Feasibility Assessment of Hydroelectric Power Plant in Ungauged River Basin: A Case Study

The accurate estimation of long-term resource availability, as represented by discharge, is an essential component of hydropower constructions for generation capacity estimation as well as environment protection on ungauged river basins. Feasibility studies concerning decision-making for various types of items to be used in a hydropower plant on ungauged river basins are important in order to estimate the energy generation, the approximate cost of the project, and the required budget allocation. A feasibility study is necessary which evaluates the energy generation cost, investment and maintenance costs for hydropower projects. The purpose of this study is to analyze the technical feasibility of hydropower plant installations at ungauged sites. A case study is performed to illustrate this investigation. By means of the methodology presented in this research work, it will be possible to carry out sound and successful research to assess the economic feasibility of a hydropower project on ungauged river basins.


Introduction
Estimation of flow volumes from an ungauged river basin is essential for planning and design of water resources' projects such as the design of storage facilities, assessment of water availability for municipal, agricultural or industrial purposes, as well as for planning irrigation operations, estimating future development for water supplies for power generation and further necessities.
The socioeconomic development and increased living standards together with the fast growing industry have forced a major increase in electricity demand and generation. Being the basic input of all kinds of economic activities, electrical energy has become an indispensable life standard.
Small hydropower plants have emerged as an energy source which is renewable, easily developed, inexpensive and harmless to the environment [1].

21-210 SGS (Eie) Values 21-157SGS (Dsi) Values
Hydropower is the most reliable, new source of power generation for the future; its share is more than 92 % of the renewable energy generated [2].
In order to increase renewable energy production, enormous research is carried out for developing efficient, small hydropower plants. In this regards, European Small Hydro Association has issued a guideline for designing small hydro plants [3]. However, feasibility studies should not be neglected for the suitable evaluation and assessment of bigger hydro projects.
In the river basins with no flow-gaugings, the discharges in certain sections can be estimated taking into account the parameters like the basin area, rainfall, evaporation, weather temperature and altitude above sea level, besides the correla-tion-regression technique from a nearby gauged stream. The natural flow statistics may be estimated for an ungauged site, which may include the long term mean flow and flow duration curve, monthly mean flows and monthly flow duration curves.
Regionalization can be defined as the transfer of information from one catchment to another [4]. This information may consist of characteristics describing hydrological data or models. In order to reach a greater confidence in extrapolating hydrological behavior from catchments with flow records for an ungauged catchment, all the data should form a relatively homogeneous group ( [5][6][7]). Vandewiele and Elias [8] reconstruct monthly runoffs for basins which are notably ungauged; Post and Jakeman [9] and Sefton and Howarth [10] predict daily flow time series by developing relationships between the parameters of a daily time step rainfall-runoff model and physical catchment descriptors. This study aims at giving a general idea about the feasibility assessment of hydropower projects in ungauged river basins. In this respect, a feasibility report is of great importance for it is capable of performing desired computations and is developed by a highly experienced group of planners and engineers. Case study gains foreground in this research work which will be applied to the Cardakli Weir and hydropower plant in Turkey.

Feasibility Study
This feasibility study contains an estimation of design flow, design and probable maximum floods; determination of power potential for a range of dam or weir heights and installed capacities for project optimization; determination of the project design earthquake; design of all structures in sufficient detail; determination of the diversion structures' dimensions and project schedule; optimization of the project layout, water levels and components; production of a detailed cost estimate; and finally, an economic and financial evaluation of the project along with a feasibility report.

Description of the Project Area
The Cardakli Weir and hydropower plant will be constructed on the Ulucay River in the countryside of Sivrice at the Elazig region where continental climate is mostly influential. Ulucay basin (207,0 km 2 ) having a main branch length of 25 km, originates in the Hazarbaba Mountains, and receives flow from one major tributary before it discharges into the Karakaya Dam reservoir. Elevations range from 700 to 2,366 m. The Ulucay basin has warm, humid summers and cold winters. Heavy snowfalls are not rare in November, December, January, and February, while the driest months are July and August. The average annual precipitation is about 594.7 mm. The temperatures are −1.4 • C in January and 29.5 • C in August [11,12]. Three-dimensional topographic map of the Ulucay River is shown in Fig. 1.
The geological structure of the site is obtained from the Earthquake Maps of Turkey prepared by The Ministry of Public Works and Settlement in 1996, which indicates that the region is sited in a 1st degree earthquake region.

Hydrology Data
There is no flow observation station on the Ulucay River. For the estimation of water potential of the river in the study, the area Buyukcay (no. 21-210 (DSI) SGS), which is in the same basin, has been taken into account. The daily flow observation data of no. 21-210 SGS between 1985 and 2004 are present in official sources. The missing daily average flow values of no. 21-210 SGS from 2004 have been completed by those of no. 21-217 of Seyhan River SGS.
The catchment area of the Ulucay River has been identified as 207.0 km 2 and the average annual precipitation is 594.7 mm according to the data collected by Karakaya and Hazar stations [11,12].
The  Fig. 2. The calculated monthly average flow (m 3 /s) values of the Ulucay river are given in Table 1 and the flow-duration curve is shown in Fig. 3.

Design Flow and Power Optimization
The design flow of a project is the most important feature of hydropower projects. All the other components of the projects are designed according to the selected design discharge.
Depending on this design discharge, the transmission canal dimensions, the penstock diameter and power central dimensions have been selected; based on these data, the net heads have been established with hydraulic calculations.
Normally, design discharges corresponding to 20-30 % of time are appropriate as the design discharge. The discharge used in the Cardakli Feasibility Report, is 8 m 3 /s and it corresponds to 22 % of time in flow duration curve.
Together with the net head corresponding to each of selected discharges, the installed power and annual production has been calculated. The investigations have been carried out based on the 6.00, 6.25, 6.50, 6.75, 7.00, 7.25, 7.50, 7.75, 8.00, 8.25, 8.50, 8.75, 9.00, 9.25 and 9.50 m 3 /s discharges. The total cost, annual income and annual expense rates pertaining to each discharge and installed power have been specified. Then, the profitability and marginal profitability calculations have been done, and the optional system whose marginal rent ability is closest to 1, and which has a design discharge of 8.0 m 3 /s and 11.03 MW installed power has been obtained as the optimal result. Generator efficiency is given as 97 %. Transformer losses, parasitic energy losses and annual downtime losses are assumed as 1, 2 and 3 %, respectively. Energy cost escalation rate is assumed as 0 %. The calculation details are given in Table 2.

Components of the Project
The components of the Cardakli HEPP project and the feasibility, presented in this study, are listed below:    Table 3.

Energy Production
The water of the Ulucay River is diverted by weir to a conveyance tunnel-canal, and then through a penstock to the turbines with total installed power of 11.02 MW and annual energy generation of 40.51 GWh in powerhouse that is located on 700.00 m elevation. Water is then discharged back into the Ulucay River which flows again into the Karakaya Dam reservoir. The gross head of the project is 162.08 m and the discharge flow is determined as 8.0 m 3 /s. The monthly energy produc-tion data of the Ulucay River are given in Table 4 and the energy graph is shown in Fig. 4.

Firm and Secondary Energy
Firm capacity is the amount of energy available for production or transmission which can be (and in many cases must be) guaranteed to be available at a given time. Firm energy refers to the actual energy guaranteed to be available. Firm energy is the energy that a plant can generate 95 percent of the time. Cardakli hydropower plant is generated firm energy, 7.82 GWh.
Secondary energy refers to all available energy above and beyond firm energy. Energy producers such as hydroelectric plants and wind farms may have secondary energy available due to unexpected weather or seasonal conditions. Secondary energy is not guaranteed. Cardakli hydropower plant is generated secondary energy, 32.69 GWh.

Economic Analysis
The economic analysis, envisaged economic life of the project for the Cardakli HEPP was predicted as 50 years. The key question related to the economics of the project is who will consume the electricity produced by the project. Energy-purpose projects, the avoided cost of energy is entered as firm energy 0.07 US$/kWh and secondary energy 0.06 $/kWh which was the average value in the market for the year 2010. There is peak power benefit to plant with no storage is considered to be worthless. As a result of the calculations, 7.82 GWh firm energy 32.69 GWh secondary energy, total 40.51 GWh energy production per year is planned. As a result, the total energy benefit of the Cardakli HEPP is calculated as 2.511.620 $. The project is examined in two parts which take into account the annual expenses, these, interest, depreciation and amortization expenses consist of operating and maintenance costs. Energy-purpose investments, interest and depreciation as a factor of 9.5 % interest rate and 50 year economic life of the project correspond souts to the value of 0.09603. Operation and maintenance expenses, as well as  criteria for each unit were taken into account by means of Dsi factors. Because of these principles, the total annual cost of the project is calculated as 1.306.759 $. Income and expense ratio (Profitability) was calculated as 2.08 for the Cardakli HEPP with respect to this cost ratio.

Conclusions
The feasibility works has resulted in that a Cardakli hydropower project on the ungauged Ulucay river basin is technically favorable, potentially, commercially viable and could bring to the community financial and other benefits. The typical design lifetime for hydropower project is approximately 50 years, but a large proportion of the equipment (weir, grid connection, cabling, other infrastructure) has a much longer lifetime. Although other parts like control equipment and electro mechanic equipment either have a shorter life time or need periodic refurbishing. Consequently the long term financial benefits of the hydro project seem to be very useful.
An increase in renewable energy generation is world priority over the long term future. With a target of 10 % of gross electricity consumption in 2015, the aim is set to increase this to 20 % by 2020. It is also possible that the renewable share in production may increase further after this date. Because the importance of renewable energy increases over time, the long term significance will be maintained. This paper presents a method for estimating hydropower capacity of ungauged sites. The results obtained from this study suggest this, especially in the catchments with inadequate or non-flow gauging. Solutions that are faster and more affordable than the geodetic gauging can be obtained with the values obtained depending on the topographic, physical and hydrometeorological parameters of the catchments itself.
In the feasibility and master plan works, the project discharge could easily be identified by obtaining the "stream rainfall-flow parameters" with the method presented in this