Interactive Effects of Copper Sources and a High Level of Phytase in Phosphorus-Deficient Diets on Growth Performance, Nutrient Digestibility, Tissue Mineral Concentrations, and Plasma Parameters in Nursery Pigs

The present study investigated the interactive effects of copper sources and a high level of phytase on growth performance, nutrient digestibility, tissue mineral concentrations, and plasma parameters in nursery pigs. Weaning piglets (N = 192; 6.06 ± 0.99 kg), blocked by body weight, were randomly allotted to 1 of 4 dietary treatments, with 12 pens per treatment and 4 pigs per pen. A basal diet for each phase was formulated to meet nutrient requirements for nursery pigs with the exception that standardized total tract digestibility (STTD) P was reduced by 0.12% and Ca was adjusted to achieve Ca/STTD P = 2.15. The 4 dietary treatments were arranged in a 2 × 2 factorial design, with 2 Cu sources (125 mg/kg Cu from copper methionine hydroxy analogue chelate (Cu-MHAC) or copper sulfate (CuSO4)) and 2 phytase levels (0 or 1500 phytase units (FTU)/kg). Results showed that there was an interaction (P < 0.05) between Cu sources and phytase on ADG during days 0–41. When phytase was not present in the diets (P deficient), there was no difference between the two Cu sources in terms of ADG during days 0–41, whereas with phytase in the diets, Cu-MHAC tended to improve (P < 0.10) ADG during days 0–41 compared with CuSO4. Pigs fed Cu-MHAC had greater apparent total tract digestibility (ATTD) of neutral and acid detergent fiber and STTD of P than those fed CuSO4. Phytase increased (P < 0.05) growth performance, ATTD of Ca and P, and plasma inositol and growth hormone concentrations. In conclusion, Cu-MHAC may be more effective in improving growth rate than CuSO4 when phytase was supplemented at 1500 FTU/kg. Cu-MHAC enhanced fiber and P digestibility regardless of phytase, compared with CuSO4. Phytase addition in P-deficient diets was effective in improving growth performance, Ca and P digestibility, and plasma inositol and growth hormone concentrations.


Introduction
High levels of copper sulfate (CuSO 4 , 150 to 250 mg/kg Cu) are widely used in nursery pigs to promote growth and improve feed efficiency [1]. It has been demonstrated that chelated Cu is more bioavailable in both chickens and pigs than CuSO 4 [2,3]. Supplementation of Cu as Cu-citrate (125 mg/kg Cu) or Cu-proteinate (100 mg/kg Cu) has been shown to achieve similar growth performance in nursery pigs as CuSO 4 supplementation at 250 mg/kg Cu [4,5]. Similarly, supplementation of copper methionine hydroxy analogue chelate achieved greater average daily gain and feed efficiency in nursery or grow-finish pigs compared with pigs fed CuSO 4 or tribasic copper chloride at equivalent Cu levels [6][7][8][9].
Copper sulfate is easily dissociated in the acidic pH in the stomach, allowing Cu to interact with phytate and resulting in the formation of Cu-phytate complexes [10,11]. These complexes could impair phytase efficacy, resulting in lower P release from the phytate molecule [11,12]. An in vitro model has demonstrated that Cu lysine is less inhibitive to phytase compared with CuSO 4 [11]. Our recent data also suggests that Cu-MHAC may enhance phytase efficacy on bone mineralization in nursery pigs when 500 FTU/kg phytase is used, compared with CuSO 4 [9]. However, there is no data on the interaction of copper source and phytase supplementation at high levels on growth performance and mineral digestibility in pigs. It is hypothesized that Cu-MHAC could enhance the efficacy of phytase at 1500 FTU/kg on growth performance and mineral digestibility in nursery pigs, compared with CuSO 4 . Therefore, the objective of this study is to investigate the interactive effects of copper sources and phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg on growth performance, nutrient digestibility, tissue mineral concentrations, and plasma parameters.

Experimental Design and Dietary Treatments
At weaning (day 0), piglets were weighed individually and allotted to 1 of 4 dietary treatments according to a randomized complete block design, which was blocked by initial BW. There were 12 pens per treatment and 4 pigs per pen. A basal diet for each phase was formulated to meet the energy and nutrient requirements for different stages of pigs according to the recommendation by NRC [13], with the exception that standardized total tract digestibility (STTD) P was reduced by 0.12% and Ca level was adjusted to meet the fixed ratio of Ca to STTD P of 2.15. The 4 dietary treatments were arranged in a 2 × 2 factorial design (Table 1), with 2 Cu sources (125 ppm Cu from copper methionine hydroxy analogue chelate (Cu-MHAC, MINTREX® Cu, Novus International, Inc., St. Charles, MO, USA) or CuSO 4 (Old Bridge Chemicals, Inc., Old Bridge, NJ, USA), respectively) and 2 phytase levels (0 or 1500 FTU/kg phytase (PHYTAVERSE®, Novus International, Inc., St. Charles, MO, USA)). The basal diet composition for the 3 phases is presented in Table 2.

Measurements and Sample Collection
Piglet body weights (BW) were measured at the initiation of the study (day 0) and at the end of each phase (days 14, 28, and 41). Feed addition to each feeder was recorded each time when the feed was added to the feeder. At the end of each phase, the remaining feed in the feeder was weighed. Average daily gain (ADG), average daily feed intake (ADFI), and gainto-feed ratio (G:F) were calculated for each phase and the entire nursery period.
Fresh fecal samples were collected via grab sampling from each pig in each pen twice a day from days 36 to 41. The fecal samples were stored at − 20°C immediately after collection. At the end of sample collection, fecal samples within each pen were thawed, homogenized, and immediately placed in a heated oven (NHP-PD-ECO, Win-Holt, Woodbury, NY, USA) at 65°C for 48 h. All dried fecal samples were ground using a rotor mill (PULVERISETTE 14, Fritsch GmbH, Idar-Oberstein, Germany) fitted with a 1-mm screen. Ground feces were thoroughly homogenized, and a subsample was collected for chemical analysis.
At the end of the study (day 42), one pig from each pen with the BW closest to the average BW of the pen was selected and approximately 7 ml of blood samples was collected via jugular puncture, followed by euthanasia using captive bolt. The blood samples were centrifuged at 1500 × g at 4°C for 15 min to obtain plasma samples. The third metacarpal samples were collected from selected pigs. Liver (approximately 50 g of the right lobe) and kidney (approximately 50 g of the right kidney) samples were collected in the selected pigs. The metacarpal, liver, and kidney samples were stored at − 20°C until chemical analysis.

Chemical and Biological Analyses
Diets and feces samples were analyzed for dry matter (DM, method 934.01), Ca (method 985.01), P (method 985.01), Zn (method 985.01), and Cu (method 985.01) according to AOAC [14]. Phytase activity in the diets was analyzed according to ISO [15]. Gross energy was analyzed in diets and feces using an isoperibol bomb calorimeter (Model 6300, Parr Instruments, Moline, IL). Acid detergent fiber (ADF) and neutral detergent fiber (NDF) in diets and feces were analyzed using ANKOM Technology method 12 and 13, respectively (ANKOM 2000 Fiber Analyzer, ANKOM Technology, Macedon, NY). Titanium concentration in phase 3 diets and fecal samples was analyzed according to the procedures described by Myers et al. [16]. Plasma samples were used for malondialdehyde (MDA) analysis, which was quantified using thiobarbituric acid reactive substances assay kit 10009055 (Cayman Chemical Company, Ann Arbor, MI). Plasma inositol was measured using myo-inositol assay kit from Megazyme (Wicklow, Ireland). Growth hormone and insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) concentrations were measured using porcine growth hormone enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kit from MyBioSource (San Diego, CA) and porcine IGF-1 ELISA kit, respectively.
Metacarpal, liver, and kidney samples were ashed in a muffle furnace at 600°C overnight in porcelain crucibles. The concentrations of ash, Ca, P, Zn, and Cu in metacarpal, liver, and kidney samples were determined using the procedure  [14]. Ash, Ca, and P percentages in metacarpal samples were expressed as grams of ash, Ca, and P per 100 g of dry, fat-free metacarpal weight, respectively.

Calculations
The apparent total tract digestibility (ATTD) coefficient for Ca and P in each treatment was calculated according to equations proposed by NRC [13]. Standardized total tract digestibility of Ca and P were calculated by accounting for endogenous losses of Ca (330 mg/kg dry matter intake) [17] and P (190 mg/kg dry matter intake) [13], respectively.
Statistical Analysis SAS® 9.4 (SAS Inst. Inc., Gary, NC) was used for all data analysis. Pen served as the experimental unit. The LSMEANS statement was used to calculate the least square means. The Tukey-Kramer adjustment was used for multiple comparisons of the least square means. Pooled SEM was calculated for each measurement. A probability of P ≤ 0.05 was considered as significant and 0.05 < P ≤ 0.10 was declared as a trend. The GLIMMIX procedure was used to analyze all the data. Copper source, phytase level, and their interaction were considered as the fixed effects, whereas block was considered as the random effect. All the data were analyzed using default normal regression model.

Effect of Cu Sources and Phytase on Growth Performance
Pigs fed diets containing Cu-MHAC tended (P < 0.10) to have greater G:F during days 0-14, compared with those fed diets containing CuSO 4 ( Table 3). Pigs fed diets containing 1500 FTU/kg phytase had greater (P < 0.05) ADG, ADFI, and G:F during all phases, except for G:F during days 28-41, compared with those fed diets without phytase.
There was an interaction (P < 0.05) between Cu sources and phytase in terms of BW on day 41. When phytase was not present in the diets (P deficient), there was no difference between the two Cu sources in terms of BW on day 41. In contrast, when phytase was included in the diets, Cu-MHAC tended to have greater (P < 0.10) BW on day 41 than CuSO 4 . Similarly, there was an interaction (P < 0.05) between Cu sources and phytase on ADG during days 0-41. When phytase was not present in the diets (P deficient), there was no difference between the two Cu sources in terms of ADG during days 0-41. In contrast, when phytase was included in the diets, Cu-MHAC tended to increase (P < 0.10) ADG during days 0-41 compared with CuSO 4 .

Effect of Cu Sources and Phytase on Nutrient Digestibility
The ATTD of NDF and ADF was greater (P < 0.05) in pigs fed diets containing Cu-MHAC compared with pigs fed diets containing CuSO 4 ( Table 4). Pigs fed diets containing Cu-MHAC had greater (P < 0.05) ATTD and STTD of P than those fed diets containing CuSO 4 . Phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg increased (P < 0.01) ATTD of ash, Ca, and P, and STTD of Ca and P, compared with no phytase supplementation. However, phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/ kg resulted in lower (P < 0.05) ATTD of NDF, ADF, and gross energy, compared with no phytase supplementation.

Effect of Cu Source and Phytase on Bone Mineralization
Cu sources did not affect fat-free bone weight, bone ash, Ca, P, Zn, and Cu concentrations from pigs on day 42 (Table 5). Phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg increased (P < 0.05) fat-free bone weight and bone P concentrations compared with no phytase supplementation. Similarly, phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg tended to increase (P < 0.10) bone ash and Ca concentrations compared with no phytase supplementation. However, phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/ kg reduced (P < 0.01) bone Cu concentration compared with no phytase supplementation.

Effect of Cu Source and Phytase on Liver and Kidney Mineral Concentrations
There were no differences (P > 0.10) among the two Cu sources in terms of liver and kidney Cu and Zn concentrations ( Table 6). Phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg reduced (P < 0.01) liver Cu concentration compared with no phytase supplementation. In contrast, phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg resulted in greater (P < 0.05) kidney Cu and Zn concentration compared with no phytase supplementation.

Effect of Cu Source and Phytase on Plasma Parameters
There were no differences (P > 0.10) between the two Cu sources in terms of plasma inositol, TBARS, growth hormone, and IGF-1 concentrations (Table 7). Phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg increased (P < 0.05) plasma inositol and growth hormone concentrations compared with no phytase supplementation.

Discussion
Cu Sources and Its Interaction with Phytase on Growth Performance, Nutrient Digestibility, Tissue Mineral Concentrations, and Plasma Parameters High levels of CuSO 4 (150 to 250 mg/kg Cu) are traditionally used in weaning pig diets to promote growth and improve feed efficiency [1,7,18]. Technology advancement has led to the development of numerous forms of organic Cu, which have been shown to be more bioavailable than CuSO 4 [3]. Studies have demonstrated that Cu-proteinate [5] and Cu-MHAC [6,7,9] achieved greater growth performance in nursery pigs than CuSO 4 at the same Cu inclusion levels, which was further supported by the current study that Cu-MHAC achieved greater average daily gain than CuSO 4 in the presence of phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg. The fact that average daily gain in nursery pigs was not different between Cu-MHAC and CuSO 4 without phytase in the present study indicated that the impact of P deficiency might overshadow the beneficial effect of Cu-MHAC or P deficiency may impair the function and utilization of Cu in the body. Additionally, Cu-citrate yielded similar growth performance as CuSO 4 in nursery pigs at the same inclusion level of Cu [4]. It was also shown that Cu-MHAC led to greater growth performance in nursery pigs than tribasic copper chloride at the same Cu inclusion levels [8]. These studies suggest that Cu sources play a critical role in its function and utilization in the body, thereby affecting growth performance of pigs.
Several modes of action could be responsible for the growth performance benefits by Cu-MHAC supplementation. Firstly, Cu could exert antibacterial effect directly or indirectly via bile salts and therefore modulate gut microbiota [19][20][21]. It was reported that supplementation at 100 mg/kg Cu as Cu-     [20,24]. It can also elevate serum growth hormone and IGF-1, enhance both ghrelin mRNA expression in the fundic region of the stomach and growth hormone-releasing hormone, and suppress somatostatin mRNA expression levels in the hypothalamus [25][26][27]. A recent study conducted by Gonzalez-Esquerra et al. [28] demonstrated that nursery pigs fed Cu-MHAC at 50 mg/kg Cu had increased serum growth hormone concentration than those fed CuSO 4 at 160 mg/kg Cu. However, plasma growth hormone and IGF-1 were not    [2,3,29]. The reduction of Cu-phytate complexes by Cu-MHAC could also improve P digestibility without phytase supplementation compared with CuSO 4 [29]. In contrast, approximately 40 to 50% of Cu in CuSO 4 was formed as insoluble Cu-phytate in the pH range 5.5 to 6.5, which resulted in reduced phytase efficacy to break down the phytate molecule to release P [11]. Indeed, increasing Cu levels as CuSO 4 in the diets containing 600 FTU/kg resulted in a linear reduction of average daily gain, feed efficiency, and apparent P retention rate in broilers [12], which reinforced that CuSO 4 at high inclusion levels could impair phytase efficacy. However, the in vitro model demonstrated that the magnitude of inhibition on phytate hydrolysis by phytase was much less when Cu-lysine was used as Cu source compared with CuSO 4 [11], most likely indicating that a lower level of Cuphytate complex was formed when using chelated Cu source. To the best of our knowledge, the current study was the first study to report increased P digestibility by chelated Cu compared with CuSO 4 in pigs in the presence of phytase. It was not known why the improved P digestibility by Cu-MHAC did not lead to increased bone P compared with CuSO 4 , which warrants further investigation. The improved ADF and NDF digestibility by Cu-MHAC supplementation compared with CuSO 4 could also partially explain the improved growth rate in nursery pigs in this study. It has been reported that Cu supplementation at 10-20 mg/kg could increase NDF digestibility in cashmere goats probably due to enhanced rumen fermentation [30]. It was probable that Cu-MHAC supplementation could increase the number of fiber-degrading gut microbes in pigs, thereby improving fiber digestibility, compared with CuSO 4.

Phytase on Growth Performance, Nutrient Digestibility, Tissue Mineral Concentrations, and Plasma Parameters
The observation that phytase increased growth performance and bone mineralization in pigs was also observed in previous experiments [31][32][33]. The improved growth performance and bone mineralization by phytase supplementation were mainly a result of increased P digestibility [33][34][35], which was consistent with the findings of the current study.
Phytate is negatively charged in aqueous solutions, especially under acidic conditions, which makes the phytate molecule bind other nutrients, including starch, protein, and minerals [36].
Additionally, phytate may bind to endogenous digestive enzymes and thereby reduce their capacity to digest nutrients [37]. As a result, increasing phytate levels in the diets may reduce pepsin activity in weanling pigs [38] and intestinal α-amylase, sucrase, and maltase activities in chickens [39]. Phytase supplementation may result in a step-wise hydrolysis of the phytate molecule, thereby releasing phytate bound P and other nutrients, which may improve the digestibility of these nutrients.
Results of experiments to study phytase supplementation on the ATTD of nutrients and energy have been inconsistent. Increasing the dosage of phytase from 0 to 4000 FTU/kg did not affect the ATTD of dry matter and gross energy in growing pigs fed corn-soybean meal-based diets [40], but a linear increase in the ATTD of dry matter and gross energy was observed if the dosage of phytase was increased in corn-soybean meal diets fed to nursery pigs [41]. Increasing levels of phytase from 0 to 4000 FTU/kg did not affect the ATTD of NDF, but linearly increased the ATTD of ADF by nursery pigs fed corn-soybean meal diets [40]. However, a linear reduction in the ATTD of NDF was observed when phytase supplementation was increased from 0 to 20,000 FTU/kg in nursery pigs fed a cornsoybean meal diet [42], which was consistent with the findings of the current study. Phytase in the current study could reduce Ca and P flow to the hindgut, thereby impairing the microbial fermentation and reducing fiber digestibility [43]. The reduced fiber digestibility may partially explain the reduced energy digestibility by phytase in the present study.
It is well documented that phytase supplementation could increase Zn digestibility and bioavailability in pigs [9,[44][45][46]. However, phytase effect on Cu bioavailability in pigs was inconsistent. Some studies reported phytase supplementation improved Cu digestibility and bioavailability [34,46], whereas other studies showed no response or even negative effect on Cu digestibility and bioavailability in pigs [45][46][47][48]. The amount of Zn release from the phytate complex by phytase supplementation and relative Zn and Cu concentrations in the diets might explain the various responses from different studies. Hill et al. [49] reported the antagonistic effect of excess dietary Zn on Cu availability in pigs. The antagonism between Zn and Cu is primarily mediated through the absorption process, where Zn induces high concentrations of metallothionein in the intestinal mucosa and the binding affinity of metallothionein for Cu is greater than Zn [50,51]. The Cu bound to metallothionein is not absorbed and sloughed with mucosal cells, therefore reducing Cu bioavailability [52]. To our best knowledge, it is the first study to report the increased kidney Cu concentrations caused by phytase supplementation, along with the reduced bone and liver Cu concentrations. It seems that the improved Zn bioavailability caused by phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg not only impacts Cu absorption in the intestinal level but also shifts Cu metabolism and distribution among various tissues, including bone, liver, and kidney. Further studies are warranted to explore this intriguing question.
Numerous studies have reported that phytase supplementation above 1000 FTU/kg could lead to increased plasma inositol concentration in pigs and broilers [53][54][55]. It has been suggested that inositol could stimulate insulin signaling pathway and protein synthesis [56], which may explain the improved growth performance of phytase supplementation above 1000 FTU/kg in pigs and broilers [54,57]. Plasma growth hormone concentration was reduced under phosphorus deficiency in broilers [58,59]. It could be speculated that increased P bioavailability by phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg in the current study may contribute to enhanced pituitary activity and thereby higher growth hormone secretion. The increased plasma inositol and growth hormone may partially explain the improved growth performance by phytase in the present study.
In conclusion, Cu-MHAC led to greater growth rate in nursery pigs than CuSO 4 in the presence of phytase supplementation at 1500 FTU/kg. Cu-MHAC enhanced fiber and P digestibility regardless of phytase in comparison with CuSO 4 . Phytase addition to P-deficient diets was effective in improving growth performance, Ca and P digestibility, and plasma inositol and growth hormone concentrations.
Funding The study was funded by Novus International, Inc.
Data Availability The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest All authors are employees of Novus International, Inc.

Ethics Approval
The animal protocols used in the current study were approved by Novus International, Inc. Animal Ethics Committee.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.