Abstract
We cannot directly perceive and experience objects of words such as “apūrva” “devatā,” and “svarga,” while objects of words such as “cow” and “horse” are perceptible. Therefore in the Indian linguistic context, some assert that there are two categories of words. However, a grammarian philosopher Bhartṛhari (450 CE) in the second book of his Vākyapadīya, introduces a verse stating that there is no difference between them. Other Indian thinkers as well deal with this issue in various contexts. This paper aims at exploring the ideas expressed in Bhartṛhari’s verse and the related arguments found in other treatises of different schools. It consists of discussions of the followingt: (1) Bhartṛhari’s Vākyapadīya 2.119 and its commentarial texts; (2) Kumārila’s Criticism; (3) The Nyāya context; (4) The Sāṃkhya and the Buddhist context; (5) Related grammatical passages and the background of the Vākyapadīya 2.119; and (6) Conclusion.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- MD:
-
Mahābhāṣyadīpikā: Bronkhorst (1987)
- MH:
-
Madhyamakahṛdaya: Lindtner (2001)
- NC:
-
Dvādaśāra-Nayacakra: Jambuvijaya (1966)
- NV:
-
Nyāyavārttika: Nyayatarkatirtha et al. (1985)
- SK:
-
Sāṃkhyakārikā: Larson (1969)
- TS:
-
Tattvasaṃgraha: Krishnamacharya (1984)
- TV:
-
Tantravārttika: Subbāśāstrī (1929); Joshi (1981)
- VP:
-
Bhartṛhari’s Vākyapadīya
- VPI:
-
Vākyapadīya, Kāṇḍa 1: Iyer (1966)
- VPII:
-
Vākyapadīya, Kāṇḍa 2: Iyer (1983)
- VPwr:
-
Vākyapadīya: Rau (1977)
- YD:
-
Yuktidīpikā: Wetzler and Motegi (1998)
References
Akamatsu, A. (1991). A study of the Nyāyavārttika (2): Uddoyotaka on Apūrva. In H. Tosaki, et al. (Eds.), Essays in honor of Dr. Shoren Ihara on his seventieth birthday (pp. 377–398). Fukuoka: Committee for the Commemoration of Dr. Shoren Ihara’s Seventieth Birthday (in Japanese).
Bronkhorst, J. (Ed. & Trans.). (1987). Mahābhāṣyadīpikā of Bhartṛhari. Fascicule IV: Āhnika I. Post-graduate and research department series 28. Poona: Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute.
Coward, H. G., & Raja, K. K. (Eds.). (1990). Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies. Vol. V: The philosophy of the grammarians. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.
Harikai, K. (Ed. & Trans.). (1991). “Kumārila’s theory of Śabdārtha (3): A Japanese translation of the Lokaveda Adhikaraṇa.” In H. Tosaki, et al. (Eds.), Essays in honor of Dr. Shoren Ihara on his seventieth birthday (pp. 353–376). Fukuoka: Committee for the Commemoration of Dr. Shoren Ihara’s Seventieth Birthday.
Houben, J. E. M. (2008). Doxographic introductions to the philosophical systems: Mallavādin and the grammarians. In W. Slaje (Ed.), Śāstrārambha: Inquiries into the preamble in Sanskrit (pp. 83–95). Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz.
Houben, J. E. M. (2009). “Bhartṛhari and the Jainas.” In M. Chaturvedi (Ed.), Bhartṛhari: Language, thought and reality: Proceedings of the international seminar, Delhi, December 12–14, 2003 (pp. 384–413). Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.
Iyer, K. A. S. (Ed.). (1966). Vākyapadīya of Bhartṛhari. Kāṇḍa 1. Deccan College monograph series 32. Poona: Deccan College.
Iyer K.A.S. (1977) The Vākyapadīya of Bhartṛhari. Kāṇḍa II, English translation with exegetical notes. Motilal Banarasidass, Delhi
Iyer K.A.S. (1983) Vākyapadīya of Bhartṛhari, containing the Ṭīkā of Puṇyarāja and the ancient Vṛtti. Kāṇḍa II.. Motilal Banarasidass, Delhi
Jambuvijaya, M. (Ed.). (1966). Dvādaśāraṃ Nayacakram. Part 1. Bhavnagar: Śrī Jaina-Ātmānanda-Sabhā.
Jha, G. (1915). The Nyāya-sūtras of Gautama: With Vātsyayana’s Bhāṣya and Uddyotakara’s Vārttika. Indian thought series 7 (Vol. 1). Allahabad: Belvedere Steam Printing Works.
Jha, G. (Ed. & Trans.). (1965). The Tattva-Kaumudī: Vācaspati Miśra’s commentary on the Sāṁkhya-kārikā. Translated into English by Mahāmahopādhyāya Ganganatha Jha; with introduction and critical notes by Har Dutt Sharma; revised and re-edited by M.M. Patkar. Poona oriental series 10. Poona: The Oriental Book Agency.
Jha, G. (1979 [1916]). The Pūrva-Mīmāṃsā-Sūtras of Jaimini: With an original commentary in English. Varanasi: Bharatiya Publishing House.
Jha, G. (1998 [1924]). The Tantravārttika of Kumārila Bhaṭta (Vol. 1). Delhi: Pilgrims Book.
Joshi, G. (Ed.). (1981). Mīmāṃsādarśanam. Ānandāśrama Sanskrit series 97 (3rd ed., Vol. 2). Pune: Ānandāśrama (First edition: Subbāśāstrī, 1929).
Joshi, S. D., & Roodbergen, J. A. F. (Ed. & Trans.). (1986). Patañjali’s Vyākaraṇa-Mahābhāṣya. Paspaśāhnika, introduction, text, translation and notes. Publications of the Centre of Advance Study in Sanskrit, Class C, No. 15. Poona: Poona University.
Kataoka, K. (2000). “Reconstructing the Dharma-abhivyakti-vāda in the Mīmāṃsā tradition.” In M. Sengaku, et al. (Eds.), The way to liberation: Indological studies in Japan. Japanese studies on South Asia 3 (pp. 167–181). Delhi: Manohar Publishers & Distributors.
Kawasaki S. (1992) A study of the omniscient being (Sarvajña) in Buddhism. Shunjūsha, Tokyo in Japanese
Krishnamacharya, E. (Ed.). (1984 [1926]). Tattvasaṃgraha of Śāntarakṣita with the commentary of Kamalaśīla. Gaekwad’s oriental series 30 (Vol. 1). Baroda: Oriental Institute.
Larson G.J. (1969) Classical Sāṃkhya: An interpretation of its history and meaning. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
Lindtner E. (E.d.). (2001) Madhyamakahṛdayam of Bhavya. Adyar library series 123. The Adyar Library and Research Centre, Chennai
Nyayatarkatirtha, T., Tarkatirtha, A. M., & Tarkatirtha, H. K. (Eds.). (1985 [1936–1944]). Nyāyadarśana. Calcutta Sanskrit series 18 and 29. Calcutta.
Ogawa H. (2005) Process and language: A study of the Mahābhāṣya ad A1.3.1 bhūvādayo dhātavaḥ. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
Potter, K. H. (Ed.). (1995). Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies: Volume I: Bibliography (sections I and II). Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass (3rd revised edition).
Raja C.K. (1963). The Sāṅkhya Kārikā of Īśvarakṛṣṇa: A philosopher’s exposition Woolner Indological series 4. Vishveshvaranand Vedic Research Institute Press, Hoshiarpur
Rau, W. (Ed.). (1977). Bhartṛharis Vākyapadīya. Abhandlungen für die Kunde des Morgenlandes Bd. XLII. 4. Wiesbaden: Komissionsverlag Franz Steiner GMBH.
Sarup, L. (Ed. & Trans.). (1998 [1920–1929]). The Nighaṇṭu and the Nirukta: The oldest Indian treatise on etymology, philology and semantics. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.
Scharf, P. M. (1996). The denotation of generic terms in ancient Indian philosophy: Grammar. Nyāya, and Mīmāmsā (Vol. 86, No. 37). Transactions of the American Philosophical Society.
Subbāśāstrī. C.K. (1929) Mīmāṃsādarśanam. Ānandāśrama Sanskrit series 97 (Vol. 2).. Ānandāśrama, Pune
Unebe T. (1999) Bhartṛhari on Sattā. NantoBukkyo/Journal of Nanto Society for Buddhist Studies. 6: 1–25 (in Japanese)
Unebe T. (2002) All words denote being (asti, sattā): Vākyapadīya 2.119 and later interpretations on it. Indo-Shisoshi Kenkyu/Studies in the History of Indian Thought 14: 45–70 (in Japanese)
Unebe, T. (2004). “The “Grammarian’s objection” in Sthiramati’s Triṃśikābhāṣya and Bhartṛhari’s argument on the secondary application of words.” In S. Hino & T. Wada (Eds.), Three mountains and seven rivers: Prof. Musashi Tachikawa’s felicitation volume (pp. 133–151). Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.
Unebe, T. (2009). “Mīmāṃsā and Buddhist criticism on Bhartṛhari’s Vākyapadīya 2.119 and his counterarguments”. In M. Chaturvedi (Ed.), Bhartṛhari: Language, thought and reality proceedings of the international seminar, Delhi, December 12–14, 2003 (pp. 415–431). Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.
Wezler, A., & Motegi, S. (Ed.). (1998). Yuktidīpikā, the most significant commentary on the 558 Sāṃkhyakārikā (Vol. 1). Stuttgart: Franz Steiner.
Yoshimizu, K. (2000). Change of view on Apūrva from Śabarasvāmin to Kumārila. In M. Sengaku, et al. (Eds.), The way to liberation: Indological studies in Japan. Japanese studies on South Asia 3 (pp. 149–165). Delhi: Manohar Publishers & Distributors.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Unebe, T. “Apūrva,” “Devatā,” and “Svarga”: Arguments on Words Denoting Imperceptible Objects. J Indian Philos 39, 535–552 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10781-011-9134-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10781-011-9134-z