Augmented antifungal potential of benzothiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates as hybrid-silver aqua nanoformulations

This study was focused on the preparation of benzothiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates–silver nanoconjugates (BCDTC–AgNPs) for their in vitro antifungal evaluation against various phytopathogenic fungi viz. Pyricularia grisea, Drechslera oryzae, Fusarium moniliforme and Ustilaginoidea virens. Benzothiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates (BCDTCs) were used both as capping as well as stabilizing for silver nanoparticles (AgNPs). The prepared nanoconjugates were analysed by UV–visible and TEM studies. The comparative antifungal evaluation of BCDTC–AgNPs with precursor BCDTCs and AgNPs indicated the manifold increase in antifungal potential when applied as nanoconjugates. The promising results were comparable to the standard commercial fungicides Tilt and Bavistin, in most of the cases.


Introduction
Conventional formulations of bioactive organic compounds (suspension or emulsion) suffer from limitations of low or zero water dispersibility, high dose of applications, low bioavailability, instability and usually inability of producing the sustained effects. Nanotechnical methodologies of application of bioactive materials as their conjugates with metal nanocarriers (Kora and Rastogi 2013) or their loading on metal nanoparticles is a matter of intense interest (Duncan 2003;Ferrari 2005) and most pertinently emerging field. Nanoconjugates showed significant enhancement in biological activity in comparison to free drug molecules because of dispersion of organic molecules on the metal nanoparticle surface (Bordes et al. 2009;Gajbhiye et al. 2009;Saha et al. 2016). This is also attributable to advanced morpho-topological properties as well as inherent biological properties of metal nanoparticles (Kanhed et al. 2014;Liversidge et al. 2003).
Among metal nanoparticles, silver nanoparticles is eliciting area of interest due to its hypotoxicity (Stewart and Costerton 2001;Fabrega et al. 2011), efficient biopotential (Lok et al. 2006) and no resistance-causing behaviour (Stewart and Costerton 2001), along with a unique physical, chemical and morpho-topological properties, leading to their diverse and augmented biological potencies. Silver nanoparticles are referred as magic bullets which take the bioactive materials into the interior of the cell surface (Faraji and Wipf 2009), thus providing an increased scope of biological potential of bioactive compounds at low concentrations (Neu 1992). Wide variety of capping and stabilizing agents are used for AgNPs, which affect their size, distribution and bioactivity. Thio compounds among them act as excellent surface stabilizing agents for the soft metal nanoparticles, owing to their soft acid-soft base stabilizing interactions (Tong et al. 2006;Vyas et al. 2015).
Our previous results on the synthesis of novel hybrid organic molecules as antifungals, series of benzothiazol-2ylcarbamodithioates Ghatelwal et al. 2017) based on the concept of lead hybridization Sidhu and Kukreja 2015;Gumber et al. 2015;Kukreja et al. 2016) inflicted remarkable antifungal properties. But low water dispersibility and low stability of carbamodithioates, as well as remarkable potential of medicine-nanosilver hybrids impelled us for their modification as benzothiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates-silver nanoconjugates, as ecofriendly aqua colloidal solutions. Mycocidal potential of benzothiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates-Ag nanoconjugates against various phytopathogenic fungi were compared with naked AgNPs and benzothiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates, to observe the effect of nanoconjugation. The simple structural activity relationship (SAR) was established in this paper.

Instruments and measurements
The UV-Vis absorption spectra were recorded on UV 1800 Shimadzu double beam spectrophotometer over the wavelength range of 300-700 nm using quartz cuvettes of 1 cm path length. The size of nanoparticles was studied in Hitachi transmission electron microscope at an accelerated voltage of 200 kV. Benzo[d]thiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates (BCDTCs) (1-8) were synthesized by previously standardized work of our lab Ghatelwal et al. 2017)

Synthesis of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs)
A 10-ml volume of 1.0 mM silver nitrate was added dropwise (about 1 drop per second) to 30 ml of 5.0 mM sodium borohydride solution while sonication, which was continued for another 5 min. The solution turned light yellow after the addition of silver nitrate which was primary indication for the synthesis of silver nanoparticles (Aashritha 2013). It was further analysed and confirmed on the basis of UV-visible and TEM analysis.
Different concentrations of benzo[d]thiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates (1 and 2) were dissolved in minimum volume of DMSO and added to 10 ml of 25 9 10 -6 M naked silver nanoparticle solution under sonication to obtain the benzo[d]thiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioate-capped silver nanoparticles. The concentration optimization was made on the basis of UV-visible spectrophotometric results and TEM micrographs. The experiment with optimized concentration was repeated for compound 3-8 to obtain the series of BCDTC-AgNP 1-8 .

Toxicity analysis
Toxtree v2.6.6, an open-source software application was used to analyse the toxic effect of different molecules. In order to find out the toxic hazards, two-dimensional models of all the synthesized compounds were first converted into its simplified molecular-input line-entry system (SMILES format) using the online SMILE converter. Then SMILES code was simply put into the Chemical identifier row available in the Toxtree software, to get the toxic characters of the molecule.
The concentration of prepared naked silver nanoparticles and benzo[d]thiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates-capped silver nanoparticles (BCDTC-AgNP 1-8 ) were 25 9 10 -6 M and the nanoconjugates formed by adding optimized concentration of BCDTC were used as such as a stock solution. The required dilutions were subsequently made from the stock solution by adding distilled water, as and when required. The in vitro effective concentrations of the compounds were determined by Spore germination inhibition technique. For assays, 0.02 ml of the title compounds to be tested and 0.02 ml of spore suspension were seeded in the cavity of the cavity slide and incubated at 15 ± 2°C. Growth was determined at 24 h for all the phytopathogenic fungi. The EC 50 values (concentration which induces a response halfway) were calculated using the probit analysis (Finney 1971). The data points are the mean of triplicates. The results of assay along with the data of BCDTC (1-8) obtained from the earlier laboratory studies are summarized in Tables 1 and 2.

Synthesis, optimization and characterization of BCDTC-AgNPs
A solution of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) was synthesized by chemical reduction of dilute aqueous solution of silver nitrate, using sodium borohydride.
AgNO 3 þ NaBH 4 ! Ag þ 1=2 H 2 þ1=2 B 2 H 6 þ NaNO 3 : Compounds 1-8 were capped on naked AgNPs to obtain benzo[d]thiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates-capped silver nanoparticles (BCDTC-AgNP 1-8 ). The colour of naked AgNP solution changed gradually from light yellow to brown after addition of capping agent, which was primary identification of formation of BCDTC-AgNPs (Guzman et al. 2009). The concentration optimization was further made by repeating the experiment with four different concentrations viz. 0.015, 0.030, 0.045 and 0.060 mmol. The UV-Vis spectroscopy and transmission electron microscopy further revealed that 0.015 mol of compound 3-10 in 10 ml of 25 9 10 -6 M was optimum concentration for exact capping of AgNPs. This was supported by the observation that the excessive amount of carbamodithioates settled down after some days when the concentration was more than 0.015 mol, whereas the BCDTC-capped silver nanoparticles at 0.015 mmol concentration of capping agent were stable for long time.
In UV-Vis spectra a very pronounced plasmon absorption band of naked silver nanoparticles appeared at 405 nm (k max ) characteristic of a silver colloid as represented by curve (a) in Fig. 1. The curves (b-e) in the same figure corresponded to the 0.015, 0.030, 0.045 and 0.060 mmol of BCDTC in 10 ml of 2.5 9 10 -6 M AgNPs, respectively. The broadness of the absorption band takes place with increase in concentration of BCDTCs, whereas there was a sharp peak with absorbance maxima at 401 nm at concentration 0.015 mol of BCDTC. It was relatively blue shifted with respect to naked AgNPs that were at 405 nm and indicated that after the capping, particle size reduced (Tong et al. 2006). And the broadened peaks (c-e) in the same spectrograph appeared due to the loss of surface plasmon resonance which is attributed to the formation of metal nanoparticles (Naz et al. 2014). The morphology and particle size of BCDTC-AgNPs were studied by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). TEM micrograph depicted that prepared naked nanoparticles were in spherical shape and uniformly distributed without any agglomeration with diameter in range of 25-30 nm (Figs. 2a, 3a). The capped particles had reduced size in a range 20-25 nm at 0.015 mol of capping agent, with no extra BCDTC sited around the nanoparticles (Fig. 2b), whereas when the concentration of BCDTCs was 0.030, 0.045 and 0.060 mol, an excessive amount of material was witnessed around the nanoparticles in the TEM micrograph (Fig. 2c-d). The standard deviation in the size of dispersed particles is witnessed in form of histogram (Fig. 3). The silver nanoparticles were synthesized by chemical reduction method in all the samples. During addition of capping agent they were sonicated resulting in their further dispersal to some extent and capping molecules do not allow their aggregation leading to their reduced size (Saha et al. 2016).
The synergistic effect of conjugation of two precursors was seen both in stability and size of the particles, whereas there is negligible effect of increased size of alkyl chain on the stabilization and size of the conjugates. The nanoformulations were found to be stable even after 8 months of standing making it a good choice in terms of high shelf-life.

In silico toxicity analysis
The toxicity analysis, made by using the toxtree v2.6.6 software, revealed that all the compounds belong to class III level of toxicity, which was at par with the toxicity of standard fungicide, Tilt. The results were obtained on the basis of Cramer's rule of toxicity analysis (Patlewicz et al. 2008). Antifungal evaluation Mycobiocidal efficacy of the series of BCDTC-AgNP 1-8 was evaluated against four phytopathogenic fungi viz. Pyricularia grisea, D. oryzae, F. moniliforme and U. virens by spore germination inhibition technique and results were compared with naked AgNps (Table 1) and BCDTC (1-8) ( Table 2). The results expressed are in terms of EC 50 values (lmol/ml). The naked silver nanoparticles were practically inactive at 25 9 10 -3 lmol/ml concentrations and, therefore, their EC 50 values were expected to be much higher than this value against all the test fungi. The surface functionalization of AgNPs with myco-active BCDTC (1-8) (Ghatelwal et al. 2017) revealed very promising results. Against, P. grisea BCDTC-AgNP 3 and BCDTC-AgNP 5 were found to be the effective with EC 50 values, 0.20 9 10 -3 and 0.13 9 10 --3 lmol/ml, respectively. BCDTC-AgNP 1 was the most active nanoconjugate against D. oryzae, F. moniliforme and U. virens with EC 50 values 0.10 9 10 -3 lmol/ml, in all the cases. There was multifold enhancement in the fungitoxicity potential of AgNps when capped with BCDTC revealing favourable effect of conjugation. The results are in consonance with the earlier reports where the AgNP conjugates with most active compounds gave augmented biopotential than the bare ones (Saha et al. 2016;Vyas et al. 2015;Kumar and Poornachandra 2015), even against resistant strains of micro-organisms (Gajbhiye et al. 2009;Tiwari et al. 2014).
Comparison of these nanoconjugates in terms of drug equivalence of BCDTCs gave enthusiastic results (Table 2). Against P. grisea, compound 5 was the most active compound with EC 50 value 0.38 lmol/ml but in coated form this value reduced to 0.075 lmol/ml, which revealed five times increase in the potential in nanodispersed formulation (excluding the contribution of AgNps in terms of activity or bulk). Against D. oryzae, F. moniliforme and U. virens, compound 1 inflicted the maximum inhibition of fungal spores with values 0.13, 0.32 and 0.58 lmol/ml which got reduced on nanodispersion on silver nanoparticles, to 0.062, 0.062 and 0.075 lmol/ml, giving threefold increase in the mycocidal potential of all the test nanoconjugates. The results of most of the nanoformulated BCDTCs were also far better than the standard fungicides, Tilt and Bavistin used against these fungi.
This was attributed to the improved dispersibilty of waterinsoluble BCDTC leading to more number of molecules available (active) per unit volume (Santra 2014), leading to their better bioavailability (Tiwari et al. 2014). The AgNps also affect the bioefficacy by acting as carrier, taking the active molecules into the interior of the diseased tissues with favourable effects (Sevilla et al. 2009). Our results were on the same line as the previous reported literature which indicated the effect of nanoconjugation on the bioefficacy non nanoformulations of bioactive compounds (Saha et al. 2016;Vyas et al. 2015;Kumar and Poornachandra 2015).
The individual investigation of antifungal screening clearly revealed that most of lower alkyl chain substituted benzo[d]thiazol-2ylcarbamodithioates showed significant inhibition of germination against all the test fungi. Further, chloro-substituted benzothiazol-2-ylcarbamodithioates derivatives were found to be more effective than their floro analogues. On the basis of alkylation, the butyl-and hexylsubstituted derivatives gave better results (Ghatelwal et al. 2017).

Conclusion
Silver sprays were not recommended till date due to various application issues but BCDTC-AgNP nanoconjugates can be efficiently used for localised seed treatments for eradication of fungal menace. They may act as excellent replacement of organo-mercurials (banned) with much lower toxicity hazards.
The study further advocates the exploitation of the results by replacement of expensive Ag metal with costeffective metals which are essential micro or macro nutrients of the plant kingdom. This could be able to fulfil the twin objective of nutrition and antifungal activity by single moiety, keeping the risk of metal accumulation and toxicity at bay. Our endeavours in the direction are under way.