Extreme secondary sexual dimorphism in the genus Florarctus (Heterotardigrada: Halechiniscidae)

Secondary sexual dimorphism in florarctin tardigrades is a well-known phenomenon. Males are usually smaller than females, and primary clavae are relatively longer in the former. A new species Florarctus bellahelenae, collected from subtidal coralline sand just behind the reef fringe of Long Island, Chesterfield Reefs (Pacific Ocean), exhibits extreme secondary dimorphism. Males have developed primary clavae that are much thicker and three times longer than those present in females. Furthermore, the male primary clavae have an accordion-like outer structure, whereas primary clavae are smooth in females. Other species of Florarctus Delamare-Deboutteville & Renaud-Mornant, 1965 inhabiting the Pacific Ocean were investigated. Males are typically smaller than females, but males of Florarctus heimi Delamare-Deboutteville & Renaud-Mornant, 1965 and females of Florarctus cervinus Renaud-Mornant, 1987 have never been recorded. The Renaud-Mornant collection was re-examined, and type series were analysed. Florarctus heimi and F. cervinus were always found together in the coralline sand of Heron Island (Great Barrier Reef). The animals were kept alive and surveyed in the laboratory of the Queensland Museum. All studied individuals of the larger F. heimi (up to ca. 400 μm) were females, and all adults of the smaller F. cervinus (about 170 μm) were males. Males of F. cervinus were observed mating with females of F. heimi. Following those morphological and behavioural lines of evidence, we propose that F. cervinus is a junior synonym of F. heimi. Based on the discovery of dimorphism in F. bellahelenae sp. nov. and the strong sex-related morphological disparities in F. heimi, we suggest that extreme secondary dimorphism may be present in other florarctin arthrotardigrades.


Introduction
Meiofauna comprises microscopic animals (Schmidt-Rhaesa 2020), some of which were often referred to as "smaller neglected phyla" (e.g. Kershaw 1983;Blaxter et al. 2004). This is probably because meiofauna has been largely understudied in many aspects, such as the lack of biodiversity surveys and the unknown overall species richness (Curini-Galletti et al. 2012), through uncertain conservation needs (Roberts et al. 2002;Martínez et al. 2020), to obscure role in ecosystem functioning (Schratzberger and Ingels 2018). In tardigrades, there has been an additional bias towards studying limno-terrestrial lineages, while marine taxa have been left relatively unexplored (Bartels et al. 2016).
Unsurprisingly, mating, copulation and related sexual reproduction behaviours remain generally poorly investigated for most meiofaunal organisms. There is a single report on Kinorhyncha (Neuhaus and Higgins 2002), two studies on Gastrotricha (Ruppert 1978a(Ruppert , 1978b, and a few studies on monogonont Rotifera (Gilbert 1963;Rico-Martínez and Snell 1997;Velázquez-Rojas et al. 2002;Rico-Martínez and Walsh 2013) and Tardigrada, although restricted to limno-terrestrial species (Bingemer et al. 2016;Sugiura et al. 2019; Bartel and Hohberg 2020). Representatives of other phyla, such as Loricifera (Kristensen 1983) or Gnathostomulida (Sterrer and Sørensen 2015), have never been observed while mating. Mating-associated behaviours in microscopic metazoans are a tabula rasa, despite the anatomy of reproductive system, and especially of parts presumed to be involved in copulation being an important character used in the systematics of some phyla, such as Gnathostomulida (Sterrer 1972) or Tardigrada (Degma and Guidetti 2018). Moreover, species identification in marine heterotardigrades also relies on genital anatomy (Kristensen and Hallas 1980;D'Addabbo Gallo et al. 1989;Kristensen and Higgins 1989;Pollock 1995;Bartels et al. 2018). Given that the genital traits have been extensively utilised in systematics, unravelling the ethological background of courtship and reproduction may likewise provide an insight into the classification of animals (e.g. Thiel and Duffy 2007).
In contrast to the exclusively microscopic tardigrades and loriciferans, the reproductive biology of phyla comprising both macrofauna and microfauna has been more thoroughly investigated and includes studies into the sexual dimorphism and parental care in annelids (Jouin 1968;Sella and Ramella 1999), mating behaviours in free-living planktonic nematodes and copepods (Jensen 1982;Uchima and Murano 1988;Buskey 1998), insemination in microscopic annelids and gastropods (Westheide 1978;Jörger et al. 2009), copulation in kalyptorhynchs and chaetognaths (Nagasawa 1985;Doe and Smith 2016) and parental care in amphipods and hermaphroditic polyclads (Thiel 1999;Rawlinson et al. 2008). The wide array of the reproductive biology topics unstudied, or poorly studied, in tardigrades means that we still lack even basic knowledge about reproduction in this group (Altiero et al. 2018).
Marine tardigrades belong predominantly to the class Heterotardigrada (Hansen 2011;Fontoura et al. 2017), with few representatives of the Eutardigrada inhabiting the sea (Ramazzotti 1972;Tsurusaki 1980;Kristensen 1982;Gąsiorek et al. 2019;Hansen and Kristensen 2020). Heterotardigrades have the gonopore separated from anus (Dewel et al. 1993;Møbjerg et al. 2018) and can be either gonochoristic (Jørgensen et al. 2014) or hermaphroditic (Suzuki and Kristensen 2014) taxa, the latter represented by only one species, Orzeliscus belopus du Bois Reymond Marcus, 1952 so far. Pacific florarctins (Halechiniscidae) have been the subject of systematic faunistic studies (Delamare-Deboutteville and Renaud-Mornant 1965;Renaud-Mornant 1967, 1989Kristensen 1984;Noda 1987;Chang and Rho 1997;Jørgensen et al. 2014;Bartels et al. 2015;Fujimoto 2015). This subfamily is particularly interesting due to the presence of epicuticular vesicles with endosymbiotic bacteria (Kristensen 1984), and a broad spectrum of sexual dimorphism, as sex-collection, is the goal of the present paper in Ligiarctus Renaud- Mornant, 1982(Gomes-Júnior et al. 2018 and Wingstrandarctus Kristensen, 1984(Kristensen 1984 but well marked in Florarctus Delamare-Deboutteville & Renaud-Mornant, 1965(Renaud-Mornant 1989. Sexspecific differences have been described in recent papers about Florarctus from the Ionian Sea and the Caribbean (Hansen et al. 2016;Anguas-Escalante et al. 2020). In this paper, we elaborate on the sexual dimorphism and provide a detailed description of mating behaviour, in this mostly subtropical-tropical genus (e.g. Renaud-Mornant 1976; Gallo et al. 2007), observed in specimens collected from the Great Barrier Reef. This inclined us to summarise current knowledge regarding mating in tardigrades. As a corollary of our results, we conclude that descriptions of new arthrotardigrades belonging to genera with known sexually dimorphic species, and represented by only a single sex within samples, should be avoided as this may deepen the confusion in systematics caused by synonymies resulting from incomplete works.

Material and methods
In May of 1979, Niels Svennevig collected 12 samples of coralline sand from different coral reefs along the east coast of Australia and the Chesterfield Islands in the Coral Sea. The samples were collected from the surface of the sediments while diving at 2 m depth, and subsequently bulk fixed in 4% neutralised formaldehyde. Five years later, in the laboratory of the University of Copenhagen, tardigrades were extracted in fresh water by decanting the detritus from the samples through mermaid-bra nets with a mesh size of 30 μm and 62 μm. All the investigated samples contained arthrotardigrades, including specimens belonging to the genus Wingstrandarctus (Kristensen 1984) and material from an atypical, undescribed species of Florarctus. The description of this last species, 40 years after its collection, is the goal of the present paper. Finally, new material of Florarctus heimi Delamare-Deboutteville & Renaud- Mornant, 1965and Florarctus cervinus Renaud-Mornant, 1987was collected from Shark Bay, Heron Island, between 1995and 1996(Kristensen 2003. Type material of these species was borrowed by Hansen (2011) from the National Museum of Natural History in Paris, where Jeanne Renaud-Mornant had held the position of curator of Tardigrada.
The detailed drawings of specimens on microslides were made based on specimens mounted in distilled water using a camera lucida. The water was subsequently replaced with glycerol, following an increased concentration series (5%, 10%, 25%, 50% and 100%), by placing the new media on the side of the microscope slide coverslip. After the process, the animals were removed from the camera lucida slide, immersed in 100% glycerol or polyvinyl lactophenol (PVL; female NHMD-636745) and sealed using Glyceel®. The specimens on the microslides were studied using a light microscope with phase (PCM) or Nomarski (DIC) interference contrast. Micrographs were taken using an Olympus C-3030 zoom digital camera mounted either on an Olympus BX51 or on a Leica DM-RXA microscope. By drawing the specimens in distilled water, we were able to examine many structures that are otherwise invisible in glycerol-mounted material, and usually only reported from transmission electron microscopy (TEM) observations. These structures include different glands ("one-celled" glands, head glands, segmental ventral/dorsal glands and the two vesicles with symbiotic bacteria) and elements of the bucco-pharyngeal apparatus (stylets, placoids). The terminology follows Fontoura et al. (2017).

Systematic account
Phylum: Tardigrada Doyère, 1840 Class: Heterotardigrada Marcus, 1927Order: Arthrotardigrada Marcus, 1927* Family: Halechiniscidae Thulin, 1928(amended by Fujimoto et al. 2017 Subfamily: Florarctinae Renaud-Mornant, 1982 (amended by Kristensen 1984) Amended diagnosis: Halechiniscids with cuticular aliform expansions (alae) with or without caestus. Cephalic sense organs without tertiary clavae, strong secondary dimorphism in the primary clavae, secondary clavae transformed to domeshaped papillae or H-shaped flat sacs. Usually, two to three cephalic vesicles containing symbiotic bacteria. Ventral segmental glands in all segments, opening near the insertion of coxae of the legs. Six to seven pairs of epidermal "one-cell" glands in total, found in the head and in the trunk. Four toes with claws present in adults, digitus externus with a hookshaped pedunculus; uncus with calcar externum, digitus internus with a simple hook-shaped claw bearing a tiny dorsal spur. Males with ovoid gonopore close to anus. Females always with two seminal receptacles, each consisting of a spheroid vesicle with spermatozoa and an S-shaped genital duct opening laterally with a small papilla (anterior or posterior), entirely separated from the six-lobed (hexpartite/rosette) female gonopore. Anus three-lobed.
*Arthrotardigrada are a paraphyletic group with respect to the monophyletic Echiniscoidea (Fujimoto et al. 2017), and their systematic rank as an order is maintained herein only traditionally.
Etymology: From Latin bella (masc. bellus) = beautiful + Helen; noun in genitive singular. The specific epithet has a twofold sense as (1) it honours Helene Møbjerg Boslev Kristensen for all the travels she has undertaken with us to collect tardigrades around the world; (2) Helen was the abducted queen of Sparta, sworn to prince Paris of Troy by Aphrodite. The morphology of F. bellahelenae strongly suggests that males, using their enormously long primary clavae, spend a substantial part of their life searching for (beautiful) females, as the Achaeans did in order to reclaim Helen, which ultimately resulted in the downfall of Troy.
The body of the female is 149 μm long and 87 μm wide. Cuticle smooth, regularly (metamerically) folded on the dorsal side. The head (Figs. 1 and 2) is distinct from the trunk and has the following set of sense organs: cephalic cirri and clavae; the primary clavae (chemoreceptors) have a standard length (61 μm), and their shape is as in all other florarctin species. The median cirrus (mc, 19 μm) arises middorsally and is placed distally to the anterior margin of the head, which has a very large rostral ala (ra). Three gland cells are located at the base of the median cirrus (rg, Fig. 1), as in the allotype (see below). The internal cirri (31 μm) are placed dorsally, partly outside the rostral ala (ra). The external cirri (24 μm) are smaller and located ventrally. Cirrus A is difficult to measure, because it is covered by the primary clava, but its length is ca. 38 μm. The secondary clavae are fused (sc) and can be clearly observed from the ventral side in the holotype. The two vesicles with bacteria (vc) are very large. All four legs have setae (se 1 to se 4 ). The seta on the fourth leg has a blunt tip and is not spine-shaped. Cirrus E consists of a large cirrophore, a well-developed scapus with a characteristic spiral structure and a long flagellum. The flagellum comprises two parts: an internal layer, with a diameter almost the same as the scapus, and an external part, which is observable only under PCM. The entire cirrus is 35 μm long. As in many florarctin tardigrades, there are two particularly large lateral vesicles, containing symbiotic bacteria in all females (vc, Fig. 1). The two large unicellular structures (hg = head gland) and the three dorsal segmental glands (dg) cannot be observed in ventral view in the holotype. However, the ventral segmental glands (vg) are visible in the head and in all four trunk segments. In the trunk, the glands open close to the coxae. Only one pair of refractive glands, called "one-cell" epidermal glands (og, Figs. 1 and 5e), is present in the head of the holotype; however, five pairs exist in the trunk. The bucco-pharyngeal apparatus is more visible in the allotype.
The legs consist of coxa, femur, tibia and tarsus. The claws have unique structures found only in florarctins. A dorsal spur is present only on the internal claws, whereas each external claw has an avicularium appearing as a small notch, and a prominent dorsal calcar. Strong hook-shaped peduncles are seen at the base of the external digits in all leg pairs. The hooks of the peduncles are partly inserted in the tarsus. The female reproductive system is fully mature. Only one large oocyte (ov) appears to mature at a time. Two seminal receptacles (rs) are filled with mature spermatozoa. The efferent genital ducts originating from these round vesicles are S-shaped and open, as two small papillae, posterolaterally from the six-lobed female gonopore. The female gonopore is located distally (20 μm) to the posterioventral trilobed anus.
The alae consist of a very large rostral ala (ra) and two lateral alae, where the first and second lateral alae (la 1 and la 2 ) are clearly separated by a fold, and la 1 is further divided into two unequal parts, hence the lateral alae are labelled as la 1 to la 3 . The caudal ala is well developed and consists of four lobes. There are four pairs of caesti (c 1 to c 4 ): anterolateral c 1 at the level of legs I, and c 2 between legs II and III; posterolateral c 3 between legs III and IV; and simple (not ramified) caudal caesti c 4 (caesti do not extend laterally to the external edge of the alae; Fig. 1). These structures comprise both epicuticle with pillars, and procuticle (see Kristensen 1984). A new feature in F. bellahelenae is the long supporting structure in the first lateral ala (la 1 ) seen in both the holotypic female and the allotypic male. This new structure, the head ala support (ha), consists of the procuticle that extends to the external edge of the ala. The head ala support is located just in front of the first caestus (c 1 ).
A similar structure appears to be present in the posterior part of the first lateral ala and forms the boundary between la 1 and la 2 .
The body of the allotype is 85 μm long and 61 μm wide. The head and peribuccal cirri (Figs. 3, 4 and 5a) are identical to those in the holotypic female; however, the primary clavae are much thicker and nearly three times longer (157 μm) than those in the holotypic female (61 μm) and are thereby completely different from all other florarctin species or any other marine heterotardigrades. Furthermore, the allotypic primary clavae have an accordion-like outer structure (Fig. 5b), not seen previously in any arthrotardigrade. The median cirrus (mc, 19 μm) arises middorsally and is distant from the anterior margin of the head, N is the number of structures measured which has a very large rostral ala (ra). At the base of the median cirrus, there are two to four rostral gland cells (more clearly seen in the holotypic female) (rg, Figs. 1 and 5d). The internal cirri (31 μm) are placed dorsally, and part of the scapus (sp) and the entire flagellum (fl) extend beyond the rostral ala (ra). The external cirri are shorter (24 μm) and located ventrally. The cirrus A length is about 28 μm. The secondary clavae are fused but cannot be observed from the dorsal side. The fourth leg seta (se 4 ) may be modified by having a blunt tip. Cirrus E is the same as in the female holotype (Fig. 5c). The whole structure is 44 μm long.
There are two small lateral vesicles containing symbiotic bacteria (vc, Fig. 3). Totally unique in the head of the allotype are two large unicellular structures (hg = head glands) similar to the dorsal segmental glands (dg) seen in the trunk. Although only three pairs  (Fig. 5e, f).
The pharyngeal bulb has three large apodemes in front of the three straight placoids. The placoids are short and slender. Unfortunately, all pharyngeal structures dissolved in the glycerol preparation.
The reproductive system comprises a small testis and two large seminal vesicles with two ventral ducts opening directly into the oval male gonopore located anteriorly of the trilobed anus. The gonopore/anus distance is very small (2.5 μm). The seminal vesicles contain only about 100 late-stage spermatids with the characteristic wheat grain-shaped head. The tail (flagellum) in the spermatids is difficult to observe as the final stage of the male germ cells (spermatozoa) only develops in the female seminal receptacles.
Alae arranged as in the holotype. The first lateral ala is divided into two almost equal sections, with the anterior section the longest. Caesti inside the alae consist of single, unbranched projections (c 1 -c 4 ). The head ala support (ha) is present, but it is indistinct and does not appear to extend through the full width of the ala.

Differential diagnosis
The absence of any form of mammiliform sculpture on the dorsal cuticle (smooth with only metameric folds in Florarctus bellahelenae sp. nov.) and the presence of   While establishing the genus Florarctus, Delamare-Deboutteville and Renaud-Mornant (1965) made a detailed description of its type species Florarctus heimi. However, due to the lack of other comparable congeneric species (except for Florarctus salvati Delamare-Deboutteville and Renaud-Mornant, 1965 described therein), some details were not studied attentively. The holotypic female is in the early stage of moulting. The new alae are captured during formation and lie folded beneath the old dorsal cuticle, along the lateral margin of the body. Neither new claws nor new sense organs are recognisable. The complete shape of the secondary clavae is evident as a large sense plate, almost completely encircling the mouth cone (Fig. 10a). The internal cirri are well developed, being proportionally much larger than in other congeneric species (Fig. 10b). Also, the fourth leg sense organ, which is usually an S-shaped papilla, is a long tapering spine (longer than cirrus E) with a basal swelling and a terminal pore (Fig.  10c). Each external claw has a strong avicularium and a large calcar, whereas each internal claw has a thin accessory hook and a long delicate calcar. Furthermore, each internal claw has a small but evident avicularium appearing as a small notch (Fig. 10d). The lateral caesti, which are poorly visible in the holotype, are more apparent in the paratype. Like in F. antillensis, the lateral caesti are continuous along the margin of the body, with only a few relatively small processes. The caudal ala is highly complex, although no caestus is evident. A deep median incision divides the ala into two large ; e, f buccopharyngeal apparatus (female and male in distilled water, respectively). List of abbreviations: cf, cirrophore; fc, furca; fl, flagellum; hg, head gland; og, "one-cell" epidermal gland; pb, pharynx; rg, rostral gland; sp, scapus. Scale bars in μm lobes. Each lobe terminates in two long and three short spines. The caudal ala spines are not evidently serrated in the holotype, whereas they are clearly serrated in the paratype. Each spine originates near the base of the ala: the short spines as internal string-like thickenings, and the long spines as broad thickenings (Fig. 10e). The paratype is in the late stage of moulting. As in the holotype, the new alae are formed and lie folded beneath the old dorsal cuticle, along the lateral margin of the body. Interestingly, the new caudal ala and spines are not folded. Instead, the new caudal ala has an orientation opposite to that of the old caudal ala, with the spines pointing anteriorly. New legs and claws are also evident. Examination of the Australian specimens collected from Heron Island allowed us to describe not only the bucco-pharyngeal apparatus but also the male of Florarctus heimi. The stylets are thin and have large furcae; the placoids are large and curved. Three large and equally sized apophyses that appear as one highly refractive bulb are inserted anteriorly to the placoids (Figs. 6 and 7). Observations were also made of live individuals, some of which were found copulating. Surprisingly, the morphology of the males of Florarctus heimi cannot be distinguished from that of Florarctus cervinus. Based on this finding, we establish Florarctus cervinus as synonymum novum of Florarctus heimi. In conclusion, the descriptions of these two species, which were based on apparent morphological differences, in reality, represent the strong secondary sexual dimorphism displayed by Florarctus heimi. Consequently, the type material of Florarctus cervinus (holotypic male [MNHN, Paris, AR593] and two paratypes [MNHN, Paris, AR594, MA6/549Ma]) is included in the type material of Florarctus heimi, thus re-designating the holotype as the allotype. As we had the opportunity for the first time to compare males and females of Florarctus heimi, the most important sexually dimorphic differences are highlighted below. The anterior margin of the rostral (frontal) ala is approximately straight in the female, whereas in the male, it has a median indentation, forming two lobes. The configuration of the lateral alae is the same in both sexes; however, the posterior lateral ala is proportionally larger in the female (compare Figs. 6 and 8 with Figs. 7 and 9). The caudal ala represents the most conspicuous difference, with the female having four long spines and six short spines (Figs. 6, 8 and 10e) and the male having only four long spines (Figs. 7 and 9). Furthermore, the caudal ala of the female is larger and has a deep medial indentation giving the impression there are two lobes. The caudal ala of the male has less deep and broadly ovate median indentation compared to that of the female (compare Figs. 6 and 7).
Differential diagnosis Florarctus heimi is currently the only representative of the genus characterised by caudal ala with long serrated spines.  Fig. 3) in Florarctus bellahelenae sp. nov., and not three as in Wingstrandarctus (Kristensen 1984). As Ligiarctus was inferred to be the sister group of the remaining florarctins (Hansen 2011), it is hypothesised that the additional vesicle is an apomorphy of Wingstrandarctus.

Mating behaviours and copulation
A summary of knowledge relating to tardigrade pre-mating, mating and copulatory behaviours is presented in Table 2. Strong sexual dimorphism in eutardigrades is rare and restricted to modifications of the claws on the first leg pair in males, an adaption for holding females during mating (Rebecchi and Nelson 1998;Gąsiorek et al. 2019). Recently, detailed descriptions of mating positions and sexual reproduction behaviours have been provided for representatives of Isohypsibiidae and Macrobiotidae. These observations, together with the first notes on the enticing actions males perform to initiate courtship in Batillipes noerrevangi Kristensen, 1978(Kristensen 1979, indicate an active role for males. The probability of internal fertilisation was hypothesised for macrobiotids based on the position of the spermatheca with respect to the rectum (Sugiura et al. 2019). Elsewhere, the reproductive system of all marine tardigrades had been thoroughly investigated (Pollock 1970;Renaud-Mornant 1982). However, there was a problem with the interpretation of the so-called "annex glands" in the family Stygarctidae and the lateral vesicles in the subfamily Florarctinae. Transmission electron microscopy investigations clearly showed that both the "annex glands" and the lateral vesicles are seminal receptacles (Kristensen 1984); thus, all arthrotardigrades likely exhibit internal  Gallo 1975). Importantly, the two seminal receptacles are surrounded with cuticle so oocytes can be fertilised when a female lays freshly formed eggs into it: one in Actinarctus (Jørgensen et al. 1999) or Florarctus (Hansen et al. 2016) and up to eight eggs in Tetrakentron (Kristensen  Kristensen, pers. obs.). Mating ending with internal fertilisation, both in a stygarctid and in a florarctin, has been referred to as "venter-to-venter".

Taxonomy
Males are typically smaller than females in florarctins. The fact that males of F. heimi and females of F. cervinus were previously unknown, combined with the fact that both species were described from New Caledonia, should have raised some doubts regarding potential conspecificity. In December 1995, during the Australian summer, large populations of a Florarctus species were found in coralline sand collected subtidally in Shark Bay, Heron Island (the southern Great Barrier Reef). Analysis revealed two species were present, Florarctus heimi and F. cervinus, and that they were always found together. In vivo observations revealed that all specimens of the larger F. heimi (up to about 400 μm) were females. In contrast, all adults of the smaller F. cervinus (about 170 μm) were males. The differences in the caudal expansions of alae between the two putative species were congruent with the original descriptions. Moreover, males of F. cervinus were observed mating with females of F. heimi.
In conclusion, the morphological and behavioural evidence indicates that F. cervinus is a junior synonym of F. heimi. It is known for other microscopic animals that describing species based on individuals of a single sex might lead to an inflation of the number of species (e.g. Karanovic 2008). Only molecular data could most objectively test the assertion of their conspecificity, analogously to actions undertaken by crustacean specialists in the copepod order Monstrilloida (Jeon et al. 2018) to link sexes of one species. As a consequence, new marine heterotardigrades with strongly sexually dimorphic traits should not be described based on individuals of one sex, if only to avoid future synonymies.

Biogeography
The vast majority of records of Florarctus fall within two regions: warm oceans and warm-temperate provinces (Briggs and Bowen 2012). There are only two reports of Florarctus species (Florarctus acer Renaud- Mornant, 1989 and Florarctus hulingsi Renaud-Mornant, 1976) from cold waters of the Bay of Morlaix, North Atlantic Ocean (Renaud-Mornant and Gourbault 1980;Renaud-Mornant 1989). All records of Florarctus published since the last summary of marine tardigrade zoogeography (Kaczmarek et al. 2015) originate from tropical or subtropical areas (Fujimoto 2015;Bartels et al. 2018;Anguas-Escalante et al. 2020); therefore, we hypothesise that such clear temperature-driven regionalisation of an entire genus of marine tardigrades is uncommon; however, it has never been rigorously tested. If positively verified, such regionalisation would appear unusual as the species composition of marine tardigrade communities changes with depth (Hansen et al. 2001), exhibiting bathymetric-dependent diversity and endemicity patterns known for other animals (Rex 1973(Rex , 1981.
There are five Florarctus species: F. antillensis, F. asper Renaud- Mornant, 1989, F. cinctus Renaud-Mornant, 1976, F. hulingsi and F. stellatus Renaud-Mornant, 1989, that are characterised by very wide distributions, always embracing many records from t he relati vel y well -sampled Mediterranean region and usually only some tropical locales (Kaczmarek et al. 2015). This situation seems incongruous given the recently revealed species complex in the genus Batillipes (Santos et al. 2019) from the Atlantic Ocean and the Mediterranean. Consequently, geographic ranges should be better documented in tardigrades if claims, for example that species occurring in both the Mediterranean and the Coral Sea are the same, are to be supported. In the light of this, a single report of F. heimi from the Maldives (Gallo et al. 2007) raises concerns about the validity of that identification, particularly as it was not supported by a more elaborate description. The presence of F. heimi in the Indian Ocean should therefore be treated with caution. A lack of taxonomic knowledge relating to the delineation of morphologically similar species similarly contributed to misleadingly wide geographic ranges in some marine animals (e.g. Cerca et al. 2020). Conversely, evidence from other meiofaunal groups supports a cosmopolitan distribution in many cases (e.g. Meyer-Wachsmuth et al.

2014).
Supplementary Information Live male of Florarctus heimi collected in Shark Bay, Heron Island; Australia. The male just after mating with a female. One of the primary clavae is broken after the copulation. The online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi. org/10.1007/s12526-021-01183-y.

Declarations
Conflict of interest The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Ethical approval All applicable international, national and/or institutional guidelines for animal testing, animal care and use of animals were followed by the authors.
Sampling and field studies All necessary permits for sampling and observational field studies were obtained by the authors from the competent authorities and are mentioned in the Acknowledgements. The study is compliant with CBD and Nagoya protocols.
Data availability All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files.
Author contribution RMK conceived and designed the research. DMK and RMK conducted the sampling and field observations. PG and RMK analysed the data. All authors wrote, read and approved the manuscript.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.