Breaking Through Bottlenecks for Thermally Conductive Polymer Composites: A Perspective for Intrinsic Thermal Conductivity, Interfacial Thermal Resistance and Theoretics

Bottlenecks in the field of thermally conductive polymer composites are raised, and corresponding reasons are analysed. Three possible directions for breaking through such bottlenecks are put forward, and current advances in these three directions are illustrated. Future development trends and demands are foreseen to help the development of thermally conductive polymers and their composites. Bottlenecks in the field of thermally conductive polymer composites are raised, and corresponding reasons are analysed. Three possible directions for breaking through such bottlenecks are put forward, and current advances in these three directions are illustrated. Future development trends and demands are foreseen to help the development of thermally conductive polymers and their composites. Rapid development of energy, electrical and electronic technologies has put forward higher requirements for the thermal conductivities of polymers and their composites. However, the thermal conductivity coefficient (λ) values of prepared thermally conductive polymer composites are still difficult to achieve expectations, which has become the bottleneck in the fields of thermally conductive polymer composites. Aimed at that, based on the accumulation of the previous research works by related researchers and our research group, this paper proposes three possible directions for breaking through the bottlenecks: (1) preparing and synthesizing intrinsically thermally conductive polymers, (2) reducing the interfacial thermal resistance in thermally conductive polymer composites, and (3) establishing suitable thermal conduction models and studying inner thermal conduction mechanism to guide experimental optimization. Also, the future development trends of the three above-mentioned directions are foreseen, hoping to provide certain basis and guidance for the preparation, researches and development of thermally conductive polymers and their composites.


Breaking Through Bottlenecks for Thermally Conductive Polymer Composites: A Perspective for Intrinsic Thermal Conductivity, Interfacial Thermal Resistance and Theoretics
Junwei Gu 1 * , Kunpeng Ruan 1

HIGHLIGHTS
• Bottlenecks in the field of thermally conductive polymer composites are raised, andcorresponding reasons are analysed.
• Three possible directions for breaking through such bottlenecks are put forward, andcurrent advances in these three directions are illustrated.
• Future development trends and demands are foreseen to help the development ofthermally conductive polymers and their composites.
ABSTRACT Rapid development of energy, electrical and electronic technologies has put forward higher requirements for the thermal conductivities of polymers and their composites. However, the thermal conductivity coefficient (λ) values of prepared thermally conductive polymer composites are still difficult to achieve expectations, which has become the bottleneck in the fields of thermally conductive polymer composites. Aimed at that, based on the accumulation of the previous research works by related researchers and our research group, this paper proposes three possible directions for breaking through the bottlenecks: (1) preparing and synthesizing intrinsically thermally conductive polymers, (2) reducing the interfacial thermal resistance in thermally conductive polymer composites, and (3) establishing suitable thermal conduction models and studying inner thermal conduction mechanism to guide experimental optimization. Also, the future development trends of the three above-mentioned directions are foreseen, hoping to provide certain basis and guidance for the preparation, researches and development of thermally conductive polymers and their composites.
KEYWORDS Thermally conductive polymer composites; Intrinsic thermal conductivity; Interfacial thermal resistance; Thermal conduction models; Thermal conduction mechanisms

Introduction
With the rapid development of energy, electrical and electronic technologies, the rapid accumulation of heat in related equipment and components will inevitably result in the serious threat to their stabilities and reliabilities [1]. Polymers are frequently used in energy, electrical and electronic fields due to their light weight, high specific strength/modulus, easy processing, excellent chemical stability and low cost [2]. However, the thermal conductivity coefficient (λ, 0.18 ~ 0.44 W m −1 K −1 ) values of polymers are often low, which cannot meet the requirements of highly efficient and fast thermal conduction/dissipation for organic solar cells, energy storage materials, UHV power transmission equipment and high-power LEDs [3]. Therefore, the researches and development of polymers and their composites with high thermal conduction/dissipation capabilities and excellent mechanical properties have urgent theoretical significance and practical application values for the design and expansion of materials in the fields of energy, electrical and electronic technologies.
Thermally conductive polymers can be divided into two types according to the preparation process: intrinsic type and filled type [4]. Intrinsically thermally conductive polymers are obtained via special physical structures (such as orientation, liquid crystalline and crystalline structure) by changing the structures of polymer chain units in the process of polymer synthesis and processing, in order to improve the intrinsic thermal conductivities of the polymers. Filled-type thermally conductive polymer composites are fabricated by adding highly thermally conductive fillers into the polymer matrix, and thereafter giving excellent thermal conductivities to the polymers by directly physical blending.
Till present, many researchers have prepared a variety of thermally conductive polymers and their composites through the two above-mentioned methods, but in the end, most of λ values are still difficult to meet expectation, which has become the major bottleneck in this field [5]. Our research group has long focused on the controllable fabrication and inner mechanisms of thermally conductive polymers and their composites. Based on the intrinsic high thermal conductivities, blending, and compounding and external field-induced processing, the thermal conduction properties of "polymers-interfaces-fillers" and constitutive relationships between "molecular chains-thermal conduction pathways-thermal conductivities" have been investigated, a series of thermally conductive polymer composites and products have been prepared, and the thermal conduction mechanisms have also been improved. Based on the previous research experiences, this paper proposes the research ideas and directions that can be taken in the future for breaking through the bottlenecks in the field of thermally conductive polymer composites, so as to provide a certain basis and guidance for the preparation, research, and development of thermally conductive polymers and their composites.

Intrinsically Thermally Conductive Polymers
One of the most important reasons why the λ values of thermally conductive polymer composites are difficult to achieve the expectation is that the intrinsic λ values of polymers are low. Therefore, even if polymers are filled with thermally conductive fillers with very high λ, the improvements of λ are still limited. Studies have shown that when the ratio of the λ values of the polymer matrix to the thermally conductive fillers is less than 1:100, it is difficult to efficiently improve the thermal conductivities of polymer composites by only filling thermally conductive fillers with high λ [6]. As a consequence, it is very critical to improve the intrinsic thermal conductivity of the polymer matrix, and the preparation of synthetic intrinsically thermally conductive polymers through molecular design is a novel idea and direction to improve the thermal conductivities of polymers and their composites.
Researches on intrinsically thermally conductive polymers firstly began in Takezawa's research group in Japan. Based on the orderly structure of the molecules, the liquid crystalline epoxy monomers with biphenyl groups were synthesized, and the λ of the cured epoxy exceeded 0.90 W m −1 K −1 , 5 times that of conventional epoxy resin (0.18 W m −1 K −1 ) [7]. However, it should be noted that the λ value was measured and calculated by the AC calorimetry method, not comparable with the existing λ test equipment, such as the Linseis THB (Germany), AB Hot Disk (Sweden) and Netzsch LFA467 (Germany) by heat flow method, plane transient method and laser flash method. Jeong et al.

3
[8] prepared a kind of side-chain epoxy resin containing cyanobiphenyl mesogenic end groups. After curing and crosslinking by diamine, the liquid crystalline epoxy resin still retained the oriented liquid crystalline region, whose λ could reach 0.46 W m −1 K −1 , because the microstructure contained anisotropic molecular orientation. In the previous work of our research group [9], we designed and synthesized side-chain liquid crystalline epoxy (S-LCE), which was prepared by thiol-epoxide nucleophilic ring-opening reaction and coating method. Intrinsically highly thermally conductive and self-healing liquid crystalline epoxy films (LCEF) exhibited excellent intrinsic thermal conductivities and self-healing capabilities, whose through-plane λ (λ ⊥ ) and in-plane λ (λ ∥ ) were 0.33 and 1.25 W m −1 K −1 , respectively, much higher than λ ⊥ (0.19 W m −1 K −1 ) and λ ∥ (0.65 W m −1 K −1 ) of general bisphenol A epoxy resin (E-51). Furthermore, Gu et al. [10] designed and synthesized a kind of liquid crystalline epoxy based on biphenyl mesogens, using 4, 4′-diaminodiphenylmethane (DDM) as curing agent, to fabricate cured epoxy resin (LCER) with λ of 0.51 W m −1 K −1 , about 2.7 times that of conventional E-51 epoxy resin (0.19 W m −1 K −1 ). When the amount of BN was 30 wt%, the corresponding λ of thermally conductive BN/LCER composites was 1.02 W m −1 K −1 , which was much higher than that of thermally conductive BN/E-51 composites (0.52 W m −1 K −1 ) with the same fillers amount, proving that preparing intrinsically thermally conductive polymers is a practical and feasible strategy to effectively improve the λ of thermally conductive polymer composites.
However, the intrinsically thermally conductive polymers prepared at present are mainly concentrated in epoxy resins, which are relatively single in types. There are few reports on intrinsically thermally conductive polyimide (PI), polyoxymethylene (POM), polycarbonate (PC) or other high-performance engineering polymers. In addition, the chains of liquid crystalline polymers are usually only partially ordered at the microscopic level, and still present the isotropically disordered state at the macroscopic level, which affects the efficient improvement of intrinsic thermal conductivities. In the future research works on intrinsically thermally conductive polymers, researchers can prepare and synthesize intrinsically thermally conductive high-performance engineering polymers to broaden the application ranges of intrinsically thermally conductive polymers. It is also an excellent direction to improve the macroscopy order of the polymer chains by reasonable molecular structure design and optimized processing technique (Fig. 1), in order to further greatly enhance the intrinsic thermal conductivities of polymers.

Interfacial Thermal Resistance in Thermally Conductive Polymer Composites
Interfaces play an important role and have great influences on λ in thermally conductive polymer composites [11]. During the thermal conduction process, vibration harmonic, acoustic & modulus mismatch occur for phonon at the interfaces, thus resulting in severe scattering and causing the mean free path of phonon to drop dramatically [12]. Corresponding macroscopic evidence is that when the heat flow passes through the interface, it is often obstructed to a certain extent, causing serious heat loss, and then reducing the λ of polymer composites [13]. Therefore, it will be the key idea to improve the interfaces in thermally conductive polymer composites and to reduce interfacial thermal resistance (ITR), so as to further improve the λ of polymer composites. The interfaces include those between thermally conductive fillers and polymer matrix and those between different types of thermally conductive fillers. The corresponding ITR are denoted as ITR F-M and ITR F-F in this paper. Researchers reported that the fabrication of thermally conductive fillers with hetero-structures can effectively decrease the ITR F-F (Fig. 2a). Zou et al. [14] coated the surface of alumina (Al 2 O 3 ) with boron nitride nanosheets (BNNS) to fabricate hetero-structured Al 2 O 3 @BNNS thermally conductive fillers, and then prepared thermally conductive Al 2 O 3 @BNNS/epoxy composites. When the volume ratio of BNNS to Al 2 O 3 was 1:7 and the amount of Al 2 O 3 @ BNNS was 65 vol%, the λ of thermally conductive Al 2 O 3 @ BNNS/epoxy composites reached 2.43 W m −1 K −1 , higher than pure epoxy resin (0.21 W m −1 K −1 ), single Al 2 O 3 /epoxy (1.39 W m −1 K −1 ) and simply blended (Al 2 O 3 /BNNS)/epoxy (1.94 W m −1 K −1 ) composites under the same fillers amount. In the previous work of our research group, Gu et al. [15] fabricated hetero-structured silicon carbide-BNNS (SiC-BNNS) thermally conductive fillers by sol-gel & in-situ growth method. When the mass ratio of SiC to BNNS was 1:1 and the total amount was 20 wt%, the corresponding λ of thermally conductive SiC-BNNS/epoxy composites was as high as 0.89 W m −1 K −1 , higher than single SiC/epoxy (0.43 W m −1 K −1 ), single BNNS/epoxy (0.61 W m −1 K −1 ) and simply blended (SiC/BNNS)/epoxy (0.52 W m −1 K −1 ) composites, which proved that fabrication of thermally conductive fillers with hetero-structures can improve the interfaces between different types of fillers, reduce the phonon scattering at the interfaces and decrease ITR F-F .
However, most of the domestic and foreign researches on ITR are not in-depth enough. The decreases in ITR are indirectly reflected by the increases in λ, and there is a lack of universal mathematical models, test methods and related measurement equipment for ITR. In the future research works on ITR, researchers would try to establish more universal mathematical models on ITR for the new forms and characteristics of thermally conductive polymer composites, and speed up the in-depth cooperation with thermal properties measurement companies, quickly develop the multi-system applicable and highly universal ITR test methods and measurement equipment.

Thermal Conduction Models and Inner Mechanisms of Thermally Conductive Polymer Composites
The λ values of the thermally conductive polymer composites are closely related to the intrinsic λ of polymers, the type and amount of thermally conductive fillers, as well as ITR. Studying the thermal conduction models will help to clarify the influencing factors theoretically, and calculate and predict the λ of composites in specific system. Researchers have proposed a variety of thermal conduction models, among which Y. Agari's [20], Maxwell-Eucken's [21] and Nielsen-Lewis' models [22] are more successful. However, the existing thermal conduction models have narrow application range, not taking into account the shape, amount and surface properties of thermally conductive fillers, as well as ITR, etc., so that there are always certain errors between the predicted λ values by models and the experimental values. In our previous works, we optimized the classic series & parallel thermal conduction models for thermally conductive BN/ cyanate ester composites, which had better λ fitting degree than other classic thermal conduction models [23]. Also, for thermally conductive carbon-based fillers/PI composites, based on the modified effective medium theory and the principle of heat energy conservation, thermal conduction models suitable for anisotropic composites were proposed, showing better λ fitting degree than other classical thermal conduction models (Fig. 3) [24][25][26]. Moreover, COMSOL Multiphysics software was used to establish models to simulate the thermal conduction process of thermally conductive epoxy laminated composites, and the simulation results had a high degree of matching with the experimental results [27]. In the future research works on the thermal conduction models, researchers need to fully consider more practical influencing factors, quantify and introduce these factors into the thermal conduction models, and improve the degree of matching between the thermal conduction models and the experimental results. Regarding the inner thermal conduction mechanisms of thermally conductive polymer composites, it is generally recognized internationally that it is based on the thermal conduction pathways formed by thermally conductive fillers [28]. However, whether the final λ values of the thermally conductive polymer composites are proportional to the number of thermal conduction pathways in the composites needs to be further verified (Fig. 4a-a′), and what form and length of thermal conduction pathways (continuous or discontinuous pathways, long or short pathways, straight or curved pathways, etc.) will determine λ values also needs further consideration (Fig. 4b-c′). Also, the percolation behaviour of thermal conduction has an extremely important impact on the rapid λ improvement of polymer composites. Based on the researches on the constitutive relationship of "thermal conduction pathways-thermal conductivities" for thermally conductive graphite nanoplatelets/polyphenylene sulphide (GNPs/PPS) composites, our research group proposed that the GNPs/PPS composites system showed thermal conduction percolation behaviour, but the behaviour mostly existed in high-λ carbon-based fillers (such as GNPs, carbon nanotubes (CNT) and graphene) [29]. However, the physical properties of the thermal conduction percolation behaviour are still the question worth discussing, due to that, with the same fillers, the increase in thermal conductivity is much lower than that in electrical conductivity. Therefore, in the future research works on the thermal conduction mechanisms of thermally conductive polymer composites, it is necessary to conduct in-depth analysis and exploration on the formation approaches, methods and degrees of thermal conduction pathways in the thermally conductive polymer composites, as well as the thermal conduction percolation behaviour, in order to develop the thermal conduction mechanisms of thermally conductive polymer composites, and ultimately guide the optimization of experiments and production.

Summary and Perspectives
In summary, although progresses have been made in thermally conductive polymer composites, their λ values are mostly still lower than expected. Aimed at that, based on the accumulation of the previous research works by related researchers and our research group, this paper proposes three possible directions to break through the bottlenecks: (1) preparing and synthesizing intrinsically thermally conductive polymers, (2) reducing the ITR in the thermally conductive polymer composites and (3) establishing suitable thermal conduction models and studying inner thermal conduction mechanisms to guide experimental optimization. Also, the future development trends of the three above-mentioned directions are foreseen, hoping to provide certain basis and guidance for the preparation, researches and development of thermally conductive polymers and their composites. It is believed that after breaking through the current bottlenecks, thermally conductive polymer composites, as the basic support for the development of human society, with further assistance by intellectualization of the materials through active heat dissipation, will show irreplaceable roles in various aspects such as aerospace, energy management, artificial intelligence, new energy, high-end equipment manufacturing and energy-efficient electronic devices. 11). It is also financially supported by Polymer Electromagnetic Functional Materials Innovation Team of Shaanxi Sanqin Scholars.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http:// creat iveco mmons. org/ licen ses/ by/4. 0/.