Real-Time Evolution of the Electron Clouds of Transition Metal Ions: Possible Electron-Pairing Medium in Unconventional High-Temperature Superconductors

The electron-pairing mechanism in unconventional high-temperature superconductors (HTS) has not been resolved. We proposed that the electron-pairing medium of unconventional HTS is the change of the electron clouds of transition metal ions, which is analogous to the lattice vibration in conventional superconductors. Real-time evolution of the electron clouds of transition metal ions under excitations in La2Fe2As2O2, FeSe sheet, and HgBa2Ca2Cu3O8 was calculated by the time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT). The characteristic frequencies are 160 meV, 190 meV, and 250 meV, respectively. The frequencies are close to that of the lattice vibration in conventional HTS at high pressures, showing that the change of the electron clouds of the transition metal ions can be the electron-pairing medium.


Introduction
The discovery of copper oxide [1,2] and iron-based [3,4] superconductors indicates that the electron-lattice interaction cannot explain the electron-pairing mechanism in unconventional HTS. According to the BCS theory [5,6], the superconducting transition temperature (T c ) caused by the electron-lattice interaction (at normal pressures) cannot be higher than 40 K. In 1987, P. W. Anderson [7] has put forward the famous RVB model for copper-based superconductors. Other theories [8][9][10] have also been proposed. But P. W. Anderson [11] stated in 2007 that many theories about hightemperature superconducting electron-pairing mechanism might be in the wrong direction. Recently, orbital fluctuation has been extensively studied [12][13][14][15], but the characteristic frequency of the fluctuation has been not obtained. The pairing mechanism for unconventional HTS is still under debate. There are two main viewpoints on the electron pairing. One is that there is a lattice-like medium. The other is that there is no lattice-like medium.
This paper explores the first point of view. We think that, if a medium does exist in unconventional HTS, the medium should change under excitations and the characteristic frequency should be close to that of the lattice vibration. Table 1 gives the maximum phonon frequencies and T c of three typical conventional superconductors. It is reasonable to guess that the characteristic frequency of the electronpairing medium in unconventional HTS should be about 100-200 meV. If the frequency is too low or too high, it is unlikely to be an electron-pairing medium in HTS. If the frequency is too low, T c cannot be so high. If the frequency is too high, it cannot be excited by free electrons.
Based on the above consideration, T. G. Zhou had studied eight typical unconventional superconductors (Fe 2 KSe 2 , La 2 Fe 2 As 2 O 2 , Nd 2 Fe 2 As 2 O 2 , Ba 2 Fe 4 As 4 , YBa 2 Cu 3 O 7 , HgBa 2 Ca 2 Cu 3 O 9 , Tl 2 Ba 2 CaCu 2 O 8 , and Bi 2 Sr 2 Ca 2 Cu 3 O 10 ) [18]. Under a static electric field, the electron clouds of transition metal ions change significantly. A pairing mechanism was proposed. When a free electron comes to a new place, the electron clouds of the neighboring transition metal ions will change. In this way, the charge densities around the free electron will decrease. When the free electron leaves, the electron clouds of the transition metal ions will not relax immediately, so that there will be a region lack of charge. Another free electron will be attracted. An attraction appears. This mechanism is essentially the same as the electron-lattice interaction, except that the medium is the change of the electron clouds, not the displacement of the ions.
Based on the previous studies, we have made a further investigation, investigating the frequencies of the change of the electron clouds of transition metal ions. The real-time evolution of charge densities under some excitation of La 2 Fe 2 As 2 O 2 , FeSe sheet, and HgBa 2 Ca 2 Cu 3 O 8 has been calculated by TDDFT [19,20] method. This paper will report the methods and results.

Methods
Calculations were conducted within the Octopus package [21,22]. The generalized gradient approximation (GGA) of Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) was used to describe the exchangecorrelation energy. The GGA+U method [23,24] was considered to deal with the strong correlation of the 3d electrons. HSCV pseudopotentials [25] were adopted. Approximated enforced time-reversal symmetry (AETRS) algorithm was used to approximate the evolution operator and the time step is 0.002 ћ/eV.

La 2 Fe 2 As 2 O 2
The k-point setting is 4 × 4 × 2 and 5p 6 d 1 6s 2 of La, 3p 6 d 6 4s 2 of Fe, 3d 10 4s 2 p 3 of As and 2s 2 p 4 of O are taken as valence electrons in the calculation. The real space spacing is 0.35 Bohr. The change of charge densities is induced by a timedependent electric field: where F 0 = 1.0 eV/Å, ω = 1.8 eV, τ 0 = 5.0/eV, and t 0 = 5.0/eV. The electric field is along the [111] direction. The excitation vanishes after 5000 steps and the charge densities vibrate freely thereafter. After 8000 steps, the charge densities are recorded. Figure 1 shows the crystal structure and the real-time evolution of the charge density. 100 represents the charge density difference between the 8100th step and the 8000th step and the same below. The change of the electron clouds of Fe ions become obvious gradually with the evolution steps. After 100 steps, almost no change can be seen, while after 500 steps, the change has been obvious. To give a better illustration, Fig. 2 shows the maximum value of the charge density change as a function of the evolution steps. The charge density change reaches its maximum after about 800 steps, and the corresponding time is 1.6 ћ/ eV. It is the time from zero to the maximum. The time of one period should be 4 × 1.6 ћ/eV, so the frequency is about 160 meV. The frequency given in this way is not very accurate and may have an error as large as ± 20%, but the frequency is consistent with the authors' guess, indicating that it can be the electron-pairing medium in HTS. Calculations with 2 × 2 × 1 and 6 × 6 × 2 k-point settings give consistent results. Figure 3 shows the results of FeSe sheet. The k-point setting is 2 × 2 × 1 and 3p 6 d 6 4s 2 of Fe and 4s 2 p 4 of Se are taken as Fig. 1 Crystal structure and the charge density evolution of La 2 Fe 2 As 2 O 2 . Plots were generated using VESTA [26] (the same below). The isosurface is 0.02 e/Bohr 3 . The yellow color represents an increase of the charge density, while the blue a decrease (the same below)

(HgBa 2 Ca 2 Cu 3 O 8 ) 2
The k-point setting is 2 × 2 × 1 and 5p 6 d 10 6s 2 of Hg, 5p 6 6s 2 of Ba, 3p 6 4s 2 of Ca, 3p 6  The characteristic frequencies are 160 meV, 190 meV, and 250 meV, respectively, for La 2 Fe 2 As 2 O 2 , FeSe sheet, and HgBa 2 Ca 2 Cu 3 O 8 . The results are unexpected, because the general view is that the change of the electron density is very quick and the frequency is much higher than the lattice vibration. The frequencies the author obtained are close to that of the lattice vibration, indicating it can be excited by free electrons. So, the change of the electron clouds of transition metal ions can be the electron-pairing medium. W. A. Little et al. [28] gave similar results, but the frequencies are too high. Whether it can be excited by free electrons should be justified.
We also studied other systems, such as Fe 2 KSe 2 [29] and CaCuO 2 [30]. Similar results were obtained. It is worth noting that the change of the electron clouds of transition metal ions is very complicated. For the same superconductor, there may be different modes, corresponding to different frequencies.
For the same mode, the frequency is the same. Changing the parameters of the applied electric field may lead to different modes or may not affect the results. Why do the electron clouds of transition metal ions change this way? The main reason is that the 3d shell of transition metal ions is not fully filled. The electron clouds possess no spherical symmetry, and easy to change under electric fields.

Summary
Real-time evolution of the electron clouds of transition metal ions in unconventional HTS was calculated by the TDDFT method. The frequencies of evolution of electron clouds match well with the frequencies of the lattice vibrations in Fig. 3 Crystal structure and the charge density evolution of FeSe sheet. The excitation is the same as above. The isosurface is 0.015 Fig. 2 The relationship between the maximum value of charge density change and the evolution steps conventional HTS at high pressures. Though the frequencies obtained by this method are not accurate, it can give a significant evidence that the change of electron clouds can be the electron-pairing medium in HTS.