Abstract
Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) is one of the most promising biological control agents used commercially. Its products can contribute to reducing ecological and environmental problems associated with the use of chemical pesticides. Among the limiting factors of using Bt as bioinsecticide are the costs and ensuring its biological activity, which may vary according to the strain and culture conditions. This systematic review aimed to collect state-of-the-art information on the production of Bt endotoxins and to score the methodological feasibility of the data obtained, thus highlighting possible incoherencies. In order to consolidate recent findings and guide future studies, a total of 47 original articles from the last 10 years was analysed, with special attention being given to corroborating data, identifying inconsistencies and suggesting future adjustments so as to increase data reliability. With a maximum score of 8 points, three production parameters were classified on the following scale: preferable (score: 2), adequate (score: 1) and inadequate (score: 0), and another two parameter were classified as adequate (score: 1) or inadequate (score: 0). No article scored more than 6 out of the maximum of 8, thus reflecting the need for more detailed studies regarding Bt endotoxin production. The lack of standardization of methods and units of measurement also have made a comparison of results and an overall analysis difficult. Standards are suggested in the present study. The inclusion of bioassays and quantifying toxin via alkaline dilution are strongly recommended for studies of this nature, along with LC50 expressed in mg/L. Sixteen articles (34%) did not use either of these suggested methods, which indicates the need for further supporting studies. These findings reinforce the need for robust studies in this area, which could include the development of more affordable and effective bioinsecticides, thus increasing their competitiveness against insecticides derived from unsustainable sources.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adjalle KD, Brar SK, Tyagi RD et al (2009a) Photostabilization of Bacillus thuringiensis fermented wastewater and wastewater sludge based biopesticides using additives. Acta Trop 111:7–14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actatropica.2008.11.016
Adjalle KD, Tyagi RD, Brar SK et al (2009b) Recovery of entomotoxicity components from Bacillus thuringiensis fermented wastewater and sludge: ultrafiltration scale-up approach. Sep Purif Technol 69:275–279. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.seppur.2009.08.003
Angelo EA, Vilas-Bôas GT, Castro-Gómez RJH, Lopes J (2015) Utilisation of response surface methodology to optimise the culture medium for Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis. Biocontrol Sci Technol 25:414–428. https://doi.org/10.1080/09583157.2014.983457
Ballardo C, Abraham J, Barrena R et al (2016) Valorization of soy waste through SSF for the production of compost enriched with Bacillus thuringiensis with biopesticide properties. J Environ Manag 169:126–131. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2015.12.029
Ballardo C, Barrena R, Artola A, Sánchez A (2017) A novel strategy for producing compost with enhanced biopesticide properties through solid-state fermentation of biowaste and inoculation with Bacillus thuringiensis. Waste Manag 70:53–58. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2017.09.041
Ben Khedher S, Jaoua S, Zouari N (2011a) Improvement of bioinsecticides production by sporeless Bacillus thuringiensis strains in response to various stresses in low cost medium. Curr Microbiol 62:1467–1477. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00284-011-9884-6
Ben Khedher S, Kamoun A, Jaoua S, Zouari N (2011b) Improvement of Bacillus thuringiensis bioinsecticide production by sporeless and sporulating strains using response surface methodology. New Biotechnol 28:705–712. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nbt.2011.01.008
Ben Khedher S, Jaoua S, Zouari N (2013) Application of statistical experimental design for optimisation of bioinsecticides production by sporeless Bacillus thuringiensis strain on cheap medium. Braz J Microbiol 44:927–933. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1517-83822013000300043
Ben Khedher S, Jaoua S, Zouari N (2014) Overcome of carbon catabolite repression of bioinsecticides production by sporeless Bacillus thuringiensis through adequate fermentation technology. Biotechnol Res Int 2014:1–8. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/698587
Boniolo FS, Rodrigues RC, Prata AMR et al (2012) Oxygen supply in Bacillus thuringiensis fermentations: Bringing new insights on their impact on sporulation and δ-endotoxin production. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 94:625–636. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00253-011-3746-9
Crickmore N (2006) Beyond the spore – past and future developments of Bacillus thuringiensis as a biopesticide. J Appl Microbiol 101:616–619. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2672.2006.02936.x
Devidas PC, Pandit BH, Vitthalrao PS (2014) Evaluation of different culture media for improvement in bioinsecticides production by indigenous Bacillus thuringiensis and their application against larvae of Aedes aegypti. Sci World J. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/273030
El-Bendary MA, Elsoud MMA, Mohamed SS, Hamed SR (2016a) Optimization of mosquitocidal toxins production by Lysinibacillus sphaericus under solid state fermentation using statistical experimental design. Acta Biol Szeged 60:57–63. https://doi.org/10.1080/09583157.2016.1177710
El-Bendary MA, Moharam ME, Mohamed SS, Hamed SR (2016b) Pilot-scale production of mosquitocidal toxins by Bacillus thuringiensis and Lysinibacillus sphaericus under solid-state fermentation. Biocontrol Sci Technol 26:980–994. https://doi.org/10.1080/09583157.2016.1177710
El-Bendary MA, Abo Elsoud MM, Hamed SR, Mohamed SS (2017) Optimization of mosquitocidal toxins production by Bacillus thuringiensis under solid state fermentation using Taguchi orthogonal array. Acta Biol Szeged 61:135–140. https://doi.org/10.1080/09583157.2016.1177710
Ennouri K, Ben Khedher S, Jaoua S, Zouari N (2013a) Correlation between delta-endotoxin and proteolytic activities produced by Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki growing in an economic production medium. Biocontrol Sci Technol 23:756–767. https://doi.org/10.1080/09583157.2013.791364
Ennouri K, Ben HH, Zouari N (2013b) Optimization of bioinsecticides overproduction by Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki using linear regression. Polish J Microbiol 62:287–293
Ennouri K, Ben AR, Ben HH et al (2015) Experimental design and bayesian networks for enhancement of delta-endotoxin production by Bacillus thuringiensis. Acta Microbiol Immunol Hung 62:379–392. https://doi.org/10.1556/030.62.2015.4.3
Ennouri K, Ben Hassen H, Zouari N (2016) Statistical analysis of cultural parameters influencing delta-endotoxins and proteases productions by Bacillus thuringiensis kurstaki. Arab J Sci Eng 41:1–8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13369-015-1722-x
Ennouri K, Ben Hassen H, Zouari N (2017) Nutritional requirements to improve delta-endotoxins production of Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki using mixed designs modelling. Proc Natl Acad Sci India Sect B 87:307–314. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40011-015-0620-z
Ernandes S, del Bianchi VL, Moraes IDO (2013) Evaluation of two different culture media for the development of biopesticides based on Bacillus thuringiensis and their application in larvae of Aedes aegypti. Acta Sci Technol 35:11–18. https://doi.org/10.4025/actascitechnol.v35i1.13831
Eski A, Demir İ, Sezen K, Demirbağ Z (2017) A new biopesticide from a local Bacillus thuringiensis var. tenebrionis (Xd3) against alder leaf beetle (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae). World J Microbiol Biotechnol 33:1–9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11274-017-2263-0
Foda MS, Moharam ME, El-Bendary MA, Kahil T (2009) Overproduction of mosquitocidal toxins of Bacillus thuringiensis serotype 14 on cost effective media. Biosci Biotechnol Res Asia 6:481–488
Greenhalgh T (1997) How to read a paper. Papers that summarise other papers (systematic reviews and meta-analyses). BMJ 315:668–671. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.315.7109.668
Jisha VN, Babysarojam Smitha R, Priji P et al (2015) Biphasic fermentation is an efficient strategy for the overproduction of δ-Endotoxin from Bacillus thuringiensis. Appl Biochem Biotechnol 175:1519–1535. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12010-014-1383-3
Jouzani GS, Abbasalizadeh S, Moradali MF, Morsali H (2015) Development of a cost effective bioprocess for production of an Iranian anti-coleoptera Bacillus thuringiensis strain. J Agric Sci Technol 17:1183–1196
Kim K, Kabir E, Ara S (2017) Science of the total environment exposure to pesticides and the associated human health effects. Sci Total Environ 575:525–535. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.09.009
Mazmira MMM, Ramlah SAA, Rosfarizan M et al (2013) Relationship between total carbon, total nitrogen and carbon to nitrogen ratio on growth, sporulation rate and d-endotoxin synthesis of Bacillus thuringiensis. Minerva Biotecnol 53:411–418
Mounsef JR, Salameh D, Louka N et al (2015) The effect of aeration conditions, characterized by the volumetric mass transfer coefficient K<inf>L</inf>a, on the fermentation kinetics of Bacillus thuringiensis kurstaki. J Biotechnol 210:100–106. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiotec.2015.06.387
Ozcan O, Icgen B, Ozcengiz G (2010) Pretreatment of poultry litter improves Bacillus thuringiensis-based biopesticides production. Bioresour Technol 101:2401–2404. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2009.11.048
Özkan M, Dilek FB, Yetis Ü, Özcengiz G (2003) Nutritional and cultural parameters influencing antidipteran delta-endotoxin production. Res Microbiol 154:49–53. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0923-2508(02)00006-2
Pang JC, Chen ML, Ho YC et al (2010) Effect of fermentation conditions on the enterotoxigenicity, cytotoxicity and pesticidal activity of Bacillus thuringiensis strains isolated in Taiwan. Bioresour Technol 101:1871–1876. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2009.09.090
Patil SR, Amena S, Vikas A et al (2013) Utilization of silkworm litter and pupal waste-an eco-friendly approach for mass production of Bacillus thuringiensis. Bioresour Technol 131:545–547. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2012.12.153
Poopathi S, Abidha S (2009) A medium for the production of Biopesticides (Bacillus sphaericus and Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis) in mosquito control. Biol Microb Control 102:1423–1430
Poopathi S, Abidha S (2011) Coffee husk waste for fermentation production of mosquitocidal bacteria. J Econ Entomol 104:1816–1823. https://doi.org/10.1603/EC11125
Poopathi S, Abidha S (2012) The use of clarified butter sediment waste from dairy industries for the production of mosquitocidal bacteria. Int J Dairy Technol 65:152–157. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-0307.2011.00745.x
Poopathi S, Archana B (2012a) A novel cost-effective medium for the production of Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis for mosquito control. Trop Biomed 29:81–91
Poopathi S, Archana B (2012b) Optimization of medium composition for the production of mosquitocidal toxins from Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis. Indian J Exp Biol 50:65–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2009.11.011
Poopathi S, Archana B (2012c) Wastewater management from slaughterhouse—a new approach to control mosquitoes. Water Air Soil Pollut 223:3263–3270. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11270-012-1107-7
Poopathi S, Archana B (2013) Management of waste product from watermelon for culture and production of mosquitocidal toxins (bio-pesticide). Int J Environ Waste Manag 12:442. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJEWM.2013.056669
Poopathi S, Mani C, Rajeswari G (2013) Potential of sugarcane bagasse (agro-industrial waste) for the production of Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis. Trop Biomed 30:504–515
Rigotto RM, Vasconcelos DP, Rocha MM (2014) Pesticide use in Brazil and problems for public health. Cad Saúde Pública 30:1360–1362
Salazar-Magallon JA, Hernandez-Velazquez VM, Alvear-Garcia A et al (2015) Evaluation of industrial by-products for the production of Bacillus thuringiensis strain GP139 and the pathogenicity when applied to Bemisia tabaci nymphs. Bull Insectol 68:103–109
Saour G, Al-Mariri A, Hashem A (2016) Evaluation of Bacillus thuringiensis cultured in wastewater sludges against the potato tuber moth (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae). Entomol Gen 36:149–161. https://doi.org/10.1127/entomologia/2016/0212
Shojaaddini M, Moharramipour S, Khodabandeh M, Talebi A (2010) Development of a cost effective medium for production of Bacillus thuringiensis bioinsecticide using food barley. J Plant Prot Res 50:9–14. https://doi.org/10.2478/v10045-010-0002-8
Smitha RB, Jisha VN, Pradeep S et al (2013) Potato flour mediated solid-state fermentation for the enhanced production of Bacillus thuringiensis-toxin. J Biosci Bioeng 116:595–601. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiosc.2013.05.008
Smitha RB, Jisha VN, Sajith S, Benjamin S (2014) Dual production of amylase and δ-endotoxin by Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki during biphasic fermentation. Microbiology 82:794–800. https://doi.org/10.1134/s0026261714010147
Tomiazzi JS, Judai MA, Nai GA et al (2018) Evaluation of genotoxic effects in Brazilian agricultural workers exposed to pesticides and cigarette smoke using machine-learning algorithms. Env Sci Pollut Res 25:1259–1269
Vu KD, Tyagi RD, Brar SK et al (2009) Starch industry wastewater for production of biopesticides—ramifications of solids concentrations. Environ Technol 30:393–405. https://doi.org/10.1080/09593330902753495
Vu KD, Tyagi RD, Valéro JR, Surampalli RY (2010) Batch and fed-batch fermentation of Bacillus thuringiensis using starch industry wastewater as fermentation substrate. Bioprocess Biosyst Eng 33:691–700. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00449-009-0391-0
Vu KD, Tyagi RD, Surampalli RY, Valéro JR (2012) Mathematical relationships between spore concentrations, delta-endotoxin levels, and entomotoxicity of Bacillus thuringiensis preparations produced in different fermentation media. Bioresour Technol 123:303–311. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2012.07.110
Zhuang L, Zhou S, Wang Y et al (2011a) Cost-effective production of Bacillus thuringiensis biopesticides by solid-state fermentation using wastewater sludge: effects of heavy metals. Bioresour Technol 102:4820–4826. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2010.12.098
Zhuang L, Zhou S, Wang Y, Chang M (2011b) Mosquito biolarvicide production by sequential fermentation with dual strains of Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis and Bacillus sphaericus using sewage sludge. Bioresour Technol 102:1574–1580. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2010.08.090
Zou H, Ding S, Zhang W et al (2016) Study on influence factors in Bacillus Thuringiensis production by semi-solid state fermentation using food waste. Procedia Environ Sci 31:127–135. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proenv.2016.02.018
Zouari N, Dhouib A, Ellouz R, Jaoua S (1998) Nutritional requirements of a Strain of Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki and use of gruel hydrolysate for the formulation of a new medium for 8-endotoxin production. Appl Biochem Biotechnol 69:41–52
Zribi Zghal R, Kharrat M, Rebai A et al (2018) Optimization of bio-insecticide production by Tunisian Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis and its application in the field. Biol Control 124:46–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocontrol.2018.06.002
Acknowledgements
Dra. Ana Porto and Dr. José Manoel Duarte Neto are grateful to CNPq (National Council for Scientific and Technological Development) for her “Bolsa Produtividade em Pesquisa” (Research Productivity Grant), 305719/2016-5, and his pos-doctorate Grant, 152774/2018-1. Dra. Maria Carolina de Albuquerque Wanderley to FACEPE (Foundation of Support to Science and Technology of Pernambuco) for her “Bolsa de Fixação de Pesquisador” (Researcher Grant) BFP Also, Túlio Freire da Silva to FACEPE for his master’s scholarship, IBPG-0475-5.05/17. This study was supported by Dra. Ana Porto FACEPE’s Projeto Institucional Pesquisador Visitante (Visitor Researcher Institutional Project) Grant, SIN-0156-5.01/17, and CNPq’s Universal MCTIC Grant (426192/2018-4).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Duarte Neto, J.M.W., Wanderley, M.C.d.A., da Silva, T.A.F. et al. Bacillus thuringiensis endotoxin production: a systematic review of the past 10 years. World J Microbiol Biotechnol 36, 128 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11274-020-02904-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11274-020-02904-4