tailings, and to the low content or even absence of pyrite (not detected by our XRD analysis). The alkaline reaction of the tailings of the Musina mine means that no, or little, mobilisation of toxic and other metal ions is likely to take place. Instead, adsorption will dominate.
Due to erosion, tonnes of tailings material spill from the Musina mine tailings into the nearby river and surrounding environment every year in the rainy season. Spillage samples, like the tailings themselves, have neutral to slightly alkaline pH values (7.5-8). This river is an important water source for communities living downstream [32], and it is thus important to note that this pH value signals no high level of metal contamination risk.
Tailings samples analysed from the Musina mine (Table 1) comprise amphibole, quartz and clinochlore (a variety of chlorite) as the most abundant minerals. No dolomite, talc, ilmenite or serpentine was detected, but gypsum and smectite occurred as secondary minerals. The primary ore is chalcopyrite, with quartz and albite gangue [40]. The presence of plagioclase and abundant quartz in the tailings is in accord with this. Amphibole is known to occur in the Singelele gneiss, which forms most of the country rock of the mineralisation. Chlorite is the low-grade metamorphic or hydrothermal alteration product of most of the mafic minerals including probably biotite. When chloritisation occurs, alkali minerals are usually released which means some neutralising capacity arises from that process. Although sulphides are seen in some rock samples, they were not detected in the XRD analysis and therefore are minor. Also, they are already oxidised as seen from the presence of malachite. Aluminosilicate minerals, such as plagioclase, can also neutralise acid upon weathering, although they are not as reactive as carbonate minerals [35]. In this process, Na and Ca are dissolved out of plagioclase while Al and Si produce clay minerals. Gypsum occurs as a secondary mineral, probably formed due to the alteration of plagioclase during the oxidation of sulphides in the tailings.

Element concentrations and correlations
Concentrations of the elements analysed for (Al, As, Au, Ca, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mg, Mn, Ni, P, Pb and Zn) are listed in supplementary  [22] aqua regia procedure, that is, not hosted in silicates (except clay minerals and chlorite). Correlation patterns in geochemical datasets are useful to establish associations between elements, for instance, to elucidate in which phases they occur [8,23]. We have explored this aspect using Microsoft Excel. The raw Musina mine tailings data show many significant correlations (correlation coefficient r > 0.5, see Supplementary Table S2). These are, however, dominated by the variations in total content of extractable elements (those not hosted in insoluble silicate minerals) in the tailings and therefore not informative. This effect is eliminated by considering element amounts as percentages of the sum of element contents determined for each sample. These values are listed in supplementary Table S3. The correlation matrix (Table S4) shows few significant correlations (Fig. 2), which, however, can yield relevant information. Negative correlations (Fe vs. Ca, Mg vs. Fe, Cu vs. Al, Mn vs. Fe) indicate that the respective elements are hosted in different minerals of which one is (or both are) unevenly distributed, while positive correlations (Fe vs. Cu, Mn vs. Ca, Mn vs. Mg, P vs. Fe, Zn vs. Cu) suggest that these elements occur at least partly in the same mineral or mineral association.
The correlations can be used to address two main questions on the Musina mine tailings: first, the mode of occurrence of Cu, and second, those of Fe and Ca, related to the potential for acid mine drainage generation. A correlation of Fe with Cu (r = 0.358, but the slope is 1.9) indicates that Cu chiefly occurred as chalcopyrite (atomic Cu/ Fe ratio ≈ 1) associated with pyrite during deposition of the tailings. This correlation is superimposed on a large amount of Fe in excess to this association that is uncorrelated with Cu. Further, Fe and Mg are negatively correlated, which means that this excess Fe was not primarily hosted in minerals like chlorite or smectite (which would also be leached by aqua regia). The negative correlation of Mn with Fe (Fig. 2) further indicates that neither Fe, nor Mn exists primarily as Fe-Mn oxyhydroxide coatings on grains, which form under oxidising weathering. Taken together, this points to Fe being present mainly as pyrite.
The acid-generating potential of the tailings is therefore a concern. No S analyses were carried out in this study. For acid-base accounting (ABA) using the traditional Sobek method, 4.8 N hydrochloric acid and 2 N nitric acid are used sequentially to leach the sulphate and sulphide sulphur, respectively, and carbonate content is analysed by titration [15]. With an aqua regia leach as carried out in this study, analysing for S is uninformative, as it does not discriminate sulphide and sulphate-hosted S. However, the metal content correlations yield helpful information. First, the positive correlation of Mn with Ca coupled with the absence of any correlation between Mg and Ca indicates that extractable Ca mainly occurs as calcite. This is because Mn is highly compatible in calcite [14]. The additional correlation of Mn with Mg, which indicates its presence in clay minerals or chlorite, does not detract from this conclusion. Thus, the tailings contain some neutralisation potential. However, the average molar ratio of Ca:Fe is 0.3 and of (Ca + Mg): Fe is 1.06, and as 2 mol of divalent cations are required to neutralise the acid produced from 1 mol of pyrite [15], the Musina mine tailings would be expected to produce some acid drainage and it is puzzling that the measured pH values are neutral to slightly basic. A possible explanation is that pyrite is already partly oxidised in situ. An indication for this is given by the presence of gypsum and also the positive correlation of P with Fe (the only positive correlation found for P), which can only be explained by adsorption of phosphate from solution. As the surface of a pyrite grain is oxidised, an iron oxide hydroxide layer is formed. Phosphate ions are irreversibly adsorbed onto this, and even minimal amounts of adsorbed phosphate have been found to prevent further oxidation of the pyrite [16]. From a metallurgical perspective, this is interesting: the high levels of Fe (up to 6%), if wholly present as sulphides, could create problems in recovering Cu, as iron sulphides normally float with Cu, making Cu and Fe separation difficult and consequently rendering liberation an issue [1]. If Fe sulphides are coated with hydroxides and phosphate, this problem would be less severe.

Distribution of copper in the auger holes
While drilling, it was observed that there were a general homogeneity and lack of distinct layering in the tailings, and this is confirmed by the lack of systematic variation in Cu concentrations with depth in all boreholes, shown in Fig. 3.
In all borehole profiles, there is a generally sufficiently high concentration of Cu (mean 940 µg/g) to be extractable economically. Copper is what the previous operator was attempting to recover, and recovery was clearly poor in some instances. This can be observed at a depth of 3-4 m in boreholes KSM04, KSM05 and KSM08 (Fig. 3).
All profiles show different patterns of localised enrichment of Cu with depth. It is therefore highly unlikely that there is a single leaching mechanism operating whereby the metal would be transported downwards via seepage. Boreholes KSM04 and KSM05 were drilled in a waterlogged area of the tailings dump, where a consistent distribution with depth would be most likely to result if leaching was a major factor controlling concentration. However, their distribution patterns are irregular and not mutually similar. Thus, it is more likely that variations in Cu concentration are simply caused by fluctuations in the concentration of the ore mineral, or minerals, in suspension as the tailings dump was deposited over time. This is in accord with the above conclusion that Cu was deposited mainly as chalcopyrite.

Harmful elements assessment summary
The Musina mine tailings have no detectable concentrations of Pb, Cd or As (Supplementary Table S1). This finding, together with the neutral to weakly basic pH values, indicates a low environmental and health risk from these elements. The high concentrations of Cu are, however, a concern. While Cu is unlikely to present an important groundwater or surface (river) water contamination, its dispersion in dust in the dry season could pose a health risk to the large population living in the immediate vicinity. Ingestion of can lead to its damaging accumulation  Table S3 in liver, brain, kidney and cornea. A retreatment of the tailings dump to extract copper would have the added advantage of mitigating this risk.

Modelling and resource estimation
In order to evaluate the economic feasibility of reclaiming the Musina tailings dump, the Cu concentrations of the borehole samples were incorporated in a block model of the dump. This involved constructing a 3D model as described below.

Triangulation and block model design
Solid triangulations or wireframes were generated from the interpretation of drill hole sections. Line sections were digitised from each drill hole, snapping to the collar points for top surfaces and end-of-hole points for basement surfaces. The ideal method of modelling a tailings dump is through 3D laser scanning to output point cloud data points for high resolution.

Block model design
A block model was created for the entire tailings dump area and included the upper and bottom surfaces as constraints. The block model definition files were generated with the following parameters ( Table 2): Air blocks outside dump domains were deleted to optimise block model size and to ensure that no air blocks outside the dump wireframe were estimated. The block model was validated through visual inspections and creating diagonal sections across dump domains. For visualisation purposes, the tailings dump has been exaggerated 10 times in the Z dimension.
Block model validation shows that no air blocks exist outside dump domains. Multiple sections were created across the dump-modelled surfaces to identify any irregularities in the block model design. The block model of the Musina mine tailings dump (Supplementary Figs. S4-S7) is valid and accurate for the next stage of resource estimation.

Statistics (composite data)
Further statistical analysis was conducted for the tailings dump-analysing grade variables (Cu) in the databases because raw drilling databases cannot be used for grade estimation without statistics. As a result, a compositing method was used to break down assays into equal sampling lengths. As boreholes were sampled at 1-m intervals, a 1 m length compositing method was chosen to ensure that sample support remained constant [9]. Computational compositing is a method of breaking down a sample set according to how it was sampled in the field and in the laboratory during sample analysis [37]. The 1-m compositing method chosen resulted in a composite database with downhole mid-sample points that were used in grade estimation. Basic statistics were investigated for the composited databases (Table 3). All these samples were used in variography modelling. Table 3 presents general statistics analysed for all grade samples.
The histogram presented in Fig. 4 illustrates sample counts compared to sample grades. The purpose of presenting this histogram is to identify outliers (anomalous samples) that can be removed from the sample database It is important to note that the distribution of elements in the tailings is essentially attributed to how material has been dumped. This is not a natural deposit-geologically formed and in situ; instead, it is synthetic. Because of this, it is difficult to draw robust conclusions in this case. The observation (Sect. 4.3) that no significant enrichment or depletion in Cu with depth has been noted (nor for the other elements analysed in this study) indicates that the effects of the dumping season and fluctuating mining operations dominate.

Resource block model validation
Various methods were used to validate the estimate against the composite data, including visual validation and drift analysis, also known as swath plots (Supplementary Figs. S8-S10). Visual validation was performed by viewing cross sections and comparisons of the grade in the block model to the sample database. The correlation between the sample grades and the block model was good. Sufficient high-quality data were collected, increasing the confidence in the tailings dumps determination. The total tonnage of tailings material was used to deduce the total amount of elements. The total area of the tailings dumps at the Musina mine is 95 hectares (ha) (950,000 m 2 ) as given by the model and the volume calculated is 4,750,000 m 3 . The average density is 1.7 ton/m 3 . No geological losses were included in the mineral resource estimation as there should not be any structure (dyke or sill) present in the dump that will cause losses and a 100% reclamation of the dump is assumed. These values were calculated and tabulated in Microsoft Excel (Table 4).

Mineral tonnage estimations and resource reporting
The cut-off grade is the lowest grade material constituting all or part of an ore body that can be profitably treated. It is anticipated that the Musina dumps would be reclaimed by hydraulic mining, which is normally used for this type of deposit. This dump reclamation method makes the mining of selective areas or layers difficult, making a cut-off grade possibly irrelevant. A cut-off grade was, however, applied in the resource estimation as it is assumed that the tailings dump might be reclaimed using several options, depending upon the technology available at the time.
In order to check for potential biases in the block model grade estimate, the inverse distance block grades were compared to the OK estimation at a zero-cut-off grade. Ordinary kriging estimations provide more robust estimates of the mean grade of tailings because the sample data of drill holes are declustered. Figure 5 compares the exploitable grades (in ppm, i.e. g/tonne) and tonnages as a function of the cut-off grade, two grade models at a zero cut-off grade for two mineral resource categories.

Conclusions
Conclusions from this study relate to (a) economic potential through exploitability, (b) environmental and health risks and (c) potential for other purposes.
The results presented in this paper indicate the lack of full copper recovery by the operator, leading to a significant amount of Cu (up to 8 555 tonnes) still in the tailings, and can be concluded that the processing plants were not efficient during earlier days. A correlation between Fe and Cu suggests that the Cu was deposited in the tailings as an association of chalcopyrite and pyrite.
A geometallurgical study would help assess the economic feasibility of extracting Cu, with a view to reworking these tailings. Tailings, specifically those that are in close proximity to nearby communities, should be removed or remained in a wet process (unearthing them would release dust laden with possibly toxic elements). While up to 6% Fe may be present in the tailings as pyrite and insufficient neutralisation potential is present, the samples present neutral to slightly basic pH and we suggest that the formation of AMD is prevented by Fe oxyhydroxide coatings with adsorbed phosphate. As long as pH remains non-acidic, the metal levels in tailings solution and plants would remain below toxic levels. It is important that these tailings are rehabilitated in future, to ensure the sterilised land can be used for other purposes. Mining the tailings for copper could offer a self-funding option that has the potential to complete proper rehabilitation.
The main risk is associated with the possible inhalation or ingestion of dust, and any remediation of the tailings dumps and rock dumps should include stabilising the surface (e.g. by using vegetation). As it stands, short-term solutions include rehabilitating tailings and rock dumps with vegetation cover in order to prevent loose soil from being blown or washed away by wind and water, and relocating communities living in affected areas.
Author's contributions Material in this article is from the first author PhD thesis and the co-author contributed equally to this article as a supervisor.
Funding The analytical work was funded jointly by the Geological Society of South Africa Research Education and Investment Fund (GSSA REI) and the DST-NRF Centre of Excellence for Integrated Mineral and Energy Resource Analysis (CIMERA).

Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest The authors declare that no competing interests exist. Availability of data and materials We confirm data were created during the research and they are available.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creat iveco mmons .org/licen ses/by/4.0/.